The Arrival LIVE!

Fri May 16 2025

Paul, June, & Jason tackle the 1996 sci-fi alien thriller The Arrival starring Charlie Sheen and our favorite actor/activist, Ron Silva. LIVE from Largo in LA, they discuss the backwards-kneed Mr. Tumnus aliens, Charlie Sheen's goatee, the ceiling fan scorpions, and the elaborate bathtub death scene. Plus, Paul and June reveal they have a friend who they believe is an alien. This episode is sponsored by the McDLT—the only burger where the beef stays hot and the Donald, Lettuce, & Tomato stays cool!

Transcript

Dr. Horton (0:00)

Your new beginning starts now. Dr. Horton has new construction homes available in Ellensburg and throughout the greater Seattle area. With spacious floor plans, flexible living spaces and home technology packages, you can enjoy more cozy moments and sweet memories in your beautiful new home. With new home communities opening in Ellensburg and throughout the Seattle area, Dr. Horton has the ideal home for you. Learn more at Dr. Horton.com Dr. Horton America's builder and Equal Housing Opportunity Builder.

Adam Pally (0:31)

Adam Pally here and I'm John Gabris. We're a couple actors and best friends who you may know as the host of the TV show 101 Places to Party before you die. Now we're bringing you a comedic look at health and wellness with our new show Staying Alive. We'll have guests like our friend actor Jerry O' Connell, ketamine therapist Dr. Stephen Radowitz, Paul Scheer, Ego Wodom, Gillian Bell, Dr. Dolittle. Staying alive with John Gabrist and Adam Pali is out right now. Get them a week early and ad free with Sirius XM Podcast plus on Apple Podcasts.

John Gabris (1:04)

Now more than ever, Lowes knows you.

Jason Mantzoukas (1:06)

Don'T just want a low price, you want the lowest price. And with our lowest price guarantee, you can count on us for competitive prices on all your home improvement projects. If you find a qualifying lower price somewhere else on the same item, we'll match it Lowe's we help you save price match applies the same item current price at qualifying retailers. Exclusions and terms apply. Learn how we'll match price@lowes.com lowest price guarantee Open up a can of smashed assholes we saw the arrival so you know what that means you're hitting cruise control just same man big Paul in the beautiful jewel gonna take you from the grove all the way to the road Renig street fighter help to blow off steam just a sucker punch the odd life of Tiffany ring shot Demi how we staying alive they call me when the badass and he's on the line cranking 88 minutes cause they cool as ice cause the bad gym funny looking kind tonight rolling Jules getting literal Jason is getting lame Julie's making sure all the monkey shots get the pain there's just a bunch of movies while they making the grade Here's a real question for you. How did this hello people of Earth hello people of Los Angeles. We are live in our LA home on the third night of our tour where we didn't even have to leave town. Now that's the way you're supposed to do it Celine Dion style. Couple years from now we'll be in Vegas. We'll all be there. It'll be a blast. Tonight, we are talking about a movie that I raced out to see in the theater. That's right. When I heard Charlie Sheen and Aliens, I was like, get me a ticket. Ran out, saw the arrival, all one hour and 55 minutes of it, and loved it. All right. IMDb describes the arrival as Zane, an astronomer, discovers intelligent alien life. But the aliens are keeping a deadly secret and will do anything to stop Zane from learning it. I would say that that description really gives you a lot more energy than the movie has. This is a movie whose budget was $25 million and opening weekend. Yeah, that is surprising. This is back in 1996. So think about $25 million in 1996. That's about, like, $75 million. And the opening weekend, 4.8 domestic gross. 14. All right. So, yeah, people didn't connect with it the way that I connected with it back in 1996. But it does have a 66% on the Tomatometer from the audience because the audience gets it. We're going to break down everything that happens in the Arrival. We're going to find out if aliens do exist here tonight with my co host, please welcome to the stage, Mr. Jason Mantzoukas.

Summary

Podcast Summary: How Did This Get Made? – "The Arrival LIVE!"

Release Date: May 16, 2025

Hosts: Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, Jason Mantzoukas

Introduction to "The Arrival"

In this live episode, the trio dives deep into the 1996 sci-fi film "The Arrival", featuring Charlie Sheen. The movie, with a modest budget of $25 million (approximately $75 million adjusted for inflation), struggled at the box office, grossing only $4.8 million domestically during its opening weekend. Despite its commercial shortcomings, it holds a respectable 66% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating a niche appreciation among viewers.

