History Extra Podcast Summary
Episode: Sir Simon Sharma on the Holocaust
Release Date: April 6, 2025

Introduction

In this poignant episode of the History Extra podcast, host David Musgrove engages in a profound conversation with Sir Simon Sharma, one of the world's leading historians, best-selling authors, and renowned documentary makers. Sir Simon delves into his latest film, The Road to Auschwitz, which offers a heartfelt exploration of the Holocaust, emphasizing the widespread complicity across Europe in this unimaginable atrocity.

Film Overview

Sir Simon Sharma's documentary, The Road to Auschwitz, premiered on BBC Two and is available on iPlayer. The film challenges conventional narratives by highlighting the broader European complicity in the Holocaust, moving beyond the commonly cited figures and events like Auschwitz and Anne Frank to shed light on lesser-known yet equally harrowing aspects.

Key Topics Discussed

1. Approach to Auschwitz and Personal Hesitation ([02:21] - [08:24])

   Sir Simon opens by explaining his initial reluctance to visit Auschwitz, fearing that the physical presence of the site might not adequately convey the horror of the Holocaust. He recounts an encounter in Krakow where a tourist advertisement trivialized Auschwitz, reinforcing his desire to approach the subject with the necessary gravity. Despite his reservations, visiting the site ultimately deepened his understanding, revealing the stark emptiness and the pervasive sense of loss that mere physical remnants evoke.

   "The emptier the site, actually, the more immediately present it is to me." ([07:50])

2. The Holocaust of Bullets in Lithuania ([08:24] - [15:26])

   A significant portion of the film focuses on the mass shootings in Lithuania, particularly in Kaunas and surrounding areas. Sir Simon details the brutal massacres orchestrated by Nazi forces with the active participation and complicity of local populations. He highlights events such as the Lyotechus Garage massacre, where nearly 70 Jews were brutally murdered while being filmed by the Luftwaffe, demonstrating the systematic nature of these atrocities.

   "There are 289 massacres in Lithuania alone in 1941." ([10:52])

   Sir Simon emphasizes how these public executions were used by the Nazis to legitimize their extermination plans, presenting them as chaotic violence rather than orchestrated genocide.

3. Complicity of Local Populations ([15:26] - [25:44])

   The discussion shifts to the roles of local populations in facilitating the Holocaust. In Lithuania and other regions, enthusiastic local support and bureaucratic efficiency enabled the Nazis to carry out mass exterminations with alarming effectiveness. Sir Simon underscores the horrifying reality that ordinary citizens were not mere bystanders but active participants or passive enablers of these crimes.

   "The Nazis thought about making it a public savagery spectacle to encourage local populations." ([14:28])

4. The Netherlands: From Tolerance to Intolerance ([17:28] - [24:37])

   Sir Simon explores how the Netherlands, once a bastion of tolerance, rapidly descended into complicity under Nazi occupation. He recounts the meticulous data collection practices, such as the Amsterdam dot map, which facilitated the identification and deportation of Jews. Despite initial resistance and public outcry, the bureaucratic machinery of the Nazis, combined with local indifference, led to the near-total annihilation of the Jewish population.

   "75% of the 116,000 Jews in Holland were killed." ([17:51])

   He poignantly describes scenes from Amsterdam, where Jewish individuals were publicly paraded, often watched by indifferent or complicit locals, highlighting the systemic nature of their persecution.

5. Auschwitz: Personal Encounter and Emotional Impact ([25:44] - [35:23])

   Visiting Auschwitz was a transformative experience for Sir Simon. He distinguishes between Auschwitz I and Auschwitz Birkenau, emphasizing the vastness and the haunting emptiness of Birkenau. The film captures the mechanical horror of the selection process and the relentless efficiency of the extermination machinery.

   "Acknowledging the extraordinary presence Auschwitz holds is essential." ([25:59])

   Sir Simon discusses the resilience and courage of the Sonderkommando, Jewish prisoners forced to manage the gas chambers and crematoria. Their clandestine efforts to document atrocities through hidden writings and drawings provide crucial testimonies of resistance and survival.

   "The hidden writings are powerful pieces of literature that survived against all odds." ([31:48])

6. Lessons and Contemporary Relevance ([35:23] - [40:22])

   As the film concludes with interviews from Holocaust survivors, including the poignant words of Marion Tursky, Sir Simon articulates the central lesson: the gradual erosion of humanity can lead to catastrophic consequences. He warns against indifference and the dehumanization of others, drawing parallels to current antisemitic incidents and broader societal hate.

   "Once you start to really treat people as having no relationship to you in a humane way, you are in deep trouble." ([38:02])

   Reflecting on the 80th anniversary of the Holocaust, Sir Simon underscores the urgent need to recognize and combat rising antisemitism and hatred globally.

   "We need absolutely to learn where this can lead." ([40:04])

Conclusion

In this deeply moving episode, Sir Simon Sharma not only recounts the harrowing events of the Holocaust with unparalleled depth but also connects these historical atrocities to present-day issues of hate and intolerance. His emphasis on active remembrance and the imperative to oppose indifference serves as a vital reminder of the lessons learned from history. The Road to Auschwitz is a compelling call to witness, remember, and act to prevent the repetition of such horrors.

Notable Quotes

• "The emptier the site, actually, the more immediately present it is to me." ([07:50])
• "There are 289 massacres in Lithuania alone in 1941." ([10:52])
• "The Nazis thought about making it a public savagery spectacle to encourage local populations." ([14:28])
• "75% of the 116,000 Jews in Holland were killed." ([17:51])
• "Once you start to really treat people as having no relationship to you in a humane way, you are in deep trouble." ([38:02])

Further Resources

To explore more about the Holocaust and understand its enduring impact, visit HistoryExtra.com and consider unlocking full access for six months.