Loading summary
Evan
Well, it's that time again. It's been a while, but it's me, Evan, and I'm joined by John Tottenham.
John Tottenham
Yeah. In the house.
Evan
Tottenham.
John Tottenham
Tottenham. I can't pronounce it either.
Evan
In your house. Yes. And we're here to talk about the. Did we get what numbers fall record it is.
John Tottenham
Let's guess. I'm gonna take a what? 15.
Evan
15. Okay.
John Tottenham
What do you think?
Evan
I'm gonna say 16.
John Tottenham
Let's see. Can't split the difference.
Evan
It's a middle class revolt. Which is the. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16th.
John Tottenham
So I was closer.
Evan
I was right. I said 16.
John Tottenham
What did I say? 15.
Evan
I was dead on.
John Tottenham
You can't cut the live ones though. All compilations.
Evan
No, these aren't. I'm talking about studio records. It is literally the 16th. I'm standing on your shoulders having just done that. But I'm right and you're wrong. It's the 16th studio album by default from 5-3-94. And yeah, we're going to be talking about it in the following episode, which we recorded before we recorded this intro. Welcome to Jokerman.
Unknown
We're gonna have a really good time.
Evan
Together.
Unknown
We'Re gonna have a real good time together we're gonna laug dance and child together we're going to have a real good time together we're going to have a real good time together.
Evan
Okay.
John Tottenham
My mind is scrambled.
Evan
Yeah, well, mine too.
John Tottenham
No, no, you're still young.
Evan
It doesn't feel like it. I just had an hour and a half argument with somebody about Israel where I was on the the good side and they were on the bad side and so I feel I've aged a decade.
John Tottenham
Sounds futile.
Evan
That's what I was trying to say. That was my angle. But the other person seemed to think that it wasn't. So we're back and we're here to talk about a fall LP again. It's been a long time since we did this. It was. What was the last one we did?
John Tottenham
I don't know. I'm very feeble.
Evan
I think the last one we did was.
John Tottenham
The last one we did was.
Evan
It was. RU Are Missing winner.
John Tottenham
Yes. Where are you gonna go after that? It's their most reviled record.
Evan
Yeah. Basically, that's their most reviled record. R U R Missing winner. And so then this time I think we're doing probably their least. One of their least even thought about records.
John Tottenham
Yeah. In fact, I was just reading a review of it on which someone posited that the. It was such a weak record that the best tracks were the COVID versions, of which there are three. And I think those are the worst tracks on it. And actually, they're the worst selection of covers that appear in any of their records.
Evan
I'm not even sure which ones are the covers.
John Tottenham
Well, it's a Henry Cow thing. War.
Evan
That's a Henry Cow cover.
John Tottenham
Yeah. And a Groundhog's Junk Man, Both of which betray Smith's PRG roots. And then. And then there's something by the Monks, too.
Evan
Well, wait, what's that?
John Tottenham
Shut up.
Evan
Yeah, Shut up is. It's like a sort of. There's a couple of those. There's also Black Monk Time on Extra Kid, I think, which is a. I like hearing those. I'll never complain hearing Marky Smith in the fall covering the Monks. But, yeah, it's a bit of a mess. I mean, as if that's, like, an issue. We haven't even said the name of the record. It's Middle Class Revolt, and I don't even. You have it on cd, right?
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
Where?
John Tottenham
In my car.
Evan
In your car? Because I was gonna, like, look at it.
John Tottenham
But you could. There's nothing. There's no information on that.
Evan
I have this test pressing, which was gifted to me by a very kind listener a long time ago. It's literally just a vinyl with just a white generic test pressing label.
John Tottenham
It doesn't have a track listing on it?
Evan
No, there's nothing. It's just a technical demo. But, yeah, you've got a volume. What is that?
John Tottenham
The users go to the full.
Evan
I've never seen that one.
John Tottenham
Oh, yeah, that's the track listing.
Evan
Okay, great. So, yeah, this is 1994, the year of my birthday. Came out on Matador. As if. You know, we never say these things, but I'll just read what. What it says here.
John Tottenham
You don't have to.
Evan
I know I don't have to, but it's like. It's not like there's that much on this subject, so I. There's not, like, a ton written about the. Geez, what number Fall album?
John Tottenham
I don't know. I mean, it seems to me the ones directly after this are more disregarded, you know, Cerebral Caustic, and I like Cerebral Caustic.
Evan
That would be a good one to do.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I agree. Because I don't really know it.
Evan
Well, it has. What it has. Maybe my favorite song.
John Tottenham
Bonkers in Phoenix. Life Still Bounces Life Just Bounces.
Evan
Life Just Bounces, yeah. Life Just Bounces is one of the Best fall songs.
John Tottenham
Yeah, There's a couple of the best ones on this record. In fact, I think one that always makes my top 10 is 15 ways. No. M5.
Evan
Yeah. What's the deal with that one? I guess we'll just start at the top. I mean, the COVID I didn't read what this said, so it came out May 94. When Smith remarked later in the year that he was looking. Yeah, yeah. That he was looking for a new producer to give the fall a kick in the pants. The. Wow. This word. The mirror.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I know. That was amazing. I was gonna look. That word.
Evan
Mirror. Mail. Mermet. Collegical.
John Tottenham
It doesn't really fit.
Evan
Merriment.
John Tottenham
What does he say?
Evan
What is merriment?
John Tottenham
I don't know. I was gonna look it up. It may be invented.
Evan
Middle Class Revolt is probably the first to stand up and applaud. By no Means a bad album. I don't. I don't. Yeah, I mean, they. I think that maybe that's a weird typo.
John Tottenham
I think it might be a typo.
Evan
By no Means a bad album. I think that's right. The way that, say, an R.E.M. or fish album is bad. It was, nevertheless an unconvincing and more seriously unconvinced offering, built around songs that were only halfway to completion and arrangements that seemed to know it. Smith's lyrics are louder and clearer than ever before, as if to disguise the fact that the band seems simply to be busking, or worse, merely cruising with the paucity of ideas or an exaggerated need to annoy. Best illustrated by Symbol of Morgan, a telephone conversation about football and Manchester City between Craig Scanlon and DJ John Peele set to a lo Fi twanging that sounds like an unrehearsed garage band trying to play the shadows. It was no coincidence at all then that the best numbers were the covers. Yeah, okay. We don't need to keep reading this. I'll keep it open for the track listing. But, yeah, the best versions are not the covers. The best versions, the best songs.
John Tottenham
Some great songs in this tracker. The first song is marvelous. 15 ways.
Evan
Yeah, 15 ways is good.
John Tottenham
That's a delight.
Unknown
Something to be down Harder there must be 10 ways to live your mouth don't be broken Harder There are many ways to leave your man.
