Loading summary
Transcript18 lines
- [00:00]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. You chose to hit play on this podcast today. Smart Choice make another smart choice with Auto Quote Explorer to compare rates from multiple car insurance companies all at once. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in all states or situations. Prices vary based on how you buy.
- [00:28]
Mayra Amit
A Mochi moment from Sadie who writes I'm not crying, you're crying. This is what I said during my first appointment with my physician at Mochi because I didn't have to convince him I needed a GLP one. He understood and I felt supported, not judged. I came for the weight loss and stayed for the empathy. Thanks Sadie. I'm Mayra Amit, founder of Mochi Health. To find your mochi moment, visit joinmochi.com.
- [00:53]
Peyton Moreland
Join Sadie is emoji member compensated for her story? You're listening to an Ono Media podcast. Hey everyone and welcome back to the into the Dark podcast. I'm your host Peyton Moreland. I'm so glad you are here and listening or watching. Happy Holidays everyone. If you celebrate, I hope you have an amazing week filled with whatever it is that you want to fill your holiday with. I know holidays can be hard for a lot of people. I don't particularly love holidays days, so just know I am here with you. It is just another week if that is how you feel. My 10 seconds. There is a ramen place near Garrett and I's home and let me tell you, I love like top ramen. I grew up eating top ramen a lot but I have never loved big fancy authentic ramen. So anyways there is a new chain place, I think it's a chain, it's called Jinya Ramen. It is near our home and they just have like a plain spicy chicken ramen. It's just thin noodles, chicken, green onion, spicy sauce, bean sprouts. Honestly so good. So freaking good. And I have been eating it so much multiple times a week. Okay, I order it. I will go there and get it. Get pickup. I will go eat at the restaurant. The vibe is so fun. Honestly. Okay, just my favorite place that really doesn't even matter. All this to say there is something in my Jinya ramen order that my stomach does not like. Okay. I don't like immediately finish immediately. I've got stomach cramps that are giving me the sweatshirt and if you know, you know. Okay. They are hurting so bad I can barely sit still and it's just cramping and cramping. Okay. There is something about that ramen that my Stomach absolutely revolts against every single time. Okay? And it only lasts for about 15:20 minutes and then it goes away. Hence why I continue eating it. I am only telling you this because do you think that this spicy ramen is eating my stomach? What is going on? Anyways? I love it so much. I will continue to eat it until I get tired of it. But my stomach does not like it. Does anyone else experience this? And it can't be like killing me, right? Like it can't be hurting me. It's just like my stomach doesn't like it, right? I don't know. Anyways, that's my obsession with Junior Ramen. If you don't know, now you know. You guys know I love a good micro obsession. And that is mine. Currently that is all I have for my 10 seconds. Let's get into today's episode now. Trigger Warning this episode includes discussions of physical abuse, sexual assault, self harm and violence against animals. I will always give you a trigger warning against that one in story, but please listen with care. I want to start today's episode with an idea that shouldn't be controversial. There is no good reason to murder someone. Most people would agree with that statement. It doesn't matter how angry you are, how broke you are, or what your mental health situation is. It is never okay. Still, sometimes you hear about a murder case where the motive makes sense and it doesn't make sense, but our brains can fathom. And then sometimes it stuns you because it seems even more senseless, pointless and impossible to understand than usual. Where the killer took someone's life for reasons that are completely baffling or arbitrary. It's hard to wrap your head around. And today's case is just that. So let's go back to late July of 2004. That is when a 22 year old woman named Erin Bellinger was living in an Orlando suburb called Deltona, Florida, not Daytona, Deltona. Now, Aaron wasn't originally from Florida. She was actually from Massachusetts. But Aaron was young, she didn't have much work experience and her parents thought she would be better off looking for a job in Florida. The cost of living was lower than it would be back home, and Aaron believed there would be less competition for the kinds of positions she was looking for in adulthood. The good news was that Erin wasn't completely on her own. For one thing, she had a boyfriend, 30 year old Francisco A.O. roman. He lived with her and he was also job searching with her. She also had family in Deltona, or at least she did for about half of the year, Aaron's grandparents owned a house in town where they stayed over the winter and then in the summers they would go to Maine. So that summer, Aaron's grandparents weren't in Deltona with her. Their