Transcript
Rabbi Ami Hirsch (0:00)
Rabbi.
Dr. Barry White (0:01)
I'm Rabbi Ami Hirsch of the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue in New York. And you're listening to in these Times.
Dr. Joanna Sleva (0:12)
The Countess Janina Sukadolska saved as many as 10,000 prisoners from the Majdanek concentration camp in Nazi occupied Poland. Fluent in German, this self assured aristocratic woman negotiated with the Nazi and SS officials in Lublin to secure the release of thousands of Poles at Majdanek and save thousands more through deliveries of food and medicine. Countess Sukadolska was stubborn and persistent. She never accepted no for an answer, and when she got a yes, she considered it an invitation to ask for more. It might not be so surprising that this noble and elegant woman was secretly a member of the Polish resistance. But her comrades in the underground Polish Home army had no idea that Countess Janina Sukhadowska was in actuality a Jew and not a countess at all, and that her real name was Janina Mahlberg. Janina died in Chicago in 1969 and her story was almost lost to history. Eventually, Dr. Barry White, a Holocaust historian and Department of Justice Nazi hunter, received Janina's incomplete memoir, A new mother with a busy job. Barry had neither the time nor the Polish language skills to verify the incredible account. But haunted by a sense of responsibility to history, Barry eventually connected with Dr. Joanna Slieva, an expert on the Holocaust in Poland, and the two set about researching Janina's story. Published in January of this year, their book, the Counterfeit Countess, brings Janina's story to light in stunning detail. Dr. White and Dr. Sleva, welcome to in these Times.
Rabbi Ami Hirsch (2:08)
Thank you so much for having us. This is a great opportunity for which we are very grateful.
Dr. Barry White (2:14)
I was very taken by the fantastic story that came to light by virtue of your research.
Dr. Joanna Sleva (2:23)
Before we even get into the story itself, there's a background story to how you discovered all the details of Janina's life.
Dr. Barry White (2:30)
So can you tell us about that? It took quite a few years to uncover her story and verify it.
Rabbi Ami Hirsch (2:37)
Yes. Well, this goes all the way back to 1989, when I gave an academic conference paper on Maidanic concentration camp, which was located in German occupied Lublin, Poland during World War II. After the panel, a historian I didn't know handed me a package containing a carbon copy manuscript. He said it was the memoir of Janina Melberg, a Polish Jewish mathematician who had aided prisoners at Majdanek while pretending to be a Polish Christian aristocrat. Maelberg had died in Chicago in 1969. She didn't have any children and there had been efforts to publish the memoir, but they hadn't succeeded. So this historian was going to give it to a couple of archives, including at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. But he really wanted me to take this copy because I was writing about Majdanek, and so he hoped that I could make the story known. So I read this story with just increasing astonishment, because Janina Mailbert claimed that she survived the Holocaust in German occupied Poland by posing as the Countess Sukhodowska. And she used this aristocratic guise to become an official of a Polish relief organization that the Germans allowed to operate in Poland, but only to help non Jewish Poles. Her job included negotiating with Nazi and SS officials in Lublin because she had flawless German. And so she was, according to her memoir, extraordinarily persistent in her negotiations. And a particular focus of her efforts was at Majdanek, where she continually badgered the SS for permission for her organization to bring in ever increasing quantities of supplies for the prisoners, to the point that she was bringing in food and other supplies for thousands of prisoners five days a week. And she brought these deliveries herself inside the camp, a place where 63,000 Jews were murdered in gas chambers and shooting pits. And she not only brought these deliveries, but she also used them as cover to smuggle messages and supplies from members of the resistance imprisoned in the camp. So I found this story so incredible that I really had to question whether it was true. I could imagine writing something about the memoir and then having the real countess of her descendants come forward and accuse me of fraud. So I couldn't use the memoir without verifying it, and I didn't have any way to do so then, particularly because I don't know Polish. So I figured another historian would come across it in the archives and do what was necessary to bring it to light. But that didn't happen for years. Decades. And I never forgot this incredible story. And so then in 2017, I really started digging into who Nina Naelberg was. And I found just enough to make me think that she probably was the countess. And that's when I reached out to Joanna, whom I only knew by reputation as an expert on the Holocaust in Poland. And when she read the memoir, she was all in for investigating Janina's life and bringing her memoir to light.
