History As It Happens: Episode Summary – "India and Pakistan's Forever War"

Date Released: May 16, 2025
Host: Martin Di Caro

In this compelling episode of History As It Happens, host Martin Di Caro delves deep into the enduring and volatile conflict between India and Pakistan over the region of Kashmir. Through insightful interviews with esteemed historian Anatole Leven and enriched with historical accounts from William Dalrymple, the episode unpacks the complex origins, pivotal moments, and contemporary challenges of one of the world's most protracted conflicts.

1. Introduction to the Conflict

The episode opens with Martin Di Caro setting the stage for the discussion on the renewed tensions between India and Pakistan.

• Martin Di Caro [00:28]: "India and Pakistan are once again on the brink of all-out war."

He highlights recent events where Pakistan's Defense Minister, Khwaja Asif, acknowledged Pakistan's historical support for terrorist organizations, igniting further hostilities.

• Khwaja Asif [00:39]: "Acts of terrorism are criminal and unjustifiable, regardless of their motivation, wherever, whenever and by whomever committed."

2. Historical Background: Partition of 1947

The roots of the India-Pakistan conflict trace back to the partition of British India in 1947, a moment marked by immense violence and mass migrations.

• William Dalrymple [02:20]: "Independence has not yet brought them peace. Rejoicing turned quickly into horror and mourning."

Partition led to the creation of two separate nations, with Kashmir emerging as a contentious princely state due to its Muslim-majority population and Hindu Maharaja.

3. The First War Over Kashmir (1947-1949)

Shortly after partition, disputes over Kashmir's accession led to the first Indo-Pakistani war.

• Martin Di Caro [01:10]: "What began as a retaliatory strike by India in response to the Pulwama terror attack spiraled into an undeclared war."

Anatole Leven provides insights into the Maharaja Hari Singh's indecision and the subsequent invasion by Pakistani tribesmen, prompting Kashmir's accession to India under duress.

• Anatole Leven [09:17]: "Kashmir should have come to Pakistan at independence and partition in 1947. But Pakistan then sent in armed volunteers to overthrow him."

A UN-brokered ceasefire in 1949 ended the conflict, establishing the initial Line of Control (LoC).

4. Subsequent Wars and the Simla Agreement (1965 & 1999)

The dispute over Kashmir reignited in subsequent decades, leading to more wars and temporary ceasefires.

• William Dalrymple [05:52]: "The brief war... cost 5,000 lives."

In 1972, the Simla Agreement formalized the LoC, yet failed to bring lasting peace.

• Martin Di Caro [06:10]: "In 1972, India and Pakistan formalized the original UN ceasefire line, now the line of control in the Simla agreement."

5. The Rise of Insurgency and Militancy (1980s-1990s)

The late 20th century saw a surge in insurgency within Kashmir, fueled by both local discontent and external militant support.

• Anatole Leven [12:25]: "Pakistan was sending those Pakistani volunteers to fight in Afghanistan. When the Soviets withdrew, they were redirected to fight against India in Kashmir."

This period was marked by brutal violence, including mass abductions, arson, and sexual violence against civilians.

• William Dalrymple [03:54]: "In Punjab and Bengal provinces... massacres, arson, forced conversions, mass abductions and savage sexual violence."

6. Attempts at Peace and Renewed Violence

Efforts to broker peace in the early 2000s faltered amidst continued terrorist attacks and political upheavals.

• Anatole Leven [34:51]: Discusses General Musharraf's attempts at peace, which were thwarted by domestic instability in Pakistan.

Recent incidents in 2025, including a massacre of tourists in the Baiseran Valley, have reignited fears of full-scale war.

• Martin Di Caro [37:55]: "India said Pakistan, because of its history backing Kashmiri militants, was involved in the massacre."

7. Nuclear Tensions and the Risk of Escalation

The presence of nuclear weapons in both nations adds a perilous dimension to the conflict, raising the stakes of any military engagement.

• Anatole Leven [41:59]: "This is a source of restraint... both sides say, look, you have nuclear weapons. Why shouldn't we have nuclear weapons?"

He warns of the terrifying threat of nuclear conflict, exacerbated by the proximity of the capitals and the lack of warning time.

8. Contemporary Challenges and Future Outlook

The episode concludes with reflections on the seemingly intractable nature of the Kashmir conflict and the urgent need for international intervention to prevent escalation.

• Anatole Leven [43:56]: "The international community really needs to drill into both sides, because both sides say, look, you have nuclear weapons. Why shouldn't we have nuclear weapons?"

Martin Di Caro underscores the humanitarian and geopolitical ramifications, questioning the rationality of persistent warfare over Kashmir.

• Martin Di Caro [44:04]: "Is Kashmir important enough to have a nuclear war over? I mean, to you and I, of course not. But we are not Indian or Pakistani."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Khwaja Asif [00:39]: "Acts of terrorism are criminal and unjustifiable, regardless of their motivation, wherever, whenever and by whomever committed."

• William Dalrymple [03:54]: "In Punjab and Bengal provinces... massacres, arson, forced conversions, mass abductions and savage sexual violence."

• Anatole Leven [09:17]: "Kashmir should have come to Pakistan at independence and partition in 1947. But Pakistan then sent in armed volunteers to overthrow him."

• Anatole Leven [41:59]: "This is a source of restraint... both sides say, look, you have nuclear weapons. Why shouldn't we have nuclear weapons?"

• Martin Di Caro [44:04]: "Is Kashmir important enough to have a nuclear war over? I mean, to you and I, of course not. But we are not Indian or Pakistani."

Conclusion

History As It Happens provides a thorough examination of the India-Pakistan conflict over Kashmir, highlighting its historical depth, the cyclical nature of violence, and the looming threat of nuclear war. Through expert analysis and poignant historical accounts, the episode underscores the urgent need for a sustainable resolution to prevent further loss of life and regional instability.

Stay Tuned: In the next episode, military historian Antony Beaver discusses the "Unsettled Legacies of the Second World War and Vladimir Putin's Uses and Abuses of Soviet Memory," offering insights into how historical narratives shape contemporary geopolitics.

Subscribe: For more in-depth historical analyses, subscribe to History As It Happens and receive updates directly to your inbox at historyasithappens.com.