Evan
I knew that you'd like this one. 15 waves is like the. One of the more like sarcastic, emotionally scorned Mark E. Smith Productions. But, I mean, the first two songs you're getting kind of like, oh, was he. Like, he was just freshly broken up with or Something.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I think so. I'm not sure with whom. It wasn't Bricks. That was ended a couple of years earlier. And then she rejoined the band just after this record, actually. But no, I mean, 15 ways, of course, is a. Let's say, piss take on that Paul Simon song.
Evan
Oh, yeah.
John Tottenham
How many ways to. What is it? 21 Ways to Leave your lover.
Evan
What do you think about Paul Simon?
John Tottenham
I love Simon Garfunkel. Obviously you can't. They can't be denied. They have to be reckoned with.
Evan
So here's the thing is, on the episode of Jokerman that I was just doing, we had a guest who talked about how much she hated Paul Simon. Hates him, hates, hate. And I said, bridge over troubled Water, and she said, hate it.
John Tottenham
Who was this?
Evan
I'd rather not.
John Tottenham
That's crazy.
Evan
I don't want to give you. I want to bias anything. I just want to tell you what you. I want to get your read on what somebody who hates Paul Simon says Graceland is.
John Tottenham
I think there's something unlikable about him.
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
But I don't mean as a person. For some reason.
Evan
Yes, I agree, but as a person, it's different than, like, are you.
John Tottenham
I mean, I love. He's a great songwriter.
Evan
I mean, I think so.
John Tottenham
Obviously, Bookends and Bridge Over Trouble Ward is some of the best songwriting ever. And not. Godfunkel's voice is a thing of beauty. I don't like Paul Simon's voice so much at all, though.
Evan
Yeah, his voice is okay. I. I do think that he's talented, and I don't think you can take that away from him. Yeah. 15 Ways to Leave you. Is that so this is just Mark doing that.
John Tottenham
Well, I mean, the beauty of it is, you know, he says there's 15 ways to leave your man.
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
So it's directed at a woman. But then he keeps switching around saying, there are 20 ways to leave your man. There are eight ways to keep your man. As if just making fun of the whole idea of the complete absurdity of these breakup songs.
Evan
It's a catchy song, and I think that it kind of just works. Having that one idea.
John Tottenham
It's like Rarity. That other full song, the Older Lover.
Evan
Which one's that?
John Tottenham
It's on slates. You know, she'll take. You'll take the older lover, you'll take the younger lover. You'll leave.
Evan
It is like that.
John Tottenham
Yeah. There's a great line. You'll get a dallying notion, but you will soon recover.
Unknown
You got a Beautiful party. There's at least 15 ways to leave your mouth Get a flat on a magazine get your body ahead and out of that sim but don't be this don't shut up the uphead waiters to keep your man on Dump it down hard at there are 50 ways to leave your man.
Evan
I do like the production generally on this. This is. When was the era with the production from Craig Leon. This isn't Craig Leon.
John Tottenham
I think it was just before because there's that song, the five hundred Dollar Bottle of Wine.
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
Apparently that's about a bottle of wine that Craig Leon bought for bricks. Really expensive bottle of wine.
Evan
Wow.
John Tottenham
And she left it on in the kitchen and told Mark not to drink it. And of course he did. And he said it tasted like shit. He didn't realize it was a five hundred dollar bottle.
Evan
Yeah, well, all I needed here was just a little bit of it.
John Tottenham
Well, then we've got the next song, Reckoning.
Evan
This is like one of the. This is kind of a top tier fall song.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I think. I think songs. Or the first three or four. But Reckoning is Matt Fishback's favorite fall song. Wow. Which makes sense.
Evan
That's good.
John Tottenham
And it's a breakup song. It sounds really hurt in it.
Evan
Yeah. No, it's like kind of you're living.
John Tottenham
With some hippie heart which.
Evan
Who thinks he's Mr. Mark Smith. Yeah. The whole thing is really unusually poignant and like direct. And you definitely get a sense that he's actually, you know. He throws himself by name into the song.
John Tottenham
Yeah. That I. Right.
Evan
When does that ever happen? That's not.
John Tottenham
Well, he mentions the Fall a lot. I don't know if he's ever said Mark Smith before.
Evan
I don't know that he has the before or after. I need a new drink.
John Tottenham
I'll too.
Evan
I've always loved the intro to the Reckoning. It's a very peculiar tone that it strikes. Yeah.
John Tottenham
Actually, you know, that song's a. He was. I was reading about it. He was seeing some girl who lived in Dallas.
Evan
Well. Yeah, I called you up from Dallas.
John Tottenham
Yeah. And I think it's about her, right.
Evan
Yeah, I guess so.
John Tottenham
But then it could be about two different chicks at the same time. I mean, Marks. It doesn't seem like he was. Was single very often.
Evan
No, he was a serial monogamous.
John Tottenham
He was. And there is a remarkably high degree of comeliness among his women, I think you'll agree.
Evan
Comeliness. Yes.
John Tottenham
They're all very fetching.
Evan
They look good too.
Unknown
I thought you were from Dallas. But your heart was still in marble and your brain was reckoning. Your friends are discompense mentors. And most in leather jackets are conversing. Rational. Rational. I are sleeping with some hippie Halfway perfect.
Evan
Wow. Matt Fishback's favorite song by the Fall is the Reckoning.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
Good choice. Behind the Counter. I think that this one is kind of. I don't know that I love it, but I think it's good. I guess it's not like a favorite of mine.
John Tottenham
No, me neither.
Evan
It pops up on compilations all the time. It's kind of like. I guess. Mark. Mark. Eve Smith must have liked it.
John Tottenham
I don't. He probably wasn't responsible for most of those compilations.
Evan
I just feel like it shows up like that.
John Tottenham
Yeah, it does.
Evan
Like it was played a lot. Yeah. It's got a whistle in it. What's it about?
John Tottenham
Impossible to say. We don't have the lyrics, do we?
Evan
I'm getting thin from idiots who write rock books. Disparate ex groups cold would have played this for Nose Pin and the Punk Piggies didn't quite make it. They say get behind the counter. The other side of the counter. Chill it, boy. The other side of the counter. Yeah, it. I. I don't know.
Unknown
But I'm getting them from way down. They just want us to be behind the council. Behind the counter. The helicopter.
John Tottenham
I think it's just a. Got a catchy chorus and he just. That's about it.
Evan
Yeah. Next song.
John Tottenham
M5. Yeah, that's one of my favorite.
Evan
So what's the deal with this one?
John Tottenham
Great song. You want to hear it? Yeah, but the better version is the appeal sessions 1. I don't know why they.
Evan
Yeah, this one's good. Wait, this is behind the counter.
John Tottenham
I mean this. The lyrics to M5 are pretty cohesive. You'll never see me try to ru cane. You'll never see me wear a suit of grain.
Evan
We'll wait for it. We haven't started.
John Tottenham
We got SM.
