
Jonathan Taylor Thomas and Martin Landau star in the 1996 fantasy adventure film The Adventures of Pinocchio. LIVE from Chicago, Paul, June, and Jason discuss the donkey transformations, Pepe the Cricket, Geppetto and Pinocchio getting in a bathtub, and so much more. Plus, Paul drops a new childhood story involving his Grandma and an evil butcher. (Ep. #232 Originally Released 01/30/2020)
Loading summary
Paul Scheer
America's best network just got bigger.
Jason Mantzoukas
Switch to T Mobile today and get
Paul Scheer
built in benefits the other guys leave out plus our five year price guarantee and now T Mobile is available in US Cellular stores. Best mobile network based on analysis by Google of speed test intelligence data 2H 2025 bigger network the combination of T Mobile's and US cellular network footprints will enhance the T Mobile network's coverage price guarantee on talk text and data exclusions like taxes and fees apply. See t mobile.com for details. Adobe Acrobat your new foundation. Use PDF spaces to generate a presentation. Grab your docs, your permits, your moves, AI levels up your pitch gets it in a groove.
Jason Mantzoukas
Choose a template with your timeless cool.
Paul Scheer
Come on now let's flex those two draft design deliver make it sing AI builds the deck so you can build that thing do that, do that, do that with Acrobat. Learn more@adobe.com do that with Acrobat
June Diane Raphael
Taxact knows every small business owner has different tax filing needs. With TaxAct you can file yourself with the help of an expert or taxact can do it all for you. You're the boss, the head honcho, the top banana. And TaxAct is like your loyal, trusty
Paul Scheer
tax aide, ready to pounce on any tax needs you might have.
Jason Mantzoukas
TaxAct is dying to pounce on some small business tax needs.
June Diane Raphael
TaxAct and let's get them Over With.
Paul Scheer
It's a movie where you get an accent. You get an accent.
Jason Mantzoukas
You get an accent, we all get an accent.
Paul Scheer
We saw the Adventures of Pinocchio, so you know what that means. Hey everybody. Now it's time for
Jason Mantzoukas
hdtgm.
Paul Scheer
Hey everybody.
Jason Mantzoukas
Now it's time for. Hello people of Earth and hello people of Chicago.
Paul Scheer
We are live at the Chicago Theater. Holy. This is amazing. Chicago, home of how did this get made? First you saw Hurricane Heist, you saw Blues Brothers. But we didn't torture you enough with those two films. We needed to turn it up a notch and we did with the Jonathan Taylor Thomas Martin Landau fantasy child's film
June Diane Raphael
film
Paul Scheer
JTT in full effect for the last 30 seconds of this movie. The Adventures of Pinocchio is everything that you love about the beloved classic Pinocchio, but really fucked up and weird. It's like they took all the children aspects out and replaced it with like David lynch crazy. It's going to be very hard to talk about this movie because Jiminy Cricket's not called Jiminy Cricket. Stromboli is not called Stromboli. So we may have to get around that a little bit. But to help break it down, Tonight, we have two amazing people. My two co hosts. Please welcome first Mr. Jason Mantzoukas.
Jason Mantzoukas
What's up, jerks? What's up, Chicago? How we doing? Balcony. Well, well, well. We meet again, Jason. Paul.
Paul Scheer
Have you ever seen this movie before?
Jason Mantzoukas
I have not ever seen this waking nightmare of a film. This was haunting.
Paul Scheer
It was like a diamond in the rough that no one even mentioned it. Like, in the millions of suggestions that we get for this show, no one ever said, did you know there's a Jonathan Taylor Thomas Pinocchio movie?
Jason Mantzoukas
Never heard that you would characterize this as a Jonathan Taylor Thomas movie. This is a Martin Landau vehicle, friend. This is part of the Landau essence as far as I'm concerned.
Paul Scheer
We can agree to disagree. I mean, JTT is getting top billing
Jason Mantzoukas
in this and he's in it for barely minutes, but his voice.
Paul Scheer
His voice is in it the entire film. Oh, so good.
Jason Mantzoukas
This was straight up garbage. This was like. This was. It reminded me of another terrible. All of the cg, all of the effects look like previs.
Paul Scheer
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
They look like the big. Like the idea of what we were gonna draw. But then they're like, fuck it, put it in.
June Diane Raphael
We're in.
Jason Mantzoukas
We're in.
Paul Scheer
It is a disturbing movie, especially as a father going, if I was ever tricked into taking a child to this, I am creating trauma for my children.
Jason Mantzoukas
It was also, like, overtly sexual in any and all ways. Every time that nose grew, I was like, somebody in this room is turned on. There wasn't me.
Paul Scheer
Way too many mouths open with water jutting into it, too.
Jason Mantzoukas
That was like, slowed down and they were like, getting a gulp.
Paul Scheer
Pinocchio meets Flashdance. Well, I know that someone here is gonna have a very strong opinion about this film. She is my other co host. Please welcome June. Diane Raphael. How are you, June?
June Diane Raphael
I'm doing okay. How are you?
Paul Scheer
I'm fine, thank you for asking. June. We watched the Adventures of Pinocchio together today.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. And let me just say set the scene because we're staying in a very nice hotel. I love a luxury hotel experience, but
Jason Mantzoukas
let's not tell anyone.
June Diane Raphael
I'm not going to say where it is. I'm feeling. It's a Sheraton.
Paul Scheer
Four points. Get used to it. If you're in Naperville, come knock on our door.
June Diane Raphael
I'm just going to say it's a very. It's a luxury experience.
Jason Mantzoukas
Sure.
Paul Scheer
It's between a subway and a Domino's. And it's totally cool if you send it up. To the room.
June Diane Raphael
And I love that experience so much that I'm willing, I'm willing and able to watch whatever comes my way. I mean, you saw when you came back last night what I was watching.
Paul Scheer
Yes. We were watching Chicago Live. The replay. It's at night.
June Diane Raphael
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
So it's a replay of what is a live morning show?
June Diane Raphael
I think so. And it was still.
Jason Mantzoukas
And it's still called Chicago Live, even though it's the replay.
June Diane Raphael
But I can fall into whatever the TV has to offer me happily.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, if I'm in a hotel, Guy Fieri is on. I mean, Triple D, baby. But if I'm at home, if I'm at home and Guy Fieri comes across the screen, I'm like, this fucking guy. Get him out of here. But in a hotel, I'm like, this is the best thing I've ever seen.
June Diane Raphael
Absolutely. I'm just happy to be there, happy to have been invited to the experience.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah.
June Diane Raphael
And so for me to have such a negative reaction to a movie during a luxury hotel experience means it's really quite, quite bad.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah. Like, would you rather watch this movie again or have 1 hour and 45 minutes of diarrhea? Like, isn't that's the life story?
June Diane Raphael
There was no way the movie was an hour and 45 minutes. This was a five hour movie.
Paul Scheer
96 minutes. That felt longer.
Jason Mantzoukas
It has to be longer. 96 minutes.
Paul Scheer
It felt like longer than Endgame and Infinity War put together.
Jason Mantzoukas
I'd watched, I'll say this, I watched the whole movie. Then I clicked on it to see how far it had progressed. 22 minutes. I was like, that can't be right. I've watched all of Gepetto's nightmares now.
Paul Scheer
It was a tricky 96 minutes.
Jason Mantzoukas
Now, I, I, I don't remember. I guess the story of Pinocchio was Pedro the Cricket part of it.
Paul Scheer
Jiminy the Cricket.
June Diane Raphael
That's what Paul and I thought. We turned to each other and said, wasn't it Jiminy Cricket?
Jason Mantzoukas
Jiminy Cricket. Though my belief is the Pinocchio story must be public domain. Anybody can tell it. But my guess is Jiminy Cricket was a Disney creation.
Paul Scheer
Well, I think the idea of a cricket that has the moral compass for Pinocchio is true. And I think then Disney may have labeled him as Jiminy and that was it. Because also all the characters in the classic Pinocchio tale, I mean, there's a lot of differences. I think this is more based on the book.
June Diane Raphael
Okay, so the book Pinocchio. Well, yes, the book Pinocchio. I Mean, I remember reading Pinocchio and I. I don't think that's what I saw. I mean, this is not the story that I remember and see the title now. It did make a little more sense that this is just one of the many adventures of Pinocchio.