house was supposed to be empty. And Aaron had her own separate house just four miles away, which she shared with roommates. Now for the rest of this episode, I will refer to Aaron's home as the Deltona house because it's going to be important. And every now and then, Aaron would drive through her grandparents neighborhoods just to check on their place, make sure everything was okay while they were away for the summer. Want to make sure the yard was trimmed, the lights were off, everything was where it was supposed to be except beginning around June or July, Aaron began to notice something odd. This same car was always parked in front of her grandparents house in Florida. And at first she thought it could have belonged to the neighbors or someone who was just visiting the block. But each time she passed through, Aaron keeps seeing the same car. And by July 30, Aaron thought this was strange enough that she actually decided to just park and watch. She walked up to the garage eventually and peered through a window. And that was when she saw a mattress lying on the floor in her grandparents garage. Of course this is odd. Her grandparents don't have any mattresses in their garage. Nobody else was supposed to have access to the house while her grandparents were gone. So she gets a bad feeling about the situation. Erin decides to call the police to report that she thought someone had broken into her grandparents home while they were away. Now later that day, a pair of officers responded to investigate and sure enough, there were a man and a boy inside the house. They were squatters, people who didn't know Erin or her grandparents, but had basically broken into the house to live in it rent free. Now one of the squatters was a minor and the other was a 27 year old man named Troy Victorino. Now if I can only tell you one thing about Troy, it is that he had a very rough background. His personal challenges began during his childhood. This is the squatter, okay. According to Troy, he was sexually abused by a neighborhood teenager when he was very young. And his father was also physically violent at home. On top of that. Now Troy frequently showed up at elementary school with bruises and belt marks on his body. And when teachers contacted child services, Troy's father admitted to beating him, claiming, no, this is how I discipline my son. And apparently anytime Troy acted up or broke the rules, his father smacked him sometimes he used his fists, but he frequently used a belt. Now, in spite of this, the authorities chose not to remove Troy from his household. They let him stay under his father's care, where the violence continued. And to make matters worse, Troy had a protective streak, especially so far as his siblings were concerned. He didn't want his father to hurt his little brothers or sisters. So whenever his dad seemed angry or aggressive, Troy would get in trouble on purpose. That way, his father would focus all of his anger on him and not on the other kids. So needless to say, this was not a healthy way to grow up. And Troy struggled emotionally and mentally. He engaged in self harm and actually attempted to take his own life multiple times before his 18th birth day. Now, on top of that, Troy began committing crimes when he was a teenager. He abused drugs and alcohol and also sold them to other people. And of course, eventually the law caught up with him. When Troy was just 15 years old, he was arrested for stealing a car. Now, Troy spent some time in prison, and then when he got out, he committed another crime, this time a violent one. In 1996, Troy was arrested for aggravated battery. And this led to another prison sentence. And when Troy got out eight years later, it was almost the summer of 2004. He almost immediately got into a fist fight with someone else. This was a parole violation, the sort of thing that could get him tossed back into prison. But the officials agreed to look the other way and just give him another chance. The problem was that even with this lucky break, Troy was still in a rough position. He had absolutely nowhere to go. It obviously wasn't an option for him to move back in with his parents. He actually asked them, but they refused to let him come back. Troy's been in prison for a while. He doesn't have a job or money. He doesn't even have a car because his had been towed. It was a hopeless position to be in. But then Troy got a tip from a friend of his. For context, this friend knew Aaron. Aaron is the woman watching over her grandparents home. The woman I mentioned at the start of this episode. And this friend connecting the two was also aware that her grandparents were out of town and their house was empty. So basically the friend went to Troy and told him, hey, I have a friend named Aaron. And she's watching over a house. It should be easy to break into. It was going to be vacant for the rest of the summer. It was safe for Troy to live there and he didn't have to pay rent, pass a background check, or deal with landlord's Rules. So with this friend's help, Troy got into Aaron's grandparents home. He laid out a mattress on the floor of the garage and