Join us for the ultimate Christmas movie draft as we crown our personal Hall of Fame picks and dive deep into alternative holiday cinema! I am joined by Sugar Bob, in spirit, to compare our individual rankings and debate everything from heartwarming classics to dark festive horror. From National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation to the terrifying Black Christmas, plus our controversial take on whether Eyes Wide Shut really counts as a Christmas movie (spoiler: it does).

Whether you're team wholesome holiday cheer or team creepy Christmas horror, this three-way movie showdown has something for every type of movie fan this holiday season.

Christmas Movies Hall of Fame - The Rankings

My List

1. National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation - The undisputed champion of Christmas chaos and family dysfunction

2. Home Alone 1 & 2 - Kevin McCallister's double feature of holiday mayhem deserves the tie

2.5 Black Christmas (Original) - The OG slasher that defined Christmas horror

3. Bad Santa - Billy Bob Thornton's delightfully twisted anti-hero performance (check out my Letterboxd review!)

3.5 Jim Carrey's How The Grinch Stole Christmas - Love it or hate it, this one's a holiday staple

4. Elf - Will Ferrell's pure holiday joy in human form

5. Eyes Wide Shut - Yes, it's a Christmas movie. Fight us.

5.5 The Family Man - Nicolas Cage's underrated holiday redemption story

6. The Holdovers - The emotional toll is real, but this Paul Giamatti masterpiece might deserve to rank even higher

7. The Santa Clause - Tim Allen's transformation launched a franchise for good reason

8. The Holiday - The ultimate cozy Christmas rom-com comfort watch

9. It's A Wonderful Life - The obligatory classic (full disclosure: needs a rewatch for proper ranking)

10. The Polar Express - Tom Hanks and motion capture magic on the rails to the North Pole

Sugar Bob's List

[Her picks discussed in the episode]

Beeshee's List

[Their picks discussed in the episode]

Movies We Need To Catch Up On

Klaus - This Netflix animated gem keeps coming up in recommendations

Top 5 Christmas Horror Movies

When you need your holiday cheer with a side of screams:

Rare Exports - Finnish horror that reimagines Santa Claus as nightmare fuel
Krampus - The anti-Santa gets his due in this creature feature
Eyes Wide Shut (yes, again!) - Kubrick's psychological thriller set during the holidays
Gremlins - The perfect blend of comedy, horror, and Christmas carnage
Black Christmas - The 1974 original remains the gold standard of holiday horror

Honorable Mentions

Violent Night - David Harbour as action-hero Santa
The Nightmare Before Christmas - The eternal debate: Halloween movie or Christmas movie?

Topics Discussed

Comparing our three different Hall of Fame lists and finding common ground
Why Bad Santa holds up as the perfect anti-Christmas movie
The emotional weight of The Holdovers and why it's climbing the rankings
Eyes Wide Shut as Christmas movie: A controversial but correct take
The original Black Christmas vs. modern horror remakes
Home Alone's cultural impact and sequel success rate
Which Christmas movies are genuinely rewatchable vs. obligatory viewings
Where Sugar Bob and Beeshee agree (and violently disagree) with my picks

Connect With Us

Found a Christmas movie we missed? Think our rankings are completely wrong? Let us know! Don't forget to check

Christmas Movies Hall of Fame + Top 5 Alt-Christmas Movies and Christmas Horror Movies