Jason Mantzoukas
No, this is June. This is all the adventures.
June Diane Raphael
This is one of many.
Jason Mantzoukas
Because he's one of many. Pinocchio. He is made a child slave turned into a donkey. He is his part of the, the. The show. He is the lead of the musical performance. He is swallowed by a sea monster.
Paul Scheer
Well, who was a man?
Jason Mantzoukas
Who was a man? Like, I think these are in fact all of the adventures.
Paul Scheer
This is like, there isn't another Pinocchio story. Or is there? Because there was a sequel to this film. The sequel was released three years later. It was called the New Adventures of Pinocchio.
Jason Mantzoukas
Please tell me he comes to contemporaries Earth.
Paul Scheer
Martin Landau did reprise his role.
Jason Mantzoukas
Wow.
Paul Scheer
And Udo Kerr came back not as Lorenzini, but as Lorenzini's wife, Madame Flambeau. So he went a different direction. And then Gabrielle Thompson played the title role replacing JTT. By the way, June, this is 96. Were you a JTT head?
June Diane Raphael
See, I was 16. I was a little too old to be a full JTT head.
Paul Scheer
Got it.
June Diane Raphael
I mean, I remember knowing of him and seeing him in, in the, you know, on the rags, but I did.
Paul Scheer
Was he getting a lot of gossip
Jason Mantzoukas
rag on the rags?
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, he was.
Jason Mantzoukas
When you were having your period, you
June Diane Raphael
would see you were gonna say that
Jason Mantzoukas
Jonathan Taylor Thomas, like, oh, no, my Aunt Flo's visiting. Guess I'm gonna see JTT's face everywhere. I only seem to see it when I'm on the rags.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, I was like a few years too old for him, but not me.
Jason Mantzoukas
I loved him.
June Diane Raphael
The problem with the puppet though, of JTT Pinocchio was he looked nothing like Jonathan Taylor Thomas at the end.
Jason Mantzoukas
He looked much younger than Jonathan Taylor Thomas. When Pinocchio the.
June Diane Raphael
The man by about 10 years, he
Jason Mantzoukas
looks like a, I don't know, 6 year old boy, something in there. And Jonathan Taylor Thomas appears to be 12 when he transforms into a human boy.
Paul Scheer
Well, I mean, at the end of the movie, you think, you know, he's gonna be asking for like a sister, but he's like, get me a girlfriend, Dad. I want to fuck some wood dolls now. Get some dick splinters.
Jason Mantzoukas
So here's my question. Here's my question. Just because you brought it up, this is my genuine question. He's now A real boy. He's been transformed into a living boy played by Jonathan Taylor Thomas. Why not try and get a girlfriend amongst the living? Why have Geppetto carve a wooden girlfriend? You then will have to find a magical way to bring that marionette to. Do you know the odds of twice transforming? Or he's just gonna.
Paul Scheer
That.
Jason Mantzoukas
That wooden.
June Diane Raphael
So. But this is what is so weird about the movie. I mean, I asked the very same question when Pinocchio is trying to save other puppets in the theater scene, because it's as though he's saving his friends and. And actual people. And I did not know if. I mean, is the premise of this movie that every puppet has the potential to.
Jason Mantzoukas
I don't think so.
Paul Scheer
I was doing some thinking about this, too, June. Because you said you were. Yes, because when June said we were watching it and Pepe, Jiminy Cricket says, go save your brothers and sisters. They never come to life, but they're treated like when two of them are left on the ground for dead. Like, oh, he left them for dead. But then I remember in the beginning of the movie, Martin Landau and his great attention accent says, meet your brothers and sisters. And so I think it was sort of like a little bit of like a flour sack baby scenario for Pepe was sort of like, hey, if you want to be a responsible real boy, you gotta care about people. And that was his first challenge, huh? Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
Maybe I don't get what I get.
Paul Scheer
I mean, I get it.
Jason Mantzoukas
What I thought was, I think all the other marionettes are just that marionettes. Because the Pinocchio marionette was carved from the tree that had the heart carved into it. That was the magic that allowed for him to have infused in him the love of Geppetto and Leona.
Paul Scheer
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
That their love is the bit of magic that allowed him to come. But no, no, no, no.
Paul Scheer
I just want to pull this back because I want to get to your saying, but that's a problematic thing.
Jason Mantzoukas
Hashtag problematic.
Paul Scheer
Because Geppetto was in love with the woman who married his brother. Didn't seem like she was in love with him or knew about it till he was rowing off the seas.
Jason Mantzoukas
Like, by the way, I fucking love you also.
Paul Scheer
And you're like, I don't have time for this.
Jason Mantzoukas
Also, this is. Do you have access to the movie right there?
Paul Scheer
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
Can you, while I set this up, go to the very last beat of Geppetto. After Pinocchio runs away, we have a shot of just Geppetto and Leona, and it's now they are in love, they live happily ever after. And she looks miserable.
Paul Scheer
And there you have it. Geppetto and Leona lived happily ever after.
Jason Mantzoukas
They lived happily ever after. He touches her shoulder. She recoils.
June Diane Raphael
Yes, she looks like she is not there at her own will.
Jason Mantzoukas
She does. She. It literally looks like she's being held prisoner by the puppet maker.
Paul Scheer
She expected him, and rightly so, to die at sea. And she didn't want to be like, I never loved you in that moment, because she thought that would be too harsh. And now she's, what a. You know, what a wicked web we weave when we try to deceive. Am I right?
Jason Mantzoukas
What if we reversed around this right now? What if in this shot we reversed all the way around and saw what they were looking at and it was just the. The. The Pinocchio marionette lying on the ground and the whole thing was Martin Landau's crazy. His. He. He was insane. And everyone is humoring him.
June Diane Raphael
Did anyone else think that the magic. That Pinocchio might be the spirit of Geppetto's brother?
Paul Scheer
Oh, hold on. What now?
Jason Mantzoukas
How so?
June Diane Raphael
I think there's a world in which, because the magic of the movie is so strange, I don't know if he's their child. Did Leona and Geppetto's brother have any children?
Jason Mantzoukas
Doesn't seem like it.
Paul Scheer
No, it doesn't seem like they. Like, the brother was a really interesting add on because it felt like it was always an unrequited love. And then at a certain point, it's revealed, oh, that was a Leona. And he was married. She was married to my brother.
Jason Mantzoukas
Well, what was interesting is when we. We in the beginning scene is when they're carving the tree. Carving. He's carving the initials in the tree. And they're young. And then it cuts to, like they say, a few years later, but it's. Martin Landau is an old man.
Paul Scheer
Yeah.
June Diane Raphael
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
By the way, he missed his shot, like, by a lot.
Paul Scheer
I mean, by the way, I love the opening VO in this movie because you're introduced to Geppetto through his voiceover, which just sounds like an old man, like, ordering a bagel. I just gimme. And the poppy seeds and, And. And tomatoes. Not too much. It's like yelling at you. Am I.
Jason Mantzoukas
Might as well be Richard kind narrating this movie. I don't know what.
Paul Scheer
What is going on with.
Jason Mantzoukas
All right, so I'm a baker. I'm carving my initials in a tree.
June Diane Raphael
I always thought the story of Pinocchio was that Geppetto wanted a Child, I don't believe that.
Jason Mantzoukas
I don't think the legend of Pinocchio has as its root like an enchanted log.
Paul Scheer
No, I mean, the whole idea. Well, this is the issue they have. He's in love with Leona, so the love becomes enchanted. So his love.
Jason Mantzoukas
The lightning strikes it, too, I think.
Paul Scheer
Right. So his love then gets him a boy. It's like, oh, I would love to be in love. You got a son, huh? Okay, I get. I mean, yeah, it's. It's sort of like I'm in kind of the right place. I got the lift, left me in the general area. I got to walk a little bit further to get to where I want to go. But, like, it's a weird. It's a weird thing that he gets a boy because he's in love. Not.
June Diane Raphael
I wonder, though, in making this movie, they were. You know, because it was live action, they felt it was too creepy to have a man of Landau's age just want a little boy.
Jason Mantzoukas
I have.
Paul Scheer
You think he avoided creepy stuff?