brought his things over, like all of his clothes, even an Xbox system. It wasn't much, but it was all Troy had after getting out of prison. And eventually he started feeling a bit more comfortable at the house. Enough so that he made some stupid, reckless decisions. He stole some of the grandparents things so he could resell them for quick cash. Eventually he gets his car back and he begins parking it out front just in the open. And when he learned that some other friends were looking for a place to live, he invited them to just stay at this empty house too. In fact, Troy begins throwing parties at the place. So basically he's not even being careful or hiding the fact that he's squatting. It was inevitably that eventually Aaron would see his car and his mattress and call the police. So now we're caught back up. And when the officers came to investigate, they obviously found Troy. They knew he didn't own the house. In fact, after Aaron had called to report the car, the officers had spoken to her grandparents to explain what was going on because they are the owners of the house. And the grandparents confirmed that they didn't know who Troy was and he didn't have permission to be there. So. But they also said they didn't want to press charges. So the officials told Troy he wasn't in any trouble. He wasn't even under arrest. But he did have to leave immediately. He didn't have enough time to gather his things before he left the house. So once they were gone, the officers called Aaron and asked her to come back. Go through the home to see if everything was there, is anything missing, make sure it's locked up. And they also encouraged her to remove Troy's things from the house. So she tossed all of his stuff into a box. And then she asked the police, what am I supposed to do with it? They're like, it doesn't matter. She could keep it, she could throw it out, she'd give it to charity. It's her call. He was a squatter, he left it here. But Aaron didn't want the stuff. So she asked around to see if any of her friends wanted it. She gave a few things away, she threw the rest in the garbage. And finally she made sure her grandparents doors were all locked and everything was secure so Troy and his friends couldn't get back in.
- [13:38]
ADT Announcer
It's that time of year again when you start arranging pumpkins on the stoop. Try out a new cranberry sauce recipe and plan out a tablescape that'll outdo last year's. In other words, it's when you break out all your DIY holiday skills. And now ADT is making it easy to DIY your home security too. Their systems aren't just simple to set up, they also fit within your budget. So get excited for your next project because your peace of mind just went DIY. Visit ADT.com or call 1-800-ADT ASAP. When every second counts, count on ADT.
- [14:15]
Peyton Moreland
So good, so good, so good.
- [14:17]
Nordstrom Rack Announcer
Give big, save big with RACC Friday deals at Nordstrom RAC. For a limited time, take an extra 40% off red tag clearance for a total Savings up to 75% off. Save on gifts for everyone on your list from brands like Vince Cole, Haan, Sam Edelman and more. All sales final and restrictions apply. The best stuff goes fast, so bring your gift list and your wish list to your nearest Nordstrom rack today.
- [14:42]
Peyton Moreland
Okay, to recap, Troy had never even met Aaron before. He only knew about the empty house because of their mutual friend. Now, after Troy got evicted, Aaron, he reached out to that friend to say, hey, they kicked me out and I've lost all my stuff. He needed to get it back and he didn't know who to talk to. So the friend gave him Aaron's name and address. And then that same evening, just hours after Troy was kicked out of the house, he allegedly showed up at Aaron's home. Now, it's hard to say for sure because witness statements were contradictory. I do know Aaron was at home with her roommates and everyone agreed that several people showed up at their front door. But it is hard to say how many were there and if Troy was even with them. The point is, is that as soon as Aaron answered the door, the new arrivals were like, hey, we need Troy's stuff back again. I don't know if Troy's with them and Aaron has no idea what they're talking about. It took some back and forth, but eventually she realized, oh, Troy's the squatter and he wants the things that he left in my grandparents home. And she's like, hey, I don't have the stuff anymore. Like as soon as police got there, I handled it. She explained she'd thrown a lot of it out, even given some things away. And this made the people who were here for Troy or Troy very angry. They told her that she'd had no right to get rid of Troy's stuff and they weren't gonna leave until they got it back. Now eventually Aaron calls the police and is like, help. Before the officers could arrive, the people at the front step left. They didn't want to get into any legal trouble. But very late that same night they come back. Okay, they pounded on Aaron's front door and rang the doorbell demanding that she come out. Now of course Aaron doesn't answer. She stays inside where it's Safe and she