Still Billy Joel to Me Edition

Summary

---

Hit Parade | "Still Billy Joel to Me Edition"

Host: Chris Molanphy
Date: April 30, 2020

---

Episode Overview

This episode of Hit Parade explores the musical evolution and surprising chart success of Billy Joel—focusing on how, in 1980, he broke out of his established "Piano Man" persona to embrace new genres and styles that sent him to the top of the Billboard charts. Host Chris Molanphy dives into the period when Joel downplayed his signature piano sound and experimented freely, asking: What really makes a Billy Joel hit, and how did he keep reinventing himself while dominating the pop charts?

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Context: Billy Joel’s 1980 Reinvention

• Forty years ago in April 1980, Billy Joel, already a well-established artist, re-entered the top 10 with music that sounded dramatically different from his earlier work (01:27).
• Joel's 1980 singles, including "You May Be Right" and "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me," featured rock and guitar-forward sounds rather than his trademark piano style (01:57).

Shattering the "Piano Man" Myth

• Despite his nickname, piano was not always the center of Joel's hits. Even "Piano Man" itself was not as huge a Billboard hit upon release as fans might think (02:30).
• Molanphy highlights that Joel is more accurately a musical chameleon—"the pastiche man"—who adopts styles and genres as needed to keep his music fresh (03:10).

Chris Molanphy (03:28):
“The truth is, Billy Joel never really was the Piano Man. Not entirely anyway. Some of his most famous piano standards weren’t actually Billboard chart hits in their day. And even on the massive Grammy winning smashes, keyboards were just one tool in Joel’s bag of tricks.”

Chart Success Through Reinvention

• Joel’s experimentation reached a peak with the album Glass Houses, which featured harder-edged rock tracks and marked the zenith of his chart power (04:00).
• “[Billy Joel] tried on genres, styles and even voices like they were clothing. Sometimes he didn’t need any instruments besides the human voice.” (03:50)

The Big Moment: "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me"

• The episode zeroes in on the week ending July 19, 1980, when "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me" became his first number one on the Hot 100 (05:28).
• At the same time, the album Glass Houses was in the midst of a six-week run atop the Billboard album chart (05:35).
• Joel cleverly pokes fun at his own musical anxieties and the pop landscape in the self-aware lyrics of the song.

Chris Molanphy (06:05):
“He even poked fun at his own stylistic insecurities right in the lyrics of a hit.”

Enduring Legacy and Perceptions

• To younger generations, Joel is often associated with “that apocalyptic history lesson song with too many words”—a reference to “We Didn’t Start the Fire” (04:20).
• Molanphy asks: Was there ever a singular Billy Joel sound, and did it really matter, given his astonishing hit-making ability?

Chart Factoid & Trivia Asides

• Joel’s genre experimentation—including forays into new wave, dance crazes, and more—helped sustain his popularity in a fast-changing musical era (06:35).
• The concept of "exit velocity": Molanphy describes the exact moment when Joel’s career blasted beyond his original image (04:55).

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Chris Molanphy on Joel’s Versatility (03:45):
  “Forget Piano Man. Joel was the pastiche man by the Eighties, when he was at the peak of his hit generating powers.”
• Chris Molanphy on Joel’s Approach to Hits (06:38):
  “He was trying on genres, styles and even voices like they were clothing...Any ways to get on the radio.”

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 01:27 – Introduction to Joel’s 1980 comeback and shift in sound
• 02:04 – Analysis of “You May Be Right” and its rock sensibility
• 03:28 – Debunking the Piano Man myth
• 04:00 – Examination of the Glass Houses era and Joel’s pastiche style
• 05:28 – Chart breakthrough: “It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me” hits #1
• 06:05 – Joel’s self-aware lyricism and genre-bending approach
• 06:38 – “Next Phase, New Wave, Dance Craze, Any ways to get on the radio”

---

Summary & Takeaway

Chris Molanphy expertly recounts how Billy Joel, far from being stuck as the Piano Man, continually reinvented his musical persona. The episode spotlights Joel’s 1980 pivot to harder rock, his playful attitude towards genre, and his remarkable run on the charts—culminating in his first Hot 100 #1 with "It's Still Rock and Roll to Me." Ultimately, the episode leaves listeners with a fresh appreciation for Joel's adaptability and his lasting impact on pop music history.