Unknown
Ground. There's a slip road up right ahead. L into the agro gul city Bone umbrella Too many coffee. Just a well wrapped up. But you just think a country man would understand the devil makes work for idle hounds. M560.
Evan
Yeah, this one sounds like the beginning of it. Sounds like a haunted house. Like the haunted mansion music.
John Tottenham
It's a good driving record. And I think it's named after the motorway. M5.
Evan
M5.
John Tottenham
Yeah, it's about England. And there's a split road lying straight ahead leading to the agrarian. That's a great night. I'm city born and bred. Too many car fumes in my head. Just a well read peasant.
Evan
That's good.
John Tottenham
Thanks.
Evan
Work with idle hands.
John Tottenham
7:00Pm I mean, captures that atmosphere of being on a. On a highway, you know, being on a highway, being in a city in the evening.
Evan
Yeah, it definitely does.
John Tottenham
It's got that smoky kind of feeling to it, you know, that leads to the Hayway. And he writes about. That's obviously referring to the Constable painting, the Hay Wayne.
Evan
The Hay Wayne, yeah.
John Tottenham
It's a very popular painting in England. It's almost as popular as American Gothic by Grant Wood is over here. But it's a.
Evan
It says a pastoral image.
John Tottenham
Yeah, the Hayway.
Evan
Yeah. I. I just need to situate myself. Which were like, what were the records before and after this? Because we haven't been doing this in no chronological order.
John Tottenham
I'm not sure. I think afterwards was cerebral caustic.
Evan
I need to look at the discography.
John Tottenham
Was it infotainment?
Evan
I mean, I. We have to do infotainment. We done? Okay. I'm thinking if we have to do shift work, that comes after this, right? No, shift work is before this.
John Tottenham
I'm not sure.
Evan
Jesus. The Marshall suite is until 99, but you definitely have touches of the Marshall Suite and levitate. Like. Like, I feel like this is.
John Tottenham
They sort of entered their wilderness years after this.
Evan
I mean, this period. I like levitate, I like them all.
John Tottenham
But people just weren't paying attention to them.
Evan
Yeah. I mean, wilderness in the sense that they were lost to the public eye, but they were still toiling away and definitely like hit a groove of. Yeah, the 90s. I think the 90s has been basically an under respected period. We've already. Yeah, we did infotainment, which was 93.
John Tottenham
But that was right before this.
Evan
Yeah. Okay, wait, so. So shift work was 90, code selfish is 92, infotainment is 93, and then this is 94.
John Tottenham
What was 91?
Evan
There's no 91. It's just 90 and 92. Shift work is a big album. I. We have to do Shift Work next.
John Tottenham
I know that you had. You were listening to this record recently and you had some issues with it.
Evan
Well, I realized that it's not a good thing to. It wasn't intentional, but I was.
John Tottenham
You just. Yeah.
Evan
Listening to this and then found myself in a romantic context. And then it was still playing during. And then this song came on.
John Tottenham
Which one?
Evan
The. The next one.
John Tottenham
Here? Yeah. It's like a challenge, wasn't it?
Evan
Like, God, really not good music to have a tender Moment to.
John Tottenham
That might.
Evan
No.
John Tottenham
Not be incompatible with thrusting, depending on.
Evan
What you're interested in. I mean, at this point of the.
John Tottenham
Record, I don't think any Fall records would make great makeout albums.
Evan
No, not. Not at all. But this one in particular, I do think that this record is kind of abrasive in a way that like. It's a little bit uncharacteristic. Even like Surmountable Obstacles kind of like takes off from M5 number one and sort of like brings it into a. Just a greater intensity but also kind of less compelling on its face.
John Tottenham
It's one of those. It's just a groove classic Fall cuts where he has a very declarative title and uses it as a vehicle for a journey into the abstraction and the surreal.
Evan
Yeah, exactly. But he doesn't do that as often in like the two preceding records. Like I feel like with. Well, maybe on Code Salvage more. But on shift work there's like songs that are songs pretty much exclusively.
John Tottenham
Well, there's some on this one too. The first two songs, 15 Ways and Reckoning.
Evan
Yeah. Suffice it to say that Surmount All Obstacles is not really worth delving deeply into. It's more of like a one, one track thing with.
John Tottenham
I like that line. His face is full of XXX sex cruelty.
Evan
Well, I guess that's technically sexual. Sexy.
John Tottenham
Yeah. Guilt, Blue eyed A caring, sharing man Embarrassed them into extinction but where things.
Evan
Really got bad was when the next song started playing.
John Tottenham
Oh yeah, what's that? The Henry Cow.
Evan
Yeah. Because of that.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Unknown
Tell her the birds Tell her what.
John Tottenham
Appeared on earth.
Unknown
Musicians with gongs Permeated the autobahn she split the egg and pieces of disgusting breath.
John Tottenham
She spread the.
Unknown
World Cast the spell of war was born.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I mean. Henry Cow. Have you ever listened to them?
Evan
Yeah, I have.
John Tottenham
I've tried to.
Evan
I mean I. Yeah, exactly. I've tried to.
John Tottenham
I mean I wanted to. I wanted to like them. They wouldn't let me.
Evan
I was a big amount still, you know, a huge fan of this Heat.
John Tottenham
Oh yeah. That would be.
Evan
The thing about this Heat and Henry Cow as I understand it, is that they shared a practice space or like they were adjacent to each other. And that makes sense. But this Heat is much more as experimental as they are to, you know, especially on their non. Non album releases. Like, I mean everything that's not deceit is much more like textural and based on just sort of these exercises that are a little bit more like music concrete or whatever. But they're more song oriented than Henry.
John Tottenham
Cal even Henry Cow is very cerebral. Challenging. Mostly sort of math. Rock Froggy.
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
Stuff. I mean, obviously a bunch of students, they're like.
Evan
If the residents weren't joking.
John Tottenham
Yeah. Though they were affiliated with Slap Happy, who I like quite a bit.
Evan
What's the deal?
John Tottenham
They put a record out together.
Evan
Slap Happy. Is that Peter Blegman?
John Tottenham
Yeah, exactly.
Evan
I only. Mainly because of his great comic series, Leviathan, which is just really great. What am I looking at?
John Tottenham
What? What are you looking at?
Evan
You put, like, something on your. Your window. It's moving.
John Tottenham
What, behind it?
Evan
No, right here. Right there.
John Tottenham
Oh, for sake. Is there a bird there?
Evan
I don't think so.
John Tottenham
Don't look. I'll do it.
Evan
A bird?
John Tottenham
There's nothing there.
Evan
No. I don't know why it's moving then.
John Tottenham
It's just the wind, I think. It's a windy night, is it not?
Evan
I don't know what's next.
John Tottenham
People are watching love streams at the moment.
Evan
Who?
John Tottenham
Various people.
