Summary of "The Haymarket Affair" Episode on In Our Time
In Our Time, hosted by Melvyn Bragg on BBC Radio 4, dedicates its October 31, 2024 episode to exploring the Haymarket Affair—a pivotal event in labor history that has had lasting impacts on workers' movements worldwide. The discussion features experts Ruth Kinner, Gary Gerstel, and Christopher Phelps, who delve into the socio-political climate of late 19th-century America, the events of the Haymarket rally, the ensuing trial, and the affair's enduring legacy.
1. Historical Context: Labor-Industry Tensions in 19th Century America
Gary Gerstel, Paul Mellon Professor Emeritus of American History at Cambridge, sets the stage by outlining the rapid industrialization of the United States post-Civil War. This period was marked by unregulated capitalist growth, resulting in significant economic inequality and widespread worker exploitation. The absence of a welfare state left workers vulnerable, leading to increased unionization and frequent strikes.
"Capitalist development was unregulated, it was raw, it was rapid. And if you leave capitalists and their industries to their own devices, you get a cycle of boom and bust. Inequality is spreading."
— Gary Gerstel [01:59]
Gerstel emphasizes Chicago's explosive growth as an industrial hub, attracting vast numbers of immigrants who brought diverse languages, cultures, and radical ideologies, particularly anarchism. This melting pot environment intensified labor disputes, often escalating into violence due to the lack of peaceful resolution mechanisms.
2. The Haymarket Rally and Bombing Incident
Ruth Kinner, Professor of Political Theory at Loughborough University, explains that the Haymarket Affair unfolded against a backdrop of intense labor strife. On May 4, 1886, a worker’s rally in Haymarket Square, Chicago, advocating for an eight-hour workday, turned violent when a bomb was thrown at police officers. The explosion killed a policeman and injured many, sparking a chaotic shootout that resulted in multiple deaths.
"It was not the huge demonstration that they were expecting. It was winding down. By the evening, most of the speakers had left. There were only 2 of the people who would be arrested, who were still at the rally... someone tossed a bomb."
— Gary Gerstel [14:10]
The incident was immediately attributed to anarchists, despite the bomber never being conclusively identified. This misattribution fueled anti-anarchist sentiments and led to the arrest and trial of several labor activists.
3. Key Figures: Albert Parsons, August Spies, and Johann Most
Albert Parsons and Auguste Spies emerged as central figures in the aftermath of the Haymarket Affair. Parsons, a passionate labor activist and anarchist, had a profound background marked by his radicalization during the Civil War and his subsequent advocacy for workers' rights alongside his wife, Lucy Parsons.
"Nothing said in this courtroom over these weeks and months has proven anything about my involvement in this particular violent act."
— Albert Parsons [16:18]
Johann Most, though not present at the rally, was a prominent anarchist whose writings and advocacy for "propaganda by the deed"—the use of violence as a means to inspire revolutionary change—greatly influenced the movement. His manifesto, the Pittsburgh Manifesto, and his publication, Freiheit, played significant roles in shaping anarchist ideology in America.
4. The Trial and Its Implications
The subsequent trial was marred by bias and prejudice against anarchists. Ruth Kinner highlights that the prosecution's case was built on circumstantial evidence and a portrayal of anarchism as inherently violent and un-American.
"The prosecution persuade the jury... popular opinion was swayed by fear of foreign radicals who were seen as profoundly unamerican and profoundly threatening to the American way of life."
— Gary Gerstel [21:23]
The defendants were charged not with throwing the bomb but with conspiracy and inciting murder through their anarchist rhetoric and publications. Despite the lack of concrete evidence, eight anarchists were convicted, with four, including Parsons and Spies, ultimately being executed on November 11, 1887.
"The strongest evidence perhaps was against Ling because Ling was indeed found to have manufactured bombs and in fact proclaimed it."
— Ruth Kinner [19:12]
The trial underscored the judiciary's role in suppressing radical movements and set a precedent for persecuting individuals based on their beliefs rather than tangible actions.
5. International Reaction and Legacy
The executions sparked international outrage, transforming the Haymarket Affair into a global symbol of labor struggle. Intellectuals like Oscar Wilde and George Bernard Shaw advocated for clemency, and the event galvanized the international labor movement, leading to the establishment of May Day as International Workers' Day in honor of the martyrs.
"Four of them were dead, five of them were dead. But I think the reason that they become so important... because their standing, their status... encapsulate all that's best, if you like, in labour activism and anti-capitalist resistance."
— Ruth Kinner [39:23]
Despite its significance, May Day remains less celebrated in the United States compared to other countries, where it serves as a cornerstone of labor rights observance.
6. Decline and Rebirth of Anarchism in the US
In the decades following the Haymarket Affair, anarchism in the United States waned due to ongoing repression and the rise of state-centric socialism. Gary Gerstel notes that the refusal to abandon violent tactics hindered the movement's growth, leading to its marginalization.
"The refusal to renounce revolutionary violence in the United States hurt radicalism more than it helped it."
— Gary Gerstel [30:02]
However, towards the late 20th and early 21st centuries, anarchist ideals saw a resurgence, particularly in movements like Occupy Wall Street, reflecting a renewed interest in self-governance and opposition to state and corporate power.
7. Conclusion: Enduring Significance of the Haymarket Affair
The Haymarket Affair remains a potent symbol of the struggle for workers' rights and the complexities of labor movements. It highlights the lengths to which authorities may go to suppress dissent and the enduring spirit of those who fight for social justice.
"The legacy is profound in the form of workers and their unions saying, we will not rest until a better system of industrial relations comes to the United States."
— Gary Gerstel [35:43]
The episode concludes by reflecting on the dignity and martyrdom of the Haymarket anarchists, whose sacrifice continues to inspire labor movements and discussions about workers' rights and social equality today.
Notable Quotes from the Episode:
-
Gary Gerstel [01:59]: "Capitalist development was unregulated, it was raw, it was rapid. And if you leave capitalists and their industries to their own devices, you get a cycle of boom and bust. Inequality is spreading."
-
Albert Parsons [16:18]: "Nothing said in this courtroom over these weeks and months has proven anything about my involvement in this particular violent act."
-
Gary Gerstel [21:23]: "The prosecution persuade the jury... popular opinion was swayed by fear of foreign radicals who were seen as profoundly unamerican and profoundly threatening to the American way of life."
-
Ruth Kinner [39:23]: "Four of them were dead, five of them were dead. But I think the reason that they become so important... because their standing, their status... encapsulate all that's best, if you like, in labour activism and anti-capitalist resistance."
-
Gary Gerstel [35:43]: "The legacy is profound in the form of workers and their unions saying, we will not rest until a better system of industrial relations comes to the United States."
This episode of In Our Time provides a comprehensive exploration of the Haymarket Affair, offering listeners a deep understanding of its causes, events, and long-term effects on labor movements and political ideologies both in America and globally.