calls 911 again. And once more the people at the door leave before anyone can get arrested. But I think it's safe to say this was not over for Troy. The next day he actually went back to the grandparents house for himself. He tries to get inside, peer through the windows, see if his stuff is still there. But of course the garage had been cleaned out. And that's when Troy calls the police to complain. Okay, this is a mess. Calls the police. Now he tells the officer someone had broken into his home and stolen his things. Which of course isn't true. The good news was that as soon as the detective looked up the address Troy gave, they saw the report on what happened the day before. They were like, okay, are you the owner of the home? He admits he isn't. He'd just been living there and he wanted his clothes and his other things back. The police are like, yeah, we can't help you. This is not your home. They had the right to get rid of this stuff. They explained, you know, this isn't, there's no crime been committed. Nobody has stolen your stuff. It was left behind. And this is when Troy literally tells the officer on this 911 call, don't worry, I'll take care of it myself. And then he hung up. And just like he said he'd do, Troy really did decide to take care of the matter for himself. He had to get his property back by any means necessary. And he wanted to punish Aaron for calling the police on him in the first place, getting him kicked out of her grandparents house and then getting rid of his stuff. So on August 4th, Troy reached out to three friends of his. Their names were Jaron Hunter, Michael Salas and Robert Cannon. Troy told his three friends the same thing he had told the police. You know, Aaron stole from me. And unlike the police, they were like, yeah, this is bad. Aaron was definitely in the wrong. She had disrespected Troy and she needed to be taught a lesson. You can't just take people's things. So they all agreed to go to the Deltona house for revenge. This is Aaron's home. They spent the next Two days planning this attack, okay? It was modeled on a movie that Troy had seen recently called Wonderland. Now, in this film, a group of home invaders broke into a house and beat the people living there with aluminum bats. Troy wanted to do something similar to Aaron and the people that lived in her home. He also told everyone exactly how all of the rooms in Aaron's house were laid out. Presumably, someone had gotten a look at this during one of the earlier visits. And he knew the house was big and there were a lot of places to hide. So he suggested, all of us are going to split up once we get inside. These are four. Four men, okay? He says that way they could cover more ground, make sure nobody got away. Troy told everyone to bring a clean set of clothes with them so they could change if they did get blood on themselves. They're attacking everyone in this home, okay? Not just Aaron. Jaren wanted a face mask. He wanted to hide his identity. But Troy was like, you're not going to need to. According to him beforehand, he tells his friends, there are not going to be any living witnesses by the time we leave this house. And then finally, on the evening of August 6th, just one week after Troy's eviction, him and his friends put their plan into action. They started by driving to a Walmart, and each man bought an aluminum bat there. Then they drove to the Deltona house and parked out front. At this point, it was about one in the morning and the home was packed. That night, Erin was there with her three roommates, including her boyfriend Francisco. She also lived with a friend from work named Michelle and Nathan, who was just 19 years old. And finally, the fourth person was Michelle's boyfriend, Anthony Vega. Now, on top of that, there were two house guests staying over for the night. Their names were Jonathan Gleason and Roberto Gonzalez, who went by Tito. I know I just threw a lot of names at you, but we have Aaron and Michelle, the two girls, their two boyfriends at the house with them, and then two other friends, so six people total. And the two other friends, Anthony and Roberto, who went by Tito, worked with Aaron and Michelle at a local Burger King. Okay? So six people, two girls, two boyfriends, two coworkers, and then we have four men coming to attack the six people in this house. Okay? Now, both of the friends were scheduled to be on the opening shift in the morning, meaning they had to wake up very early. And they were staying at Aaron's house because it was close to work, the commute was shorter, they could get a little bit more sleep. These are the two co worker friends. Six people in this house, feeling safe and secure. Everyone was in bed. Some were asleep. Others were trying to fall asleep. But then, in the middle of this night, Troy, the squatter, kicked the front door open. He and his friends tried to be quiet so as not to wake any of their victims or give them a chance to escape. So instead, they went straight toward the kitchen. There, each of them grabbed a knife, and finally they spread out. Now, even though they were trying to be quiet, they kicked the door