Transcript

[Amazon Music Announcer]

You're listening ad free on Amazon Music.

[Chris Melaniphy]

Hey there Hit Parade listeners. What you're about to hear is a preview of our latest episode. As we announced in mid April, Slate, like many media organizations at the moment, is getting hit pretty hard by what's going on with the economy in the wake of the COVID 19 pandemic.

[Narrator]

We need your help to continue producing.

[Chris Melaniphy]

This show and all the other work we do at Slate. So we're asking you to sign up for Slate plus our membership program. It's just $35 for the first year and it will go a long way towards supporting us at this crucial moment. Sign [e-mail] hitparadeplus and you'll get to hear this and every episode of Hit Parade in full. That's slate.com hitparadeplus thanks. And now your episode preview.

[Narrator]

Welcome to Hit Parade, a podcast of.

[Chris Melaniphy]

Pop chart history from Slate Magazine about the hits from coast to coast. I'm Chris Melanfy, chart analyst, pop critic and writer of Slate's why Is this Song Number One? Series.

[Narrator]

On today's show. Forty years ago in April 1980, a well established pop star was making his comeback into the top 10 on the Billboard charts. In popular parlance, this guy was nicknamed the Piano Man. Only piano wasn't the most prominent instrument on his latest hit. It was basically a guitar rock song.

[Billy Joel (singing)]

If I'm crazy then it's true that it's all because of you and you.

[Narrator]

Wouldn'T want sure Way back in the mix on youn May Be Right, you could hear its singer and songwriter Billy Joel pounding away on the piano as usual. But not much about this song was usual for for Joel, it was snotty, snide, snarky. Not the first time he'd tried on that attitude, but the first time he'd made it the first single from a new album. In fact, every single that Billy Joel Hit machine released in 1980 downplayed the piano in 10 entirely. But while this was the most rock forward that Joel had been in his career to date, it was hardly the first time he'd tried on a new style and scored a hit with it. The truth is, Billy Joel never really was the Piano Man. Not entirely anyway. Some of his most famous piano standards weren't actually Billboard chart hits in their day. And even on the massive Grammy winning smashes, keyboards were just one tool in Joel's bag of tricks. The song, not the tinkling of the ivories, was what made Joel a hitman. Forget piano Man. Joel was the pastiche man by the 80s, when he was at the peak of his hit generating powers, he was trying on genres, styles and even voices like they were clothing. Sometimes he didn't need any instruments besides the human voice. And to a generation born after the 80s, he is now mostly known as the guy with that apocalyptic history lesson song with too many words in it. Yes, we will talk about that strange, unkillable Hot 100 number one hit and all of Joel's Billboard chart Toppers Was there ever a Billy Joel sound at all and did it matter? Because good God, all those hits. How did this guy do it? Today on Hit Parade, we are going to pinpoint the moment that Joel's career attained exit velocity from his so called Piano man Persona. The year he won the top Grammy, he released an album full of rock songs where the piano was an afterthought and he was rewarded for it, topping the charts more consistently the than ever before. He even poked fun at his own stylistic insecurities right in the lyrics of a hit. And that's where your Hit Parade marches today. The week ending July 19, 1980, when it's still rock and roll to me, became Billy Joel's first number one song on the Hot one. The same week his album Glass Houses was completing a six week run on top of the Billboard album chart, Joel had established himself as one of the new decade's top pop stars and a man who would try anything the Next Phase New Wave Dance Craze Any ways to get on the radio?

[Chris Melaniphy]

Thanks for listening to this episode Preview to listen to the full Hit Parade episode, please go to slate.com hit parade plus.