Evan
Various people are watching the cassava film. I saw it at the Egyptian not that long ago.
John Tottenham
Did you like it?
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
It's a bit much, isn't it?
Evan
I mean, yeah, there's like. There's like a dream ballet, basically, which doesn't necessarily need to be there. I really love the ending because it has a great scene where he puts on a hat because he's drunk.
John Tottenham
But he's drunk throughout the entire film.
Evan
Yeah, but at the end he's just like the type of drunk where he just puts a hat on, like a silly hat.
John Tottenham
And does what?
Evan
Nothing. He's just like kind of in his house and it's raining. It's like pouring rain. I like that because you never get to see that moment depicted in film, except for that example that I know of. But it's a real thing. Just being really drunk and kind of depressed and just putting on a silly hat alone to be lying around alone or with people. But it's more poignant alone.
John Tottenham
I mean, the amount of drinking that goes on in that film is almost unbelievable.
Evan
It's bleak. And it's also real, I think.
John Tottenham
You think they're drinking real alcohol?
Evan
I mean, he died of alcoholism.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I know.
Evan
So, yeah, probably. Like, you don't just die of cirrhosis if you aren't drinking to a degree that would be considered cartoonish by most people. What does the original sound like? You sent it to me.
John Tottenham
I only listened to it for the first time.
Evan
I mean, this one has that oppressive bang, bang, bang, bang thing that you do.
John Tottenham
I think all of the COVID Potions on this record, very loose. I mean, is that it?
Evan
Yeah. Side B. Oh, what's this?
John Tottenham
Oh, this is a good one. Some of my favorites. You're not up too much.
Evan
Yeah, this is good.
John Tottenham
Well, it's one of his sort of classic put down songs, isn't it?
Evan
You know, it's got a great title for being a classic put down song. You're not up to much.
John Tottenham
Yeah, yeah, it's got some good notes in it, too. What does she want?
Evan
What does she want?
John Tottenham
Isn't. Oh, my friend is watching Love Streams and she said it's not a complete film. I'm not sure what that means. You know, fun fact about this song. What happened to the song Middle Class Revolt?
Evan
It's still on there.
John Tottenham
Oh, is it? We haven't gotten this one. You know, there's a one. The lyrics are great on this and interesting. I was reading about. Her mind's in pieces, her ballroom days are deceased.
Evan
That's good.
John Tottenham
Yeah. Well, apparently there's something about ballroom days in a Door song Five to One. And not only that, but that Doors song, Five to One. The lyrics are, your ballroom days are over, baby. Night is drawing near. Shadows of the evening crawl across the years. And that in itself was derived from a 19th century hymn.
Evan
What's the hymn?
John Tottenham
I don't know.
Evan
Maybe I know.
John Tottenham
No, no, it was anonymous. I mean, it was an unknown author. It was a hymn, but it's great.
Evan
How do you know it was a hymn if it was, if it was.
John Tottenham
Anonymous, could have been a her song. Could have been. Yeah. But another fun fact about this lyric is in the last, love's boat is smashed against existence. Yeah, well, you know what? That's taken from the Russian poet Mayakovsky. Suicide note.
Evan
Oh, God, I was laughing and now I'm not.
John Tottenham
And he wrote in his suicide note, love's boat has been shattered against the life of every day. Oh, you and I are quits and it's useless to draw up a list of mutual hurts, sorrows and pain.
Evan
He said you and I are quits.
John Tottenham
I guess he must have killed himself over a woman.
Evan
I mean, this was in Russian, right?
John Tottenham
Yeah, so I don't think that's extraordinarily good looking. And he.
Evan
Yeah, but he wasn't saying like, you and I are quits, toots.
John Tottenham
Oh, yeah. Maybe he's talking about life itself.
Evan
I don't think he used the word quits is what I mean.
John Tottenham
No, of course he didn't. That's a translation by a very modern.
Evan
By who? New York gangster with A cigar.
John Tottenham
Someone from Times Square.
Evan
You and I are quits. Yeah, that's how they talk in Dime Square.
John Tottenham
I didn't even know what Dime Square was when I up until 6.
Evan
Sounds like you still don't.
John Tottenham
I went out with someone last night who was part of the Dime Square world. Was it christened Dime Square purely on account of the literary scene?
Evan
No, no, no. It's because of the restaurant Dimes, which had its initial outpost, which is now the Dimension Deli. Basically, like they. It was just this one little restaurant that sort of expanded to like they have a little market and a little deli and a little. And a more. A bigger little restaurant now. But it's like triangulated in this one little zone on Division and East Broadway mostly. And I lived on Division street right over there. And, you know, now there's all these people who just like, go there to be around it, which is now, you.
John Tottenham
Know, during the day.
Evan
Yeah, yeah, people just go there.
John Tottenham
Coffee houses.
Evan
Yeah, there's coffee shops. But mostly it's like there's little restaurants and bars and I mean, it's really not that different from like, from Silver Lake and Echo park, but there's. Because it's in Manhattan, as everything in Manhattan is like. You know, the real estate is so concentrated that people mythologize regions much more, with more alacrity. I'll say. It's like it takes longer for a place in Los Angeles to be considered important probably by like a cultural measure. But as soon as people start moving, like, you know, anybody who has any kind of like, clout moves to a region of lower Manhattan, it's like clout chase is suddenly important. But anyway, it seems like a lot of people down there these days kind of like our. Into being conservative as like, as a larp. This is a good time to just sort of shoot the shit because after you're not up too much, we've got symbol of Mordg.
John Tottenham
Well, yeah, that's when I talk about full hard mode, I don't think. It's not even a song. It's just John Peele and Greg Scanlon talking about a football match.
Evan
There is like this sort of standard, like surf rock thing that sounds like it's. Sounds like it's being played through interesting.
John Tottenham
Cultural artifact now because at the time Manchester City were a shit team and now they're the biggest team in Europe. At the time, only 15% of Mancunians supported Man City.
Evan
That has always sounded to me like Manchurian. Yeah.
John Tottenham
I've never known how to Say that word. Is it man or man?
Evan
You're asking me? We play near, like, football at the.
John Tottenham
Moment because Mal there, he used to.
Evan
Like, kind of just boot the ball.
John Tottenham
And he'd head it to the opposing side. Of course, you know, the Craig, Skyland and Smith and the rest. And the boys in Oasis, of course, love the underdog team. And just a city. You're not a victim.
Evan
So did Marky Smith like Oasis?
John Tottenham
He's a good question.
Evan
What is the right side of history regarding Oasis?
John Tottenham
I think it's right to enjoy them as people, but not to think much of their music. I think they're always entertaining.
Evan
I certainly don't think much of their music, but that. I mean that literally. I want you and the listeners to understand that, as literally as you can take it. I don't think much of their music.
John Tottenham
No, I don't either. But I like it better than Blur.