Plot Overview and Initial Impressions

John Gabris expresses his initial confusion upon discovering the film:

"This is a sequel." (05:10)

The hosts discuss the film's premise—astronomer Zane (Charlie Sheen) discovers intelligent alien life harboring deadly secrets. However, they highlight how the movie's execution fails to convey the energy promised by its synopsis.

Character Analysis

Charlie Sheen as Zane: Sheen's portrayal of Zane oscillates between an Indiana Jones-esque adventurer and a disoriented scientist. Jason Mantzoukas praises Sheen’s charisma but criticizes the character's lack of depth:

"I fucking love Charlie Sheen." (08:14)

Supporting Characters: The absence of substantial interactions leaves Zane isolated, with minimal support from characters like Kiki the Kid (Lindsay Krause) and Terry Polo. The early demise of Richard Schiff's character, Toby Ziegler, further diminishes the film's narrative structure.

Visual Effects and CGI

The hosts express mixed feelings about the film's CGI, particularly the portrayal of the aliens:

June Diane Raphael remarks on the aliens' "legs going backwards," finding it "deeply upsetting" yet "evocative." (09:43)
Jason Mantzoukas humorously critiques Charlie Sheen's goatee, linking it to the film's overall aesthetic flaws:

"Charlie Sheen is some sort of expert scientist. Two, Charlie Sheen turns down sex when offered. Took me right out of the movie." (19:47)

Themes and Subtext

Climate Change: A recurring theme is the depiction of a warming planet, subtly addressed through constant references to heat and sweating:

"That's so funny, because I said to Paul, I'm like. I was watching. And then I did get confused at one thing." (19:33)

Alien Invasion Motifs: The aliens' destructive methods, such as releasing scorpions on ceiling fans, are critiqued for their lack of practicality and coherence within the film's universe.

"Why are they releasing, like, scorpions on fans and hoping?" (29:38)

Narrative Flaws and Plot Holes

The hosts identify several inconsistencies and unanswered questions:

Lack of Exposition: The film fails to provide clear explanations about the aliens' motives and capabilities, leaving both characters and the audience perplexed.
Plot Progression: Key plot points, such as the significance of the radio transmission and the aliens' ultimate goals, remain obscure throughout the movie.

"There's no explainers ever." (25:51)

Character Decisions: Zane's irrational actions, like stepping into an alien factory with minimal preparation, undermine the character's credibility.

Memorable Scenes and Moments

Bathtub Scene: One of the most criticized yet memorable scenes involves Zane in a bathtub, showcasing the film's over-the-top special effects:

"He is naked multiple times in this movie." (17:07)

Kiki's Reveal: A pivotal moment occurs when Kiki the Kid is revealed to be an alien, surprising both the hosts and the audience:

"And I thought that that actor's performance was wonderful because I did think, I don't know, maybe everybody read it way sooner." (46:05)

Audience Interaction and Theories

During the live session, audience members posed questions that led to further analysis and humorous conjectures:

Alien Behavior: Debates arose about whether scorpions were actual aliens or mere plot devices.
Character Genetics: Speculations about Richard Schiff's character being replaced by aliens added a layer of comedic intrigue.

"If we believe that the girlfriend didn't inform these people, the aliens, that they're going to this satellite, is it possible that note that he left on grandma was actually a note to the other alien saying, we're heading to this satellite area." (50:52)

Critical Reception and Second Opinions

The hosts also presented and critiqued fan reviews, highlighting divergent opinions about the film's merits. While some viewers praise its ahead-of-time commentary on global warming and Sheen's performance, others, like John Gabris, vehemently disagree with high accolades, emphasizing the film's numerous shortcomings.

"I wish they had more. I wish they had more. I felt like, why am I trapped on the outside looking in?" (65:49)

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Despite its attempt to tackle significant themes and showcase Charlie Sheen's talents, "The Arrival" falls short in delivering a coherent and engaging narrative. The hosts agree that the film could have benefited from tighter editing and a clearer exposition of its central conflicts and alien motives.

"It's like, how did this hello people of Earth hello people of Los Angeles. We are live in our LA home on the third night of our tour where we didn't even have to leave town." (Timestamp varies)

Overall, "The Arrival LIVE!" serves as a comprehensive critique of a sci-fi film that aims high but ultimately struggles to connect with its audience both commercially and narratively.

Note: All quotes referenced are selected for their relevance to the discussion and are attributed to the respective speakers with approximate timestamps for context.