Jason Mantzoukas
Like, I have an update. They did not succeed. This was straight up erotic.
Paul Scheer
The first moments that Pinocchio comes to life when. And I'll say it the Italian way, when Pinocchio comes to life, he immediately gets into a bathtub with Martin Landau.
Jason Mantzoukas
Martin Landau is wearing clothes in the bath. Fucking Italians.
Paul Scheer
I literally thought that Martin Lando was like, I can't be naked, and a little boy gets in the bathtub. Like, I can't.
Jason Mantzoukas
Because the little boy puppet is also naked. He's not wearing anything at that point. Right? Yes, but I don't mean Jonathan Taylor Thomas is doing that on set.
June Diane Raphael
No, And I don't think that the little boy. I don't think Pinocchio was Carved genitalia.
Paul Scheer
No.
Jason Mantzoukas
We don't know.
Paul Scheer
And that's kind of what the sequel gets into.
June Diane Raphael
Now, listen, Did I cry during the courtroom scene when they ripped Pinocchio away? I did, June. I did sob.
Paul Scheer
Not cried. Sobbed.
Jason Mantzoukas
Whoa, whoa.
Paul Scheer
Yeah, you sobbed that. The evil puppet owner. The court decides. Evil puppet owner. You get this kid. And then the evil puppet guy's like, come with me, son. Now he's his son.
Jason Mantzoukas
And then later, Pinocchio is like, well, Lorenzini is my papa now. I was like, oh, this poor kid is literally being human trafficked.
June Diane Raphael
Yes.
Jason Mantzoukas
Between people in the same town. His father is, like, five blocks away, and he's in the theater. Like, guess I live here now. I'm the star of the show. But what about my papa? He's literally over there.
Paul Scheer
I will say I was impressed with how off book he was at that show. It seemed like he was given away in court in the afternoon, and by nighttime he was ready to go. He had all the lyrics, by the way.
Jason Mantzoukas
Not a bad gig. He's the star of the show. Everybody. He's improvising. Everybody thinks he's hilarious. He's getting paid in gold coins. Like, not too bad for a kid who was born, like, a month ago, speaking fluent English.
June Diane Raphael
It's so crazy, though, that this evil guy is involved in children's theater.
Paul Scheer
When they cut to that audience at night, it's all. It's children. And what is he doing with these children? Because. Because he's entertaining them there. But then he also has a side gig where he's turning kids into donkeys.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah.
Paul Scheer
Like, merge the two. Like, why don't you put the theater and the donkey thing together? You gotta run two separate businesses.
June Diane Raphael
But why does he. Why does he want to turn little boys into donkeys? Why?
Paul Scheer
We don't know.
Jason Mantzoukas
I think he's trying to get that ass. Sorry, it's. It's not. It's not very good wordplay. Not very good wordplay. The whole booze. Booze from Chicago. Fair enough. I couldn't figure out. I couldn't figure out if that's because he was, like, selling them as, like, work animals or. I don't. I literally was like. I don't know what this is.
June Diane Raphael
Like, he. I mean, if you just look at them as his customers, like, why. It just, from a business perspective, didn't make. Makes sense.
Jason Mantzoukas
I thought they were being sent to, like, work in the mines or something, and then they all turned into donkeys, and I was like. Or then. No, no, what it is. I'm sorry, is anybody gets turned into whatever they're acting like. So they happen to be acting like jackasses turned into jackasses.
Paul Scheer
I mean, that is in the Disney cartoon. They all turn into jackasses in the Disney cartoon, too, but they.
Jason Mantzoukas
Rod Schneider and that woman got turned into a fox and a cat.
Paul Scheer
Oh, wait.
Jason Mantzoukas
Right.
Paul Scheer
And yet he got turned into, like, a human whale.
Jason Mantzoukas
So they get turned into what they are. A monster. But. So I couldn't figure out.
Paul Scheer
Here, let's listen to.
Jason Mantzoukas
Why does this happen?
Paul Scheer
Let's listen to what Vinzini says here.
Jason Mantzoukas
Act like a jackass if you have the nerve. Drink up the water. Get what you deserve. Be you wicked. Be naughty. Come drink from my fountain. Then I will be rich. Oh, yeah.
Paul Scheer
So he's. He just happens to have A magic fountain that turns people into animals, but we don't know why.
Jason Mantzoukas
Is that in the book?
Paul Scheer
I know that Pleasure Island. They. They go there and they turn into jackasses.
Jason Mantzoukas
Do you want to tell us very quickly what the deal is? What are we missing?
Paul Scheer
Hold on, let me get.
Jason Mantzoukas
Is there a librarian in the house?
Paul Scheer
How many librarians are in here?
Jason Mantzoukas
Wait a second.
Paul Scheer
All right, you can come.
Jason Mantzoukas
Can I get minor house lights up for a second? I do want to hear this. Okay, that's great. I'm going to ask you in a sec.
Paul Scheer
Yes. Hi. How are you?
June Diane Raphael
Good. I'm not a librarian, but I love books. So in the original Pinocchio, it's real fucked up.
Paul Scheer
So this is accurate.
June Diane Raphael
They turned them into donkeys to kill them and sell them for skin. And the cat and the fox show up a lot to fuck with Pinocchio. I know one time they take him to a tavern and they have him spend all this money for food. And then they rob him and string him up, hang him. And then they encounter him again and they like convince him to bury a bunch of money in a field. And I think then they run up again.
Paul Scheer
Well, that happened in this movie.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, yeah. And throughout the. They keep popping up and like throughout the book. And then I know where they turned into.
Paul Scheer
For the skins.
Jason Mantzoukas
For the skins then they would be skinned.
June Diane Raphael
Oh, so they're turned into. Anything that can turn into skin? No, no, no. They were turned into donkeys for the donkey skin to be made into like drums or something.
Paul Scheer
Okay, so they were.
Jason Mantzoukas
They would.
Paul Scheer
So there was a big drum market.
Jason Mantzoukas
Very quickly. If you're a librarian, will you please stand up?
June Diane Raphael
Wow, that's a decent number.
Jason Mantzoukas
All right. Okay. All right. Oh wow. Look it up there. Lice. This is. These are heroes.
Paul Scheer
We love our librarians. All right, so if donkeys are being
Jason Mantzoukas
turned into snakes, who wants to fight a librarian? You see where they are? Get em. So we're on a. This tour is just subtly so we can go to cities and wipe out all the librarians.
Paul Scheer
We find them and we take them out.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, they'll be at. How did this get made? They'll be easy picking. How did this get made?
Paul Scheer
America's best network just got bigger.
Jason Mantzoukas
Switch to T mobile today and get
Paul Scheer
built in benefits the other guys leave out. Plus our five year price guarantee. And now T mobile is available in US Cellular stores. Best mobile network based on analysis by Oogle of speed test intelligence data 2H 2025 bigger network. The combination of T Mobile's and US cellular network footprints will enhance the T Mobile Network's coverage price guarantee on talk text and data exclusions like taxes and fees apply. See t mobile.com for details from. Premieres April 19th on MGM. In a small, inescapable town, understanding the monsters may be the only way out. Desperate hope may lead residents toward even darker truths. I think they're doing it to make us afraid.
June Diane Raphael
Well, then it worked.
Paul Scheer
Something ancient is feeding off of their suffering, and it won't stop. Survival will demand impossible choices. From season four. Premieres April 19th on MGM. I wrote a little song to remind you. Choice hotels get you more of the experiences you value. Mm. The Cambria Hotel's got it all. A rooftop bar. Have a ball. Cocktails up here. Feel just right. Ms. Cambria.
Jason Mantzoukas
Amazing.
Paul Scheer
All right. Bring a date, your team, or even your mom. Book direct@ChoiceHotels.com. see you on the roof.
Jason Mantzoukas
All right.
Paul Scheer
So that description is disturbing. They are to be skinned for their skin. For their skin. They're turned into, like, drums. That's bizarre. But it does answer a big question for me because when I saw Rob Schneider, I said, is he supposed to be playing a lion? He looks to me like a performer in the Broadway version of Cats. Yes. BB Neuwirth doesn't look like a cat, but he looks like an animal. Like, he does look bizarre in this movie.
