Podcast Summary: Why Are Populists Winning?

Intelligence Squared | March 27, 2026

Host: Will Hutton

Guest: Liam Byrne, Labour MP and Author

Episode Overview

This episode of Intelligence Squared features political economist and Labour MP Liam Byrne discussing his new book, Why Populists Are Winning and How to Beat Them. Will Hutton, former editor-in-chief of The Observer, hosts the conversation, which explores the surge of right-wing populism across Western democracies, its psychological and economic underpinnings, its funding and media ecosystem, and strategies for the political center to respond effectively.

Key Discussion Points

1. Defining Right-Wing Populism

(02:02 - 06:04)

• Thin vs. Thick Populism:
  • Byrne distinguishes right-wing populism as "authoritarian populism," marked by three features:
    • Appeasement: Particularly towards Russia in foreign policy.
    • Autocracy: Domestically strongman leadership.
    • Avarice: An intensely self-enriching business model.
    • Quote:

      "Appeasement, autocracy, and avarice is kind of three of the things that they've got in common." — Liam Byrne (03:35)

• Semantic Analysis: Byrne’s research highlights three rhetorical tropes in populist speeches:
  • National renewal through an ethno-nationalist story of decline.
  • Nostalgia for a lost "better" past.
  • Creation of a sense of emergency requiring strongman intervention.

  • "It's a struggle for national renewal, but set against this kind of ethno nationalist story of decline... nostalgia and a hunger for something lost... and a sense of emergency crisis, struggle, which of course can only be solved by a strong man..." — Liam Byrne (05:00)

2. Populist Strategy vs. Mainstream Political Storytelling

(06:04 - 08:36)

• Hutton challenges Byrne to explain what sets populism apart from standard political narrative techniques.
• Byrne points to the overtly autocratic style, close ties to Russian interests, and the "Nostronomics" (economics of nostalgia), a longing for the economic structures of the past.

3. Racial and Ethno-nationalist Undercurrents

(09:53 - 12:36)

• Hutton presses Byrne on whether populism is inherently racist. Byrne points to the "Great Replacement Theory," which alleges that immigration and progressive changes are eroding the "native" population.

  > "It's that they're all kind of, of a type, but they're basically taking aim at foreigners, especially if they're Mexican or Muslim. And so it really isn't very far before you get into some pretty racialized tropes.” — Liam Byrne (12:07)
  

4. The Five Tribes of Reform Voters

(13:47 - 14:55)

• Byrne introduces five kinds of populist-leaning voters, uncovered through original polling:
  • Disgusted disruptors
  • Left-behind collectivists
  • Traditional conservatives
  • Melancholy middle
  • Civic pragmatists
• Emphasizes targeting messages at the pragmatic middle rather than hard-core populists.

5. The Supply Side: Money, Message, Media

(16:03 - 24:29)

• Populists as Political Entrepreneurs:
  • "They have invented this message, they've invented a social media system and the money is jaw dropping." — Liam Byrne (16:05)
• Algorithmic Outrage:
  • Populist messaging thrives in outrage-driven social media environments, amplifying their reach.
• Media Ecosystem Construction:
  • £173 million spent on right-wing media ecosystem in the UK over 5 years, largely from just four major donors (Marshall, Chandler, Hoskins, Harbor).
  • Ties to American Christian right and Russian interests, with similar figures involved.

  • "From the CIA estimates, we know that the Russian intelligence service has put in about the same amount over the last 10 years as well." — Liam Byrne (21:46)

• Learning from Gramsci:
  • Populists seek cultural dominance before political power, guided by the maxim: "Politics is downstream of culture." — Citing Andrew Breitbart (22:47)

6. The Economic and Social Drivers

(26:40 - 33:24)

• Stagnant wage growth since the financial crash and decreased social capital leading to multi-generational decline.

• Populist voters are increasingly pessimistic, financially under pressure, feel dispossessed, and angry at broken politics.

  > "For many people... the collapse of local high streets is for many people the most potent symbol of whether the community is going forward or backwards." — Liam Byrne (44:00)
  

• The "anger is visceral and real"—populism is what rebellion looks like in a democracy.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Nostalgia and Populist Messaging:

  "They couple it with what I call Nostronomics... the economics of trying to recover the past." — Liam Byrne (06:51)

• On Populists’ Use of Social Media:

  "Their message structure actually rhymes with the logic of algorithmic amplification... Social media companies are doing it for money, populist politicians are doing it for votes." — Liam Byrne (18:16)

• On Funding Sources:

  "Most of the money comes from four people... but, you know, they have built this extraordinary political media complex in the UK." — Liam Byrne (21:07)

• On Economic Impact:

  "Populists are a disaster economically because they do go to war with the institutions that help ensure an economy runs." — Liam Byrne (39:21)

• On Democratic Rebellion:

  "Populism is what rebellion looks like in a democracy." — Liam Byrne (33:24)

• On Roosevelt as Inspiration:

  "You gotta ride the storm and... use the legitimate anger that is out there to actually build a different kind of progressive politics for this new era." — Liam Byrne (53:09)

Prescriptions: How to Beat Populism

(40:17 - 49:52)

1. National Renewal and a New Story

• Counter nostalgia with a credible vision for the future and a "story about national renewal."
• Message Target: Don’t attack the outsider—focus on the "selfish minority" (insider cartels) that hold back economic progress.

2. Aggressive Fairness and Regulation

• Be assertive towards companies "shortchanging their workers, screwing their customers, or dodging their taxes."
  • More interventionist on consumer protection and the regulation of market abuses.

3. A Renewed Opportunity Economy

• Public investment in technology, small business support, and local infrastructure.
• Proposals for sovereign wealth funds and universal basic capital (asset-building for all).

4. Strengthening Civic Society

• Promote hyperlocal agency—give communities power and resources to revitalize public institutions and local high streets.
• Foster "civic gospel": pride in place and active community engagement.

5. Tackling Inequality Directly

• Address wealth and income inequality through fairer taxation, reinvest wealth tax revenues to strengthen individual assets (housing, pensions, retraining).
• Universal basic capital proposal, funded by wealth taxes.

Challenges and Skepticism

(45:07 - 51:41)

• Hutton presses on whether Britain's political and regulatory institutions have the will to act assertively—a critique agreed by Byrne.
• Points to overlap with some populist economic prescriptions but underscores need for a progressive, civic vision.

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Defining Populism & the "Three A's": 02:55–06:04
• Racial and Ethnic Underpinnings (Great Replacement Theory): 09:53–12:36
• Five Populist Voter Tribes: 13:47–14:55
• Engineering Outrage: Social Media & Funding: 16:03–24:29
• Economic and Social Roots: 26:40–33:24
• Policy Prescriptions for the Center: 40:17–49:52
• Roosevelt Analogy & Final Thoughts: 51:41–53:38

Conclusion

Liam Byrne’s analysis posits that right-wing populism is driven by a mix of nostalgic longing, economic grievance, cultural displacement, and sophisticated digital plus financial engineering. To counter it, he advocates for a politics that is simultaneously bold, assertively fair, and rooted in civic renewal. Both speakers agree: the coming struggle will be fought as much on stories, values, and community agency as on policies and electoral strategies.

Further Reading:

• Why Populists Are Winning and How to Beat Them by Liam Byrne
• The Inequality of Wealth by Liam Byrne

For more debates and deep dives, visit Intelligence Squared.