Clues with Morgan Absher and Kaylin Moore Episode: The Laci Peterson Case Release Date: April 25, 2025

Introduction

In the premiere episode of Clues, a Crime House Original hosted by Morgan Absher, a seasoned Internet sleuth, and Kaylin Moore, an adept analyst, the duo delves deep into the perplexing and heartbreaking case of Laci Peterson. Released on April 25, 2025, this episode meticulously unpacks the events surrounding Laci's disappearance, the subsequent investigation, and the eventual conviction of her husband, Scott Peterson.

Background of Laci and Scott Peterson

Morgan and Kaylin begin by painting a vivid picture of Laci Peterson's life and her relationship with Scott Peterson.

• Laci Peterson (Born May 4, 1975): Described by her friends as a "spark of light," Laci was a vibrant individual who cherished her role as a wife and aspired to be a mother. Her passion for homemaking and love for simple pleasures like watching Martha Stewart showcases her nurturing nature.

• Scott Peterson: Meeting Laci in 1994, their relationship blossomed, leading to marriage in 1997. Initially hesitant about fatherhood, Scott seemed supportive when Laci became pregnant in May 2002.

Morgan Abshur ([09:54]): "Just happy to be where she is and who she is. Just so sure of herself."

The Disappearance on December 24, 2002

The episode meticulously outlines the timeline of the day Laci vanished:

1. Morning Activities:

   • Laci attended a Christmas party on December 14, while Scott claimed absence due to a "business trip."
   • On December 24, Laci ran errands, attended a doctor's appointment, and visited her sister. Scott was supposed to watch Martha Stewart on TV.

2. Suspicious Behavior:

   • Scott's alibi began to crumble as inconsistencies emerged. Initially stating he played golf, he later confessed to taking his boat out from the Berkeley Marina—a detail unknown to his family.

Morgan Abshur ([13:16]): "Given that he pulled the parking ticket at 12:54pm and then left a voicemail for Lacey at 2:15 saying he was headed back, doesn't give you a lot of time to fish."

3. Discovery of Missing Laci:
   • Laci was reported missing the same evening, leading to frantic searches and growing suspicion towards Scott due to his detached demeanor.

Key Evidence and Clues

1. Hair Found on Pliers

A pivotal discovery was Laci's hair embedded in a pair of pliers found on Scott's boat.

Morgan Abshur ([39:06]): "Finding her hair wrapped up in the pliers, I find it really hard to think it's from any other reason."

This evidence suggested a direct physical link between Laci and the tools potentially used in her disappearance.

2. Homemade Concrete Anchors

Scott had fashioned concrete anchors for his boat, an activity scrutinized for its oddity and timing.

• Concrete Dust: Excessive dust in his warehouse indicated multiple anchors were made, contradicting Scott's claim of creating just one.

• Missing Anchors: Prosecutors argued that missing anchors could have been used to restrain Laci.

Kaylin Moore ([44:52]): "It's about what Scott did with that concrete or says he didn't do with the concrete that makes him look suspicious."

3. GPS Tracking Data

The installation of GPS trackers on Scott's vehicles revealed multiple, brief visits to the Berkeley Marina post-disappearance.

Morgan Abshur ([53:32]): "This GPS data kind of showed this obsession with returning to the marina, and it put him right at the location where Lacey and Connor's bodies were later discovered."

The proximity of these visits to the eventual discovery of Laci and her unborn son Connor's bodies heightened suspicions.

4. Sale of Personal Possessions

Amidst the search, Scott sold Laci's car and pawned valuable jewelry, raising questions about his motives and awareness of her fate.

Kaylin Moore ([67:39]): "The jewelry ended up coming out to over a hundred thousand dollars."

The Trial and Conviction

Morgan and Kaylin discuss the five-month-long trial that culminated in Scott's conviction.

• Conviction: Scott was found guilty of first-degree murder for Laci and second-degree murder for Connor on November 12, 2004.

• Sentencing: Initially sentenced to death on December 13, 2004, Scott's sentence was later overturned in August 2020 due to judicial misconduct regarding juror selection. He was re-sentenced to life imprisonment without parole in September 2021.

Morgan Abshur ([75:13]): "It was the pliers for me."

Appeals and Current Status

Two decades post-conviction, Scott Peterson remains incarcerated, continuously asserting his innocence. The LA Innocence Project (Laip), an independent organization, has taken up his case, advocating for DNA testing and post-conviction discovery.

Kaylin Moore ([61:21]): "Scott reached out to Laip the summer of 2023 requesting that they re-investigate his case."

Despite the overwhelming evidence presented during the trial, ongoing debates and uncovered clues keep the case in public discourse.

Host Reflections and Conclusion

Both hosts express a personal conviction regarding Scott Peterson's guilt, citing the accumulation of suspicious behaviors and evidence.

Kaylin Moore ([75:26]): "Turning Connor's room into a storage unit. Like that just, to me, comes across as someone who not only knows that his family's not coming back, but doesn't want them to come back."

Morgan Abshur ([74:50]): "But using those as a way to tie weights to her, I think by his own admission, and him saying, like, she was never on the boat. Yeah, that kind of sealed it for me."

They also highlight the broader impact of Laci's case, including the enactment of the Unborn Victims of Violence Act of 2004, ensuring legal recognition for unborn children in cases of violence.

Kaylin Moore ([77:56]): "What remains undeniable is the profound loss felt by Lacey's family, her friends, and everyone who continues to seek and fight to uphold justice in her name."

Key Takeaways

• Behavioral Red Flags: Scott Peterson exhibited numerous suspicious behaviors post-disappearance, including inconsistent alibis, sale of possessions, and questionable use of forensic evidence.

• Forensic Evidence: Physical clues like Laci's hair on pliers and homemade anchors played a significant role in linking Scott to the crime.

• Legal Proceedings: Despite robust evidence leading to Scott's conviction, appeals and involvement from organizations like Laip indicate enduring controversies surrounding the case.

• Legacy of Laci Peterson: Beyond the immediate tragedy, Laci's case has influenced legal frameworks and continues to serve as a poignant reminder of the dark realities faced by many families.

Engage with Us

Clues encourages listeners to reflect on the evidence and share their own perspectives. Whether you find one piece of evidence more compelling or believe there's room for alternative interpretations, your insights are valuable.

Kaylin Moore ([75:26]): "If you are one of those people that doesn't think Scott did it. What is the one thing you point to where you are like, it couldn't have been him because of this?"

Follow Clues wherever you get your podcasts and stay tuned for more in-depth explorations of some of the most notorious true crime cases.