Jason Mantzoukas
He is. I was shocked when Rob Schneider came on screen. I was like, oh, oh, what's up with. What are we doing here? I mean, this is what it was. Their whole subplot was fascinating because he appears to be like. Like, not in control of any. He is like, a straight up moron throughout.
Paul Scheer
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
In a fascinating way. The fact that he got turned into a fox, I was like, okay. But, like, he should be turned into a jackass, I think.
Paul Scheer
Well, he's a foxy guy. He's not a jackass, Jason.
Jason Mantzoukas
I guess so. I guess so.
Paul Scheer
I mean, let's listen to a little bit of BB Newhurst, who I thought was Kate Hudson for a majority of the film.
Jason Mantzoukas
Really?
Paul Scheer
She looks like.
Jason Mantzoukas
Excuse me, but haven't you two got a push card to Rob. We've already done that.
June Diane Raphael
Oh, but Geppetto, darling, we were just playing with him.
Jason Mantzoukas
He'll play with his own sword.
Paul Scheer
Thank you. And one sword.
Jason Mantzoukas
Now, these three people are supposed to all be Italian. Correct. All three of these people are doing Italian accents.
June Diane Raphael
These accents are gonna come and they're gonna go. Can't hang on to them.
Paul Scheer
Yeah. The context clues is that this is Italy. But, I mean, John The Taylor Thomas just speaks straight up, like he's on Home Improvement.
Jason Mantzoukas
And all the. And all the kids all, like, the kind of stuff street urchin kids talk. Like they are, like newsies from the 20s.
June Diane Raphael
Yes. Or they're British.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah. And I'm just like, Rob Schneider's eyebrows are on, like, another level.
Paul Scheer
A lot of eyebrows. A lot of.
Jason Mantzoukas
A lot of, like, that, like, reddish brick color.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. I don't like that.
Paul Scheer
I'll tell you what was wrong, weird about this movie. In a children's film, to watch your main character get shot. That was bizarre. A bizarre moment to watch him get shot and then play himself as a recorder or some sort of musical instrument.
Jason Mantzoukas
But I also thought my. My whole thing was. Okay, I get it. Geppetto made him a mouth. That's cool. He's gonna eat. Okay, great. He likes sweets and stuff. Did Geppetto make him an asshole? Like, is he just filling up with stuff? How's he getting rid of it?
Paul Scheer
Is he like a giant pinata? Are you, like, at one point, should they break open his belly and everyone runs?
Jason Mantzoukas
Shot cream and sweets should come pouring out of him. It's gone nowhere else.
Paul Scheer
I mean, when he sneezes. Sawdust. Sawdust covers that teacher's face.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah. So that teacher is standing there, by the way, waiting for it. The nose and boosh. Straight face, shot of sawdust. Just like the porns I watch on pornhub. Sawdust porn.
Paul Scheer
I mean, we're getting into the school part and the kids. And there is something very bizarre about this movie. Besides everything that we've just mentioned for the last 40 minutes, it's the fact that no one has any real, like, reaction to. There is a wooden boy.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yes.
Paul Scheer
Walking and living amongst us.
Jason Mantzoukas
Geppetto. Geppetto never once tries to hide it. Like when. When Pinocchio gets out of the house, Geppetto just picks him up, is like, oh, my God. Picks him up and walks hand in hand with him rather than carrying him so that nobody will see. Like, an enchanted puppet is walking through the streets of Italy.
Paul Scheer
Yep.
Jason Mantzoukas
And everybody's like, oh, cool. Cool, man.
Paul Scheer
Hey, Wood.
Jason Mantzoukas
Magic puppet.
Paul Scheer
Ah, cool. Hey, they give him a nickname. Hey, Woody. You know, they start to punch him. They throw balls at him. Like, no one's frightened by him. He is a part of society. Society. Which makes me go, did he do this before? I don't know. I like, is this a town where this happens?
Jason Mantzoukas
How does Pinocchio end up matriculating in school? How does he get a desk? How does he know to go there. How does he get. What. What did the. Did the attendants get called Pinocchio? New student Pinocchio here?
Paul Scheer
Like, he just.
Jason Mantzoukas
How did that happen?
Paul Scheer
I mean, simply. It happened the same way that everything in this movie happens. He just sees something and gets in line.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah.
Paul Scheer
Then he's there on a bus going to school.
June Diane Raphael
He just simply sees a line of boys and just tags on to the end. I mean, there are worse ways to go through life than to just sort
Jason Mantzoukas
of tagging along at the end of a line of boys.
June Diane Raphael
They're probably going somewhere.
Jason Mantzoukas
You should be. I'll give it a try, but I can't imagine it going well, I gotta say, what's the story? You guys getting on this school bus? All right, I'll do it. I gotta say, I mean, you have
June Diane Raphael
to remember there's quite literally nothing in his head. There's nothing inside his head.
Jason Mantzoukas
How does he know anything? How does he know anything?
Paul Scheer
Well, that's the weird thing about him. He knows enough when he's immediately born to give Geppetto a bar of soap for the bath, but then crawls in with him, but then doesn't know other simple things. Like, he'll be like, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha. All right. Weird. Yeah, there are some weird things. I just wanted to say one thing about the school, and I think this is about, you know, I just want to say, like, this is where Italian schools are so great. You just show up any day, they'll put you in. You know, it's not like American school system. It's a real good school system there.
Jason Mantzoukas
You're really negative on American schools also.
June Diane Raphael
I guess girls just don't go to school there in Italy.
Paul Scheer
Yeah. Are there many women? There's not many. Yeah, there's not many. There's no. I don't think I saw any young girls at all in this.
June Diane Raphael
There's a couple who are watching the puppet show.
Paul Scheer
Okay.
June Diane Raphael
And that's it.
Paul Scheer
The puppet show, by the way, that was. That music was all done by Brian May from Queen.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, wow.
Paul Scheer
He wrote a seven minute puppet opera for that. You can hear it on the soundtrack, which also includes a song from Stevie Wonder,
Jason Mantzoukas
to be fair. Also, there will be more girls in class when Geppetto gets around to carving them. That's true.
June Diane Raphael
I felt like the fun that we didn't have in this. This movie and the scenes that I wanted to see were. And maybe I'm remembering the. The cartoon. Yeah, yeah. But we never got to see him also pretend to be a puppet, like, have to. There's one scene where he just sort of falls asleep. But the. The sheer comedy of watching him have to pretend to have strings and be a puppet when he is a. Well, not boy, but whatever.
Paul Scheer
He is a sentient law.
June Diane Raphael
Sentient. A sentient doll. I felt like we. There were just so many missed opportunities there.
Jason Mantzoukas
There was also very little of what I consider to be Pinocchio's like, true thing, which is there was very little lying. There was very little nose growing because he was.
June Diane Raphael
The whole thing.
Jason Mantzoukas
I thought that was pin. Pinocchio's like whole. With great power comes great responsibility.
Paul Scheer
You know, they kind of blew it out in that schoolroom scene. It grew so big, so fast. So oddly phallically too like that. You're like, never again.
Jason Mantzoukas
They never did.
Paul Scheer
I've learned my lesson by watching that nose grow so dramatically.
Jason Mantzoukas
Do you. Do you have the scene with the. In the whale in the. This is the scene. This is overtly sexual. So they're in the. Pinocchio and Geppetto have been swallowed by the Lorenzini once he's turned into the sea monster. So they're both in the monster's belly and they crawl all the way to the monster's throat. But it's too tight to get through. They can't. We can. You okay? Yeah. It's too tight to get through. So Pinocchio's idea is he'll use his nose to stretch out or irritate the animal so that they can get expelled, basically.
Paul Scheer
So basically they do like reverse bulimia here and they make him puke from the inside with his long, long nose. But by the way, they could have totally gotten out.
Jason Mantzoukas
Now look at this first moment where Pinocchio's nose is. Enters frame while he and Martin Landau are in the same shot is pretty sexual, I think. Eye contact. Eye contact. I know what I have to do.
Paul Scheer
I hate you, Papa.
Jason Mantzoukas
What?
June Diane Raphael
I never ever missed you.
Jason Mantzoukas
That's a Malay.
June Diane Raphael
I wish I never found.