Evan
Well, Blur seems like they want you really badly to think much of their music, but as far as Blur goes, I like a couple Gorillaz records.
John Tottenham
There are a bunch of art school boys who are pretending to be working.
Evan
Class, whereas Oasis are working class boys who are happy to not be anymore.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I mean, something very irritating about. I don't know what it is. I mean, it was nice Pulp over the weekend, of course, but they're head and shoulders above those two bands.
Evan
Pulp is actually, I think, a really good band. Thank you. I think Pope is underrated.
John Tottenham
Not anymore. It's unbelievable how excited people are about the OS history. And they're so boring to look at, too. They don't move on stage. Are those my headset? Are those my.
Evan
No, these are my. I've just got an earpiece in so I can listen to Symbol of Mord.
John Tottenham
You're listening to it?
Evan
Yeah, but I think we could move on to the next tune.
John Tottenham
How many people listening to your Fall Hard Mode on Spotify?
Evan
That's a good question.
John Tottenham
It is a playlist of genius.
Evan
Anybody who's listening here ought to know that. I made a playlist called the Fall Hard Mode, which is every fall song that I'm aware of. If there's anything missing, I encourage 48 saves.
John Tottenham
That's not bad.
Evan
Yeah, it's three hours and four minutes of the most difficult, unlistenable, songless songs by the Fall songs that are basically, by a. By definition, not songs, not music. Some would say there's at least one.
John Tottenham
On almost every record.
Evan
Almost every record has at least one. This one has Symbol of Morgan, which is, as we discussed, a good A curio for. I mean it's not even that interesting. If you're interested in football, it's like, oh, they're talking about out of date bullshit. Is that interesting?
John Tottenham
I think there's more deliberately irritating songs on this record than most of them.
Evan
Well, I think War that Goes by.
John Tottenham
And also Junk man is irritating.
Evan
But the next song, hey Student, I actually think is one of the best songs on the record as just like a kind of keyed up straight fall rocker, you know, it makes sense that Cerebral Caustic.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
Is next because you've got. What is the song on that that reminds me of it is the Joke is kind of like that.
John Tottenham
Well, hey Student was. It's derived from one of their very earliest songs which. No, never recorded. Hey Fascist. That was pre. Very early on, before their first single even.
Evan
Hey Fascist.
John Tottenham
Yeah, it's the same. Different lyrics. I don't really like this song personally.
Evan
It's not my favorite.
John Tottenham
He hates students.
Evan
Yeah, I do kind of like hate Student because I just think it's energetic. But it's no. It's no Birmingham School of Business School.
Unknown
Entirely fictional. A long head down that sneakers on your feet Iron is to the news I'm glad. The best steps in this Jew.
Evan
I said.
John Tottenham
I like this quote from Smith here quite a bit where it says I think we missed middle class before.
Evan
No, we didn't miss middle class.
John Tottenham
He said that. I hate that image of me hating everything. That's middle class. It's horrible when people are frightened of you because of it really. They're just other people with their own set of problems. Very true. Other people there no middle class people like me. Us.
Evan
Actually we. We do have middle class. Rivel skipped.
John Tottenham
We skipped it.
Evan
So it's after some mountain. All obstacles. That's fine. It's the middle. It's in the middle.
Unknown
Everything is.
John Tottenham
Great title.
Evan
It's a funny title because what is a middle class revolt? It's like the least thing, the last thing. The last group that would have something to complain about. But that is everything.
John Tottenham
The middle class revolt one day Revolting.
Evan
The middle class revolt. Is that what he's saying?
John Tottenham
It could be.
Evan
I mean knowing him, it's. I'm sure that the double meaning of a word isn't lost on his. No, it never is. That's something that. About Mark E. Smith that you learn, I think are your best. If we teach you nothing else, John and I, during the course of this episode or any other about the fall, I think that that's a good lesson. It's like Marky Smith is never to be assumed not to understand that a word has a double meaning. He's always going to have at least thought of it it, if not found a way to use it very confusingly.
John Tottenham
Well, you know, the class system in England is like Orwell said, the English are branded on their tongues and it's, it's a cancer, isn't it?
Evan
I watched this video the other day, like somebody on YouTube, some British guy talking about British life today and I think more generally just British sensibilities and was saying that it's so depressing to be there. I guess he's like a well traveled guy, probably like a travel vlogger. But he was just saying like people complain about things all the time, but then if you have something to say about how to fix it, they'll complain about you. They'll be like, they'll be like, well, shut up. So like there's no moving past anything. It's just this kind of like you get to feel like you're superior to the person who has the bright idea because that's foolish. But also you spend all your time suffering because you don't adopt the idea that something like that is what he was saying, that it's very dreary and people sort of repress themselves to death.
John Tottenham
Yes, they do. So I mean it's a very homogenized culture.
Evan
Do you think it's different here?
John Tottenham
Yes, completely. You can't imagine how refreshing it was when I came over here initially.
Evan
I guess.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
I mean the only thing that is sort of the caveat with the refreshment is that some people are so individualistic that they kill you. Yeah, yeah.
John Tottenham
What do you mean?
Evan
I mean like shootings and stuff, you know, you just have like.
John Tottenham
Oh, I mean, England's worse. I mean it's a barbaric society. Violence is endemic and epidemic there.
Evan
Really?
John Tottenham
I mean it's absolutely. I mean violence is a sport over there.
Evan
That's what you've said. It's like you either get beaten down.
John Tottenham
Beaten down or beaten up. Yeah.
Evan
Beaten down or in the United States, in this country you get beaten up.
John Tottenham
Yeah. But you get beaten down.
Evan
In the United Kingdom you get beat down.
John Tottenham
They don't like you getting above your station over there.
Evan
And here you just get beaten up physically and then it doesn't necessarily affect your station.
John Tottenham
The class system here doesn't dictate everything.
Evan
No. Because you can get past it in the stupidest ways.
John Tottenham
Well, in England everyone thinks that every, I mean, punk was the great equalizer There people felt guilty about him being middle class and affected working class mannerisms. Joe Strummer would be the perfect example of that.
Evan
So do you not like Joe Strummer? He is kind of like the.
John Tottenham
I dislike him. He's just. He was a middle class guy who affected working class mannerisms and attempted to fob himself up as a working class bloke, which he was just. I mean, yeah, of course, rock and roll is all about reinvention and so on, but there was something a little dishonest about it.
Evan
Well, it's an odd question because it's like, would it be better if all artists were just happy to be middle class, upper class and not think about the lower class at all?
John Tottenham
Well, maybe he should have just written about his middle class guilt rather than pretending to be working class.
Evan
Yeah, the whole guilt thing is kind of a trap, though.
John Tottenham
Yes, the guilt trap.
Evan
It doesn't necessarily make you interested to be guilty.
John Tottenham
I think he did great work on the first Clash record. It was all crap after that.
