Killer Minds: Inside the Minds of Serial Killers & Murderers
Episode: SERIAL KILLER: "The Baton Rouge Killer" Pt. 2
Release Date: April 10, 2025
Hosts: Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels
Produced by: Crime House Studios
Introduction
In the second installment of their deep dive into the psyche of Derek Todd Lee, known as the Baton Rouge Serial Killer, hosts Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels continue to unravel the complexities behind Lee’s heinous crimes. This episode explores Lee’s escalating violence, his interactions with law enforcement, and the psychological factors that led to his eventual capture.
Escalation of Violence and Changing Methods of Operation
Vanessa Richardson [04:32]:
"Derek Todd Lee’s obsession with women, which began in his childhood, took a sinister turn into violence as he matured. His early crimes involved voyeurism and peeping, which later escalated into brutal assaults and murders."
Dr. Tristan Engels [03:05]:
"Lee’s inability to handle rejection manifested in violent outbursts, shifting his modus operandi from beating his victims to stabbing them and experimenting with new ways to dispose of their bodies."
Lee’s second confirmed victim, Gina Wilson Green, was sexually assaulted and strangled, marking a shift in his killing style. Unlike his earlier victims, Lee disposed of Gina’s personal belongings, hinting at a strategic attempt to move on from his fixation.
Dr. Tristan Engels [05:54]:
"Most serial killers keep mementos as trophies, but Lee disposed of Gina’s cell phone and wallet shortly after the murder, indicating his need to sever his obsession quickly."
This pattern of escalating violence continued with Geralyn Bar DeSoto and Charlotte Murray Pace, where Lee’s brutality increased, and his attempts to evade detection became more calculated.
Psychological Profile and Personal Life
Dr. Tristan Engels [09:37]:
"Lee exhibited traits of emotional dysregulation and impulse control issues, exacerbated by alcohol abuse. His self-centered and controlling behavior was evident in his abusive relationship with his wife, Jackie."
Lee’s personal life was tumultuous, with financial stress and a second child contributing to his psychological strain. His relationship with his wife became a source of further violence, culminating in the murder of their neighbor, Pam Kinamore.
Dr. Tristan Engels [10:37]:
"Serial killers like Lee often present as abusive partners, using psychological manipulation to maintain control and evade suspicion."
Jackie’s dependency on Lee made it difficult for her to leave the abusive relationship, illustrating the manipulative control Lee exerted over those close to him.
Police Investigation and Challenges
Despite forming a multi-agency task force involving the Baton Rouge Police Department, Louisiana State Police, and the FBI, the investigation faced significant hurdles.
Vanessa Richardson [25:31]:
"The task force struggled to connect Lee to the murders partly due to prevailing stereotypes. Lee, being black, did not fit the typical profile of serial killers investigated at the time, who were predominantly white men targeting victims of the same race."
The presence of another serial killer, Sean Vincent Gillis, further complicated the investigation, leading to misattributed cases and delayed connections to Lee.
Dr. Tristan Engels [25:54]:
"Confirmation bias among law enforcement made it difficult to consider Lee as a suspect, allowing him to continue his spree undetected."
Turning Point and Capture
Lee’s capture came after a series of missteps and persistent investigative efforts. The breakthrough occurred when DNA analysis revealed that the killer was predominantly African, which shifted the task force’s focus.
Vanessa Richardson [34:03]:
"With DNA evidence pointing towards Lee, Detective Mac McDavid’s long-held suspicions were validated. Jackie’s cooperation provided the final clue needed to locate Lee in Atlanta, Georgia."
Lee’s attempt to evade capture by relocating and blending into a new community in Atlanta ultimately led to his downfall. His involvement with the community and continued manipulative behavior enabled the authorities to track him down through a combination of DNA evidence and testimonies from acquaintances.
Dr. Tristan Engels [40:00]:
"Lee’s charm and manipulative skills, honed through numerous encounters with law enforcement, ironically facilitated his capture by creating a breadcrumb trail that led back to him."
Legal Consequences and Final Outcome
Lee faced multiple charges and was convicted for the murders of Geralyn Bar DeSoto and Charlotte Murray Pace, receiving life sentences and the death penalty. However, he never stood trial for all of his crimes, passing away in 2016 while on death row.
Vanessa Richardson [48:03]:
"In the end, Lee’s arrogance and inability to adapt ultimately led to his capture. His DNA was the key that sealed his fate, bringing justice to his victims' families."
Conclusions and Insights
The episode highlights the intricate relationship between a serial killer’s psychological makeup and their methods of operation. Lee’s case underscores the importance of overcoming biases in criminal profiling and the critical role of DNA evidence in modern investigations.
Dr. Tristan Engels [20:15]:
"Lee’s random selection of victims and his ability to adapt his methods made him a particularly elusive and dangerous killer. Understanding his motivations provides valuable insights into preventing similar crimes in the future."
Vanessa Richardson [34:42]:
"Despite his efforts to hide, Lee's psychological need for control and his eventual underestimation of law enforcement capabilities led to his eventual capture."
Notable Quotes
-
Vanessa Richardson [05:54]:
"Lee disposed of Gina’s belongings shortly after the murder, indicating his need to sever his obsession quickly." -
Dr. Tristan Engels [10:37]:
"Serial killers like Lee often present as abusive partners, using psychological manipulation to maintain control and evade suspicion." -
Vanessa Richardson [25:31]:
"The task force struggled to connect Lee to the murders partly due to prevailing stereotypes." -
Dr. Tristan Engels [40:00]:
"Lee’s charm and manipulative skills, honed through numerous encounters with law enforcement, ironically facilitated his capture by creating a breadcrumb trail that led back to him."
Final Thoughts
Through meticulous analysis and gripping storytelling, Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels shed light on the dark complexities of Derek Todd Lee’s criminal mind. This episode not only chronicles his gruesome path but also emphasizes the critical lessons in criminal investigation and psychological profiling necessary to bring such criminals to justice.
Follow "Killer Minds" wherever you get your podcasts and join the conversation on social media @KillerMinds. Subscribe to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts for an ad-free experience and exclusive content.