Summary of "Women's Hidden Role in Religious Reformation" – History Extra Podcast

Episode Release Date: March 17, 2025
Host: Emily Briffet
Guest: Mary Wiesner Hanks, Author of "Women and the Reformations"

Introduction

In this enlightening episode of the History Extra podcast, host Emily Briffet engages in a profound conversation with historian Mary Wiesner Hanks. Hanks delves into her book, "Women and the Reformations," shedding light on the pivotal yet often overlooked roles women played during the religious reformation periods across the globe. The discussion challenges the traditional male-centric narratives, presenting women as central figures in shaping religious transformations.

The Global Scope of the Reformations

Mary Wiesner Hanks emphasizes that the Reformations were not confined to Europe but had a global impact intertwined with the spread of Christianity worldwide. She states:

“So when Europeans first travel around the world... there's only one Christian church at the time. But shortly after that... there's more than one. So the story needs to be told together of the splintering of Christianity in Western Europe and the taking of Christianity or the spread of Christianity around the world...” (02:39).

This perspective underscores the interconnectedness of internal European religious shifts and the outward expansion of Christianity, highlighting the simultaneous emergence of multiple Christian denominations globally.

Centrality of Women in the Reformations

Hanks argues that women were integral to both the internal splintering of Christianity in Europe and its global dissemination. Traditionally, figures like Martin Luther and male Jesuits have dominated historical accounts. However, recent research over the past several decades reveals that women actively participated and influenced these processes.

“But the more that we look at it and what has happened in the last... we know that women are involved in all of these various kinds of things. And that's the story that I wanted to tell...” (04:32).

Timeframe and Context

The discussion broadens the conventional timeframe of the Reformations. While traditionally marked by Luther's 95 Theses in 1517, Hanks incorporates earlier events like the 1492 Alhambra Decree and extends the narrative into the 18th century, encompassing movements such as Methodism and the Moravians.

“I sort of end the time of the French Revolution about 1800 or so. So that includes Moravians and Methodists...” (06:42).

This expanded timeframe highlights the prolonged and evolving nature of religious reforms and migrations.

Women's Influence and Boundary-Pushing

Women navigated societal boundaries, often acting within established norms while simultaneously challenging and redefining their roles. Hanks illustrates this with the creation of the "pastor's wife" role by Katerina Van Bora, Martin Luther's wife.

“She creates this sort of new occupation, if I think about new role, which is a pastor's wife... they completely changed the societal view...” (11:22).

Hanks points out that such innovations were not only practical but also transformative in altering societal perceptions of women's roles in religious contexts.

Mystics and Visionaries

Women mystics held significant influence through their purported direct connections to the divine. Figures like Teresa of Avila exemplify how mystical experiences granted women authority and respect, allowing them to lead reforms within religious orders.

“Mystics chapter is kind of prophets and visionaries and mystics... they could have great power...” (19:37).

These women often faced scrutiny and challenges from religious authorities but remained steadfast in their spiritual missions.

Martyrs: Depth of Conviction

Martyrdom among women during the Reformations exemplifies their profound convictions. Hanks discusses how many women were willing to sacrifice their lives for their beliefs, highlighting their unwavering dedication.

“They are so convinced that their view of things is absolutely correct... they were martyred for their faith...” (29:29).

This unwavering stance underscores the intense personal and communal stakes involved in religious disputes of the time.

Missionaries: Bridging Cultures

Women missionaries played crucial roles in bridging European Christianity with indigenous cultures worldwide. Their efforts included translating languages, establishing convents, and facilitating cultural exchanges, often facing immense challenges in foreign lands.

“They serve as translators and kind of go betweens and emissaries...” (32:16).

Hanks highlights stories like that of Louisa de Cariel, a Spanish missionary in England, who not only sought to convert others but also navigated linguistic and cultural barriers to sustain her mission.

Notable Women in Reformation History

Several women stand out for their extraordinary contributions:

• Catherine Van Bora: Martin Luther's wife, who redefined the role of women in Protestant households.

  “They created this completely new social role... not the edges.” (06:42).

• Isabel of Castile: One of the first monarchs to issue edicts of religious toleration.

  “What's her actual credit, but I try to focus on her...” (09:28).

• Teresa of Avila: A mystic who reformed the Carmelite order and established the Discalced Carmelites.

  “She forms a separate branch... whose visions were at least not demonic.” (19:37).

• Louisa de Cariel: A missionary who worked tirelessly to convert English Catholics back to Catholicism, ultimately sacrificing her health for her mission.

  “She really wanted to die for the faith...” (32:16).

Common Themes and Lessons

Hanks identifies several recurring themes among these women:

• Resilience Against Misogyny: Despite patriarchal structures, these women persisted and established enduring legacies.

  “Never bet against misogyny... it's a moment of resurgent patriarchy...” (40:19).

• Institutional Legacy: Many religious orders founded or influenced by women continue to thrive today, reflecting their lasting impact.

  “There’s a direct institutional legacy... Ursulines still exist today.” (40:19).

• Redefining Roles: Women often redefined their societal roles, such as the pastor's wife, elevating their status and responsibilities within the religious community.

Conclusion: Lessons from History

Mary Wiesner Hanks underscores the importance of recognizing and learning from the formidable roles women played during the Reformations. Their actions not only shaped religious landscapes but also laid foundations for future generations.

“They would probably be disappointed... they were in some cases, in prison and certainly directly criticized...” (40:27).

Hanks calls for a continued acknowledgment of these women's contributions, advocating for a more inclusive historical narrative that honors their extraordinary legacies.

Final Thoughts

This episode serves as a compelling reminder of the indispensable roles women have played in shaping religious and cultural transformations. Mary Wiesner Hanks' research illuminates these hidden narratives, offering a richer, more nuanced understanding of the Reformations' global impact.

Thank you for listening to the History Extra podcast. For more insights into history's untold stories, subscribe and explore our extensive library of episodes.