History Extra Podcast Summary: "Joanna Plantagenet: Life of the Week"

Release Date: April 21, 2025

Introduction

In the episode titled "Joanna Plantagenet: Life of the Week," host Emily Britt engages in an in-depth conversation with historian and author Catherine Hanley. The discussion explores the captivating and tumultuous life of Joanna Plantagenet, sister of the renowned Richard the Lionheart. Through Hanley's extensive research, listeners gain insights into Joanna's adventures, political maneuverings, and the challenges she faced as a medieval royal woman.

Early Life and Upbringing

Catherine Hanley begins by providing an overview of Joanna Plantagenet's early years, emphasizing her often-overlooked position in history compared to her male siblings.

Catherine Hanley [02:48]: "Joanna comes from a very famous family, but relatively her life has gone unknown. [...] Joanna had a really exciting, action-packed life, just as exciting as that of her brother, Richard the Lionheart."

Joanna was born in October 1165 to Henry II of England and Eleanor of Aquitaine. Unlike many royal daughters of her time, her birth was noted by chroniclers, allowing historians to trace her early life more accurately. As a child, Joanna traveled with her mother before being sent to Fontevra Abbey with her younger brother, John, around the age of four or five. This placement was intended to provide a stable education amidst the family's frequent relocations.

Catherine Hanley [05:07]: "At this point in her life, really, the only significant relationship she had with a close family member was with John..."

Despite her royal lineage, Joanna had limited personal interactions with her immediate family due to the political alliances and marriages that sent her sisters to foreign courts at a young age.

Marriage to William II of Sicily

At the age of ten, Joanna was married to William II of Sicily, a politically strategic union designed to strengthen alliances between England and Sicily.

Catherine Hanley [07:04]: "Sicily was quite a long way from England, but it was politically linked to the Anglo-Norman realm. [...] It suited both Henry II of England and William II of Sicily that this alliance should take place."

Despite her youth, Joanna navigated the complexities of the Sicilian court with remarkable poise. William II, twelve years her senior, ensured she received a proper education, including a Latin tutor, and fostered a close and affectionate relationship.

Catherine Hanley [08:15]: "They had a close relationship, an affectionate relationship. He looked after her, he made sure she got an education."

Joanna's role extended beyond that of merely a queen; she acted as a bridge between her birth family and her marital family, effectively influencing political decisions and governance within Sicily.

Imprisonment and Rescue

Tragedy struck when William II died in 1189, leaving Joanna a young widow without any children. This event plunged her into political turmoil as competing factions vied for control over Sicily.

Catherine Hanley [13:22]: "She was imprisoned for the rest of her life, a sentence that's been written more than once about medieval women."

Tancred, an illegitimate member of the Sicilian royal family, seized the opportunity to declare himself king, leading to Joanna's imprisonment. Her status as a royal sister eventually led to her brother Richard the Lionheart intervening.

Catherine Hanley [17:07]: "Richard landed on Sicily and demanded Joanna's release. Tancred complied, but strained on financial demands, leading to chaotic consequences."

Richard's military intervention resulted in Joanna's brief captivity under his control before they set sail together. However, disaster struck when a severe storm scattered Richard's fleet, leaving Joanna stranded with only a few other ships.

Catherine Hanley [20:00]: "Joanna found herself with just three other ships near Cyprus, facing imminent danger and potential capture."

Utilizing her diplomatic skills, Joanna negotiated with Isaac Komnenos, the ruler of Cyprus, delaying their fate until Richard's arrival to rescue her and her companions.

The Third Crusade and Diplomatic Endeavors

During the Third Crusade, Joanna accompanied Richard to the Holy Land, where she remained actively involved in the Crusaders' siege of Acre.

Catherine Hanley [27:08]: "Joanna takes up residence in the Crusaders' siege camp, which was quite claustrophobic due to the surrounding enemy forces."

When stalemate ensued, Richard sought to negotiate with Saladin. In a bold move, Richard proposed marrying Joanna to Saladin's brother, Al Adil, as a means to secure peace and facilitate territorial agreements. However, Saladin recognized the proposal as insincere, leading to Joanna's rejection of the arrangement.

Catherine Hanley [29:45]: "Joanna was absolutely adamant that she was not going to do this. She stood up to Richard and refused the marriage."

This episode underscores Joanna's agency and her ability to assert her will, even in the constrained context of medieval politics.

Second Marriage and Subsequent Challenges

Upon returning to Europe, Joanna entered into a second marriage with Raymond VI of Toulouse. This union initially appeared promising, as Joanna bore Raymond a son and a daughter, restoring her reputation as a capable queen capable of producing heirs.

Catherine Hanley [40:37]: "She gives birth to a son and heir to Raymond, which he didn't have before from either of his marriages."

However, the marriage soon deteriorated due to personal and political conflicts. Raymond's favoritism towards his illegitimate son and his alleged sympathy towards the Cathar heresy caused significant strain.

Catherine Hanley [41:44]: "Joanna was starting to encounter the slightly less pleasant side of Raymond's personality."

Amidst these challenges, Joanna faced a rebellion linked to the Cathars, during which she narrowly escaped betrayal by her own troops. This series of adversities culminated in her decision to seek a divorce—a rare and bold act for a medieval woman of her standing.

Final Years and Legacy

Joanna's attempt to leave her troubled marriage and return to a life of stability led her to seek entry into Fontevrault Abbey as a nun. Unfortunately, her plans were thwarted by a severe illness and complications during childbirth, leading to her untimely death at the age of 34.

Catherine Hanley [48:53]: "Joanna died in childbirth, a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities faced by medieval royal women."

In her final moments, Joanna demonstrated remarkable agency by drafting a detailed will, ensuring her assets were allocated according to her wishes and excluding her husband entirely.

Catherine Hanley [49:17]: "Joanna left a very detailed will about who was to have her money, bequests to her maids of honor and many to Fontevrault Abbey, and they were all carried out exactly as she wished."

Hanley concludes by reflecting on Joanna's legacy, highlighting her as a testament to the complex interplay of power and vulnerability experienced by medieval women.

Catherine Hanley [50:26]: "Joanna is a brilliant example of the contradictions in the lives of medieval royal women, that in some cases they had a lot more power and a lot more influence on events than they've ever been given credit for."

Conclusion

Joanna Plantagenet's life, as detailed by Catherine Hanley in this episode, offers a nuanced perspective on the roles and agency of medieval women. Her story challenges the often male-centric narratives of history, showcasing a woman who navigated the intricacies of power, diplomacy, and personal adversity with resilience and determination. Joanna's legacy underscores the importance of reevaluating historical accounts to acknowledge the significant yet frequently overlooked contributions of women in shaping the past.

For more enlightening historical discussions and analyses, subscribe to the History Extra podcast where leading experts bring the stories of the past to life.