Evan
You don't like London College?
John Tottenham
No, it's horrible. The Clash. I mean, they said everything they had to say with the first record. They addressed every issue that required addressing White Riot. With the Clash, it's all about the first record. Ultimately, it's all about that one song, White Riot. It's an amazing song.
Evan
Of course, it was like, one of the first records I ever listened to. By choice. By choice, you know, like of my. Of the CDs floating around the house.
John Tottenham
Oh, your dad had it?
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
Nice.
Evan
So I listened to the first Clash record and London Calling, like, at the same time. And I liked the first one. And I liked, I think, Lost in the Supermarket, I thought was that was the first emo song I ever heard. Kind of the first emo song ever written.
John Tottenham
Yeah, good point.
Evan
Okay, Junk man is next after. Hey, student.
John Tottenham
That's a Ground Toes record. Apparently the first gig Mark Smith went to was a Groundhogs gig.
Evan
Who are the Groundhogs?
John Tottenham
They were blues rockers.
Evan
Very grubby, hairy, like ZZ Top.
John Tottenham
No. Yeah, a little bit. It was more they actually. I guess Tony McPhee of the Groundhogs is still alive, which is incredible to consider because he always seemed. He had a band, the Groundhogs. And they were the sort of band that when John Lee Hooker or whomever came over to the uk, they would back him up. This would be in the mid-60s. And then they became progressively more far out after that and put out that record split, which some people like a lot. Which Junkman is on.
Evan
Well, I don't know. Junk man. So it just kind of of. Should I throw this on Fall Hard mode? Honestly, it's kind of like the easier end of that. But it's not very fun to listen to.
John Tottenham
Should you do what?
Evan
Throw junk band?
John Tottenham
No, it doesn't belong on there. It's too melodic. Way too melodic.
Evan
It is long. Yeah, it is 4 minutes, 22 seconds of just like the same plodding thing. But whenever I get to a song like this and like all the fall Hard mode songs like, the. The question I ask myself is, like, what would you rather listen to? Say if you want to listen to music, would you rather listen to this? Or silence or top 40?
John Tottenham
And that's it.
Evan
Obviously, it's. This is. You know, you. You don't want to not listen to music. This is much more like engaging music than just sort of pop song top 40. So, yeah, it'll actually, like, do the trick. Even if it's not through the me not the way you wanted it done, It'll get the job done. Of like. Like, I'm listening to a song and I'm. It's making me. Taking me somewhere.
John Tottenham
Have you managed to listen to it all the way through? That would be quite an achievement.
Evan
Passively. I have. What?
John Tottenham
No, it's the hard mode.
Evan
Oh, no, I should. We should. That should be the next one.
John Tottenham
Well, how. You said it's five hours long or something.
Evan
It's three hours. But we don't have to, like, do we could just both have listened to it.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
And then we just talk about what that was like. That's a good idea.
John Tottenham
It'll never happen.
Evan
Why not? You don't have three hours of time.
John Tottenham
No, I do, but I just don't think it's ever gonna happen. It'd be great.
Evan
That's what I'm saying. It should happen. You know, people like these episodes.
John Tottenham
Famous last words.
Evan
This could be the one that breaks.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I think so.
Evan
The $500 bottle of wine.
John Tottenham
While I was researching this record, somebody unequivocally came out and said, this is the worst fall song ever. I think it's a great one.
Evan
I think it's good. I think it's kind of the. Actually, when I didn't know this record at all.
John Tottenham
Can't she.
Evan
And I didn't even really want to. This was the first song on it that I was kind of like, oh, maybe there's something to this record.
John Tottenham
Oh, yeah. You know, there was an event here in this city not long ago that I Appeared at, on occasion, a wine event. Yeah, it was a wine. It was called Irregular Wine Tasting. It took place at the Echo, and it was hosted by this Englishman, in fact, full fan, Julian Davies and cousin Roy, who, you know, Liz Garrow's boyfriend, who was the fall road manager on several of their tours during the. During the sort of country on the clique here and through whom I actually met Smith briefly. Cousin Roy. Yeah. He drove the Ford around the country for several years on their American tours. Anyway, he hosted the Irregular Wine Tasting. And that was the theme song. Five hundred dollar bottle of Wine.
Evan
That's great.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
When was that?
John Tottenham
Oh, it was about. Probably stopped about 10 years ago and went on for about five years while it lasted.
Evan
We should do that somehow.
John Tottenham
Yeah, I mean, the guy's a wine expert connoisseur, and so he would get certain bottles of wine and he pair.
Evan
Them with fall records.
John Tottenham
He paired them with various things. Like, for example, he had me reading my Inertia Variations one time and he paired that with Wine.
Evan
That's great.
John Tottenham
And he would pair all kinds of things with it.
Evan
What a genius idea.
John Tottenham
It was great. I wish it was still going on.
Evan
You know, I should revive that idea. I wish I knew more about wine. I have the same amount of knowledge about wine as I do about jazz, which is to say some.
John Tottenham
Yeah, that's a good comparison.
Evan
I'm not like, oh, yeah, this and that player. I know where he was born.
John Tottenham
Well, I mean, there's. I think I know a lot more about Chaz than wine because I don't have a taste for wine. I just don't understand it. I understand tequila and whiskey, but not wine.
Evan
Well, I don't really get how when people talk about wine, they're like. Like this tastes like. And then they'll say these other things.
John Tottenham
It's very pretentious.
Evan
How can you. I mean, it's like easily clowned upon, but, like, I want to know what that means. But then when I actually drink wine, I'm just kind of like, I can't get past knowing that it's just grapes and that it's like, yeah, that's there. But it's kind of hard to, like, force myself to imagine that it's. It's a cigar box or whatever they say, you know, or that this is like wet leaves and clay, like, I guess. But mostly I'm just thinking about different types of grapes that might have literally actually caused this.
John Tottenham
I don't know anything about wine, but I can tell the difference between Night Train and Thunderbird.
Unknown
A $500 bottle of wine. A $500 bot.
Evan
Wine.
Unknown
A fly bottle dollar bottle of wine.
Evan
That's all we get for beer.
Unknown
Whip them all the time. Give them a five bottle bottle of wine. That's what we get most of the time.
Evan
A $500 bottle of wine. A $500 bot. Which one is worse?
John Tottenham
I don't know if Night Train even exists anymore. I remember when I first came over to this country, I didn't understand what those were. Just very colorful and seductive sounding names you were chucking in. Just like Thunderbird. Yeah, because I heard him in Tom Waits songs or rock and roll songs. I wanted to drink Thunderbird wine. I got over here, I got a bottle of it and sat in the park in San Francisco and drank a whole bott bottle one afternoon.
Evan
What was that like?
John Tottenham
I don't know. It was disgusting. It's very syrupy and thick, you know?
