Invest Like the Best with Patrick O'Shaughnessy: Darren Farber - The Business of Defense (EP.417) Summary

Release Date: April 1, 2025

Introduction

In Episode 417 of "Invest Like the Best," host Patrick O'Shaughnessy engages with Darren Farber, the Managing Partner of Albion River—a private direct investment firm focused on acquiring companies that produce highly technical defense products and services. Farber brings a wealth of experience, including roles as a Special Advisor to the Deputy Undersecretary of Defense and a member of the U.S. Department of Defense Task Force for Business and Stability Operations. The conversation delves into the evolving landscape of U.S. defense, the impact of recent global conflicts on military technology and strategy, and investment strategies within the defense sector.

The Changing Landscape of U.S. Defense

Decoupling from Post-WWII Alliances

Farber begins by addressing the significant shift in global defense dynamics, highlighting a decoupling from the long-standing alliances formed post-World War II. He uses an analogy to explain the erosion of contractual obligations between the U.S. and its European allies:

"[06:28] Darren Farber: ... borders did not change in the western world through force for the last 80 years. And we're seeing that paradigm change..."

This shift underscores a reevaluation of defense dependencies, particularly within Europe, which historically relied heavily on U.S. military support. Farber points out Europe's limited nuclear capabilities and its growing realization of the need to bolster its own defense mechanisms, a transition that will take time to materialize fully.

Defense Budget Allocation and Organizational Efficiency

Front Office vs. Back Office

Farber introduces a framework to understand the Pentagon's budget allocation by dividing it into the "front office" (war fighting and lethality) and the "back office" (business mission area, encompassing all non-war fighting activities). He observes that while advancements in the front office have been impressive, the back office lags in efficiency and modernization:

"[08:23] Patrick O'Shaughnessy: ... the shifting nature of that thing... how the Pentagon is keeping up with a shifting landscape in the way it spends its money."

Operational Complexities and Technology Integration

Farber critiques the Pentagon's approach to technological integration, emphasizing the importance of leveraging dual-use commercial technologies rather than developing exclusive defense-specific solutions. He cites the example of drone technology evolution in Ukraine, where low-cost, commercially adapted drones have proven highly effective compared to expensive, legacy systems:

"[09:20] Darren Farber: ... the department does best when it lets dual use commercial technology advance so it can adapt it and pull it in internally..."

Investment Approach at Albion River

Focus on Technical Foundations

Farber outlines Albion River’s investment philosophy, which centers on acquiring "one-of-one" suppliers in defense technology. Their strategy involves getting as close to the fundamental components ("the molecule") of defense systems as possible, ensuring they control critical parts of the supply chain:

"[63:46] Patrick O'Shaughnessy: Ergo get closer to the molecule."

Acquisition Strategies and Valuation

He shares insights into successful acquisitions, such as purchasing the nation's only manufacturer of missile fuel at a fraction of its replacement cost. Farber emphasizes the importance of owning essential, hard-to-replace assets that provide steady annuity-like returns through long-term government contracts:

"[60:16] Darren Farber: ... our analysis of the factories, there's no alternative. There are ways for us to improve it. Technologically the business is unbelievable..."

Technology in Modern Warfare

Lessons from Ukraine

The ongoing conflict in Ukraine serves as a case study for the integration of old and new technologies in warfare. Farber highlights how low-cost, commercially available drones have outperformed some of the newer, expensive models, demonstrating the rapid adaptability and innovation at the battlefield level:

"[36:40] Darren Farber: ... Ukrainian drone is this little printed thing that they do themselves and they're running the software and they just need the shape charge and they're printing it."

Net-Centric Warfare and AI Integration

Farber discusses the concept of net-centric warfare—the interconnectedness of all military assets for enhanced situational awareness—and the vulnerabilities it introduces. He warns of the potential for adversaries to disrupt these networks, which could level the playing field by rendering advanced systems ineffective without their connectivity:

"[66:35] Patrick O'Shaughnessy: ... net-centric warfare."

Furthermore, he explores the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in overcoming institutional weaknesses within adversarial military structures, suggesting that AI could be leveraged to enhance command and control in ways that human-led systems cannot:

"[68:27] Darren Farber: ... AI could overcome the institutional resistance..."

