Kibbe on Liberty Ep 357: “Mike Johnson Is Holding the Government Hostage over the Epstein Files”

Guest: Rep. Thomas Massie
Host: Matt Kibbe
Date: October 29, 2025
Duration: ~56 minutes

Episode Overview

In this episode, Matt Kibbe continues his in-depth conversation with Rep. Thomas Massie, focusing on Massie’s controversial effort to force a vote to release the names in the Epstein files via a rare Congressional discharge petition. The discussion covers Rep. Massie's campaign for government transparency, the political resistance he’s facing (including from Speaker Mike Johnson), and broader questions on foreign influence, particularly regarding Israel and its effect on US politics and foreign policy. The conversation blends Massie’s first-hand Congressional insights with candid, often provocative, exchanges about the suppression of information, pressure campaigns within Congress, and the cross-party establishment's stakes in keeping Epstein-related secrets.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Epstein Files Discharge Petition and Congressional Stalemate

• [01:13–05:23]
  • Matt Kibbe theorizes that the only reason Speaker Mike Johnson hasn’t reconvened the House is to block Massie's discharge petition that would force the release of Epstein files.
  • Massie explains: House leadership is preventing the swearing-in of a new Democrat member, thus halting progress on the discharge petition which requires 218 signatures.
    • “He’s keeping the clock from moving, and he’s keeping a congressional district in Arizona from being represented.” — Massie [02:57]
  • Pro forma sessions count toward the required seven legislative days before a vote, but the Speaker could swear in the new member during these, choosing not to for political reasons.

2. Political and Institutional Resistance to Releasing Epstein Files

• [05:23–08:15]

  • Massie points out that Johnson’s use of a shutdown as an excuse for recess is unprecedented.

  • Opposition from all sides—even Trump—confounds Massie, given years of Republican rhetoric demanding transparency on Epstein.

  • Survivors and their advocates have provided at least 20 suspect names. The White House called GOP support for Massie's petition a "hostile act," placing immense pressure on signers like Marjorie Taylor Greene, Lauren Boebert, and Nancy Mace.

    “The pressure is, when you get down to that one last house on the block that hasn't sold... The price is high. And all three of them are paying a large political price to represent their constituents and these survivors.” — Massie [08:11]

3. The Human Cost and Systemic Evil of Epstein’s Trafficking

• [09:23–13:00]

  • Massie describes the traumatic testimonies of Epstein’s survivors—some coerced into trafficking other girls in exchange for getting out of abuse.

    • The process led to lifelong shame, discouraging victims from coming forward, while the accused remain shielded by power and wealth.

  • Survivors face the threat of devastating defamation suits if they accuse rich, litigious perpetrators.

    “I didn't really fully grasp how evil this is. Like, it's one thing to do evil things to people, but to make them do evil things.” — Massie [11:10]

4. Congressional Manipulation: Blocking Hearings and Delaying Justice

• [13:00–16:18]

  • The House recess halts not just Epstein votes but also hearings, e.g., the Attorney General cannot be made to testify, further stalling accountability.

    “It’s very convenient. It drags that out… So the speaker is having a recess, not just to avoid the impending vote on this issue, but to avoid any hearings whatsoever where this issue would come up.” — Massie [14:05]

• Massie tried to leverage limited committee time to push for information about Epstein’s intelligence connections and the integrity of FBI records.

  “There is a CIA file on Jeffrey Epstein that I want to see… Like, you're suspiciously uncurious about that.” — Massie [15:35]

5. Word Games and Evasion from Federal Agencies

• [16:50–18:13]

  • FBI and DOJ use subjective terms like “credible evidence” to avoid admitting the existence of other perpetrators—deflecting responsibility and masking political manipulation.

    “Credible is a politician word. It's not something you would use in a courtroom, I don't think.” — Massie [18:10]

• Speech or Debate Clause shields Massie from retaliation or defamation lawsuits when speaking in Congress, explaining why he named a single suspect publicly.

6. Why the Sudden Opposition? Motivation of Politicians and the ‘Uni Party’

• [22:13–25:46]

  • Kibbe raises the theory that Trump opposes release not because he’s implicated, but to protect embarrassment among associates or under pressure from intelligence agencies, particularly with connections to Israel.

  • Bipartisan or “Uni Party” reluctance reflects protection of elite reputations rather than ideological grounds.

    “Once you get to billionaire level, you transcend the whole party game. You're just, you're rich enough to influence whoever is in power.” — Massie [23:10]

• Former Israeli Prime Minister/Ehud Barak’s ties to Epstein also potentially motivate secrecy.

7. Political Reality: Hall Passes, Pressure, and Historical Precedent

• [26:26–31:23]

  • Party leadership may grant “hall passes”—private permission for some members to vote against leadership for political cover.

  • Massie and Khanna’s discharge petition is extraordinarily rare (only 20 have succeeded), making the attempt both controversial and notable. Khanna’s Rules Committee effort inspired Massie to pursue this unusual legislative maneuver.

    “I'm literally going to get a bill passed in the hardest way possible. It's only been done 20 times in the history of Congress and I'm about to pull it off.” — Massie [31:30]

8. Epstein, Israel, and Foreign Influence: The Nexus

• [32:28–39:48]

  • Kibbe suggests the fight over Epstein files proxies deeper issues—America’s relationship with Israel and foreign influence on policy.

  • Massie details the three billionaires targeting him for defeat—Miriam Adelson (dual citizen, major GOP donor), Paul Singer (media influence, major donor), and John Paulson (in Epstein’s book but not necessarily guilty). Their involvement illustrates the “small universe” of interlocking political and financial interests.

