Are the Numbers Too Good to Be True?

Summary

Podcast Summary: Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger

Episode Title: Are the Numbers Too Good to Be True?
Date: December 5, 2025
Host: Jill Schlesinger, CFP®
Producer/Co-Host: Mark
Featured Caller: Brian (from Tucson)

---

Episode Overview

In this episode, Jill Schlesinger addresses a classic financial anxiety: “Are the numbers too good to be true?” She speaks with Brian, a longtime corporate employee on the verge of a major career and life transition, who’s grappling with whether he can afford to leave his high-stress job for a less lucrative but more enjoyable future. The conversation dives deep into real-life retirement math, the limitations (and usefulness) of financial calculators, and the emotional complexity of stepping away from a decades-long career—even when the numbers say you’re more than fine.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Brian’s Financial Picture (03:12 – 06:00)

• Brian is in his early 50s, single, no kids, earning $140K/year in IT.
• Consistently saves, spends about $4K/month.
• Assets:
  • Traditional 401(k): $705K
  • Roth 401(k): $31K
  • Rollover IRA: $110K
  • Roth IRA: $500K
  • Brokerage account: $130K
  • HSA: $23K
  • Cash: $280K (including $70K emergency fund)
  • Home: Worth $500K, mortgage-free

Quote:
Jill: “Why? What’s wrong with you? You only spend four grand a month.” (06:00)

2. The Retirement Calculator Conundrum (06:01 – 07:57)

• Brian’s concern: Multiple calculators say he can retire now and still have money left at 95, but it feels “too good to be true.”
• Social Security projected at about $3,350/month at full retirement age (67), no pension.
• Brian wants to do a “fun job” with part-time hours, maybe earning $30–$40K/year.
• Major worry: Covering health insurance pre-Medicare.

Quote:
Brian: “...they all are basically telling me that I could retire right now if I wanted to... [but] it just seems a little too good to be true.” (03:12)

Jill: “All you really need to do is bring in enough money until you start claiming Social Security to pay for your health insurance. Everything else should be okay.” (07:59)

3. Career Burnout & The Next Phase (08:35 – 09:16)

• After 30 years at the same company, Brian feels “exhausted” and is eager to transition out.
• Considering waiting 18 months to reach age 55 for additional benefits, but is “pretty fried.”
• Wants to avoid full-time work going forward, but stay engaged “doing something fun.”

Quote:
Brian: “I’m pretty fried. It’s a fairly stressful job… after 30 years, I’m just kind of exhausted and feel like I need to do something else…” (08:42)

4. Affirming the Math & Emotional Transition (09:17 – 12:43)

• Jill and Mark do “big picture math”:

  • $1.7 million accumulated.
  • 3% withdrawal rate generates ~$50K/year—more than Brian needs.
  • For 12 years before Social Security/Medicare, Brian would supplement income by drawing minimally from savings.
  • After age 67, Social Security should cover nearly all expenses.

• Jill emphasizes the psychological challenge: Moving from an “all-in” career to a more flexible lifestyle.

• Advice: Take the time (especially next 18 months) to explore what Brian wants next.

Quotes:
Jill: “You are essentially the person who I wrote my book for... you are actually contemplating a great money reset.” (10:38)

Mark: “This is your payoff, man.” (11:14)

Jill: “It’s hard to transition from a career, a life where work is so dominant... It’s very difficult... sometimes we have a tough time finding that happy medium.” (11:22)

5. Advice for Transition & Estate Planning (12:44 – 13:27)

• Jill encourages Brian to use the next 18 months for introspection and career exploration.
• Recommends seeking enjoyable, low-stress part-time or seasonal work—even if unrelated to his current field.
• Confirms Brian has all key estate documents: will, power of attorney, and living will.