open. Michelle heard it. This is the roommate. And she instinctively knew she was in danger. So she had immediately ducked into her closet and. And pulled the door closed, hoping the attackers wouldn't find her. And for extra camouflage, she'd actually thrown some dirty clothes on top of her. That way, if someone did look in the closet, they wouldn't realize she was inside. But while she's hiding in this closet, okay. She hears horrifying sounds as the men start finding their victims. Screams, beatings. She realizes while hiding in this closet that there were people intruding on her home and beating her friends. I mean, this is straight out of a scary movie, but this is a real life story, you guys. Michelle is hiding in her closet. And then, to her horror, the closet door swung open in the middle of this attack, and it was Jiren. He had his bat in one hand and a knife in the other. He saw right through her hiding place. He tosses the dirty clothes aside, exposing her. And while Michelle screamed for help, Jarin alternated between stabbing and beating her. And by the time he was done, Michelle was dead. Her remains were so badly bruised and beaten, she'd later have to be identified by her tattoos. From there, Jaron went into Anthony's bedroom. Now, even though Anthony and Michelle were dating, he's one of the boyfriends. They had separate rooms with separate beds at their house. And sadly, Jaron found Anthony and killed him, too. And in the meantime, Troy had crept into Aaron's room. She was in bed with her boyfriend, Francisco. But as soon as Troy opened the door, her dog George began barking and trying to protect Aaron. Unfortunately, he was a tiny dog, and Troy was a big man. So animal cruelty. He kills George, okay, just immediately. And then turns toward the couple. He murdered Francisco quickly, but he takes his time with Aaron. She's the whole reason he's here. He beat her with a bat. He stabbed her. He slit her throat. But even once Aaron was done breathing, he wasn't finished with her. He wanted to humiliate her. So he sexually assaulted and mutilated her body before leaving her room. And finally, before they went home, Jaron and Troy murdered the two other guests that weren't roommates. The co workers, Tito and Jonathan. And by the time they were done, just like they had planned, nobody in this house was left alive. So Troy, Jaron, Michael, and Robert thought that they had committed a perfect murder. They had gotten their revenge on Aaron, which was the sole purpose. They even came up with this plan. And they had eliminated all of the witnesses. But Troy and his friends didn't realize that the clock was already ticking for them. Remember Aaron's house guests, Anthony and Tito? They were supposed to work an early shift at Burger King that morning. So when the both of them didn't show up for work, their manager found it very strange. And they called around to see if anyone knew where they were, if they were maybe sick, had they been in a car accident on the way to work. And eventually, the manager spoke to someone who was friends with Anthony, Tito and Aaron. And the friends knew? No. The two men were actually just staying at Aaron's house. Remember, all of these people work at Burger King. So the manager goes to Aaron's house to check in on his two employees that didn't show up for work. And when he arrived, he found the front door unlocked. Nobody came when he knocked or rang the doorbell. So he just let himself inside. And this is when he sees the horrifying crime scene. Okay, there is blood everywhere. Red splatters coated the walls, the floors. It was smeared across every single room of the house. Not that the friend spent a lot of time searching. The moment he saw the blood, he left because he's too afraid to look any further. You have to remember, these people were beaten to death and stabbed to death. Now, once the manager was outside, he called the police. The friend admitted that he hadn't seen any bodies. He just know. He knew something bad had happened. But he was completely convinced at least one person was dead inside the house.
- [26:11]
Marshalls Announcer
Marshall's buyers are hustling hard to get amazing new gifts into stores right up to the last minute. Like a designer perfumer for that friend who never RSVP'd wishlist topping toys for her kids who came too. Belgian chocolates for the neighbor. A cozy scarf for your boss. And a wool jacket for your husband that you definitely did not almost forget. Marshalls, we get the deals, you get the good stuff.
- [26:36]
Peyton Moreland
Even at the last minute. Phew.
- [26:38]
Marshalls Announcer
Find a Marshall's near you.
- [26:42]
Jack Daniels Announcer
This episode is brought to you by. Jack Daniels, Jack Daniels and music are made for each Other, they share a rhythm in the craft of making something timeless while being a part of legendary nights. From backyard jams to sold out arenas, there's a song in every toast. Please drink responsibly. Responsibility.org, jack Daniels, and Old no. 7 are registered trademarks. Tennessee whiskey, 40% alcohol by volume. Jack Daniel Distillery, Lynchburg, Tennessee.
