Trump Loses All Control as MAGA Influencers Go Rogue

Summary

IHIP News Podcast Summary

Episode: Trump Loses All Control as MAGA Influencers Go Rogue

Date: October 4, 2025
Hosts: Jennifer Welch & Angie “Pumps” Sullivan

---

Episode Overview

In this episode, Jennifer Welch and Angie “Pumps” Sullivan dive into the chaotic aftermath within right-wing media following the murder of Charlie Kirk. Focusing on the rise of unhinged conspiracy theories driven by figures like Candace Owens, the hosts unpack how MAGA influencers are splintering into rogue factions, each peddling their own narratives and grievances. With sharp wit and incisive commentary, the hosts explore why such conspiracy content resonates with conservative audiences, the broader implications for U.S. politics, and the awkward relationship between American right-wing movements and Israel.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Candace Owens Takes Center Stage

• Candace Owens’ Influence: The episode begins with Jennifer describing Owens as a “big trans hater” and notable MAGA influencer who commands millions of fiercely loyal followers ([00:00]).

• Ridicule Over "Spiritual Warfare": Owens’ ongoing investigation into the murder of Charlie Kirk includes claims of involvement by witches and spiritual curses. Both Jennifer and Angie lampoon this as “magical thinking,” highlighting its roots in religious trauma and right-wing indoctrination ([01:05]).

  Quote:

  “That's the problem when people don't understand that this stuff is real, that you're saying to which, yeah, I'll...pay for you to put a curse on Charlie. And that witch did that.”
  — Candace Owens, as quoted by Hosts ([01:05])

• Right-Wing Indoctrination: Jennifer unpacks how such ideas find fertile ground:

  “They have been primed to believe this at a very early age... These kids are deeply indoctrinated and religiously abused from a very young age.”
  — Jennifer ([01:59])

---

2. Conspiracy Theories About Charlie Kirk’s Murder

• Media Vacuum and Distrust: As Candace Owens pushes multiple narratives (including a supposed suicide cover-up and federal involvement), Jennifer positions her as a grifter exploiting her friend’s death—while also expressing skepticism toward official investigations led by “Cash Patel’s FBI” ([05:40]).

• Gag Order & Secrecy: Angie reveals details of a DOJ-mandated gag order around the case—echoing how Trump previously rallied against such orders, but his own administration is now using one.

  Quote:

  “Yes, the DOJ asked for a gag order...no one involved in the case, lawyers, witnesses, can speak out...and I think we all can deduce why.”
  — Angie ([06:02])

---

3. Right-Wing Fragmentation & "Rogue MAGA"

• Splintering Narratives: Candace Owens accuses various figures—ranging from the Israeli government to unidentified “deep state” actors—of involvement in Kirk’s killing. Jennifer points out Netanyahu’s six-time denial and how the far right's appetite for conspiracy content is both endless and uncritical ([06:36–07:54]).

  Quote:

  “Benjamin Netanyahu has denied killing Charlie Kirk six times. … China’s denied killing Charlie Kirk zero times. … You catch my drift? So that shit’s weird.”
  — Jennifer ([06:54])

---

4. Israel’s Role in Right-Wing Politics

• Bipartisan Frustration: Both the far left and right are fatigued with U.S. support for Israel. Jennifer connects this to Netanyahu’s manipulative politics, stating he “paid millions of dollars and sent suitcases full of cash from Israel to Gaza to fund Hamas to keep them in power”—fact-checked as derived from reputable Israeli journalism ([08:26–09:52]).

• Netanyahu’s Propaganda: The conversation pivots to Netanyahu’s aggressive PR campaign and use of American influencers to garner support for Israel, leading Jennifer to question the expectation that all Americans “must love Israel.”

  Quote:

  “Why do two women that are atheists that live in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, why do we have to love Israel?...it’s all propaganda.”
  — Jennifer ([10:40])

• Resource Allocation: Angie raises stark contrasts between Israeli and American social services, fueling further resentment ([11:28]).

---

5. MAGA Power Struggles & Candace’s Rant

• Leadership Vacuum: Owens delivers a dramatic message to conservative rivals: no one will “replace Charlie Kirk” and threatens to expose rivals’ secrets if challenged.