Jason Mantzoukas
It's going right to his mouth. Right towards his mouth.
June Diane Raphael
I never wanted to be your son.
Jason Mantzoukas
What?
Paul Scheer
It's. It's a.
Jason Mantzoukas
What?
Paul Scheer
It's such a bold shot to just have the nose, the flesh colored nose. Enter frame.
Jason Mantzoukas
It's a lie.
June Diane Raphael
The story. The story of Pinocchio. And maybe I didn't watch it that closely as a child, but the story was always, this is a. This is a puppet who lies too much and his nose grows bigger. He does want to be a real boy, but in order to become a real boy, he has to stop lying and start telling the truth. And that's how he becomes a real boy.
Paul Scheer
I also thought that it was. There was morals throughout, but the nose never stopped. Like, the nose growing was always a thing here. It just kind of stopped. Stopped. Like he never grew again. And he seemed to tell lies later
Jason Mantzoukas
in the movie mostly. Like, you know, wouldn't each adventure involve lying or not or learning lessons that are significant towards becoming a better person, thus warranting becoming a human boy and following through on being the best possible version. Isn't it a morality tale?
Paul Scheer
Each.
Jason Mantzoukas
Each of them should be something. A lesson learned.
Paul Scheer
I think that that was what they were trying to do. But they also introduce, like, the moral compass of him so late in the movie. Like that Pepe character comes in so late. I mean, because here he goes like, this is. This is Jiminy Cricket talking about miracles.
Jason Mantzoukas
Out of the woods, huh?
Paul Scheer
What are you doing now?
June Diane Raphael
Watching you clap.
Paul Scheer
Why?
June Diane Raphael
So I can buy a miracle.
Jason Mantzoukas
Any particular brand?
June Diane Raphael
Real boy brand. Here's how it works. You dig a hole, you plant your gold, you let it cook.
Jason Mantzoukas
The first lesson about trust is learning whom to trust.
Paul Scheer
Didn't this gold deal seem a little shaky?
June Diane Raphael
I don't know.
Paul Scheer
A little. And let me guess. You ignored your instincts, didn't you?
June Diane Raphael
Maybe.
Paul Scheer
By the way, we're watching cgi. We're watching CGI on top of CGI here. It's like they're like they've created a character that really, what you said, it looks so bad. And then it's on top of something that doesn't look great either. And it's a. And this is a long scene between two CGI characters who are not there and don't look good together. They don't look like they're in the same world.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah, it is clunky as fuck, this stuff.
Paul Scheer
Wallace. Sean was the original voice of this cricket.
Jason Mantzoukas
Amazing.
Paul Scheer
Was in the trailer. And they said. And the voice of the cricket. Well, Sean. But something happened, and he is not the voice of the cricket in the movie. But this is where he kind of, I think, tells maybe to the president of the cricket union. He keeps on saying he's the president of the cricket union. And union rules say that he has to stay with Pinocchio. But are crickets moralistic creatures?
Jason Mantzoukas
Well, that's like. Is like. Is there a cricket? Is there, like. Are crickets in this world like guardian angels? One is assigned to a boy or a child and is meant to look after. I don't know.
June Diane Raphael
I don't know. I also could not understand the cricket I just simply could not hear what was being said.
Jason Mantzoukas
But. Talk about your papa or I'll be
Paul Scheer
falling down on the job.
Jason Mantzoukas
No, look again. I watch everything with subtitles on, so I'm mostly just reading.
June Diane Raphael
I forced Paul tried to watch this movie with subtitles on, and I turned it off.
Paul Scheer
It's true. You want to enjoy the magic of the cinema that's happening.
Jason Mantzoukas
You. You respect the visual image.
June Diane Raphael
I don't watch my movies and read
Jason Mantzoukas
them, but yet one of the characters you could not understand.
Paul Scheer
That's part of the joy of movie watching.
June Diane Raphael
Maybe they wanted it that way.
Paul Scheer
Well, clearly we. We have some questions about this movie. We've. We've barely kind of tackled many of them before.
June Diane Raphael
I'm sorry, we have not talked about this movie.
Paul Scheer
I mean, we are getting it to it where I wanted to open it
Jason Mantzoukas
up, but I land out bathing clothes. Puppet tries to get in bath with him, question mark, exclamation point. How does he know how to talk, question mark, question mark.
June Diane Raphael
He does impressions.
Jason Mantzoukas
Go ahead. What was it? Why doesn't Leona freak out that the puppet can talk and walk?
Paul Scheer
Etc? I wrote down this. I wrote down this isn't his job. Because Geppetto goes, you keep each other busy while I'm at work. So he just makes all those fucking puppets for fun. And then Leona says, oh, I've made these clothes for puppets. And I'm like, is there so much puppet commerce going on in this town?
Jason Mantzoukas
Well, Lorenzini basically thinks he's gonna get rich with a puppet show for kids, which itself is.
Paul Scheer
And the parents don't attend. The parents don't attend with the children either. That's like, go out. Go see your puppet show.
Jason Mantzoukas
I mean, okay, here we go. How does he have teeth? How does Pinocchio have a full set of white human teeth?
Paul Scheer
I'll do one better. How does eating hot peppers translate into breathing fire?
Jason Mantzoukas
Great.
Paul Scheer
This man eats a chili pepper, blows into a horn, and creates more fire than a giant flamethrower. All of a sudden, it looks like once upon a time in Hollywood. And he's got these chili peppers to thank.
Jason Mantzoukas
He gets during the production of his play. Pinocchio gets paid mid show. That's as if someone walked on stage currently and gave me this show's income. He's like, backstage and Lauren Zane, he's like, show's going great, Pinocchio. Listen, here are the gold. Here's the gold I owe you. You're going to be a star. Everything's great. He's like, quick, you're on. What?
Paul Scheer
Also, Pinocchio seemingly falls into a puppet orchestra because the conductor is a puppet.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yes.
Paul Scheer
And then I was like, wait, so are puppeteers like. Like, if they are controlling musician puppets?
June Diane Raphael
That's some amazing puppets here.
Jason Mantzoukas
I assumed in the pit were real musicians and a real conductor.
Paul Scheer
Okay.
Jason Mantzoukas
And that the puppet conductor was part of the show.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. But my question was also, what are the puppeteers making of Pinocchio?
Jason Mantzoukas
I mean, that's a threat.
June Diane Raphael
They're doing a.
Jason Mantzoukas
That right there. That's a threat to their livelihood is
June Diane Raphael
about to collapse before their very eyes.
Jason Mantzoukas
Puppeteers should want this kid dead.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
This. I don't know. It might catch to the other marionettes. Maybe they're gonna become alive. That's an adventure. When the puppeteers union joins up with the crickets. Union to eradicate Pinocchio.
Paul Scheer
I mean, this is like a puppet. This is really a union story. I mean, union all the way.
Jason Mantzoukas
I would love it if in the sequel, Pinocchio, like, steals an apple and turns back into a wooden boy. A wooden puppet. You don't have to like it.
June Diane Raphael
I really didn't like. I really didn't like. I was surprised at the end to realize how attached I was to. To Pinocchio, the wooden puppet, because I really did not like seeing his ears nod off like that or ripped off, too.
Jason Mantzoukas
The donkey ears are ripped off?
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, they're ripped off. And there's just those sharp edges, those sharp, rough edges.
Paul Scheer
Don't you think that his ears should be deformed? Like, he should have, like, cauliflower ears when he turns into a boy because of that? Because at the end, they make like, at the end, it feels like someone goes, yeah, what happened to all those boys that were turned to donkeys? And the narrator quickly is like, oh, yeah, they all got fixed. Wow. Where was the serum? We didn't see that scene. I saw a donkey walking with Pinocchio, and that donkey is going to live. I feel like those boys did not turn back into humans, but they just are glossing over that. Hey, you win some, you lose some. I mean, this reminds me of a story my grandmother used to tell.
June Diane Raphael
Oh, God. Let's all prepare ourselves.
Paul Scheer
My grandmother used to tell me this story when I was a kid that I needed to lock the door to my house because when she lived in Garden City. This is where my grandmother lived in New York. She's like, when I lived in Garden City, there was a little boy and he didn't lock his door. And one day he was in his bed.