Evan
Yeah, it's horrible. I mean, I've never even probably had more than a sip of it ever.
John Tottenham
A Night Train. Of course there was. Well, yeah, there was a. I don't know. Man, you don't see those wines around so much anymore.
Evan
Have you ever seen that movie Street Trash?
John Tottenham
Street Life?
Evan
No. Street Trash.
John Tottenham
What's that?
Evan
No, it's called.
John Tottenham
Not that Seattle film. No, it's not. It's called no Street Wise Street.
Evan
It's not Street Wise. Street trash is a 1987 like splatter gore movie where the conceit is that. That some guy in a. The basement of a convenience store finds this dusty old box of bum wine that looks like Thunderbird. And everybody who drinks it just liquefies into a puddle of grotesque neon goo. And like there's a scene that's infamous where like in like the ruins of a building, this bum like drinks the wine and then wine, he drinks the bullshit. And then he like liquefies into the toilet and his like arm rips off as he's like. He accidentally like flushes himself down the drain.
John Tottenham
Wow. I've never heard of it.
Evan
Yeah, it's like a really, you know, classic sort of gross out movie. Be well, but it's kind of funny that like there is a. A Thunderbird horror movie. Basically. It's called Viper in the.
John Tottenham
That's a good one.
Evan
Yeah. See, like, look at the bottle.
John Tottenham
Oh, wow. Anyway, some people, I just don't. My palette is not suited to it.
Evan
500 bottle of wine. I like that. It's sort of just a one idea and it's a strong idea. Just like it's Kind of a good idea for a poem. It's a loaded image. It's a loaded concept. That's what you get for being around him all the time.
John Tottenham
Yeah, that's what you're right.
Evan
And it was Craig Leon, apparently.
John Tottenham
Well, so the story goes, but there are several stories about it. Yeah, Mes drank it and told Brisk it tasted like shit then. The price of the bottle today is $8,000.
Evan
What was the bottle?
John Tottenham
1982 bottle of Petrus Pomerol.
Evan
Okay. Means nothing to me. Quote. I like to look at the albums like Diary. Not one for nostalgia.
John Tottenham
Well, people always say that.
Evan
Yeah. But I think that this record kind of proves it. Like, there's a few songs on here that seem pretty diaristic between. Oh, yeah, Reckoning and this song having this direct story connection to just things that peeved him.
John Tottenham
Well, you know, we missed out on one of the best songs.
Evan
Well, what?
John Tottenham
City Dweller.
Evan
We. That's next.
John Tottenham
That's maybe the last one.
Evan
No, there's. Shut up after that.
John Tottenham
City Dweller is great. It's one of those sort of vibe songs.
Unknown
Victor Vestage of the Euro War.
John Tottenham
Random. It's a Good Life, Bound to Tyrant.
Evan
Gone.
Unknown
Christian Gang Ch.
John Tottenham
Is now in.
Unknown
Dismantle All Head Stuck in Bloody Plant Pots.
Evan
Production wise is. It's worth noting that this record has that definite sort of like. Kind of overstuffed degree of like 90s like, fusion club rock signifiers with the production. It's. It's very like. Like. I guess, sort of like acid house influence influenced. Is that the genre that they're sort of grabbing from?
John Tottenham
Yeah, because the. Isn't it? Yeah. It does sort of bear some resemblance to what was.
Evan
I don't. I'm not this song.
John Tottenham
Certainly.
Evan
I know exactly as much about wine as I do trans music. Yeah. Just like techno, too. It's like techno, jazz and wine. I think I know exactly. Exactly the same amount about.
John Tottenham
What about the Stone Roses.
Evan
What about the.
John Tottenham
You like them?
Evan
I don't know.
John Tottenham
I don't either.
Evan
I remember being. I don't know how old and like, when they were announced to be headlining Coachella that one year I had never heard of.
John Tottenham
Oh, they got back together, too.
Evan
This was like a long time ago. No.
John Tottenham
Yeah. City Tour is a good one. It's apparent has some basis in Manchester's bid to host the Olympics three years later.
Evan
Did they?
John Tottenham
No, they were denied once again. Yeah. This record came out in 93. The 1996 Olympics were. Or maybe it was the 2000 ones they were bidding for. Yeah, they bid it unsuccessfully in 92, 96 and 2000 and finally landing a sort of booby prize for the 2002 Commonwealth Games. Fascinating.
Evan
Yeah, yeah, the Olympics. I don't really care. Too young. But I like this one. I'm curious which ones from this record show up on a pass Gone mat that compilation.
John Tottenham
I've heard of it cuz I like.
Evan
That compilation a lot. Oh, that's like the 90s compilation. Kind of like honoring this period from 99. It's got my. Yeah, gee, I don't see. So behind the counter is on it. Hey student. I think that's it from this record.
John Tottenham
Oh yeah. Free range, touch sensitive, old and money.
Evan
F. Old and money. That's a good one.
John Tottenham
The original is great.
Evan
Yeah. But the COVID is kind of like really good.
John Tottenham
Yeah, it's great.
Evan
It sounds like it's past your bedtime.
John Tottenham
Mine.
Evan
Shut up. That's the next song.
John Tottenham
Past your bedtime.
Evan
No. Shut up.
John Tottenham
Oh yeah, right.
Evan
Well it's a cover.
John Tottenham
I don't know the original, honestly.
Evan
Whoa, you don't know the original?
John Tottenham
No.
Evan
What do you mean you don't know?
John Tottenham
I don't know the Monks. Really.
Evan
They only have one album, John.
John Tottenham
Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean I know a few of those songs I. I've never really listened to.
Evan
Oh you really, you must.
John Tottenham
Is this awful?
Evan
Yeah.
John Tottenham
Is this. It's crucial. Right?
Evan
That's actually a huge mistake. I can't believe. And it's.
John Tottenham
And it's a compilation, right?
Evan
Basically. I mean it's. It's. It's an album. But no, we have to do a.
John Tottenham
Monks episode actually, since I've never heard. Listened to him. I don't know.
Evan
I think so. I think once you have spent some time with it, it's worth talking about. Cuz the Monks is. There's a reason why Marky Smith was obsessed with them. The Monks is like kind of this on unexplainable thing. But it was a bunch of American GIs who got like produced by these like sort of bizarre style gurus of like post Weimar Germany. Like these sort of like Bauhaus, those like German Steve Jobs types who were like we are going to make you into a sexy band. And there were just these American himbos who were like okay. And then they're playing in this band where it's like banjo and like. But it's kind of like the Velvet Underground but like before that. And they're just like going really hard and like making a huge amount of mischief in Hamburg and they're forced to dress like monks. With full on tonsures by these guys who are like their creative directors. And as soon as it became clear that they weren't gonna make any money, those guys just dipped. But they like had made this album that just ended up being.
John Tottenham
And they all had monk haircuts too.
