Hit Parade | Music History and Music Trivia Episode: Mighty Real Edition Part 2 Release Date: June 27, 2025

Host: Chris Molanphy, Slate Podcasts

Overview

In "Mighty Real Edition Part 2," Chris Molanphy delves into the intricate history of LGBTQ artists who have achieved number one hits on the Billboard Hot 100 and Billboard 200 charts. The episode examines the barriers these artists faced regarding their public personas and sexual identities, spanning from the rock era's inception to the modern-day music landscape.

LGBTQ Artists and Number One Singles

David Bowie: The Ambiguous Icon

• Timeline: Early 1970s to early 2000s
• Key Points:
  • Bowie publicly identified as gay in 1972 but later nuanced his sexual identity.
  • Achieved Hot 100 number ones with "Fame" (1975) and "Let's Dance."
  • Despite his declarations, Bowie in later interviews distanced himself from being openly bisexual.
  • Notable Quote:
    • Bowie on sex identity nuance: “[...] I used that fact very well. I suppose it's the best thing that ever happened to me.” ([03:58])
    • Later retracting: “I was always a closet heterosexual.” ([06:39])

Freddie Mercury: Hidden Persona Behind Queen’s Success

• Timeline: 1970s to early 1990s
• Key Points:
  • Mercury hinted at his sexuality but remained largely private during Queen's rise.
  • Queen's "The Game" (1980) and hits like "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" and "Another One Bites the Dust" reached number one.
  • Posthumous recognition of his influence on LGBTQ visibility.
  • Notable Quote:
    • Reflecting on “Bohemian Rhapsody”: “Tomorrow, it was received by the public as a final eulogy for a rock frontman who gave plenty of hints through his art but struggled just the same.” ([12:42])

Barry Manilow and Debbie Harry: Late Revelations

• Timeline: 1970s to 2010s
• Key Points:
  • Manilow achieved number one hits in the 70s but came out publicly in the mid-2010s.
  • Debbie Harry of Blondie had number one hits but disclosed her bisexuality decades after chart success.
  • Both faced societal pressures to remain closeted during their peak fame.

Boy George and Neil Tennant: Embracing Queer Identities

• Timeline: 1980s to 1990s
• Key Points:
  • Boy George openly embraced his sexual identity during Culture Club’s peak, culminating in a number one hit with "Karma Chameleon" (1984).
  • Neil Tennant of Pet Shop Boys hinted at his orientation through lyrical content before officially coming out in 1994.

Right Said Fred and Elton John: Partial Triumphs and Continued Struggles

• Timeline: Early 1990s to late 1990s
• Key Points:
  • Right Said Fred’s "I'm Too Sexy" (1992) featured openly bisexual themes.
  • Elton John experienced a decline in album chart performance post-coming out but remained a significant cultural figure.

Transition to Number One Albums

Challenges in Achieving Number One Albums While Out

• Key Points:
  • Prior to the 2010s, no LGBTQ artists had topped the Billboard 200 while openly out.
  • Artists like Melissa Etheridge and K.D. Lang achieved commercial success without reaching number one, highlighting the industry's hesitance.

Elton John’s Cautionary Tale

• Timeline: 1970s to 1990s
• Key Points:
  • Signed consecutive number one albums from "Honky Château" (1972) to "Rock of the Westies" (1975).
  • Coming out as bisexual in 1976 led to a significant drop in album chart performance.
  • Final number one album before full acceptance: "A Single Man" (2003) posthumously, but largely seen as a partial credit.

Adam Lambert: Breaking New Ground

• Timeline: 2010s
• Key Points:
  • Launched solo career with "For Your Entertainment" (2010), reaching number three.
  • Pivotal Moment: "Trespassing" (2012) debuted at number one, marking the first unquestionably out gay artist to achieve this milestone.
  • Collaborated with Queen as a replacement for Freddie Mercury, solidifying his status in both mainstream and LGBTQ communities.
  • Notable Quote:
    • Reflecting on being out: “I'd play a song that would never ever end.” ([62:30])

Modern Era: Embracing Diversity and Visibility

Recent Chart-Topping LGBTQ Artists

• Key Points:
  • Pentatonix, Frank Ocean, Halsey, Tyler the Creator, Sam Smith, Lil Nas X, Steve Lacy, and Kim Petras have achieved number one album and single statuses while openly embracing their queer identities.
  • Lil Nas X's "Montero (Call Me by Your Name)" and "Industry Baby" exemplify bold queer themes in mainstream music.
  • Sam Smith and Kim Petras's "Unholy" marked the first number one by both a gender non-binary and a trans artist.

Generational Shifts and Acceptance

• Key Points:
  • The zillennial generation's openness has fostered a more inclusive music environment.
  • Artists like Billie Eilish and Chapel Roan continue to push boundaries, reflecting the upward trajectory of LGBTQ representation.
  • Notable Performance: Chapel Roan's set with Elton John at the 2025 Sir Elton John's AIDS Foundation Academy Award party symbolized intergenerational support and pride within the community.
  • Notable Quote from Chapel Roan:
    • “I just like to say thank you Elton. You have sacrificed so much for the queer community and you made it so I could be the artist I could be.” ([62:30])

Conclusion: A Rainbow Arc of Progress

Chris Molanphy underscores the significant, albeit gradual, progress in LGBTQ representation within the highest echelons of the music industry. From the ambiguous declarations of early icons like David Bowie and Freddie Mercury to the unabashed visibility of contemporary stars like Sam Smith and Lil Nas X, the arc of LGBTQ history in music charts reflects broader societal changes. Despite facing ongoing challenges, particularly for trans artists, the upward trend of queer representation instills hope for a more inclusive future.

Final Thoughts:

• Notable Quote:
  • “It gives me reason to hope.” ([62:30])

Notable Quotes from Artists

• David Bowie ([03:58]): “I suppose it's the best thing that ever happened to me.”
• Freddie Mercury ([12:42]): “Tomorrow, it was received by the public as a final eulogy for a rock frontman who gave plenty of hints through his art but struggled just the same.”
• Chapel Roan ([62:30]): “I would just like to say thank you Elton. You have sacrificed so much for the queer community and you made it so I could be the artist I could be.”

Looking Ahead

The episode promises to continue exploring the challenges and triumphs of LGBTQ artists in achieving top chart positions, particularly focusing on album success in future installments.

Subscribe for More:
For those interested in delving deeper, subscribing to Slate Plus offers early-access episodes, bonus content, and ad-free listening. Visit slate.com/hitparadeplus to subscribe on your preferred platform.