Quote:
Jill: "I think you’ve earned the right to be done with [full-time work]." (13:03)

---

Memorable Quotes & Moments (with Timestamps)

• Jill [to Brian, on his savings]:
  “Why? What’s wrong with you? ...You only spend four grand a month.” (06:00)
• Brian (on job burnout):
  “I’m pretty fried... after 30 years, I’m just kind of exhausted and feel like I need to do something else.” (08:42)
• Jill (on life changes):
  “You’re actually contemplating a great money reset. The subtitle of the book is change your work, which you’re about to do...and you’re gonna be a happier human being.” (10:38)
• Mark (on Brian’s current moment):
  “This is your payoff, man.” (11:14)
• Jill (on the challenge of leaving a career):
  “It’s hard to transition from a career, a life where work is so dominant... sometimes we have a tough time finding that happy medium.” (11:22)
• Jill (on future steps):
  "Take the time before you turn 55 to really be thinking about this. What is it that I like to do? What are some jobs out there?" (12:16)

---

Important Segments & Timestamps

• Caller Introduction and Overview: 03:12 – 04:21
• Breakdown of Brian’s Savings & Assets: 04:22 – 06:00
• Social Security, Spending Needs, and Health Insurance: 06:13 – 07:59
• Brian’s Career Burnout and Transition Goals: 08:35 – 09:16
• Crunching the Retirement Numbers: 09:17 – 10:44
• Book Reference & “Great Money Reset”: 10:45 – 11:14
• Emotional/Psychological Aspects of Leaving Work: 11:22 – 12:43
• Part-Time/Fun Job Options & Estate Planning: 12:44 – 13:27

---

Takeaway Messages

• Trust the Math: If multiple calculators and a financial professional like Jill say you’re fine, you probably are—especially if you’ve tracked spending accurately.
• Healthcare is a Key “Next Phase” Expense: For pre-retirees, figuring out coverage before Medicare is crucial.
• Emotional Adjustment is Real: Even with robust finances, moving away from a long, demanding career is emotionally complex. Preparation for the next life chapter is as important as the math.
• Enjoy Your “Payoff”: Decades of steady saving create freedom—embrace it, and let your money give you flexibility and joy.
• Keep Essential Documents Updated: Will, power of attorney, and living will (especially for singles).

---

Tone & Style

The episode balances warmth, humor, and grounded financial expertise. Jill demystifies retirement planning, mixing practical math with empathetic coaching. There’s an emphasis on enjoying the fruits of disciplined saving—without guilt or fear.

---

For listeners facing a similar crossroads, Jill’s bottom line is clear:
You’ve worked hard, saved well, and have earned the flexibility to design your next phase. Sometimes, the numbers really are that good.

---

Transcript

[Jill]

This year.

[Mark]

Give a gift that goes far beyond the moment. An Invest 529 account. Whether it's a child, grandchild or someone just starting out, you're helping them save for education that can open doors for a lifetime. Invest529 is a tax advantaged way to save for college, trade school, or even apprenticeship programs. It's flexible in easy to start and you can contribute any amount, big or small. And because the money can grow tax free, it's a gift that really builds value over time. So instead of giving something that gets used up or set aside, give the gift that can change a Life. Start an Invest529 account today. Go to invest529.com to get started. You know how the holidays can sneak up on you. Suddenly you're hosting a dinner or bringing a dish to a friend's party and you're scrambling. This year I decided to make my life easier and head straight to Whole Foods Market and honestly, it's my new holiday headquarters. Whether you're looking for show stopping mains like their bone and spiral cut ham, or heat and eat sides from the prepared foods department that are seriously easy and delicious, Whole Foods Market has you covered. I stocked my pantry with all the 365 favorites too. Creamy mushroom soup, traditional stuffing, and even French style green beans prepared perfect for classic holiday meals without breaking the bank. And don't even get me started on desserts. The holiday rum cake Buche de Noel? Yes please. Plus it's easy to grab something thoughtful for the host, cheeses and crackers, seasonal candles, cookie gift boxes, or even something from the floral department to make their table feel extra festive. You can order online for pickup or delivery in select zip codes, which is a total lifesaver. Shop for everything you need at Whole Foods Market, your holiday headquarters.