- [27:06]
Peyton Moreland
So a few officers responded, came to investigate, and as soon as they got in there, they were stunned by the brutality of this crime scene, particularly when they found Aaron's body. She had been the primary target, the main person Troy wanted to hurt, and he had beaten her worse than anyone. Police couldn't even identify her from dental records. You guys. Her teeth had been smashed beyond recognition. One officer from the sheriff's office said, this is the worst thing I've seen in my career. The brutal force used against the victims, it's indescribable. This is horrible. No one. No one should ever be taken this way. The good news was that once the bodies were found, the investigation moved quickly. After all, the police knew that Troy had been evicted one week before the murders. They knew he'd apparently come to the Deltona house multiple times in the past week. Aaron had called the police twice, and then he had called the station to complain about his missing clothes and his Xbox mere days before the murder. On top of that, the officers collected blood samples and DNA at the scene of the crime. They knew it would take a while for the lab to run tests and confirm who they'd come from, but the detectives obviously had strong suspicions that at least some of it would match Troy. They also found bloody footprints in the house, which clearly hadn't been left by Aaron or the other victims. So, once again, the police collected all of the samples while assuming that they'd later be able to prove Troy had left them. And more importantly, the police got a tip involving one of Troy's ex girlfriends. Now, I don't know the woman's name, but I do know she lived in an apartment complex that had a big artificial pond near it. And a search team found an aluminum bat coated in blood near the pond, thanks to Troy's ex girlfriend. It was one of the murder weapons. Clearly, one of the killers had dumped it there. Police divers retrieved the other three bats from the pond itself. This is obviously when they realized how many accomplices Troy actually had. Four bats meant probably four killers. So now that they had DNA evidence, boot prints and fingerprints and the bats, they also knew that Troy had broken his parole earlier that month. Remember, he had punched A man in July. And while the police had been willing to look the other way back then, they could move forward now. Even though they still couldn't prove that Troy had killed Aaron, they had enough evidence to at least arrest him for the parole violation. So they brought him into the station on that same day, August 7th. And in the process, they noted that at the station, Troy literally showed up with blood on his boots. They were also the exact same size and shape as some of the prints left at the Deltona house. So the case against Troy was coming together. But during his interrogation, Troy claims to police he had nothing to do with the murders. According to him, he'd vented to Jaren, Michael and Robert, his other three friends, and about his missing clothes and Xbox. And they were such good friends and loved him so much that they decided to take matters into their own hands on his behalf. Basically, he said, yeah, I'm the reason the murders happen, but I wasn't there. Jiren, Michael and Robert, my other three friends, they're the murderers. He was innocent. Well, based on his statement, the police decided to also interrogate Troy's three friends because he basically just gave up the other three accomplices. In a matter of hours, all four men are in custody. But interestingly, they told very different stories during their interrogations. Jaren's statement basically matched Troy's. He said that he had committed the murders, but Troy hadn't. Last time, he claims he'd seen Troy. They'd been together at Walmart. Jaron had bought the aluminum bat and then left. But according to Jaren, Troy had stayed behind at the store. Eventually, though, he changes his story and admits, no, Troy was with us. And on top of that, Michael and Robert both said Troy was the ring leader. He had planned this entire thing. The whole reason we were there was for vengeance on his behalf. He was the one who had beaten and stabbed Aaron and done terrible things to her remains afterward. Now, Robert and Michael claim that they were there, but they didn't actually hurt anyone. In fact, they claimed that they'd never even wanted to do anything with this crime. They said they only went along with it because they were afraid of what Troy would do to them. They basically say, no, Troy and Jaren did all of the murders. Now, of course, police are like, why did all four of you go then? After all, if Robert and Michael really didn't want to hurt anyone, they could have called 91 1. Why did they buy bats? In fact, there was one other person who knew about the murders in advance, so there Was one other guy. It was actually a friend of Troy's named Brandon Graham. Now, before this massacre, Troy asked Brandon if he wanted to join the four men on the spree, and he had said no. Troy didn't hurt Brandon or punish him for his answer. He just accepted it. So all four men know about this. So if Michael and Robert and even Jaren didn't want to participate, they could have refused because another friend refused and nothing happened. They chose not to. Seemed obvious that all four were complicit in the crime, Even if Troy and Jaron really were the ones who actually killed everyone. Now, all four men were charged with six counts of first degree murder, one for each victim. And on top of that, each faced six counts of abuse of a dead human body with a weapon. They didn't specify who had done what. They just charged all of them, plus one count of armed robbery, cruelty to animals, conspiracy to commit murder. And the list went on. In total, each suspect received 15 charges. Three of them went on trial together, but not Robert, who pleaded guilty