Podcast Summary: How Complicated Should Investing Be? (Bestie Ep) #1017

Released on August 1, 2025, by iHeartPodcasts.

Introduction

In episode #1017 of How to Money, hosts Joel and Matt delve into the intricate question: "How Complicated Should Investing Be?" Aimed at providing straightforward, jargon-free personal finance guidance, the duo emphasizes the importance of simplicity in investment strategies to help listeners achieve their financial goals without unnecessary complexity.

Market Context: Exiting a Historic Bear Market

The episode opens with Matt highlighting a significant market milestone:

“We just exited the longest bear market since 1948. Isn’t that crazy?” ([02:13])

Joel concurs, expressing astonishment at how seamlessly many investors continued their strategies despite prolonged market downturns. This backdrop sets the stage for discussing how overcomplicating investment choices can hinder financial progress.

The Temptation of Complexity in Investing

Joel and Matt draw parallels between everyday decisions and investment choices, illustrating how an overload of options can lead to decision fatigue. Joel shares a personal anecdote about choosing a parking spot, subtly introducing the idea that too many choices can lead to unnecessary stress and suboptimal decisions.

“The choice overload. There are so many directions you can go in on the investing front... complicating things doesn’t always make them better.” ([06:15])

Matt reinforces this by discussing how the plethora of investment options can distract investors from maintaining consistent, disciplined investment habits.

Simplifying Investment Strategies

The hosts advocate for minimalist investment portfolios, primarily consisting of broad-based index funds and target-date funds. They argue that such simplicity not only reduces decision fatigue but also aligns with proven wealth-building strategies.

“The minimalist route, investing within a single fund or maybe two that are already well diversified, this is an effective strategy that will get you where it is that you want to be.” ([48:05])

Key Investment Topics Discussed

1. International Stocks

   Joel and Matt examine the role of international stocks in a diversified portfolio. While acknowledging potential benefits, they emphasize that for many investors, domestic index funds may suffice.

   “Jack Bogle, he's the founder of Vanguard... he was famously not a big fan of international diversification for a number of reasons.” ([19:32])

2. ESG Funds

   The duo critically assesses Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) funds, pointing out inconsistencies and potential underperformance compared to traditional funds.

   “ESG is largely in the eye of the beholder... Philip Morris, which is the company that make cigarettes... scoring higher in the ESG ratings than Tesla.” ([24:26])

3. Real Estate Investments: REITs and Syndications

   Joel and Matt discuss Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) as a passive way to gain real estate exposure without the hassles of property management. They caution against more hands-on real estate investments like syndications due to higher risks and complexities.

   “Most folks don't need real estate exposure because the average American homeowner... have most of their network tied up in their home, their primary residence.” ([30:07])

4. Alternative Investments: Cryptocurrencies, NFTs, and More

   The hosts advise against venturing into highly speculative investments such as cryptocurrencies and NFTs, especially for those who haven't solidified their foundational investment strategies.

   “If you've got money left over and you just love the novelty of it, then like it's not the worst thing in the world... but most people, they're just reducing their meat and potatoes style investing.” ([39:04])

Financial Advisors vs. Robo-Advisors vs. DIY Investing

Joel and Matt weigh the pros and cons of hiring traditional financial advisors, robo-advisors, and managing investments independently. They advocate for robo-advisors like Betterment as a cost-effective middle ground, offering automated investment management with some access to human advisors.

“Betterment is probably one of the best ones out there... their fees range from like 0.25% for kind of like their standard digital plan...” ([44:16])

However, they caution against traditional advisors due to their high fees, especially for those who are just starting their investment journeys.

“When you're hearing us say this, that means you're listening to the podcast, which means like, that tells me that I think you are the kind of person who's going to proactively take charge of your finances.” ([42:18])

The Power of Simplicity: Index Funds and Dollar Cost Averaging

A recurring theme of the episode is the advocacy for index funds and dollar cost averaging as the backbone of a simplified and effective investment strategy. The hosts emphasize consistency and regular contributions over trying to time the market or chase high-return investments.

“If you're trying to get that perfect allocation, create the most diverse investment account possible, you're probably not quite as focused on that more important lever.” ([50:57])

They liken maintaining a simple investment plan to following a structured program like the "Couch to 5K" running plan, highlighting the importance of gradual and sustained effort.

“If you just kind of keep doing it with every paycheck, without overthinking it, you're going to be ahead, vastly ahead of the majority of your peers on the investing front.” ([49:07])

Closing Thoughts: Stick to the Plan

Joel and Matt conclude by reiterating the importance of a disciplined, minimalist investment approach. They warn against letting market noise and the allure of novel investment opportunities derail consistent investment habits.

“Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Get started and then continue learning.” ([46:47])

They encourage listeners to focus on foundational investment practices, ensuring that simplicity enhances rather than hinders financial growth.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Matt on the Bear Market:

  “We just exited the longest bear market since 1948. Isn’t that crazy?” ([02:13])

• Joel on Decision Fatigue:

  “There are so many directions you can go in on the investing front... complicating things doesn’t always make them better.” ([06:15])

• Joel on Minimalist Investing:

  “The minimalist route, investing within a single fund or maybe two that are already well diversified, this is an effective strategy that will get you where it is that you want to be.” ([48:05])

• Matt on ESG Funds:

  “ESG is largely in the eye of the beholder... Philip Morris, which is the company that make cigarettes... scoring higher in the ESG ratings than Tesla.” ([24:26])

• Joel on Robo-Advisors:

  “Betterment is probably one of the best ones out there... their fees range from like 0.25% for kind of like their standard digital plan...” ([44:16])

• Matt on Simplicity in Investing:

  “If you just kind of keep doing it with every paycheck, without overthinking it, you're going to be ahead, vastly ahead of the majority of your peers on the investing front.” ([49:07])

• Joel on Investment Consistency:

  “Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Get started and then continue learning.” ([46:47])

Conclusion

Joel and Matt effectively articulate that simplicity in investing not only reduces stress and decision fatigue but also aligns with proven strategies for wealth accumulation. By advocating for broad-based index funds, disciplined contributions, and cautious exploration of additional investment avenues, they provide listeners with a clear roadmap to navigate the often overwhelming world of personal finance.

For more insights and detailed discussions, visit howtomoney.com and subscribe to the How to Money newsletter.