  Quote:

  “You put a shill in Charlie Kirk’s chair...I will be an enemy of you...I will release every single text message.”
  — Candace Owens, as quoted by Hosts ([12:31])

• Hosts’ Reactions: Jennifer and Angie find her tirade “psychotic” and indicative of the emotional immaturity pervasive in right-wing online spaces.

  Quote:

  “Are all of these people that listen to all these right wing media, are they that weak that they have to have some leader on the Internet guide them through life?”
  — Jennifer ([13:22])

---

6. Wider Implications and Political Messaging

• Polling & American Sentiment: Jennifer references recent polling showing declining U.S. support for Israel, noting, “what a relief considering we've all seen the images from Gaza” ([13:41]).

• Hypocrisy & Opportunism: The hosts criticize Candace Owens for cherry-picking human rights causes for “money and clicks,” juxtaposing her concern for Palestinian children with her attacks on LGBTQ+ Americans.

• Systemic Grifting: They underscore how both Trump and Netanyahu exploit their respective political bases for profit ([15:05–16:00]).

  Quote:

  “None of us are free until all of us are free...a really good indicator of somebody who really walks the walk is they leave no one behind. On the right, they leave a lot of people behind.”
  — Jennifer ([16:00])

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Candace Owens (as quoted):

  “Kings are born. You don’t just get to depose and tell us we’re going to follow this individual ... I will release every single text message ... This is not a threat. This is a promise.” ([12:00–12:53])

• Hosts on propaganda:

  “He’s a propagandist, he’s a fascist, he’s basically a dictator, Benjamin Netanyahu. And I think he’s facing like criminal charges for bribery...”
  — Jennifer ([14:08])

• Hosts on right-wing media:

  “We want to keep our eyes on what’s going on with the grifters on the right...They have this huge media enterprise that gets millions and millions and millions of views and people just eat that up.”
  — Jennifer ([16:15])

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:00–01:59 Candace Owens, spiritual warfare, and conspiracy set-up
• 02:00–06:00 Candace Owens’ theories about the Kirk murder, skepticism toward federal investigation
• 06:01–07:54 DOJ gag order, distrust of official narrative
• 07:55–10:26 Israel, Netanyahu, and American political alliances
• 10:27–13:35 Social commentary on U.S. support for Israel, influencer PR efforts
• 11:46–12:53 Candace Owens’ “enemy” warning to conservative rivals
• 13:36–16:07 Broader implications for U.S. politics, messaging, and movement grifting

---

Tone, Style, and Takeaway

• The hosts mix irreverent humor with sharp analysis, mocking the most outlandish claims while pinpointing the dangerous undertones of right-wing media fragmentation.
• Their language is direct, steeped in the frustration and exasperation of left-leaning observers watching the “MAGA infowar” spiral further out of control.
• The episode highlights the consequences of a highly propagandized, conspiracy-fueled ecosystem—and leaves listeners with a warning about grifters who profit through outrage and misinformation.

Final Thought:
Jennifer and Angie close by calling for vigilance and solidarity, pushing their audience to critically examine not just right-wing narratives, but also the left’s hesitance to challenge them head-on.

---

Transcript

[Host 1]

Foreign for us on the left to know what's going on on the right, because they have a massive media structure. It's massive. And one of their stars is, of course, Candace Owens, who our producer who prepared this episode, called her clandest, which I thought was hilarious. And Candace Owens has this very right wing rabid maga base and she's been able to kind of pop off because she's a big trans hater. And she's had this theory about Emmanuel Macron, the French president, that his wife is trans. And she's gets millions and millions and millions of views and she's been conducting an investigation into this. Well, then Charlie Kirk was murdered and Charlie Kirk was her friend. And now she's conducting an investigation into the murder of Charlie Kirk. And so let's just watch this clip right here to kind of set the soil of what we're going to take you through, what, what Candace is up to. Come Clandis. All right, play the clip to add.