from the start. For the rest of them, the hearing began in 2006, two years after the massacre. At this trial, all three men who are pleading not guilty basically point the finger at each other or say Troy was the ringleader. And this includes Robert, who actually testifies as a witness at his friend's trials. Ultimately, the jury found all of the defendants guilty. Michael and Robert were both sentenced to life in prison, and Troy and Jaron received the death sentence. Except there were some complicated issues with the ruling. A majority of the jurors wanted the death penalty, but not all of them. And in 2018, the state of Florida passed a new law. It said that jury decisions needed to be unanimous if they're voting for the death penalty, not just majority. And since Troy and Jaron's sentences were not, their rulings didn't hold up in line with this law. So in 2023, Troy and Jaron got a new sentencing hearing. It wasn't a redo of the whole trial. The guilty verdict still stood. The only question was over whether they would still have to sit on death row or if they would get resentenced to life in prison. Now, once again, the majority of the jury voted for the death penalty, but not everyone. Ultimately. Of the 12 jurors, 11 thought that Jaren should be executed, while 10 thought Troy should be executed. So in theory, that meant the two men should have been sentenced to life. That's what the law said. But on the exact same day that the ruling came down, the Governor of Florida signed a new bill into law. This one said that a 2/3 majority was necessary for a death penalty. Didn't have to be unanimous after all. So as long as eight jurors voted for it, the person could be executed. I know it's confusing. Why is the law constantly changing? Point is that because of the timing, this sentence was also overturned. So a new hearing came in 2025, and this time the death penalty held. A majority of jurors ruled that both men, Troy and Jaren, should be executed. Now, as of this recording, they still haven't been officially sentenced to death. The jury voted, but a judge still has to approve it. And so far, we don't have a date for when that ruling will come down. So only time will tell what their sentence will be and if it'll stand. Now, of course, the death penalty is controversial. I'm sure there are some people who believe justice has been served and Troy and Jaren deserve to die. And there are others who are unhappy with this resolution. But as I wrap up, I want to turn the attention away from the verdict in the sentence. I just want to get back to the victims. Michelle, Francisco, Jonathan, Tito, Anthony, and Aaron. The six people who were brutally terrorized and murdered. Every murder case is automatically a tragedy, but this one in particular is haunting. To me, it's senseless. Six people died over an Xbox and some clothes, and four people agreed to do this. Their loved ones struggled to understand how something like this could happen. This case has, like, gutted me. I don't. The brutality, the terror that everyone in that house must have went through in their final moments. And for what? Like, sometimes in cases, I try to, you know, go down this spiral of reasoning and mental health, not excuses, but, like, how could we get here? Where did we get here? How? Why? When? Is there something psychologically that I can try to grasp onto? But in this case, it just feels like pure evil. Bad people. Just bad people doing bad things to innocent people who did nothing. I hate it. Like, I can't stand it. This is the. This is just the epitome of the ugliness of true crime and the ugliness of humanity. Yet case after case like this just happens. It seems to me like the more people involved in a crime, the more horrendous it gets. Almost like there's this psychology behind, like, group crime where if one person's doing it, it makes okay, and it just gets worse and worse and worse and worse. You know that study they did where they, like, split people in half and made Half prisoners and half the guards of the prisoners, just to see, like, what people in power would do. And by the end of the study, these completely random strangers were physically hurting the prisoners because they had power. And it was a study about the abuse of power and how if you give a human brain power, it will abuse it, especially in gang mentality. And every time I come across a crime that has multiple members who are committing the crime, it just seems like this nasty group mentality where you would think human behavior, like, how can you find humans who can all do this together? And there's something about it. There's something about this, about people bringing out the worst in each other. And I think that that genuinely is what happened in this case. How could four people agree to do this to six innocent people? It's the ugly side of humanity. But I guess that is what we cover here on into the Dark. Please keep the victims of this case in your thoughts today. Keep their families in your thoughts today. And remember that despite the ugliness in this world, you can be a light in your own world. You can be good, you can feel good, and you can spread good. All right, you guys, that is our episode today on into the Dark. And I will see you next time with another one. Goodbye.
- [39:07]
Liberty Mutual Announcer
And Doug, here we have the Limu emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug.
- [39:22]
Peyton Moreland
Uh, limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us.
- [39:26]
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Cut the camera. They see us.
- [39:27]
Jack Daniels Announcer
Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com.
- [39:29]
Peyton Moreland
Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty Savings.
- [39:33]
Jack Daniels Announcer
Very underwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company and affiliates. Excludes Massachusetts.