[TikTok Business Announcer]

Find new customers on a platform that's here to stay. With TikTok for business, anything is possible. If you've ever thought about advertising your business on TikTok, now is the time to do it. You can drive more customers to your website, sell products right in the app, and you can even use TikTok's creative tools to easily make content and find creators to help sell your products for you. Find new customers today, just open your browser, type in getstarted.TikTok.com TikTok ads and grow your business fast.

[Mark]

Welcome to the Jill on Money show. It's Friday, December 5th and we are here answering your financial questions. If you've got one, just go to the website jillonmoney.com. click the contact Us button, write us a note, and if you want to join us live, you know the deal. Check that box. Mark will chase you down and arrange to bring you on the air with us. And we do love having you on the air with us because it allows us to ask nosy follow up questions. Sometimes you think something is important, but you've left out something else that we think is equally as important. So come on the air. We can change your name, don't worry, we'll make you anonymous. It's fine. But join us. It's so much more fun. Right now. We're going to talk to Brian who joins us from Tucson.

[Brian]

Hi, Joe. Hi, Mark. It's great talking with you guys. I have a question regarding basically some retirement calculators I've been looking at. I'm in my early 50s and thinking about not necessarily retiring, but I'm thinking about changing careers and working less and basically going on to maybe like my next endeavor. So I've been running the numbers through various financial calculators and they all are basically telling me that I could retire right now if I wanted to. And with the money I've saved up in retirement accounts and outside of retirement accounts, with how much I need to spend, at least as of today on an annual basis, I would still end up with quite a bit of money left over. Come to age 95 and it just seems a little too good to be true.

[Jill]

Okay, so let's think about this. Let's run the numbers with you very quickly without going into deep dive detail. I know that you don't want to have to give us every single thing, but we're going, why don't you give us right now, first of all, what do you need to spend on a monthly basis?

[Brian]

So right now I spend between three and four thousand dollars a month and I track that and that's a pretty accurate number.

[Mark]

So let's just say four.

[Jill]

Just so we have like the bigger number. Right. Are you married, partnered, single?

[Brian]

I am single, no kids.

[Mark]

Oh.

[Jill]

This is already becoming an easy scenario to figure out how you're going to do. How much do you earn right now?

[Brian]

Brian earned around 140,000 a year.

[Jill]

Tell us about the savings that you have accumulated. So let's see what the calculators are crunching for you.

[Brian]

So I have a traditional 401k with around $705,000 in it. I have a Roth 401k with around 31,000. And then I also have a rollover IRA with 110 and a Roth IRA with 500.

[Jill]

Wait, 500 grand, right?

[Brian]

500,000. Yes.

[Jill]

What about non retirement accounts?

[Brian]

I also have a brokerage account with some ETFs that are worth around 130,000.

[Jill]

Great.

[Brian]

I have an HSA with around 23,000 in it. And then I also have around 210,000 in just cash, not including my emergency fund, for which I have around $70,000 in that, which is for emergencies and some upcoming expenses.

[Jill]

Okay, so you're saying you've got 210 in cash plus 70. So $280,000 in cash right now, right?

[Brian]

Yes.

[Jill]

Okay. House. Do you own a home?

[Brian]

I do own a home. It's worth around, you know, 500,000. There's no mortgage on it. There's no debt at all.

[Jill]

Why? What's wrong with you?

[Mark]

Why are you making yourself crazy?

[Jill]

You only spend four grand a month.

[Mark]

Yeah.

[Brian]

And I think that's the kind of like the saving grace when I look at the numbers. Cause the calculators do include Social Security and Social Security.

[Jill]

Let's say you draw it at. What's your Full retirement age? 67.

[Brian]

My full retirement age would be 67? Yes.

[Jill]

Okay. What's the amount at 67?

[Brian]

At 67, it's like 3350.

[Jill]

3350. You would have no pension, right?

[Brian]

Correct.

[Jill]

Okay, but you're saying next endeavor. So are you going to go from 140 to 0 or 140 to something else?

[Brian]

I don't want to stop working because I think I get bored after probably a month. But I don't want to work full time and I don't want to. I work in IT for a large corporation and I like to do something, you know, outside of, you know, corporate America. You mentioned in one of your calls recently to some guy about doing a fun job.