[Host 2]

A little color to the story. I think that the people who did this, in what we've learned about those women, as I think they were probably who hired people that did the hiring, were probably trying to be funny. People that don't believe in spiritual forces, but contacted witches who are not trying to be funny. That's the, that's the problem when people don't understand that this stuff is real, that you're saying to which, yeah, I'll pay for you. I'm going to, you know, reach out to you to pay for you to put a curse on Charlie. And that which did that. And it brought, obviously, you can see they were distressed by this. They consulted a Catholic priest who I assume would have immediately conducted an exorcism that probably should have done in the Latin. Right. But I feel like that's just something that people should know because until something happens to you spiritually, you tend not to believe in these things. And like I said, that's a part of this. They very much know what religion they follow the numbers, numerology. It makes sense to them. The people that are in control of this world be very cautious.

[Host 1]

So she did this. And also Megyn Kelly did a whole clip about people putting curses on Charlie Kirk. They think this is real. They believe that this type of spiritual warfare is real. And they have been primed to believe this at a very early age. So you have to understand, these kids are deeply indoctrinated and religiously abused from a very young age. They're told, you're not good enough. You have to Be a good little girl, good little boy. Only Jesus can save you. And so it's the cycle of worthlessness and then rescue and worthlessness and then rescue. And it repeats over and over and over. And also they're told that there are demons and angels fighting around them all the time. And you hear this type of language expressed in the current administration when they talk about evil forces and good forces. They. They use this type of simple spiritual warfare type framing because it hits really hard in the base because they've been very primed for this. And I grew up in a Bible belt state and I can tell you with certainty that people believe in this type of magical thinking. They think it is very real. They believe in spiritual warfare and they're constantly on a shame, feel worthless, get rescued, cycle all day, every day, multiple times a day. And so they find themselves where people speak their language and say crazy things. And then next up, she reveals on her Insta stories. She goes on a rant about the alleged shooter, Tyler Robinson. Put this up. I want to break this news immediately because it feels important and I think if I don't break it immediately, something bad might happen. I hope I have earned the trust enough of the people to believe me when I say that I have verified this information but cannot reveal the source. Tyler Robinson is not suicidal. The entire narrative that was placed in the media about him having been suicidal is completely fictional, as are many other aspects of what we have been told. His father having, quote, turned him in after a confession is also complete fiction. To the contrary, Tyler Robinson maintains his innocence and has never even been to the UVU campus. There are absolutely zero photos or video that the campus can produce to the contrary, which is why they have produced nothing other than a blurry image which Tyler's family knows is not him. Tyler has never once expressed a suicidal thought. I want to make that clear. The federal government is lying about absolutely everything. Everything other than the fact that it is his gun. Not that we needed further substantiation, but Tyler Robinson did not author those discord messages. I would like to again stress that he has never been to UVU campus. But, and I need to confirm this later, I believe he was around the campus on that day. I will have more on this later, but I wanted to immediately publish that the Tyler Robinson suicide narrative, plus the quote, dad that did the right thing after realizing his son was guilty is a federal concoction. So as you can see, there's this whole vacuum on the right and it used to be filled with like, QAnon stuff like Hunter Biden stuff and Joe Biden. And Joe Biden's really dead and JFK Jr. Is running the country. All this crazy shit. And the thing is, you guys, these videos get millions and millions of views. Now I want to go on the record and say, I think Candace Owens is a grifter and she's grifting off of the death of her alleged very good friend Charlie Kirk. At the same time, I don't trust anything coming out of Cash Patel's FBI. If they had some smoking gun that Tyler Robinson was a radicalized leftist that had a penchant for trans people, it would be all over the place and pumps. You read something, there's a gag order on the case.

[Host 3]

Yes, the DOJ asked for a gag order so that no one involved in the case, lawyers, witnesses, can speak out, which I might remind everybody when Donald Trump was going through his many trials and threatening judges that he was furious about the gag order. But his Justice Department doesn't want to talk about any of this stuff. And I think we all can deduce why. And I hate to give Candace any.

[Host 1]

Credit, but she's right.

[Host 3]

Nobody can believe any of this bullshit because none of it seems true.