  • Media smear campaigns exploit tenuous associations, while ignoring connections to genuinely powerful interests.

    “The people that control the newspaper that's writing the hit piece are the same people that want the war to go on are the same people trying to take me out are friends and co donors with people who knew Jeffrey Epstein…” — Massie [38:20]

9. Massie’s Consistent Anti-Interventionism & the Israel Lobby

• [39:48–45:36]

  • Massie reiterates: He has always opposed ALL foreign aid, not just for Israel, calling for “non-intervention.”

  • US support for the war in Gaza is heavily orchestrated by lobbying, with speeches by Netanyahu presented as PR events for both American and Israeli domestic audiences.

  • Foreign lobbying—especially by AIPAC (the American Israel Public Affairs Committee)—largely escapes proper foreign agent registration and transparency.

    “I think we should have country of origin labeling on our political donations and campaigns in the United States. Which country or which countries lobby.” — Massie [43:12]

• Congress members like Massie and Marjorie Taylor Greene explicitly refuse to meet with foreign lobbyists of any kind.

10. Polling, Political Shifts, and Attack Ads

• [45:36–51:00]

  • Polls in Massie’s Kentucky district show declining support for US aid to Israel among Republicans—a trend for over a decade.

  • Attack ads against Massie are primarily on unrelated social issues (e.g., transgender sports), often funded by donors supporting opposite positions—media manipulation at play.

    “That’s the dude who’s the biggest donor... funding the ads saying that I'm for that thing that he's for and that it’s a bad thing. Obviously I’m not for it. But that's the kind of duplicitous tactics they use.” — Massie [52:20]

11. Outsider Status, Grassroots Support, and Political Isolation

• [53:07–55:56]

  • Attacks from the establishment are increasing Massie’s grassroots support—elevating his message and increasing fundraising.

  • He acknowledges his pariah status, sharing the title of “most hated” in D.C. with Marjorie Taylor Greene for their refusal to bend on principle.

  • Commentary on the disconnect between the political class and voters—being principled is now considered anomalous.

    “When you are singular and hold a position that is the majority position in the Republican Party, but you're the only Republican in Washington D.C. holding that position, you're going to find a lot of support.” — Massie [54:18]

    “If there's an issue, you know, that everybody's pretty well informed on and they are 80% in support of it, and you come here to Washington, D.C. and you support that as well, it doesn't mean you're running for president. It just means you're doing your damn job.” — Massie [55:35]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Congressional shutdown and its motive:
  “Not only are we shut down, we're in recess. And that's unconventional, unprecedented in the 13 years I've been in Congress.” — Massie [05:18]

• On the persistent pressure on discharge petition signers:
  “All three of them are paying a large political price to represent their constituents and these survivors.” — Massie [08:11]

• On Epstein survivors and systemic evil:
  “I didn't really fully grasp how evil this is... to make them do evil things. And then once he causes you to be implicated, then you don't want to come out because then that's what happens to you.” — Massie [11:10]

• On political word games:
  “Credible is a politician word. It's not something you would use in a courtroom, I don't think.” — Massie [18:10]

• On entrenched interests and bipartisanship:
  “Once you get to billionaire level, you transcend the whole party game...” — Massie [23:10]

• On being accused of ineffectiveness while making history:
  “I'm literally going to get a bill passed in the hardest way possible. It's only been done 20 times in the history of Congress and I'm about to pull it off.” — Massie [31:30]

• On lobbying and foreign influence:
  “I think we should have country of origin labeling on our political donations and campaigns in the United States.” — Massie [43:12]

• On holding principles in a hostile political environment:
  “When you are singular and hold a position that is the majority position in the Republican Party, but you're the only Republican in Washington D.C. holding that position, you're going to find a lot of support.” — Massie [54:18]

Key Timestamps

• [01:13] – Massie discusses the Congressional stalemate (House not being reconvened; Epstein petition)
• [05:23] – Massie on unprecedented Congressional recess/shutdown tactics
• [08:15] – Pressure campaign against discharge petition signers
• [09:23] – Survivor testimonies and the mechanics of Epstein’s coercion
• [13:00] – Hearings and oversight delayed by Speaker’s tactics
• [16:50] – Agency evasion and “credible evidence” word games
• [18:13] – Speech or Debate Clause protects Massie’s disclosures
• [22:13] – Kibbe and Massie discuss Trump’s motives and bipartisan elite protection
• [26:26] – Hall passes, party pressure, and discharge petition history
• [32:28] – Kibbe: Is this a proxy fight for the US-Israel relationship?
• [33:03] – Massie details the billionaires waging political war against him
• [39:48] – Massie’s consistent anti-intervention foreign policy
• [45:36] – Polls show declining Republican support for Israel aid
• [53:07] – Attacks galvanizing Massie’s grassroots support
• [54:18] – The loneliness of holding the majority’s position in DC

Takeaways for New Listeners

This episode pulls back the curtain on the rarely discussed mechanisms of Congressional obstruction and internal party warfare, all unfolding around the explosive question of Epstein's powerful clients. Rep. Massie blends deep procedural knowledge, raw survivor testimony, and unapologetic critique of US-Israel relations and lobbying power, making for a bracing listen—especially for those unconvinced by official narratives from either party. The stakes—a Congress that resists transparency and a political system addicted to foreign entanglements—are felt on every level, channeled through Massie’s iconoclastic voice and Kibbe’s probing libertarian questioning.