Jason Mantzoukas
I Already know this is deeply irresponsible of her, of her to have said.
Paul Scheer
And he heard footsteps coming up the stairs. Slowly, slowly, slowly, slowly. And then he got really nervous and he got under his bed and he was under the sheets. And the door opened. Creak it out. And then the boy looked and it was the local butcher. And he got scared. And then all of a sudden, the butcher grabbed him. And the mom came home, the boy wasn't there. She brought home her chopped meat.
June Diane Raphael
No, Paul, stop. Stop it right now.
Jason Mantzoukas
What are you talking about? Your grandpa and what?
Paul Scheer
And the mother.
Jason Mantzoukas
What are you talking about?
Paul Scheer
And then as the mother was making hamburgers for her son, she started making hamburgers that the hamburger meat starts like.
Jason Mantzoukas
Mama. No, Mama, Wait, Paul. The chopped meat. The meat knew because the meat was the boy. The meat. But the. But that again, that's. No. Once it's turned into meat, the kid wouldn't know at that point. It's just meat, you know? Oh, unreal.
June Diane Raphael
I am shaken on my insides.
Paul Scheer
My grandmother was a part of the cricket union, so I will put that out there.
Jason Mantzoukas
What are you talking about? Every step of that story is fundamentally irresponsible.
Paul Scheer
And I told you a much abbreviated
Jason Mantzoukas
version of it, that the butcher came. So your grandmother lived in Gardens City, in an environment where meat was so scarce that the local butcher would go house to house looking for unlocked doors and kids left alone at home.
Paul Scheer
Yep. I was a latchkey kid.
Jason Mantzoukas
Was this because you were a latchkey kid?
Paul Scheer
Yep.
June Diane Raphael
She was trying to get you when you came home from school, before your parents came home from work, to lock that door.
Paul Scheer
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
And her.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, I mean, that's an. Probably wasn't effective.
Jason Mantzoukas
Did she ever hire someone in a, like, butcher's apron with, like, to just stand outside your window, like,
Paul Scheer
Sharpening those
Jason Mantzoukas
knives, chop it up. Wow. Oh, boy.
Paul Scheer
That.
Jason Mantzoukas
That could be the T shirt.
Paul Scheer
As I'm.
Jason Mantzoukas
As I'm telling you, it could be the butcher outside the window.
Paul Scheer
As I'm telling you the story, I'm realizing that I think that the element that I've messed up is that the burger meat was already frying when the boy says it. So the meat is like, ready to be eaten at that point.
Jason Mantzoukas
It's not that much worse. It's not like, I mean, whether it's cooking or whatever, the kids still been through the chop.
Paul Scheer
But I think the addendum was. And then she did serve it.
June Diane Raphael
And then she served it to who?
Paul Scheer
Her husband.
Jason Mantzoukas
So they. This is starting to fall apart.
Paul Scheer
I. I remember, like a boy being Eaten too. But I know that this memory of the mama, mama, like that's where I cut off. And I. I think that she may have just added that they ate him as well. But I. That. That feels like a cruel twist at the end.
Jason Mantzoukas
It's a total snowpiercer.
Paul Scheer
All right, well then should I not tell you the second story? Because now as you're telling me this, it makes me realize this. I mean, this seems like more like in good fun. I think this is in good fun.
June Diane Raphael
Wait, hamburger story was in good fun?
Paul Scheer
No, this story I'm about to tell you, but maybe, maybe it is life or something perspective of it.
June Diane Raphael
Okay, I am changed.
Jason Mantzoukas
This is.
June Diane Raphael
I really am.
Jason Mantzoukas
Do you ever catch Paul telling your children similar scary stories?
June Diane Raphael
I feel like I have to say, you know, Paul is such a wonderful man. He really is. It's so shocking to hear these things.
Paul Scheer
Go ahead, let me tell you this story and then you could tell me from my barometer, save if I'm off or not. The first time I ever had a camping thing with my friends, I had two friends over. We put tents up in the backyard before we went out there for the night. My stepfather called us into the living room and said, guys, I don't want you guys camping out in the backyard because there's a police report on TV that a serial killer just escaped prison and he's a loose. And they said for us to lock our doors, but the kids came over to do camping out in the backyard. And so we really want to camp out. We really want to camp out. And he's like, okay, you can camp out in the backyard. And then we camped out in the backyard and in the middle of the night we would hear this noise like. And then he would basically run into our tent and go. And then we all got really scared.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, you think? Oh, you got real scared, huh?
Paul Scheer
And I was about 8 or 9.
Jason Mantzoukas
That is so young. To even tell an 8 or 9 year old about a serial killer is insane. To even make an 8 year old aware of the concept of murder for pleasure or compulsive murder to explain that is insane to 38 year olds. Never mind, then represent yourself as that serious serial killer throughout. Those kids are somewhere telling this story right now.
Paul Scheer
I didn't remember that until right now, but I always thought that was a fun all fun night. A fun, fun camping night was your
Jason Mantzoukas
stepfather, Ted Bundy,
June Diane Raphael
kind of. So, I mean,
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah, we're having fun. Chicago, what a great town. Oh, boy.
Paul Scheer
From premieres April 19th on MGM in a small Inescapable town. Understanding the monsters may be the only way out. Desperate hope may lead residents toward even darker truths. I think they're doing it to make us a fool.
June Diane Raphael
Well, then it worked.
Paul Scheer
Something ancient is feeding off of their suffering. And it won't stop. Survival will demand impossible choices from season four. Premieres April 19th on MGM. Choice Hotels get you more of what you value. Here's a little tune to help you remember. Same drive, different day don't you wish you were getting away? Pack your bags and come on through. Texas, Ohio, Alaska, Alaska, we're up there too. Comfort Inn, it's calling your name Save on the stay. Oh, and free waffles are yours to claim. Well, I hope you like my little songbook. Direct@sourcehotels.com there's nothing like your first Mac.
June Diane Raphael
Here's what people online are sharing. Rhain says everything is just so smooth and fast. I still can't get over it. Syncing stuff between my phone and this is just chef's kiss. Rincredible488 says Apple Silicon basically cures low battery trauma. That's how they felt with their first Mac. How will you. Introducing the all new MacBook Neo, an amazing Mac at a surprising price. Find out more on apple.comMac
Paul Scheer
maybe we should go into the audience.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, I'm gonna start crying.
Jason Mantzoukas
We need a palate cleanser.
Paul Scheer
All right, but before we do, I'm gonna put on my special hat. I'll hold the mic hat. This is just.
Jason Mantzoukas
So can we get house lights?
Paul Scheer
All right, so here we go. I want you to introduce yourself with your Italian name. We heard a lot of great Italian names here tonight. So introduce yourself with your Italian name and let me hear your question. Yes, you, ma'.
Jason Mantzoukas
Am.
Paul Scheer
Come over here. What's your Italian name and what's your question? Here we go. All right.
June Diane Raphael
Jesse.
Paul Scheer
No. Great. And your question?
June Diane Raphael
My question is, when Geppetto created that puppet inside the monster with, like, the spare fish parts and eyeballs, what did he use to keep it together?
Jason Mantzoukas
Fishing wire? Fishing line. But by the way, that fish boy come to life.
Paul Scheer
But by the way, that monster had only been alive for minutes because he drank the water, his eyes bugged out, and I guess like, his inner creature was a giant whale.
Jason Mantzoukas
Seema.
Paul Scheer
I mean, that was a bizarre connection. It should have been like a rat or something. All right, we're up here in the balcony with someone wearing a how dare you shirt. It's a June homemade shirt. Says how dare you from our drop dead Fred episode. Your name in Italian. Your affiliation and your question.
June Diane Raphael
My legit Italian name is Nicola Isabella Sono Caciano.
Paul Scheer
Okay, great.
June Diane Raphael
I'm at Team Sanity. Actually, this shirt is for the late show.
Paul Scheer
Okay, Got it.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. So my question. Comment? So everybody, you know, you've been saying that everyone doesn't really see Pinocchio as a puppet, except Dawn French, the baker's wife. She's the only one who sees him and fucking flips out. She's screaming, she's throwing things all over the place. She's the only woke person in this entire movie.
Paul Scheer
Or is she not woke because she sees the differences and freaked out? But that's a good point, I think.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, see, I thought she was just mad. I thought she was mad he was ruining her food.
