Mind of a Serial Killer: Jeffrey Dahmer Pt. 3 – Detailed Summary

Episode Release Date: October 14, 2024
Hosts: Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels
Podcast: Mind of a Serial Killer, Crime House Studios

Introduction

In the third installment of their four-part series on Jeffrey Dahmer, hosts Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels delve deeper into the escalating violence and psychological unraveling of one of history’s most notorious serial killers. This episode meticulously traces Dahmer's progression from his second murder to his eventual capture, offering both a narrative of his heinous acts and an expert psychological analysis of his disturbed mind.

Recap of Previous Episode

The episode begins with a brief recap of the previous episode, where Dahmer's first murder—Stephen Hicks in 1978—and his subsequent struggles to repress his murderous instincts were examined. Vanessa highlights Dahmer's initial ability to temporarily stave off his violent urges through alcohol abuse, setting the stage for his later descent into unrestrained brutality.

Dahmer’s Second Murder and Increasing Violence

Stephen Twomey’s Murder ([04:41])

On November 21, 1987, 27-year-old Jeffrey Dahmer murdered his second victim, Stephen Twomey. Dahmer lured Twomey to the Ambassador Motel in Milwaukee, drugged him with sleeping pills, and claimed to have no memory of the act. Vanessa narrates the grim aftermath, detailing Dahmer's method of disposing of Twomey's body using a wheeled suitcase and hiding it in his grandmother Catherine's cellar.

Psychological Implications ([06:34])

Dr. Tristan Engels discusses Dahmer's alleged memory loss during the murder, suggesting possibilities such as dissociative rage or intentional repression to avoid the discomfort of his actions. He posits, “If he truly does not remember it, it could likely have been a dissociative rage.”

Escalation of Murders and Ritualistic Behavior

James Doxtator’s Murder ([12:00])

Less than two months after Twomey’s murder, Dahmer killed James Doxtator, a 14-year-old boy. Unlike previous victims, Doxtator was significantly younger, redefining Dahmer’s victim profile. Post-murder, Dahmer engaged in necrophilia, a first in his series of crimes. Dr. Engels explains, “Necrophilia is the use of a corpse for sexual pleasure,” highlighting Dahmer’s deepening obsession with retaining his victims.

Richard Guerrero and Ronald Flowers ([19:42] – [27:48])

Dahmer continued his spree by murdering Richard Guerrero and later Ronald Flowers, the latter of whom survived Dahmer’s attack. Flowers’ escape led to increased tension, with Dahmer’s grandmother Catherine asking him to move out due to his erratic behavior and constant drinking. Vanessa notes, “With good behavior, he was released two months early, on March 20, 1990.”

Psychological Evaluation and Legal Maneuvering

Court Proceedings ([27:48] – [30:24])

Dahmer underwent psychological evaluations as part of his court case for sexually assaulting Somsack Sinthasemphon. Dr. Engels differentiates between psychological evaluations and therapy, emphasizing their role in determining criminal responsibility and suitability for mental health programs. Despite multiple psychologists labeling him a menace, the judge sentenced Dahmer to only a year in a minimum security facility with work release, a decision Vanessa critiques as dangerously lenient.

Setting Boundaries with Dahmer ([28:35] – [29:29])

Vanessa inquires about managing a patient like Dahmer, to which Dr. Engels responds, “It’s very important to make sure that they know that there are limits to how far they can push anybody and to not reinforce bad behavior.” This highlights the challenges mental health professionals face when dealing with individuals exhibiting extreme antisocial behavior.

Continuation and Intensification of Murders

Relocation and New Victims ([38:51] – [48:49])

After his release, Dahmer moved to a low-income neighborhood in Milwaukee, believing the community’s indifference would help him evade detection. He murdered Raymond Smith and Eddie Smith, adopting increasingly gruesome methods, including setting up a ritualistic altar with their remains. Dr. Engels observes, “He needs to keep a piece of them with him forever,” underscoring Dahmer’s compulsive need to possess his victims.

Cannibalism and Further Escalation ([47:55] – [48:49])

Dahmer’s crimes grew more horrific with attempted cannibalism, as seen in his murder of Ernest Miller and David Thomas. Dr. Engels explains, “Eating a part of them is a very symbolic way for him to feel as if they're becoming part of him and therefore with him forever,” shedding light on Dahmer’s twisted motivations.

The Breaking Point and Near Capture

Konerak Sinthasemphone’s Survival ([49:31] – [52:25])

On May 27, 1991, Dahmer murdered Konerak Sinthasemphone, the younger brother of one of his near-victims, Somsack. However, Konerak survived Dahmer’s gruesome attempts to create a “human vegetable,” leading to his rescue by bystanders and immediate police intervention. Vanessa describes this as Dahmer’s first close encounter with law enforcement: “For the first time, he'd been caught red-handed and he had no idea how he was going to talk himself out of it.”

Conclusion and Foreshadowing

The episode concludes with the revelation of Konerak’s survival, setting the stage for the investigation into Dahmer’s crimes in the upcoming episodes. Vanessa reflects on Dahmer’s relentless pursuit of his dark fantasies, despite numerous warnings and legitimate threats of exposure.

Notable Quotes

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([06:34]): “There’s another aspect here of like, a dissociative rage. And I think that is what explains Jeffrey’s behavior in this case.”

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([11:07]): “Those mementos allow them to relive covertly the memories and the associated thrill of the crime.”

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([15:14]): “Necrophilia is not something that is very common. But in the case of Jeffrey, this is the ultimate way for him to have sexual gratification with somebody who cannot reject him.”

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([34:17]): “I think it’s pretty consistent with what’s happened after each victim, is that he needs to keep a piece of them with him forever.”

Final Thoughts

This episode of Mind of a Serial Killer offers a chilling exploration of Jeffrey Dahmer’s descent into deeper depravity, coupled with insightful psychological analysis that helps listeners understand the complexities of his motivations and behaviors. Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels provide a comprehensive narrative that not only recounts Dahmer’s crimes but also probes the dark recesses of his mind, posing the haunting question: What makes a serial killer?

For more true crime content, follow Crime House on Instagram and TikTok @crimehouse. Subscribe to Mind of a Serial Killer wherever you get your podcasts and consider supporting them by rating and reviewing the show.