Podcast Summary: "Should We Invest in This Climate?" | Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger

Episode Details:

• Title: Should We Invest in This Climate?
• Host: Jill Schlesinger, CFP®
• Release Date: May 1, 2025
• Platform: Audacy

Introduction

In this enlightening episode of Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger, host Jill Schlesinger delves into the complexities of investing amidst today's volatile financial climate. Joined by her executive producer Mark, Jill addresses a series of listener questions, offering expert advice on topics ranging from tax strategies and retirement planning to investment diversification and market uncertainty. The episode is structured around real-life scenarios submitted by listeners, making the discussions highly relatable and actionable for a broad audience.

Listener Questions and Expert Responses

1. Tax Strategy for Thrift Savings Plan (Michelle)

• Timestamp: [02:37]
• Listener Profile: Michelle, 68, recently retired from a 40-year government position with $900,000 in a 401k.
• Query: Seeking advice on withdrawing from her Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) while managing tax brackets.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Tax Bracket Management: Jill emphasizes the importance of understanding tax brackets, suggesting that Michelle likely falls within the 12% or 24% brackets based on her projected Social Security and pension income.
  • Withdrawal Strategy: She advises taking out sufficient funds to stay within her optimal tax bracket, possibly distributing withdrawals over the next year and a half.
  • Qualified Charitable Distributions: Jill mentions the option of deferring withdrawals by donating to charity, though this requires rolling over funds into an IRA.
  • Notable Quote: "The money's going to have to come out one way or another." ([03:30])

2. Consolidating Retirement Investments (Norman)

• Timestamp: [07:08]
• Listener Profile: Norman, retired for several years with investments spread across multiple accounts.
• Query: Looking to consolidate his investments to simplify management and reduce market volatility risks.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Consolidation Benefits: Jill encourages consolidating accounts for greater flexibility and easier management, recommending platforms like Fidelity, Charles Schwab, or Vanguard.
  • Investment Diversification: She suggests using short-term bond funds and maintaining a minimal allocation to stocks to balance safety and growth.
  • Notable Quote: "If you just don't really care that much about capturing any upside, the only reason I would say some stocks is that it's nice to have some money that grows faster than the pace of inflation." ([08:45])

3. Growing Funds for Down Payment (Lisa)

• Timestamp: [11:02]
• Listener Profile: Lisa, planning to purchase a condo within five to seven years, currently dollar-cost averaging into index funds.
• Query: Uncertain whether to continue with index funds or switch to a CD ladder amidst market uncertainties.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Market Confidence: Jill reassures Lisa that a five to seven-year time horizon is sufficient to weather market fluctuations, encouraging continued investment in index funds.
  • Dollar-Cost Averaging: She supports Lisa's current strategy, emphasizing its effectiveness in mitigating the impact of market volatility.
  • Mark's Input: "You have money to buy, this is a great time to buy." ([11:04])
  • Notable Quote: "I don't think this is going to be a five year meltdown." ([10:55])

4. Treasury Bills vs. CDs (Ty)

• Timestamp: [12:05]
• Listener Profile: Ty, evaluating whether to invest in Treasury bills or Certificates of Deposit (CDs).
• Query: Seeking the better investment option between T-bills and CDs.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Tax Considerations: Jill explains that the choice depends on Ty's tax bracket and state of residence, noting that T-bills offer tax advantages by being exempt from state income tax.
  • Personal Preferences: She acknowledges that many prefer CDs for their simplicity and association with banks.
  • Notable Quote: "It's sort of like the same thing with if you were going to buy a municipal bond fund or a taxable bond fund. It depends on your tax bracket." ([12:25])

5. Investing IRA in Stocks (Steve)

• Timestamp: [12:45]
• Listener Profile: Steve, 47, contributing $500 monthly to a traditional IRA, currently earning minimal interest.
• Query: Considering shifting IRA investments from money market instruments to stocks.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Investment Growth: Jill encourages Steve to invest part of his IRA in stock index funds to better capture market growth, especially given his long investment horizon.
  • Mark's Support: "If you have the money to invest, now would be a really good time." ([11:58])
  • Notable Quote: "We need to hold your hand to get through this." ([12:08])

6. Retirement Timing and Social Security (Rome)

• Timestamp: [14:10]
• Listener Profile: Rome, 67, with substantial retirement savings, contemplating whether to retire immediately or work two more years to enhance Social Security benefits.
• Query: Deciding the optimal time to retire and when to claim Social Security.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Emotional Security: Jill advises considering emotional well-being, suggesting that if Rome enjoys his job, continuing to work can provide financial security and delay withdrawals from retirement accounts.
  • Social Security Timing: She recommends waiting until age 70 to claim Social Security for maximum benefits.
  • Notable Quote: "If you don't like what you're doing, then absolutely, we can help you out." ([14:24])

7. Medical Records Shredding (Roland)

• Timestamp: [16:00]
• Listener Profile: Roland, responding to a previous column about shredding medical records.
• Query: Clarifying which medical documents to shred post-recovery or dispute resolution.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Record Retention: Jill advises keeping surgical records but shredding routine medical exam papers and unused prescriptions unless involved in disputes with insurance or Medicare.
  • Notable Quote: "Once that's all done, routine stuff. Yeah. You can shred things you don't take." ([16:14])

8. Settlement from Rental Property Sale (Jenna)

• Timestamp: [16:34]
• Listener Profile: Jenna and Janice, 45 and 50, respectively, receiving $180,000 post-tax from selling a rental property.
• Query: Deciding between dollar-cost averaging into an index fund or holding cash amid market uncertainty.
• Jill's Advice:
  • Dollar-Cost Averaging Advocacy: Jill strongly recommends dollar-cost averaging, allowing them to invest methodically and mitigate the impact of market volatility.
  • Mark's Agreement: "I wouldn't even dollar cost average." followed by Jill affirming the strategy despite apparent anxiety.
  • Notable Quote: "Dollar cost averaging is a miracle. It really is." ([16:36])

Key Insights and Takeaways

1. Tax Efficiency: Understanding and optimizing tax brackets is crucial when withdrawing from retirement accounts. Strategic withdrawals can minimize tax liabilities and maximize net income.

2. Investment Diversification: Consolidating retirement accounts can simplify management and provide greater flexibility. Diversifying investments, even minimally into stocks, can protect against inflation and enhance growth potential.

3. Market Volatility Management: Maintaining a long-term perspective and continuing regular investments, like dollar-cost averaging, can help navigate market uncertainties without succumbing to anxiety-driven decisions.

4. Retirement Planning: Emotional well-being plays a significant role in retirement decisions. Continuing to work can offer financial and psychological benefits, complementing strategic financial planning.

5. Record Management: Efficient management of personal records, especially medical documents, can reduce clutter and stress, retaining only what is necessary for ongoing or potential disputes.

6. Strategic Investing Post-Sale: Investing settlement funds thoughtfully, rather than holding large cash reserves, can harness market opportunities and foster financial growth over time.

Conclusion

In this episode, Jill Schlesinger provides comprehensive, actionable advice tailored to diverse financial situations. Her empathetic approach, combined with Mark's supportive input, offers listeners valuable strategies to navigate retirement planning, investment decisions, and financial uncertainties. By addressing real-world questions with clarity and expertise, Jill empowers her audience to make informed and confident financial choices.

Connect with Jill on Money:

• Website: jillonmoney.com
• Contact: Click the "Contact Us" button on the website for personalized advice or to join the show live.
• Subscribe: Access live webinars, back catalog content, and more through Jill on Money Live for $45/year.

Stay informed, take control of your financial future, and make the most of your money with Jill Schlesinger's expert guidance.