History Daily Episode Summary: The Brownsville Affair

Release Date: August 13, 2025
Host: Lindsey Graham
Podcast: History Daily
Produced by: Airship | Noiser | Wondery

Introduction

In the August 13, 2025 episode of History Daily titled "The Brownsville Affair," host Lindsey Graham explores a significant yet often overlooked episode in American military and racial history. This detailed narrative transports listeners back to August 13, 1906, in Brownsville, Texas, to uncover the events and lasting impact of the Brownsville Affair—a tragic incident involving African-American soldiers and the ensuing quest for justice.

Setting the Scene

The episode opens in the late hours of August 13, 1906, with Mayor Fred Coombe witnessing the immediate aftermath of a violent confrontation in Brownsville. The town, marked by high racial tensions and hostility towards the newly stationed 25th Infantry Regiment, an all-black unit, becomes the backdrop for a pivotal moment in U.S. military history.

Lindsey Graham [00:00]: "It's just after midnight on August 13, 1906, in Brownsville, Texas. Mayor Fred Coombe races down the street in a horse-drawn wagon... But one thing is certain. Over 150 lives were changed forever after the deadly shooting in Brownsville that night."

Background: Racial Tensions in Early 20th Century Texas

Brownsville, Texas, was a predominantly white town grappling with the socio-economic shifts following the Civil War. The arrival of the 25th Infantry Regiment from Fort Brown two weeks prior had already stirred resentment among the local white population. These African-American soldiers, veterans of the Spanish-American War who had served alongside President Theodore Roosevelt, faced overt racism and discrimination.

Lindsey Graham [05:07]: "They came to provide a military presence and maintain order in this border town. But despite their heroics on the battlefield, these soldiers are not warmly welcomed in Brownsville."

The Fateful Night: The Shooting

On the night in question, a combination of heightened tensions and strict curfew arrangements led to a tragic encounter. Mayor Coombe and local authorities were determined to prevent violence between the soldiers and townsfolk by enforcing a curfew. However, around midnight, gunfire erupted, resulting in the injury of a police officer and the death of a young bartender. Initial reports and eyewitness accounts predominantly blamed the 25th Infantry Regiment.

Lindsey Graham [11:09]: "But then, around midnight, rifle fire echoes throughout the town. When the shooting stops, a police officer is injured and a bartender is dead. Many in Brownsville are convinced that members of the 25th infantry are responsible."

Investigation: Seeking Truth Amidst Prejudice

In the wake of the shooting, Mayor Coombe sought answers by engaging with Major Charles Penrose of the 25th Infantry. Despite conflicting testimonies and a lack of concrete evidence, Texas Rangers, led by Captain Bill McDonald, were dispatched to investigate. Captain McDonald firmly believed the soldiers were culpable, but his findings were contested in court.

Lindsey Graham [11:09]: "Captain McDonald believes the residents. In his opinion, members of the 25th infantry are guilty of killing the bartender and wounding a police officer."

Presidential Intervention and Unjust Consequences

Despite the court's dismissal of the case due to insufficient evidence, President Theodore Roosevelt took a drastic step by dishonorably discharging over 150 African-American soldiers from the 25th Infantry Regiment. This unprecedented mass discharge barred these men from receiving pensions or veterans' benefits, exacerbating their plight and embedding racial injustice within military protocols.

Lindsey Graham [11:09]: "It's the first mass discharge in U.S. army history, and it has dire consequences for the men affected."

Long-Term Impact and Rehabilitation

Decades later, in February 1973, significant strides were made towards rectifying the injustices of the Brownsville Affair. Dorsey Willis, one of the last surviving soldiers from the 25th Infantry, received an honorable discharge and financial restitution following a congressional investigation that exonerated the soldiers. This ceremony symbolized a long-overdue acknowledgment of the wrongs committed.

Lindsey Graham [18:16]: "The financial restitution is long overdue, and though it can never wipe away the injustice suffered by the soldiers of the 25th infantry, it is a meaningful recognition of the unfair hardships."

Legacy and Reflection

The Brownsville Affair serves as a poignant reminder of the deep-seated racial prejudices that have influenced American military and societal structures. The wrongful discharge and subsequent efforts to restore dignity to the affected soldiers highlight the complexities of seeking justice in the face of institutional racism.

Lindsey Graham [05:07]: "But more than a half of a century later, there will be a new development in the case that will finally deliver justice for the wronged men of the 25th Infantry."

Conclusion

Lindsey Graham's comprehensive exploration of the Brownsville Affair on History Daily sheds light on a dark chapter of American history. By unraveling the events, examining the flawed investigations, and acknowledging the long-term repercussions faced by African-American soldiers, the episode underscores the enduring struggle for justice and equality.

For listeners interested in uncovering the true stories that shaped our world, History Daily offers a captivating journey through pivotal historical moments, one day at a time.