[Jill]

Yeah.

[Brian]

Likes to do, you know, something fun, something that just keeps me busy and maybe brings in nowhere near what I'm making now, you know, maybe even close to, you know, a quarter of what I'm making now.

[Jill]

Okay, but let's. How about this? What if I said to you, all you need to do is get a job that either can cover the cost of your health insurance or have health insurance offered to you. Let's say you were like, you know what? I really, what I love is I, I'm going to make things, something up here. Like, I work for Big Brothers of America and I'm going to do it projects for like, nonprofits. And that'll be 30 or 40 grand a year. Okay. That Would, like, cover your health insurance, really, but that's really the only big expense you're going to have, because even at four grand a month, even if I put an extra thousand and made it 5,000amonth, because you'll need that for, I don't know, 12 or 13 years. So you have Medicare, Right? So even if we made it $5,000 a month, I think that everything is fine because all you really need to do is bring in enough money until you start claiming Social Security to pay.

[Mark]

For your health insurance.

[Jill]

Everything else should be okay.

[Brian]

I'm curious for all the listeners out there. I mean, you make a good salary. You're not making a ton of money. At some point, were you making a lot more money? How did you save all this money? Well, I worked for the same company for 30 years, and I've had a decent match, my 401. And I've started my 401 from the very beginning, when I first started work 30 years ago. So I've been saving money all along. But I definitely, you know, having been making, you know, this much for my whole career. But it's been at least a good last, you know, maybe 10 years or so where I'm making, you know, over 100,000 a year.

[Jill]

But do you feel like there's any way to stay with this company and work less, or is it like you just, you're done? Are you fried?

[Brian]

I'm pretty fried. It's a fairly stressful job. I do a lot of project management work, and there's a lot of reorganizations that we've been going through. And just after 30 years, I'm just kind of exhausted and feel like I need to do something else, and I'm not necessarily wanting to. There's a little bit of benefit for staying until I'm 55, which is like in another year and a half, but definitely by then, if not before, I really do want to move on to something else. Just because it's been such a long period of time within this career.

[Mark]

Well, what is it that you don't.

[Jill]

Believe about the calculators? That's the other thing. That's my other question I have.

[Brian]

It just seems too good to be true. And I have used multiple calculators. I'm not just relying solely on one, but knowing that I need to have enough money if I retire at 55 to last me until I'm at least 95, the one that I mostly use. It actually tells me that I'll have more money at 95.

[Jill]

Right. You got to spend More because otherwise. Right, exactly. Because you're a net saver, essentially.

[Mark]

Because you have a hunt. You are.

[Jill]

Right. So let's just big picture Math. You've got $1.7 million that's accumulated. Approximately 1.7. A 3% withdrawal rate, you know, jams out 50 grand a year, which you don't need all of that. I'm just saying that, like, depending on what you need, you'll need something like 20 or 30 grand a year, which you know, to supplement whatever you're earning from for the next some years. Then you claim Social Security. So you have 12 years where you're going to pull some money out of the portfolio and then you, you're going to claim Social Security, which is really going.

[Mark]

And you'll have Medicare.

[Jill]

And so your expenses actually could drop a little bit. And you're fine. I mean, you are absolutely fine. So the big question is really like, what do you want to do and how do you and I get it? If you want it, like certainly for 18 months to get a big bump is a nice thing or to get some extra money. But after that, I would spend the next 18 months figuring out what you really want to do next. You know, you are essentially the person who I wrote my book for. I'm not even kidding. Because to me, you've done such an amazing job of saving, of living within your means, and now you are actually undergoing or you're contemplating a great money reset. The subtitle of the book is change your work, which you're about to do. You're going to change your wealth, mostly because what you're going to do is you're going to access your wealth and you're gonna change your life and you're gonna be a happier human being.

[Mark]

And this is your payoff man.

[Jill]

So take advantage of it. It's so great. It really is. I mean, when people.

[Mark]

I was just having this conversation with.