[Host 1]

Did the judge grant the gag order?

[Host 3]

Yes, the judge has granted it.

[Host 1]

Okay, So I just think that's interesting because usually in a case like this, you hear from the alleged, you know, criminal that from their lawyer, especially in a high profile case like this. So I thought, I think that's rather interesting. And I just want to emphasize here, Candace Owens is a grifter and she's conducting her own investigation and she is trying to exploit her friend's murder. The only thing I agree with her on is that we cannot trust Cashel. That's it. That's, that's where I completely separate from her. But she has a bunch of splintering theories about who did this. And here's one where she thinks that Israel killed Charlie Kirk. And I want to remind everybody, bizarrely, Benjamin Netanyahu has denied killing Charlie Kirk six times. Six times I've denied killing Charlie Kirk zero times. China has denied killing Charlie Kirk zero times. Ss, France, Great Britain, Spain, Germany, Italy. You catch my drift? So that shit's weird. And so then it plays into this whole right wing base that is really primed to traffic and conspiracy theories because they can't critically think. And so they just get fake fed this conspiracy theory entertainment.

[Host 2]

More than one event. But he had essentially what was staged, an intervention was staged by Bill Ackman because Charlie's thoughts Charlie's rational thoughts about Israel were a no, no, this is, this is not the route that you should be going on. And Charlie was surrounded by his friends, his, quote, unquote friends. Bill Ackman was very upset and threats were made.

[Host 1]

Okay, so Bill Ackman is this billionaire Trump thumper and he's the guy who writes like novels on Twitter. And apparently there was this, like, meeting at the Hamptons. But I will say that there is something. Israel has a problem both on the far left and the far right, because I think Americans in general, whether they're on the Republicans right or on the left, are tired of us funding a genocide. And we see all of our taxpayer money going over there. And here's the thing about Benjamin Netanyahu. He is a crook before he was a war criminal. He has been in and out of power for the last 30 something years. Like ever since I graduated from high school. He served 17 years total as Prime Minister. And something really important to realize about Benjamin Netanyahu is how manipulative he is. He sent carfuls. And this isn't conspiracy. This is confirmed by reporting by Israeli journalists, multiple Israeli journalists, and published by very esteemed publications. Benjamin Netanyahu paid millions of dollars and he sent suitcases full of cash from Israel to Gaza to fund Hamas to keep them in power, because he knew that he could stay in power longer if he was fighting them than fighting a more centrist, Palestinian style government. So Israel has even funded Hamas. And so as the Americans on the left and on the right, the center doesn't really stay as locked in to the news cycle as they start to discover more and more about just how awful Benjamin Netanyahu is. And then the people in his cabinet are just nauseating, like complete freaks that talk about ethnic cleansing. They talk about developing Gaza. And so it's. You can see how the, the soil is primed for conspiracies like this to completely pop up.

[Host 3]

Well, and you also have Netanyahu, who is, while denying he talks about how Charlie Kirk loved Israel. And that was one of the things that he was at odds with all these other.

[Host 1]

What I think is just weird and needy is like, how, like Netanyahu wants everybody to love Israel and you don't have to love Israel. Like, why do two women that are atheists that live in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, why do we have to love Israel? You know, like, why can't we just, you know, like there's this pressure, this propaganda that's been put on American people that we are supposed to love Israel. And it's all propaganda. I mean, it. I think it's a really weird thing when you step back and think about it, that we're all supposed to love Israel. And he's going on this campaign buying all of these TikTok influencers to try to get everybody to love Israel. And it's like, bitch, please, we have so many goddamn problems.

[Host 3]

Right? Why is America supposed to fund all this when they have free health care, free college, Right? I mean, you know, it's just bananas, but here's the deal. He needs America to give him the money, and he's got his buddy Donald Trump by the horse collar. He'll do whatever the fuck he wants.

[Host 1]

Yeah, okay. And then last, here is Candace, and she has a message for conservatives gunning to replace Charlie Kirk.