Paul Scheer
Well, he was eating all the cream.
Jason Mantzoukas
You know, I don't think she was afraid of Pinocchio. I think she was upset that he was ruining all the food she'd made for the wedding. Wasn't that it? She's saying, get out of here. You know, whatever. It's. I feel like.
Paul Scheer
I also thought she was like, this is a creature. I'm a scared of this creature. I must kill it. Like, I feel like if it was a boy, she wouldn't be throwing pots at its head.
June Diane Raphael
I don't know. I think she probably would. I think she would.
Paul Scheer
I mean, she's.
Jason Mantzoukas
Remember, she's Italian.
Paul Scheer
Fair point, sir. Your name, your affiliation, your question.
Jason Mantzoukas
My name is A. Gregory.
Paul Scheer
Great Italian name.
Jason Mantzoukas
Team Sanity. You don't think. Gregorio. And my question is, since nobody in this town seems to be able to
Paul Scheer
tell the difference between a boy and
Jason Mantzoukas
a puppet, why wouldn't the guy just hire boys to be in his show?
Paul Scheer
Great question. Finally getting somewhere with the balcony.
June Diane Raphael
All right,
Paul Scheer
Because I. I mean, the simple answer is, well, Pinocchio does look well. Yeah, But I guess. No, I guess they are.
Jason Mantzoukas
I mean, it's a marionette show.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
Children.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
And what? Tie strings to their arms?
Paul Scheer
Oh, yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
We're not gonna. Team Sanity. You think that it's okay to just tie strings to kids arms?
Paul Scheer
Oh, no, no, no, no, you're right, Jason. There's a lot of. This guy really cared about the kids. That's why he turned them into donkeys. To skin them.
Jason Mantzoukas
Hey, to make drums, Italy needs skins.
Paul Scheer
All right, ma', am, how about your. Your. Your question, your name, your affiliation, your question?
June Diane Raphael
Okay, my name is Milan. Didn't make that up. Team Sanity.
Paul Scheer
Okay, great, thank you.
June Diane Raphael
So my question is, at the end of the movie, they say that the donkeys Turn back to kids based on doing good deeds. How do donkeys do good deeds?
Jason Mantzoukas
I mean, come on. Donkeys can do good deeds all the time. Donkey. They can, like pull the car at a soup kitchen.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. I mean, donkeys. I think of donkeys as like, as worker animals.
Jason Mantzoukas
Didn't donkey do a lot of good deeds in the Shrek movies?
June Diane Raphael
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
To answer your question, team sanity lots of ways. Because here's what I think when I look at donkeys. I don't think their net energy is negative. They are capable of positive actions. Maybe it's team sanity thinking that things don't capture can only be bad.
Paul Scheer
Ma', am, your name, your affiliation, your question?
June Diane Raphael
Jacqueline.
Paul Scheer
Great, thank you.
June Diane Raphael
Can we talk about the point of view shots from Pinocchio where he's basically like a serial killer shot?
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah.
June Diane Raphael
Was it like Friday the 13th inspired? It was frightening.
Jason Mantzoukas
A lot of the CG characters had point of view shots in order to order to make them cheaper. It's cheaper to shoot point of view shots than to have the CG shots of them doing stuff. So they would do that a lot. And it was. I agree. It was very unsettling. All right, everybody.
Paul Scheer
Clearly we had opinions about this movie, but now it is time for.
Jason Mantzoukas
Why do I feel like you guys are part of an acapella singing group?
Paul Scheer
Now it's time.
Jason Mantzoukas
They have a pitch pipe. I fucking called it. All right.
Paul Scheer
We are literally getting told to get off stage. Here we go. Now it's time for second opinions.
Jason Mantzoukas
When you Rate Films, 5 stars makes no difference who you are, Anything you type will go on Amazon.
June Diane Raphael
Amazing.
Paul Scheer
What are your names?
Jason Mantzoukas
Give it up for Corinne, Melissa, Ashley and James.
Paul Scheer
These are five star opinions. Cold from Amazon. There were 69.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah.
Paul Scheer
Total reviews for the film. 67. Five star reviews. And here we go. This is all compiled by Nate Kiley. This one starts off from Marianne Fish. She goes. It's what I wanted. Five stars.
June Diane Raphael
She needs to be on a watch list of some sort.
Jason Mantzoukas
Well, well, you read these. Can you go back to the preferred Pinocchio image, please?
June Diane Raphael
I'm staying right here and waiting for my miracle.
Jason Mantzoukas
Your papa one.
Paul Scheer
All
Jason Mantzoukas
right, this one, just so you can remember, this is the movie the person wrote the review about.
Paul Scheer
This one is written by Cheryl. It says this. This is an unusual production of Pinocchio. You think? My teenage son said it gave him nightmares. Five stars.
June Diane Raphael
Okay. I don't think she understood this. The rating system.
Jason Mantzoukas
That's a mom. That's a mom who. Who parents like your grandmother
Paul Scheer
Georgia Guillary writes a must Buy for children and child daycare centers. Five stars. I don't think we should be putting this in the child daycare center. This one, this one is from Linda S. Kaufman. She writes My sister's granddaughter loves it. Five stars. Kind of a delayed. All right, sure.
Jason Mantzoukas
What should I do today? I should write Amazon reviews for my niece's favorite movies or my grand niece.
Paul Scheer
And we will end on this one by A. Harenberg, which writes this. Kids films nowadays are brilliant when it comes to scary moments. But this movie was dropped like a ton of bricks on 90s kids. Pinocchio's story pretty much follows the course of a classic fairy tale. Starting out whimsical before taking a dark turn. And I mean seriously dark. I wasn't terrified as a kid, but I'm willing to bet others in the two to six year old crowd were petrified.
June Diane Raphael
Two,
Paul Scheer
Five motherfucking stars. Oh boy.
Jason Mantzoukas
Before.
Paul Scheer
Before we get into whether or not we'd recommend this movie, because I think it's pretty clear what we think about this movie, I wanted to bring up this little piece of trivia that I found about it, which is Avril Halley, our producer on the show, she finds all these movies. She found this terror nightscape for you. Also found that this movie spun off a CD ROM interactive video game starring one of the stars of Ladybugs. And I just wanted to show you. This is the girl from Ladybugs, if you remember. So here, here is.
Jason Mantzoukas
She was the one that Rodney Dangerfield is like, don't worry, when you get older, you're going to be pretty and everybody's going to like you. Or something like that.
Paul Scheer
Exactly. So now here's. You are the new Pinocchio. Martin Landau talks to you like this. How are you going to be able to find Pinocchio?
Jason Mantzoukas
You're not even made of wood.
June Diane Raphael
We'll help.
Paul Scheer
So you get to follow along with her. And then this is where it gets to terrifying. At the end of the game when she's talking to the donkey boys.
June Diane Raphael
Oh, turn this off right now.
Jason Mantzoukas
No.
June Diane Raphael
Sadie's trick is that he gets you.
Jason Mantzoukas
That's a donkey girl.
June Diane Raphael
Then he turns you into jackasses. It could never happen to me. It just did. You have.
Paul Scheer
This game is straight up terrifying.
Jason Mantzoukas
That's a game.
Paul Scheer
That is a CD ROM interactive game. They just took out all the choices. And by the way, this movie throws around the word jackass a lot for a kids film. Some notes.
Jason Mantzoukas
And is it like a jerk off game asking for a friend?
Paul Scheer
The movie came out in 1996. The tagline was, it's a new angle on a classic tale. And that's no lie. And here's the thing. The budget for this movie, $25 million.
Jason Mantzoukas
What year?
Paul Scheer
96.
Jason Mantzoukas
Wow.
Paul Scheer
Opening weekend, 3.8 million.
Jason Mantzoukas
Wow. By the way, that's not nothing.
Paul Scheer
No.
Jason Mantzoukas
You know, we came in.
Paul Scheer
I think that people probably went to go see JTT. This is the height of JTT madness. The movie came in 100. Out of all the movies made in 1996, the top three were Independence Day, Twister, Mission Impossible. It was beaten by Jingle all the Way, Dragon Heart, the island of Dr. Moreau, escape from LA, the quest, the Glimmer Man, Kazaam, and the Phantom. But it beat barbed wire and love. Lawnmower man two, which we didn't cover on this show, but that's a little fact about it.