[Jill]

A very good friend of mine last night and we were talking about how it's hard to transition from a career, a life where work is so dominant. Right. And she. So this is a friend of mine whose spouse is a criminal defense attorney. So it's not like you can do that part time. You know what I mean? So you're the same way. It's like you're all in, you're all out.

[Mark]

So then what we need to be.

[Jill]

Thinking about is how do you transition to something for the next 10, 12 years or 5 years, or however long you want to do it. Feel like you are engaged and not feel like, you're so stressed out. It's just, you know, and it's very difficult. I know that. It's just I think that sometimes we have a tough time finding that. That happy medium. And I think that what we should really be considering is for you to, like, take the time before you turn 55 to really be thinking about this. What is it that I like to do? What are some jobs out there? And I know the world could change in 18 months. There may not be a job, but if, by the way, if you don't ever get a job, even if you just, like, worked part time in, you know, the. The hardware store that you live near, like, if that's something that's fun, like, that's fine, that's fine. Just so that you're not bored.

[Brian]

That's my main goal. I want to do something that, you know, isn't really taxing on my mind and to be honest, just something fun that, you know, I would enjoy going out and doing, you know, part time or seasonally because I don't want to work full time again. I'm, you know, after 30 some years, I'm kind of done with that.

[Jill]

I think you've earned the. You've earned the right to be done with it. Okay, now you are a single dude, but do you have some estate documents?

[Mark]

Where's all of this money go?

[Brian]

So I do have the estate documents. They're pretty old, but they really won't change any. So I have my will, my power of attorney, my living will, and I have all those three main documents that you mentioned.

[Mark]

If you need some assistance making a decision, thinking through some problem that's been bubbling up, just get in touch with us. Go to jillonmoney.com and click the contact us button. Don't forget to check the box. If you'd like to join us on the air live, you can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever it is that you do listen. Our music is composed by Joel Goodman. Mark Tellercio is our executive producer and king of all things web. We are distributed by Odyssey. We ask that you put your hands, metaphorically, on someone's back. Someone needs a boost. I'm telling you right now, you're going to feel great doing it, and they're going to feel great receiving it. Change your work. Change your wealth. Change your life. Thanks for listening. We'll talk to you on Monday.

This message is from Jill on Money sponsor Charles Schwab. Here's a question for you. What question should you ask before hiring a financial advisor? Think of it this way. You're basically interviewing someone for the job of helping you manage your entire financial life. So let's get the Interview Right. Question 1 Are you a fiduciary some of the time or all of the time? This is what sets independent registered investment advisors apart. As fiduciaries, RIAs must do what's in your best interest, not just some of the time. All of the time. Assuming the answer to question one is yes, here's a follow up. How will you guide me through financial decisions while keeping my larger goals in mind? You're looking for someone who connects your financial aspirations to your big picture. Someone who takes the time to get to know what's important to you and your family so they can offer advice that fits your values. The relationship should feel personal, not transactional. Question 3 How will I know my money is safe and in the right place? It's important to make sure you always know where your money is, where it's going and why. Transparency is key and that's where RIAs excel. As fiduciaries, they're legally required to do what's best for you and your situation, like helping you understand the whys behind their recommendations and having your money held by a third party custodian. And finally, one what other services do you provide? All financial advisors can help manage your investment portfolio, but many RIAs also provide services like tax planning, education funding, business succession, and estate and trust planning to bring your broader picture into focus. It's the intersection of your money and your life where RIAs can make the biggest difference. These few short questions can have long lasting implications. Do your homework and discover the difference an independent RIA can make. Visit findyourindependentadvisor.com what's up world?

[Vaughn Miller]

Is Vaughn Miller, Super Bowl MVP, chicken farmer, and now host of Free Range. This is a show where I go off the field and off the script. We're talking what's hot in music, film, trending news and everything blowing up your feed. If you love football, you'll feel at home. But if you're here for the vibes, the Internet deep dives the conversation. This is your podcast. Join me every Wednesday. Follow and listen to Free Range with me, Vaughn Miller. Everywhere you get your podcast.