[Host 2]

I want to say this. It's important because I am angry. I will, obviously, I pray to move on from this phase, but it's a fire in my belly right now. To those of you who think that you are going to replace Charlie Kirk, Kings are born. You don't just get to depose and tell us that we're going to follow this individual, okay? I'm one of the masons of Turning Point usa. You put a shill in Charlie Kirk's chair, in Charlie Kirk's company, and you try to tell us to follow that individual. I will be an enemy of you. I don't.

[Host 1]

There will.

[Host 2]

There will be nothing that can stop me. Okay? And I want you guys to say, this is not a threat. This is a promise. There will be. These people are so crazy that can stop me. I will release every single text message. So to do those of you who are trying that I'm seeing the messages, I am telling you to back off right now.

[Host 1]

You guys, this is so psychotic. I mean, it's just unbelievable how psycho these people are, how emotionally stunted. Yes, they are, how immature they are. I mean, just. I mean, we started the thing with her talking about spiritual warfare and witches and all this, and now she's moved on to, you know, she's gonna kick ass and take names and for anybody that fills Charlie Kirk's chair and all this. I mean, like, are. Are all of these people that listen to all these right wing media, are they that weak that they have to have some leader on the Internet guide them through life?

[Host 3]

I think the answer to that appears to be yes.

[Host 1]

But here's the thing, which, by the way, we support. If you feel weak and need to.

[Host 3]

Listen to a podcast, just make it ours. That way you can buy Our book too.

[Host 1]

So anyway, just in, in wrapping that up, in summary, here's what I think is really interesting that will manifest if we get to the next election. New York Times had a report that came out, some polling that came out, Israel's polling really, really low in the United States right now, which what a relief considering we've all seen the images from Gaza. At the same time, we have Benjamin Netanyahu hiring all of these American influencers to put out all this pro Zionist and probably to suppress any sort of real imagery coming out of the horrific genocide and war crimes in Gaza. And so he's a propagandist, he's a fascist, he's basically a dictator, Benjamin Netanyahu. And I think he's facing like criminal charges for bribery and stuff in Israel. And he keeps getting all of that delayed. So he found another criminal propagandist and Donald Trump. And I think it's a very dangerous time. So I don't know, I don't know how to articulate this other than to say there is a consensus building on the right and on the left that Israel and Benjamin Netanyahu are not our friends, that they are using us for our money. There's a consensus building for that. And at the same time, if the Democrats were smart messengers, they could say, look at who else does the same thing. Kangas is doing this. He is using you rural Americans for your money. And we all know he's robbing the piggy bank and his friends are probably robbing the piggy bank and he's made billions of dollars in just nine months. But the messaging on the left is so beholden to Israel that they can't speak out with clarity about it because they're so scared of being called an anti Semite. When the anti Semites like Candace Owens giving a about Palestinian children but not giving a about gay kids in America, it tells you all you need to know. She cherry picks for money and for clicks which human rights she supports because none of us are free until all of us are free. And so a really good indicator of somebody who really walks the walk and talks. The talk is they leave no one behind and on the right they leave a lot of people behind. So it's just a weird thing. And then on top of all that, Candace is black with all these white racist followers. It's just right wing is weird, it's crazy.

[Host 3]

And she's a mason on the Charlie Kirk foundation that he said straight up that black women are not as smart as everybody else.

[Host 1]

Great point. It's weird. It's weird. It's really weird. All right. We just, we want to keep our eyes on what's going on with the grifters on the right because I think it's they have this huge media, huge media enterprise that gets millions and millions and millions of views and people just eat that up. So I think it's from time to time we need to just do a little check in. It's pretty interesting what's going on with the right wing media. All right. That's all we have by our book. We'll see you later.

[Ad Voice]

You open the fridge, there's nothing there. So what's it gonna be?

[Host 1]

Greasy pizza?

[Ad Voice]

Sad drive thru burgers. Dish by Blue Apron is for nights like that.

[Host 1]

These are the pre made meals of your dreams.

[Ad Voice]

At least 20 grams of protein. No artificial flavors or colors. No chopping, no cleanup. No guilt. Keep the flavor. Ditch the subscription. Get 20% off your first two orders with code APRON20. Terms and conditions apply. Visit blueapron.com terms for more.