Future of Defense Investing

Capital Allocation Challenges

Farber expresses concerns about the investment landscape in next-generation defense technologies. He points out that the Pentagon's budget is heavily allocated based on existing requirements and multi-year contracts, making it challenging for new entrants to disrupt established programs:

"[43:43] Darren Farber: ... the budget is not built... it's largely allocated..."

Industrial Capacity and Scale

He emphasizes the necessity for defense companies to possess substantial capital and industrial capacity to meet the scale required by defense contracts. Farber highlights that larger firms with robust financial backing are better positioned to survive and thrive in this sector:

"[52:05] Darren Farber: ... accumulating more resources is a form of industrial power..."

Learning from Defense Primes

Farber advises venture-backed defense companies to learn from established defense primes like Northrop Grumman and Lockheed Martin. He acknowledges their impressive technological capabilities and robust business models but also notes the limitations imposed by governmental procurement processes:

"[53:07] Darren Farber: ... some of these primes are very impressive to me... their incentive structure right now is to make sure that they are passing on costs..."

Lessons from Defense Primes and Market Dynamics

Marginal Efficiency and Negotiation Power

Using examples from companies like TransDigm and Northrop Grumman, Farber discusses how defense primes achieve high EBITDA margins through strategic acquisitions and robust negotiation practices. He warns of the sustainability challenges these business models may face as companies grow larger and competition intensifies:

"[54:59] Darren Farber: ... margin tells the story a lot in these businesses... the optimal business for TransDigm is owning the cup holder and the Joint Strike Fighter."

Market Competitiveness and Verticalization

Farber notes the importance of vertical integration in defense manufacturing, where controlling multiple stages of the supply chain can lead to greater efficiencies and cost savings. He suggests that smaller, agile companies may have an edge in innovating and meeting new defense requirements more effectively than large, established primes:

"[53:07] Darren Farber: ... if it's fundamentally new and novel, then there's a much greater opportunity..."

Strategic Implications and Future Outlook

Maintaining Technological Superiority

Farber stresses that technological superiority remains America's greatest advantage in defense. He advocates for continuous investment in cutting-edge technologies and the adaptation of commercial innovations to maintain this edge:

"[27:37] Darren Farber: ... we're going to need a better paradigm... technological superiority remains America's greatest advantage."

Autonomy and AI in Command Structures

He speculates on the future integration of AI in military operations, suggesting that AI could potentially streamline command structures and enhance operational efficiency. However, he also cautions about the risks of over-reliance on autonomous systems:

"[68:39] Darren Farber: ... AI could overcome the institutional resistance..."

Investment Opportunities and Risks

Farber outlines the investment opportunities within the defense sector, particularly focusing on companies that control fundamental technologies and supply chains. He also highlights the inherent risks, such as the potential for capital to leave the system and the challenges posed by entrenched procurement processes:

"[52:17] Darren Farber: ... imagine there's someone so brilliant that's figured out how to turn Apple juice into rocket fuel..."

Concluding Remarks

Farber concludes by reiterating the importance of technological superiority and the strategic allocation of capital in maintaining the U.S. defense edge. He emphasizes the need for responsible party models within the Pentagon to ensure accountability and efficiency in defense procurement and program management:

"[55:11] Darren Farber: ... responsible party who gets to own all the fame and the blame for an activity in order to move it forward."

He also reflects on the lessons learned from historical defense investments and the necessity of adapting to new technological paradigms to safeguard national security effectively.

Notable Quotes

• On Decoupling:
  “... we're seeing that paradigm change and so that's a pretty big change.” (06:28)

• On Front vs. Back Office:
  “The front office is war fighting. That is lethality. It's projecting force. The back office is called the business mission area...” (08:49)

• On Investment Philosophy:
  “My top of the mountain is to be as close to the molecule as possible.” (63:49)

• On Technological Superiority:
  “The law of large numbers, that they're getting big enough. ... it's going to be technology that remains America's greatest advantage.” (27:37)

• On Responsible Parties:
  “We've never had an incident in our nuclear navy running reactors that move with tons of kinetic stuff around it all over the world.” (48:10)

Conclusion

This episode provides a comprehensive look into the intricacies of defense investing, the strategic imperatives shaping U.S. defense policy, and the critical role of technology in modern warfare. Darren Farber's insights offer valuable perspectives for investors, defense strategists, and business leaders navigating the complex intersection of capital, technology, and national security.

For more detailed discussions and insights, visit Join Colossus and explore all available episodes and resources.