Know Your Gear Podcast with Phillip McKnight
Episode 450: The "You're Not Good Enough For That Guitar" Argument
Date: February 12, 2026

Episode Overview

In this milestone 450th episode, Phillip McKnight explores a timely and often-heated topic in the guitar community: the idea that some players "aren't good enough" for high-end or expensive guitars. Phillip debunks this notion, sharing anecdotes and industry insights. He also answers a broad range of gear questions—from industry sales trends and new product rumors, to practical advice about basses, pickups, gear promotion, and guitar maintenance. True to the podcast’s tone, the show is candid, engaging, humorous, and occasionally philosophical, with Phillip’s distinct combination of expertise and warmth.

Key Topics & Insights

1. Podcast Milestone & Lighthearted Opening

• Phillip acknowledges the 450th episode and shares a playful story about GI Joe vs. Cobra shirts, using this to segue into a discussion about childhood psychology and collecting toys ([00:01]–[03:00]).

2. Guitar Industry Sales Trends for 2026

• [03:00–10:00]
• Answers a question from Amanda about expectations for 2026 gear sales, referencing 2025's strong year and giving a cautiously realistic outlook for 2026.
• Notes guitar and pedal companies (e.g., Friedman, Synergy, Dimarzio, Throwback Pickups) and major retailers (Sweetwater, Guitar Center) reported record or strong sales, especially during Black Friday.
• Observes that although sales numbers were up, profit margins may be down due to inflation and tariffs.
• Quote: "If you're running a pedal company, a pickup company, a guitar company, an amp company, right now, I would want to be number one in quality, number one in social media presence, number 1 in prices...people are really going to scrutinize their spending." ([08:30])

3. Promotion Advice for Gear Companies

• [10:00–17:00]
• Shares a story about a company not giving away gear to influencers/artists; praises the idea of investing promotional money into people who genuinely love the product rather than just advertisements.
• Shauna’s wisdom: “Why not just put that money...into the people who already love what you do?” ([14:30])
• Encourages companies to work with fans and foster community engagement.

4. Synergy & Amp Module News

• [17:00–22:00]
• Confirms the upcoming Synergy Rockerverb two-channel module (leaked at NAMM), set to include both Rockerverb and Dark Terror channels. Unofficial release date still pending.
• Teases an even more exciting module in the works.
• Phillip gets early access to the new Orange module as a loaner.

5. Bass Gear & The Magic of 32” Scale

• [22:00–28:00]
• Reacts to a fan question about new bass gear and discusses his excitement for a rumored 32” scale Kiesel bass, his favorite format.
• Relates the story behind acquiring a custom 32” Warwick bass and its unique feel and playability.
• Explains why 32” scale offers a perfect “sweet spot” between standard (34”) and short (30”) scale basses.

6. Favorite Bass Pickup Configurations

• [28:00–32:00]
• When asked about pickup choices, highlights the double-Jazz (JJ) as his favorite, particularly on Jazz basses and his own Warwick.
• Quote: "My jazz deluxe is a double J bass...on stage, no one can tell it's 2 inches shorter than a normal bass...but when you play it, they're like rubber bands. They feel great." ([30:00])

7. Musical Humility, Imposter Syndrome & Meeting Guitar Heroes

• [32:00–38:00]
• Reflects on spending time with Tim Miller and other world-class musicians—being disarmed by their humility.
• Shares the “joke” of comparing everyday struggles to professional musicians’ extraordinary experiences:
  • Example: “My story is like: ‘one time my cable fell out’...and he's like: ‘the other day, Eric Johnson asked me to come on stage and play his songs. I had to learn them that day’."

8. Deconstructing the "You're Not Good Enough for That Guitar" Argument

• [38:00–54:00]
• Responds to a listener named John, who admits he owns better guitars than his skill level might warrant but feels no shame.
• Debunking the Critique:
  • Phillip states this argument is “never rooted in the right thing,” usually stemming from jealousy rather than concern for merit.
  • Offers the perspective that instruments are tools, but also art and objects of joy.
  • Shares an anecdote: A surgeon friend was refused service at a guitar store because the salesman decided he wasn’t “good enough” for a high-end Gibson Les Paul ("You need an Epiphone.")—costing the shop a sale and cementing the toxicity of this attitude.
  • Quote: “I'd love to see a car salesman talk himself out of a $130,000 sports car sale because the guy didn't drive great…” ([48:00])
  • Points out that advanced players (like Pete Thorn, Phil X, Larry Mitchell) routinely jam with lower skill musicians without ego, prioritizing musical fun over proficiency showmanship.

9. Protecting Autographs on Guitars

• [54:00–56:30]
• Advises finishing specialists for applying clear coat over signatures, as DIY measures (like tape) often ruin autographs.
• Cautions about ink type and proper sealing to prevent fading or bleeding.

