History As It Happens: Trump, Gaza, and the Palestinians
Hosted by Martin Di Caro
Release Date: February 11, 2025
Introduction: Trump's Controversial Proposition
In this episode of History As It Happens, host Martin DeCarlo delves into the provocative statements made by former President Donald Trump regarding the Gaza Strip and the Palestinian population. The discussion centers around Trump's proposal to have the United States take control of Gaza, forcibly relocate Palestinians, and transform the territory into a real estate investment.
Notable Quote:
Donald Trump (01:12): "US will take over the Gaza Strip and we will do a job with it, too. We'll own it and move Palestinians out."
Historical Context: Black September and the Palestinian National Movement
Colette Elgindy provides an in-depth historical background, tracing the roots of the Palestinian national movement to the refugee camps in Jordan, Lebanon, and other diaspora locations. The episode revisits the events of Black September in 1970, a brutal conflict between the Jordanian monarchy and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), which resulted in the expulsion of the PLO from Jordan.
Notable Quote:
Colette Elgindy (02:12): "The Palestinian armed and political movement grew out of the refugee camps in Jordan, Lebanon and other places of Palestinian diaspora that became the crucible of the Palestinian national movement."
Trump's Proposal Analyzed: Feasibility and Consequences
Khaled Elgindy critiques Trump's proposal, labeling it as "bizarre," "dangerous," and "monstrously stupid." He emphasizes the historical lessons that such forced relocations lead to further instability and conflict, drawing parallels with the events of Black September.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (13:23): "It's a bizarre proposal. It's, I think, equally dangerous... a monstrously stupid idea in addition to being inhumane and illegal."
The Abraham Accords and Shifting Regional Dynamics
The conversation shifts to the Abraham Accords, agreements that normalized relations between Israel and several Arab states. Khaled Elgindy argues that these accords were designed to bypass the Palestinian issue, weakening the Arab states' traditional support for a two-state solution. He asserts that the accords have ultimately undermined prospects for Palestinian statehood and contributed to regional instability.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (20:40): "They saw, well, look, we have bilateral interests vis a vis Israel and the United States... We have regional interests and we need to pursue those on our own."
Regional Reactions: Egypt and Jordan Stand Firm
Egypt and Jordan have publicly rejected the notion of accepting displaced Palestinians from Gaza. Elgindy highlights the practical and security reasons behind their refusal, noting the potential for increased militant activities and the destabilizing effect on their own nations.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (17:31): "Palestinians don't want to leave their land...There is a case to be made...they know anytime Palestinians have left, they've never been allowed back."
Blame and Responsibility: A Multifaceted Analysis
The episode explores the complex web of responsibility for the ongoing conflict. Both Hamas and Israeli leadership are scrutinized for their roles in perpetuating violence and instability. DeCarlo and Elgindy discuss how simplistic narratives fail to capture the nuanced interplay of actions and consequences on both sides.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (31:35): "Israel doesn't have to commit crimes against humanity...but it chose to do so. So, yes, Israelis are to blame for their own atrocities...also the responsibility of the Palestinian Authority..."
The Two-State Solution: Challenges and Prospects
Elgindy outlines the monumental challenges facing the revival of the two-state solution, including the need for new leadership in both Israel and Palestine, genuine representation, and a shift in U.S. policy away from proposals like Trump's. He underscores the absence of visionary leadership capable of bridging the deep-seated divides.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (45:35): "It would take an entirely new leadership in Israel...a new Palestinian leadership that is genuinely representative...and a new US Leadership."
Conclusion: Lessons from History and the Path Forward
Wrapping up, the episode reflects on the enduring lessons of history, particularly the failures of past agreements and strategies that have neglected Palestinian agency and rights. Elgindy emphasizes the necessity of recognizing Palestinian humanity and agency as prerequisites for any lasting peace.
Notable Quote:
Khaled Elgindy (48:24): "What's required is also to acknowledge Palestinian rights and Palestinian humanity and Palestinian agency, and without those, you'll never have peace."
Final Thoughts
Martin DeCarlo concludes by highlighting the persistent struggles and the cyclical nature of the Israel-Palestine conflict. The episode serves as a poignant reminder of how historical missteps continue to shape present realities, emphasizing the urgent need for informed and compassionate solutions.
Join the Conversation:
History As It Happens releases new episodes every Tuesday and Friday. Stay informed by subscribing to the newsletter @historyasithappens.com.