Jokermen Podcast Episode Summary: Billy Joel – Cold Spring Harbor

Release Date: May 19, 2025

Introduction to the Episode

In the inaugural episode of the Jokermen Podcast series focused on Billy Joel’s debut album, Cold Spring Harbor, hosts Billy Darrell and Evan dive deep into the early stages of Joel’s illustrious career. Joined occasionally by Ian, the discussion aims to dissect the nuances of Cold Spring Harbor, offering insights, critiques, and appreciations for both loyal fans and newcomers alike.

Overview of Cold Spring Harbor

Cold Spring Harbor, released in 1971, marks Billy Joel’s first foray into a solo career after his stint with the band Attila. The album presents a raw glimpse into Joel’s early musical style and personal struggles, setting the foundation for his future works.

Billy Darrell [01:14]:

"It's the Billy Joel. It's Billy Joel. It's Jokerman Billy Joel podcast, which began as something of a joke, and now it's real."

Evan [02:44]:

"This is the first one where I'm really kind of going in with a basic understanding."

Discussion of the Album Cover

The hosts discuss the album’s cover art, noting Joel’s evolving image and the artistic choices that reflect his state of mind during the album's creation.

Evan [21:17]:

"He starts to figure out as an artist, as a songwriter. He's trying something avant-garde, but the music itself ends up being more straightforward."

Billy Darrell [22:15]:

"It's a monochrome, unsmiling, high-contrast image. He’s presenting himself in a very different way."

Song-by-Song Analysis

1. "She's Got a Way"

A straightforward love ballad that showcases Joel’s melodic prowess despite simplistic lyrics.

Evan [25:07]:

"The melody of the song, the performance of the song, the way he delivers the lines, it's what sets him apart."

Billy Darrell [28:36]:

"His ability to convey intimacy in a way that isn't super quiet and intimate sounding."

2. "You Can Make Me Free"

Echoing the influence of Paul McCartney, this track highlights Joel’s skill in channeling his inspirations while beginning to carve out his unique style.

Evan [31:30]:

"He is a Beatles nut and completely leans into that here."

Billy Darrell [33:43]:

"Musically, it's Andrew Lloyd Webber and it's Billy Joel."

3. "Banger"

An energetic track praised for its fast-paced piano and innovative drumming, drawing comparisons to post-punk and post-disco sounds.

Evan [40:56]:

"It's thrilling, exciting, and sustains attention with minimal components."

Billy Darrell [42:17]:

"These drums are pretty ahead of their time. They sound kind of like post-punk adjacent."

4. "Falling of the Rain"

A fantastical narrative with ornate piano arrangements, though lyrics are deemed less compelling.

Billy Darrell [59:28]:

"It's musically as good as anything he's done, especially on this record."

Evan [62:05]:

"It's a beautiful, ornate piano playing at the beginning, extremely corny lyrics."

5. "Tomorrow Is Today"

A deeply personal and vulnerable song reflecting Joel’s struggles with mental health, offering a somber counterpoint to the more upbeat tracks.

Billy Darrell [73:03]:

"It's a sign of confidence that he's sending you out with a piano type song."

Evan [70:30]:

"He has spent time institutionalized following a suicide attempt, and this song reflects his experiences there."

6. "Got to Begin Again"

Concluding the album with a note of hope, this track encapsulates the emotional arc from despair to optimism.

Billy Darrell [76:00]:

"It's a simple chord on the piano, nothing more than that. He knows where his strengths lie."

Evan [78:08]:

"He pulls it all together with an anthemic quality, selling the song effortlessly."

Themes and Lyrics

The album intertwines themes of love, self-reflection, and personal struggle. While some lyrics are criticized for being simplistic or corny, Joel’s heartfelt delivery and musical composition compensate, creating relatable and emotionally resonant tracks.

Evan [53:42]:

"Billy Joel has an everyman feel to him, which makes his music deeply relatable."

Billy Darrell [53:42]:

"His songs trigger thoughts of being seen too clearly, drawing from everyday experiences."

Billy Joel's Early Career and Personal Struggles

Hosts shed light on Joel’s tumultuous early career, including his time with Attila, the theft of his bandmate’s wife, and his subsequent personal challenges, including a suicide attempt that heavily influenced his songwriting.

Evan [36:25]:

"Billy Joel tried to kill himself and then played a part reflecting that struggle."

Billy Darrell [70:42]:

"He spent time institutionalized following his suicide attempt."

Comparison with Other Artists

Joel’s work is juxtaposed with contemporaries like Paul McCartney, Bob Dylan, and Lou Reed. While drawing inspiration from these influential figures, Joel begins to establish his unique identity within the music landscape.

Evan [33:43]:

"It's so much like Paul McCartney... it's Billy Joel at his most Joel-esque."

Billy Darrell [69:30]:

"Bob Dylan's New Morning feels related to Joel's Cold Spring Harbor."

Reception and Critique

While Cold Spring Harbor is acknowledged for its musicality and Joel’s potential, critiques highlight its lyrical simplicity and the album’s overall cohesion. The hosts rate the album cautiously, recognizing its place in Joel’s development as an artist.

Billy Darrell [84:39]:

"One star out of three. The good type of that, though."

Evan [81:56]:

"It's not a life-changing record, but it's impressive for his debut."

Conclusion and Ratings

Concluding the discussion, the hosts emphasize the album’s role in Billy Joel’s artistic journey. They acknowledge its strengths in performance and musicality while noting areas for growth in lyrical depth and narrative cohesion. The episode serves as a sincere exploration of Joel’s early work, setting the stage for future deep dives into his subsequent albums.

Evan [84:19]:

"One star for Cold Spring Harbor. Pretty good."

Billy Darrell [84:45]:

"Thank you for listening to the first episode. There are 11 more coming."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• [02:44] Billy Darrell:
  "But he's not someone who people are, like, rushing to claim as an influence vocally, maybe."

• [25:07] Evan:
  "The melody of the song, the performance of the song, the way he delivers the lines, I think, sets him apart."

• [31:30] Evan:
  "He is a Beatles nut and completely leans into that here."

• [70:50] Evan:
  "He did end up spending a little bit of time institutionalized following that event."

• [84:45] Evan:
  "One star for Cold Spring Harbor. Pretty good."

Final Thoughts

The first episode of Jokermen Podcast’s Billy Joel series offers a comprehensive and critical examination of Cold Spring Harbor. While acknowledging the album’s imperfections, the hosts appreciate its foundational role in shaping Joel’s storied career. Listeners are encouraged to subscribe for deeper analyses in upcoming episodes, promising an engaging journey through the life and music of Billy Joel.

Subscribe to the Jokermen Podcast on Patreon for ad-free episodes and access to an extensive back catalog of music content. Follow @jokermenpodcast on Instagram and Twitter for updates.