10. Industry Financing & Banks Tangent

• [1:06:30–1:16:00]
• Discusses Guitar Center's increased gear financing offers, relating it to the broader trend that most buyers finance expensive instruments.
• Launches into a comedic and philosophical aside about the disappearance of physical banks and cash culture, illustrated with a story about driving home to fetch cash for a guitar when using an ATM would’ve sufficed.

11. Synergy Module Deep-Dive

• [1:16:00–1:27:00]
• Traces Synergy’s lineage: originally Egnater, then Randall, now Synergy, explaining module/amp compatibility.
• Praises the Synergy SYN-20 head for integrating modern features like impulse responses (IRs) and notes its potential to disrupt the lunchbox amp market.
• Tips for owners: Recommends storing modules in a customized Pelican/Apache case for safety and portability.

12. Bass Gear Release Coverage

• [1:27:00–1:30:00]
• Assures listeners that bass gear does get significant releases—just less coverage in guitar-centric media.

13. Setting Up a Used Squier (or Any Guitar)

• [1:32:00–1:36:00]
• Explains his “deep dive” methodology for guitar setup: start with a visual inspection, diagnose action, and intonation, replace strings, and ensure full playability and health.
• Affirms that his video format mirrors how he does bench work in real life.

14. Room Acoustics & Amps

• [1:36:00–1:40:00]
• On the never-ending challenge of amp sound variance based on room, player, and ear “freshness.”
• Advocates for owning 2–3 amps so there’s always a match for your mood or environment.
• Pro Tip: “I test gear in the morning because my ears are fresh...I always found that my ears—throughout the day—hear things differently.” ([1:38:00])
• Shares the bass player trick of tilting cabs upward toward the player (“Your knees don’t have ears!”).

15. Underrated Importance of Strings

• [1:40:00–1:48:00]
• Passionately discusses strings as the most underrated part of guitar tone and feel.
• Encourages experimenting with materials, brands, and gauges—flatwounds, silk and steel, nickel, coated strings, etc.
• Gives a detailed tutorial on converting a steel-string acoustic to nylon/classical using ball-end classical strings, with gear and setup tips.
• Fields a listener question about why expensive guitars come with cheap strings: it's mostly about cost-cutting and the expectation that players will swap them anyway.

16. Starting a Guitar Repair Business

• [1:48:00–end]
• Advice for listeners wanting to offer fretwork or setups:
  • Gain proficiency first.
  • Start with friends/family.
  • Build a clear service menu—only offer what you do well.
  • Never accept repair jobs outside your expertise.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Gear Promotion:
  "Why not just put that money...into the people who already love what you do?" — Shauna ([14:30])

• On “You’re Not Good Enough”:
  “That comment is never rooted in the right thing...in most cases, the criticism is just rooted in jealousy.” ([40:10])

• Example of Gatekeeping:
  “The salesman walked up to me after I was playing it, pulled it out of my hands, and said, You need an Epiphone.” ([47:40])

• On High-level Musicians & Jamming:
  “The music is the center of attention...there’s no fear they’re going to look bad. They’re too focused on having fun.” ([52:30])

• On Strings:
  "I love guitar strings. I love experimenting...I want to try every string out there." ([1:40:30])

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:01 – Podcast milestone & GI Joe/Cobra story
• 03:00 – 2026 gear sales trends & outlook
• 10:00 – Gear promo advice (partner with genuine fans)
• 17:00 – Synergy module news
• 22:00 – Medium scale bass rumors & 32” bass discussion
• 28:00 – Favorite bass pickup configurations
• 32:00 – Tim Miller, humility, and musicians’ stories
• 38:00 – “Not good enough for that guitar” argument
• 47:40 – Anecdote: Surgeon denied service at a guitar shop
• 54:00 – How to preserve guitar autographs
• 1:06:30 – Gear financing, banks, and cash culture
• 1:16:00 – Synergy module history and storage
• 1:32:00 – Used Squier setup checklist
• 1:36:00 – Amp acoustics, ear fatigue, and cab tilting
• 1:40:00 – Strings: the most underrated gear factor
• 1:48:00 – How and when to start a guitar repair business

Overall Tone & Takeaways

True to Phillip’s style, the episode blends technical expertise, industry wisdom, humor, and empathy. The "you're not good enough" argument gets thoroughly dismantled, with clear messages about inclusivity, community support, and joy in music—regardless of skill level or gear price. The show is packed with actionable tips for players, gearheads, and small business owners, while remaining breezy and accessible. Regular anecdotes and open acknowledgment of the audience’s feedback maintain the conversational, no-pretense spirit of the series.

For further details, check out the Know Your Gear Channel and join the conversation on Fridays!