Evan
Yeah, fully. They did. And like those German like handlers basically told them, like, you cannot go outside together unless you are always dressed as this. Like wearing black robes and like capes. Black suits, black capes, full monk hair. And playing this like bizarre aggressive of pseudo political proto punk music in the early to mid-1960s in Germany.
John Tottenham
It's not on Spotify.
Evan
No, it's not. For some reason. Just the sum of it is like some like. It's like a collection of.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
Demos or something that's there. But the one album. Just buy it like it's one record, however expensive it is to get it on vinyl. It's like kind of worth the price because you got only one. No, I don't have it.
John Tottenham
It's from. What the.
Evan
But yeah. Anyway, I explained all that just to bring the point home that, like, there's a reason Marky Smith covered them twice and was a huge.
John Tottenham
What was the other one?
Evan
There's Shut up here and then there's Black Monk Time. But man, I. I want to just talk about the monks. Anyway. How many stars out of three do you give Middle Class Revolt? We didn't talk about the COVID The COVID is by Pascal Legrasse, who did a lot of the great covers, did their best covers. I mean, I think that the Shift Work cover is one of my favorite album covers ever. It's a good cover, though.
John Tottenham
Yeah.
Evan
An unforgettable image. There's four little guys shaped like tops on the COVID That's all you really need, a cover.
John Tottenham
It's an unforgettable image, kind of because it's like I. If you told me to reproduce it or remember it, I never would have been able to do so without. I would have actually said those four shapes were parallel with each other. Not.
Evan
Anyway, no, it's like a diamond.
John Tottenham
Yes, exactly. I wouldn't have remembered. I think it's rather a forgettable colour. Well, in a peculiar colour scheme. Also with that beige.
Evan
It's yellow, I guess. Anyway, it's like an hour and 10 minutes less forgettable now.
John Tottenham
Joe, come in.
Unknown
Shut up, don't cry. Shut up, don't cry. Shut up, don't cry.
Podcast Summary: Jokermen – "The Fall: MIDDLE CLASS REVOLT with John Tottenham"
Episode Information
In this episode of the Jokermen Podcast, host Evan welcomes special guest John Tottenham to delve deep into The Fall's sixteenth studio album, Middle Class Revolt. Recorded prior to their introductory banter, the conversation seamlessly transitions from light-hearted exchanges to an in-depth analysis of one of The Fall's more obscure records.
Evan and John begin by establishing the album's position in The Fall's discography, clarifying that Middle Class Revolt is indeed their sixteenth studio album, released in May 1994. They express that this record is often overlooked compared to its predecessors and successors, such as Cerebral Caustic and Shift Work.
Evan [01:28]: "It is literally the 16th studio album by The Fall... and you're wrong."
They discuss the album's reception, noting that some critics deem it one of the band's weakest efforts, particularly criticizing its selection of cover songs.
A significant portion of the discussion centers around the album's inclusion of covers from bands like Henry Cow, Groundhogs, and The Monks. Both Evan and John express skepticism about these choices, arguing that they detract from the album's overall quality.
John Tottenham [04:33]: "I'm gonna have a really good time together... we're gonna have a real good time together."
Evan [04:54]: "Middle Class Revolt, and I don't even... you have it on CD, right?"
They highlight specific tracks such as "Shut Up" and "Black Monk Time," critiquing their execution and relevance to The Fall's signature sound.
The conversation shifts to an analysis of "15 Ways to Leave Your Man," a satirical take on Paul Simon's "21 Ways to Leave Your Lover." They commend the song's clever twist and its reflection of Mark E. Smith's penchant for wordplay.
Evan [10:00]: "I think 15 Ways to Leave Your Man is good. It's one of the more sarcastic, emotionally scorned Mark E. Smith productions."
"Reckoning" is lauded as one of the standout tracks, praised for its poignant lyrics and emotional depth. Evan mentions that Matt Fishback considers it his favorite Fall song, underscoring its significance.
John Tottenham [13:50]: "Reckoning is Matt Fishback's favorite Fall song. Wow. Which makes sense."
They discuss the autobiographical elements, suggesting it reflects Smith's personal experiences, possibly alluding to relationships during that period.
The track "M5" receives attention for its atmospheric depiction of English highways and urban life. They interpret the song as a commentary on the fragmented nature of city living.
John Tottenham [21:02]: "It's named after the motorway M5 and is about England..."
Evan and John examine the album's production, noting its 90s fusion influences and how it diverges from The Fall's traditional sound. They discuss the possible acid house elements and the overstuffed production style that marks Middle Class Revolt.
Evan [67:58]: "It's very like acid house influenced. Is that the genre that they're sort of grabbing from?"
The duo expands their discussion to broader cultural themes, particularly the concept of the middle-class revolt. They debate the validity and implications of the album's title, pondering its double meanings and relevance to contemporary societal issues.
John Tottenham [46:21]: "We skipped it."
Evan [47:06]: "It's a funny title because what is a middle class revolt? It's like the least thing, the last thing..."
Their conversation touches on the class system in England versus the United States, highlighting differences in societal structures and cultural expressions.
Evan and John draw parallels between The Fall and other bands like The Clash, Oasis, Blur, and Pulp. They critique certain bands for their authenticity and artistic choices, contrasting them with The Fall's approach.
Evan [51:34]: "So do you not like Joe Strummer? He is kind of like the..."
John Tottenham [52:34]: "He was a middle class guy who affected working class mannerisms..."
Throughout the episode, Evan and John share personal anecdotes, such as Evan's argument about Israel and its impact on his perception, as well as stories about wine tasting events and obscure films like "Street Trash." These tangents, while not directly related to Middle Class Revolt, provide a richer context to their personalities and perspectives.
John Tottenham [59:28]: "It was hosted by this Englishman, Julian Davies and cousin Roy, who was the Fall road manager..."
As the episode wraps up, Evan and John reflect on the enduring legacy of Middle Class Revolt. Despite its mixed reception, they acknowledge its unique place in The Fall's catalog and its reflection of Mark E. Smith's complex artistry.
Evan [65:03]: "How many stars out of three do you give Middle Class Revolt?"
John Tottenham [65:27]: "That's not bad."
They conclude with a light-hearted discussion about hypothetical future episodes, such as tackling The Fall's exhaustive Hard Mode, emphasizing their passion for exploring even the most challenging aspects of the band's work.
This episode of the Jokermen Podcast offers a comprehensive exploration of The Fall's Middle Class Revolt, enriched by John Tottenham's insights and Evan's engaging commentary. Through detailed song analyses, cultural critiques, and personal anecdotes, listeners gain a deeper appreciation for the intricacies of The Fall's music and the enduring conversations it inspires.
Subscribe to Jokermen Podcast for more deep dives into iconic bands and albums. Follow @jokermenpodcast on Instagram and Twitter for updates and behind-the-scenes content.