Hit Parade | Music History and Music Trivia

Episode: With or Without U2 Edition Part 1
Release Date: October 11, 2024
Host: Chris Melanphy
Host Role: Chart analyst, pop critic, author of Slate’s “Why Is This Song Number One?” series

Introduction

In With or Without U2 Edition Part 1, host Chris Melanphy delves deep into the evolution of U2, exploring their rise to stardom, their musical transformations, and the cultural impact they’ve had over decades. This episode serves as a comprehensive case study of how U2 has managed to remain relevant in the ever-changing landscape of pop and rock music.

Formation and Early Days of U2

Chris begins by tracing the origins of U2 back to their formation in Dublin in 1976. The band initially went by the name Feedback, featuring drummer Larry Mullen Jr., bassist Adam Clayton, guitarist David Evans (later known as The Edge), and vocalist Bono (born Paul Hewson).

• Formation Anecdote: Larry Mullen Jr. posted a notice seeking bandmates, leading to the assembly of the group. Their early performances consisted of covers like Peter Frampton’s "Show Me the Way" and the Bay City Rollers' "Bye Bye Baby".

  Bono [22:58]: "Bye Bye Baby, Baby, Goodbye."

Despite initial struggles and changes—including a brief period as The Hype—the band settled on the name U2 after rejecting other suggestions like the Blazers or Flying Tigers, finding "U2" suitably vague and open to interpretation thanks to bassist Adam Clayton and graphic artist Steve Averill.

Breakthrough with Boy and October

U2's debut album, Boy (1980), marked their entry into the music scene with an anthemic sound that resonated more with American audiences than their UK and Irish counterparts. The single "I Will Follow" became a top 20 hit on Billboard's Top Tracks chart, signaling their potential in the U.S. market.

• Chart Performance:

  • Boy reached #63 on Billboard LP chart.
  • "I Will Follow" peaked within the Top 20 on Billboard’s Top Tracks.

  Chris Melanphy [02:22]: "From Whitney to White Snake, U2 were topping the hot 100 with searching, ethereal songs that sounded like this."

Their follow-up album, October (1981), continued their exploration of spirituality, with tracks like "Gloria" pushing the boundaries of their lyrical themes. Despite critical acclaim in the UK and Ireland, October underperformed in the American market, leading to questions about the sustainability of their initial success.

Evolution with War

With their third album, War (1983), U2 shifted from spiritual themes to more direct political commentary. Songs like "Sunday Bloody Sunday" and "New Year's Day" addressed pressing global issues, solidifying U2's image as socially conscious musicians.

• Key Tracks and Impact:

  • "New Year's Day" became their first solid global hit, reaching #2 on Rock Tracks and #53 on the Hot 100.
  • "Sunday Bloody Sunday" became an anthem against violence and war.

  Chris Melanphy [32:22]: "Released as War's first single in the winter of 1983, 'New Year's Day' became U2's first solid global hit."

The album War achieved significant success, peaking at #12 on the Billboard album chart and earning gold status by mid-1983. U2's live performances, particularly at venues like Red Rocks Amphitheater, further cemented their reputation as powerful live entertainers.

Transition with The Unforgettable Fire

In 1984, U2 collaborated with renowned producer Brian Eno to create The Unforgettable Fire, an album that introduced a more ambient and atmospheric sound. This marked a significant departure from their earlier, more direct styles.

• Innovative Sound:

  • Emphasized ethereal tones and experimental sounds.
  • Featured "Pride (In the Name of Love)", a tribute to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., which became one of their most beloved anthems.

  Chris Melanphy [32:28]: "Ironically, this ethereal, heady album gave U2 their first US top 40 hit, a song Bono wrote about American civil rights hero Dr. Martin Luther King Jr."

Despite initial skepticism from some critics, The Unforgettable Fire achieved critical acclaim and commercial success, peaking at #12 on the Billboard album chart and producing multiple hits on rock radio.

Live Aid and Rattle and Hum

U2's performance at Live Aid in 1985 is a pivotal moment discussed extensively in the episode. Intended to be a brief set, Bono’s extended and improvisational performance of "Bad" became legendary, transforming U2’s image on the global stage.

• Live Aid Performance Highlights:

  • Initially planned to perform three songs but reduced to two.
  • Bono's 12-minute rendition of "Bad" included spontaneous mashups with songs like Lou Reed's "Satellite of Love" and The Rolling Stones' "Ruby Tuesday".

  Bono [42:28]: "Thank you, God bless you."

The performance, though self-indulgent and perceived as a disaster by the band, was hailed by critics as a career-defining moment that expanded U2's fanbase and solidified their status as global superstars.

Following Live Aid, U2 released Rattle and Hum (1988), a double album and film that blended live performances with studio tracks, paying homage to American roots music.

• Album Highlights:

  • "Desire" reached #3 on the Hot 100.
  • Duet with B.B. King on "When Love Comes to Town".
  • "Angel of Harlem" reached #14 on the pop chart.

  Chris Melanphy [55:20]: "Rattle and Hum reached number one on the album chart in November of 1988 and stayed there for six weeks."

While the album achieved commercial success, it received mixed reviews, with some critics praising the new material and others criticizing the band's perceived self-importance.

The Joshua Tree and Continued Success

The episode concludes with a discussion of The Joshua Tree (1987), arguably U2’s most successful album. Inspired by American folk, blues, and country music, the album juxtaposed these influences with U2’s signature atmospheric rock sound.

• Key Tracks:

  • "With or Without You" topped the Hot 100 in May 1987.
  • "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" also reached #1 on the Hot 100.
  • "Where the Streets Have No Name" peaked at #13 on the Hot 100.

  Chris Melanphy [49:18]: "'With or Without You' was a mood. The Edge filtered his playing through a device called the infinite guitar that gave his notes a chiming sustain."

The Joshua Tree achieved critical acclaim and commercial success, debuting at #7 and eventually reaching #1 on the American chart, solidifying U2's legacy as one of the world's biggest bands.

Conclusion and Teaser for Part 2

Chris Melanphy wraps up Part 1 by highlighting U2's unique ability to maintain relevance through constant evolution, contrasting them with other long-standing rock bands. He teases Part 2, which will cover U2’s reinvention in the 1990s, their engagement with irony and new technologies, and their continued chart success.

Chris Melanphy [62:50]: "Keep on marching on the one. I'm Chris Melanphy."

Notable Quotes from the Episode

• Chris Melanphy [00:22]: "What makes a song a smash? Talent? Luck? Timing? All that—and more."

• Bono [02:22]: "One man he resists, one man watched on an empty beast."

• Chris Melanphy [14:32]: "All I have to say to the haters is this. U2's hit making career is pretty unique."

• Bono [22:58]: "Bye Bye Baby, Baby, Goodbye."

• Chris Melanphy [49:18]: "'With or Without You' topped the Hot 100 in May of 87, less than a month after The Joshua Tree topped the album chart for the follow up."

Conclusion

With or Without U2 Edition Part 1 offers an in-depth exploration of U2's ascent in the music world, their strategic pivots in sound and image, and the pivotal moments that defined their legacy. From their early days in Dublin to their monumental success with The Joshua Tree, Chris Melanphy provides a nuanced analysis of how U2 managed to captivate audiences and maintain their status as music icons. Stay tuned for Part 2, where the journey of U2 continues.

Subscribe to Slate Plus to enjoy full access to Hit Parade and other exclusive content: slate.com/hitparadeplus