Jason Mantzoukas
Wait, there was a Lawnmower man sequel?
Paul Scheer
Yep. Lawnmower Man 2. Beyond cyberspace. Oh, God. Jason. June, I go to you now. Would you recommend this movie?
June Diane Raphael
Of course not.
Jason Mantzoukas
No. No.
Paul Scheer
You don't even think it's interesting to watch a little bit?
Jason Mantzoukas
I don't. Yeah.
June Diane Raphael
No.
Jason Mantzoukas
I didn't care for it and it was not fun enough.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah. I mean, I have to spend time erasing. Erasing some images, images and imagery that I saw.
Jason Mantzoukas
Now, to be fair, after this scene, I came and went to sleep.
Paul Scheer
The scene, of course, Jason's referring to is when Pinocchio has cream all over his mouth. That's what we have as our still frame for the whole show, this visual. What I want to just point out, you can search this picture at home. If you type in Pinocchio image, this normally comes up. This is not a shot that someone took. This is a press photo for the movie. So. Yes. That's why it has the water marking on it. So someone thought that this representation of an open mouth, Pinocchio with white cream all over the place mouth was the right way to advertise.
Jason Mantzoukas
This leads me to believe there was a cut of this movie that was a porno. That, like, when Pinocchio would leave Martin Landau, he would get up into, like, sexy Italian adventures.
Paul Scheer
By the way, this puppet took nine months to create and operated by 12 different technicians, 12 different people to control this masterpiece.
Jason Mantzoukas
I didn't like the scene. I didn't. I'm sorry, I'm just noticing a few things I did not like when his flesh, when the wood started to turn into flesh.
Paul Scheer
Yeah.
Jason Mantzoukas
I thought that was very creepy and unsettling to look at.
Paul Scheer
Sorry. At that point, it Was a relief because it was almost. You knew it was gonna be over. And the tear goes and.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yeah, I don't like that.
Paul Scheer
Yeah, it's his. Yeah. And by the way, when he does turn into a real boy, that version of the puppet looks just like Jonathan Taylor Thomas. Like, for a second. You see, it is Jonathan Taylor Thomas, but. But no, like, right before it, like, when it's like this, this, you'll see it like. Like that. Like.
June Diane Raphael
Yeah, he looks closer to him.
Jason Mantzoukas
Oh, I see. I see.
Paul Scheer
Maybe that was a little cgi. I don't know if I would recommend this movie either, but it's so bizarre.
Jason Mantzoukas
And you don't know if you would. I feel like there are some choice
Paul Scheer
nuggets in here that are worth, like, watching because it just keeps on going. It's a movie that when I would turn away for just merely, like, two or three seconds, I was completely lost, as if, like, hours had passed. And it's like, so now what's happening? It's like Game of Thrones.
June Diane Raphael
We watched it together and we had to recap scenes over and over again. We simply were losing the thread.
Jason Mantzoukas
I want to be clear, for this audience here and the one at home, you would not recommend watching Drop Dead Fred, but you would recommend watching the Adventures of Pinocchio. First of all, this is a classic team sanity point of view.
Paul Scheer
First of all, I don't think that I ever went on record and said I would not recommend watching team. I just said it's not a good movie. Anyway, people, that show was a lot of fun. And now we have to wrap it up. We have to say no. If it was between this and Drop Dead Fred, I'd say, watch this.
Jason Mantzoukas
Yes.
Paul Scheer
Wow.
June Diane Raphael
Paul, come on now. So, okay. I know it's all fun. I know it's fun to have a friendly rivalry. There's a lot of energy around it. It's a good time.
Paul Scheer
But seriously, no, I would watch Drop Dead Fred over this. I would. Yes, indeed. Just for the pain. This has scarred me on a deep, deep level. All right, so, Jason June, we have done it. We have had many adventures with this Pinocchio character. And there's one last thing for us to do that is to say goodnight.
Jason Mantzoukas
Thank you, Chakan.
Paul Scheer
Hey, everybody. That is our show live from Chicago.
June Diane Raphael
Woo.
Paul Scheer
Boy, that was a big one. We are continuing the conversation about Pinocchio and it does need to continue on the mini episode, which will be next week. And I implore you, I urge you to check in on what we're doing on the mini episodes. I see that the listenership is going up and I'm loving it and we're doing more and new different stuff and one of the best parts about it is the not only talking about the movie that we are talking about on the episode. This of course will be Pinocchio next week, but we're also talking about you. I'm getting to hear about all of your jobs, your love, your life. I'm giving you advice. Along with Devin and Cody. We're breaking it all down for you. So head on over to the mini episode next week to continue the conversation about Pinocchio. And if you want to call in, you can at 619-Paul-Ask. That's 619p a u l a s k. So continue the conversation about Pinocchio right there. Also wanted to let you know that Grayson Frankie Season 6 is on Netflix right now. If you've not watched the Good Place, well you're missing out on Jason and I. It's the final season and a great season at that. So many great appearances and what an amazing finale this past week. So if you've missed out, catch up. You are going to see some of us on there also. What else do I want to tell you? Oh boy, so much good stuff. Black Monday season 2 trailer dropped so so that's online right now. Check that out. It's really fun. It gives you a little taste of what you're in store for in Black Monday Season 2, which starts March 15. A big shout out and thank you to Avril Halley, one of our producers, for pulling this amazing movie. I mean she really opened our eyes to a lot of stuff. Nick Kiley for doing all that amazing research. Devin of course, who travels across country with us, our producer Cody here at Earwolf Studios, everybody at Earwolf and we will see you next week for a mini episode. And if you're bored or you just miss how did this get made in the meantime? Well, head on over to teepublic.com store hdtgm to get your official Pinocchio shirt. And if you really just want to reach out and chat, you can do that with me. You can give me a call at or not call A text please. Just a text. 917-877-0657. Let's do it people. See you next week for highlights get made mini ad episode on Etsy.
June Diane Raphael
Every sign of spring is a reason to celebrate. Welcome the warmer weather with a light linen jacket made by a real person. Or enjoy your morning coffee outdoors in a hand thrown mug. Refresh your style and your space with pieces you won't find anywhere else. Celebrate the new season and original small shops on the Etsy app.
Paul Scheer
Choice hotels get you more of what you value. Here's a little tune to help you remember. Same drive, different day don't you wish you were getting away? Pack your bags and come on through Texas, Ohio, Alaska, we're up there, too Comfort Inn, it's calling your name save on the stay oh, and free waffles are yours to claim well, I hope you like my little song book direct@sourcehotels.com.
Recorded live at the Chicago Theater — April 14, 2026
Hosts: Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, Jason Mantzoukas
On this raucous, live edition of How Did This Get Made?, Paul, June, and Jason dive headlong into the baffling nightmare that is 1996’s The Adventures of Pinocchio—starring Jonathan Taylor Thomas (“in full effect for the last 30 seconds of this movie”) and Martin Landau. What starts as a teardown of questionable CGI and even weirder narrative choices quickly becomes one of the more unhinged and hilarious explorations the HDTGM trio have done, punctuated by audience questions and wild, personal stories.
Paul’s Stories of Childhood Terror (46:39+)
Paul shares the story his grandmother told him about a butcher kidnapping children who forgot to lock their doors (47:07), and a prank his stepfather played involving a fake escaped serial killer during a backyard campout (51:05), prompting shock from June and Jason.
“To even make an 8 year old aware of the concept of murder for pleasure... is insane.” — Jason (52:45)
CD-ROM Game Spin-Off (65:22)
Paul reveals that there was a Pinocchio video game, featuring live-action sequences even creepier than the movie. “This is straight up terrifying.” — Paul (66:25)
Standout Questions:
A fever dream of a children’s film, The Adventures of Pinocchio gets the full HDTGM treatment: disbelief, laughter, and outright horror. With themes and visuals more disturbing than enchanting, and a baffling disregard for child psychology, the hosts and audience agree this one’s best left to the annals of weird 90s cinema history. As Jason puts it, "This was haunting."
For a deeper dive, catch the mini-episode follow-up and join the conversation.