Killer Minds: Inside the Minds of Serial Killers & Murderers
Episode: SERIAL KILLER: "The Killer Boy" Pt. 2
Release Date: August 14, 2025
Hosts: Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels
Introduction
In the second part of their deep dive into the chilling case of Jesse Pomeroy, Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels explore the disturbing tale of a young Boston boy whose violent inclinations endangered his community. This episode delves into Jesse's crimes, psychological profile, investigation, and eventual downfall, offering a comprehensive look into one of history’s most unsettling juvenile murderers.
Background: Jesse Pomeroy's Early Crimes
Vanessa Richardson sets the stage by recounting Jesse Pomeroy's early life and initial crimes. At just 12 years old, Jesse terrorized the streets of Boston, violently attacking young boys. His youth initially led authorities to believe he could be rehabilitated, resulting in his early release four years later at the age of 14 due to good behavior in reform school.
Vanessa Richardson [02:54]: "In 1871, 12-year-old Jesse Pomeroy sent shockwaves through Boston when he was convicted of a string of brutal acts on at least six young boys."
However, Jesse's release proved premature as his sadistic tendencies persisted. He managed to conceal his dark urges while in reform school by displaying the behavior expected by authorities, which only made him more manipulative and dangerous upon his return to society.
Escalation of Crimes: Katie and Margaret's Disappearances
Less than two months after his release, Jesse's violence escalated. On March 18, 1874, 10-year-old Katie Curran vanished near the Pomeroy's newsstand. Concurrently, Margaret, a teenage girl from Canada working at the same shop, also disappeared. Despite the mounting suspicion surrounding the Pomeroy family, initial investigations yielded no evidence linking Jesse to these disappearances.
Vanessa Richardson [05:59]: "The longer Katie was missing, the more the neighborhood speculated about what had happened to her."
Dr. Engels analyzes the shift in Jesse's victim profile from young boys to girls, suggesting it could indicate a deeper psychological change or merely crimes of opportunity.
Dr. Tristan Engels [07:09]: "These girls were in his mother's sewing shop, and he didn't seek them out. Which would suggest that his internal drive to hurt, dominate, and destroy overpowered any type of victim preference."
The Murder of Horace Millen and Jesse's Arrest
On April 22, 1874, Jesse murdered 4-year-old Horace Millen. Two brothers discovered Horace's lifeless body near Dorchester Bay, leading the police to suspect Jesse due to his prior history and the presence of larger shoe prints near the body.
Dr. Tristan Engels [16:03]: "He's acutely skilled at simulating empathy, performing compliance, and appearing harmless, all by age 14 and the seriousness of his crimes."
Jesse was swiftly arrested with a pocket knife in his possession and visible scratches on his face. Initial interrogations saw Jesse oscillate between admission and denial until police forced him to view Horace's body, leading to a partial confession.
Psychological Profile and Behavior
Throughout the episode, Dr. Engels provides an in-depth psychological analysis of Jesse, highlighting traits associated with early-onset psychopathy and conduct disorder. Despite his young age, Jesse exhibited a level of manipulation, deceit, and lack of empathy that is exceptionally rare in juveniles.
Dr. Tristan Engels [20:37]: "Jesse is truly one of the most disturbing cases of early-onset sadism, psychopathy, and calculated violence in American history."
Jesse's behavior during interrogation—fluctuating between honesty and deceit—demonstrates his sophisticated understanding of manipulation and his lack of genuine emotional attachment.
Further Crimes and Confession
In July 1874, the remains of Katie Curran were discovered in the basement of Ruth Pomeroy's old sewing shop, leading to Jesse being implicated in her murder as well. Under increased pressure, Jesse eventually confessed to Katie's murder, attributing his actions to an uncontrollable urge without providing a clear motive.
Vanessa Richardson [37:06]: "Jesse was found guilty of first-degree murder. And they recommended that he be sentenced to death by hanging."
Despite the confession, Jesse's initial reluctance and subsequent manipulative behavior cast doubts on the authenticity of his admissions, suggesting ulterior motives tied to his desire to protect his mother and brother.
Trial and Conviction
The trial of Jesse Pomeroy commenced in December 1874. The defense argued that Jesse suffered from "moral insanity," a historical concept now understood as part of personality disorders such as antisocial personality disorder. His mother, Ruth, testified that Jesse's mental state was affected by a severe reaction to a smallpox vaccine in infancy, which allegedly impaired his neurological development.
Dr. Tristan Engels [36:57]: "Most children who experience developmental delays or even mild brain injury do not go on to torture and kill other children."
The prosecution countered with substantial physical evidence, including boot prints matching Jesse's footwear and a blood-stained pocket knife. Witnesses testified to seeing Jesse with Horace on the day of the murder, solidifying the case against him.
Ultimately, Jesse was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. However, in 1876, his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment, where he remained until his death at 72. During his incarceration, Jesse authored an autobiography attempting to justify his actions, though it lacked coherence and failed to provide genuine insight into his motives.
Conclusion: The Legacy of Jesse Pomeroy
Jesse Pomeroy's case remains one of the most haunting in American criminal history due to his young age and the calculated nature of his crimes. His ability to manipulate and deceive, coupled with his lack of genuine remorse, challenges our understanding of juvenile offenders and the capacity for evil in youth.
Vanessa Richardson [43:12]: "What makes his case so unforgettable is Jesse's age. He wasn't just a killer. He was a child killing other children."
The episode underscores the complexities of diagnosing and understanding psychopathy in juveniles, the failures of the reform system in dealing with such individuals, and the enduring fascination with the darkest aspects of the human psyche.
Notable Quotes
- Vanessa Richardson [02:54]: "In 1871, 12-year-old Jesse Pomeroy sent shockwaves through Boston when he was convicted of a string of brutal acts on at least six young boys."
- Dr. Tristan Engels [07:09]: "These girls were in his mother's sewing shop, and he didn't seek them out. Which would suggest that his internal drive to hurt, dominate, and destroy overpowered any type of victim preference."
- Dr. Tristan Engels [20:37]: "Jesse is truly one of the most disturbing cases of early-onset sadism, psychopathy, and calculated violence in American history."
- Vanessa Richardson [37:06]: "Jesse was found guilty of first-degree murder. And they recommended that he be sentenced to death by hanging."
- Vanessa Richardson [43:12]: "What makes his case so unforgettable is Jesse's age. He wasn't just a killer. He was a child killing other children."
Final Thoughts
The "Killer Minds" episode on Jesse Pomeroy provides a gripping and unsettling exploration of a young man's descent into violence and manipulation. Through meticulous storytelling and expert psychological analysis, Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels shed light on the factors that contributed to one of America's most perplexing and horrifying juvenile criminal cases.
Follow Killer Minds on your preferred podcast platform and connect with them on social media @KillerMinds for more deep dives into the minds of history’s most notorious killers.