
Your favorite persnickety doctor is back!
Loading summary
Kim Holderness
Break through the busiest time of the year with the brand new Peloton Cross Training Tread Plus. Powered by Peloton iq, this is Peloton's.
Penn Holderness
Most elevated equipment with real time guidance and endless ways to move alone or with your favorite instructors. It's cross training reimagined with features designed to help you reach your goals effortlessly.
Kim Holderness
Peloton IQ has features like goal setting and weight suggestions so you're always making new progress.
Penn Holderness
Plus the new movement tracking camera allows Peloton IQ to count your reps and correct your form in real time and that takes the guesswork out of your workouts so you can train safer, lift smarter and make every rep count.
Kim Holderness
Go on a 45 minute run on the tread plus or a 5 minute stretch off of it with one smooth spin of the swivel screen. It offers endless ways to train for a well rounded routine no matter how busy you are.
Penn Holderness
As an avid Peloton user, I love that Peloton IQ creates a personal workout roadmap with weekly recommended classes led by instructors who match my mood, my vibe and my personality with features that help.
Kim Holderness
You plan, state motivated and achieve peak performance. I love that you can get your workout on while Peloton handles the rest.
Penn Holderness
So let yourself run, lift, sculpt, push and go explore the new peloton cross training tread plus@1peloton.com to all the parents out there trying to juggle work, school and sports schedules, man do we see you and are we not going through the same thing?
Kim Holderness
And Blue Apron just made our lives infinitely easier. We just got our box. It's my ultimate hack for getting a nutritious and delicious dinner off the table for my family in 30 minutes or less.
Penn Holderness
And since we're living in a world of subscription overload, Blue Apron is now making it easier than ever to get incredible meals on your table with no subscription needed.
Kim Holderness
When it comes to our busy lives, time is one thing we don't have a lot of. Blue Apron has two new product lines designed to make meal time faster and easier.
Penn Holderness
First up is Dish by Blue Apron. Those are pre made meals that all you have to do is heat them in the oven or the microwave.
Kim Holderness
And my favorite assemble and bake one pan meals with minimal prep and cleanup. I just got their sheet pan Garlic Hoisin Cod with Brussels Sprouts and Jasmine rice that's on the menu for tonight.
Penn Holderness
So literally toss the pre chopped ingredients onto a sheet pan, slide it into the oven and walk away.
Kim Holderness
You got it. Order now@blueapron.com and get 50% off your first two orders, plus free shipping with code LAUGHLINES50.
Penn Holderness
That's code LAUGHLINES50. Terms and conditions apply. Visit blue apron.com terms for more information. This episode is brought to you by Pura.
Kim Holderness
If well being means feeling grounded in your space, start with the easiest switch the air around you.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. Pura is a premium smart diffuser that makes home fragrance effortless. Control it from your phone, set it to match your day, and breathe out the chaos.
Kim Holderness
Pura lets you personalize your environment with scents that match your mood, lifestyle, and design aesthetic.
Penn Holderness
Plus, you can completely customize your scenting experience from intensity levels to scent schedules.
Kim Holderness
Whether it's for your home, your car, or a thoughtful gift, Pura brings scent design to life.
Penn Holderness
And for a limited time, you get a free Pura plus home diffuser when you subscribe to your favorite fragrances for 12 months.
Kim Holderness
This is restoration, not reinvention. Grab your free diffuser@pura.com please.
Penn Holderness
Welcome back to the show Dr. Eric Topol.
Kim Holderness
This is from Kelly. Tell Dr. Topol to stay persnickety.
Dr. Eric Topol
Very little to no evidence.
Penn Holderness
Okay.
Sam Allen
Really?
Penn Holderness
That's. There we go.
Kim Holderness
Dr. Topol.
Dr. Eric Topol
I'm sorry.
Kim Holderness
I want my new ringtone to be Dr. Topol. Going like this.
Penn Holderness
Oh, my God. We get older every day. Got more wrinkles.
Kim Holderness
That's okay.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Kim Holderness
We're laughing.
Penn Holderness
When we age, life is like a comedy stage. And that's why we got laugh lines.
Kim Holderness
Hey, everybody, I'm Kim Holderness.
Penn Holderness
And I'm Penn Holderness. Thank you so much for once again joining us on Laugh Lines. Unless it's your first time, then welcome and we're so glad you're here.
Kim Holderness
And if it's your second time. Yeah, no kidding. No. Okay. To be clear, if you ever worked out with a Taebo set or with Billy Blanks.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh.
Penn Holderness
Taking you through it.
Kim Holderness
Can I tell you this? This is probably too much. My dad loved some Taebo and he, like, fractured his, like, hip doing those, like, back. No, like, a hip. Like, he had, like, a hairline fracture from doing, like, because he can get up there high with those kicks. But we were a typo house, you guys. Yeah.
Penn Holderness
Anyway, in your home.
Kim Holderness
If that. If that was your life as well.
Penn Holderness
You'Re in the right place.
Kim Holderness
No, you guys didn't have any. Like, I. We had Jane Fonda. We had.
Penn Holderness
So you've been on the influencer train.
Kim Holderness
My entire family. Influence. We had the. What's the. The thigh thing. So the thigh master.
Penn Holderness
You had the thigh master. I. Do you know how many times My family allowed me to order anything that was seen on tv.
Kim Holderness
Columbia House Records.
Penn Holderness
No, I did that on my own and I got in trouble. Um, the answer is zero. Like any time I was like, dad, mom, they were like, is it on TV? Absolutely not. Is it ever 1, 800 number. There's no way we're ever, ever coming to your house.
Kim Holderness
So your parents were more like Dr. Eric Topol.
Penn Holderness
Yes, it's a good segue.
Kim Holderness
Dr. Eric Topol, this is our. He's returning to the podcast by Popular Demand. He. We had him on in 2025 where he just has a very lovely, no nonsense approach.
Penn Holderness
And the lovely part is that we name something that TikTok is telling us is really healthy and smart and he just goes and just, just rails on it. Research and science based does this too. And he does it in a, in a very fun way.
Kim Holderness
We get so many amazing comments. Thank you so much for having Dr. Topol. I am a physician and I kept nodding in agreement. Excellent discussion points. I think he is, he just wants the evidence. It is definitely worth going back and giving a listen. Our first interview with Dr. Eric Topol. But you can keep listening now if, if you want to. I will say we did get a really funny email from the laugh line.
Penn Holderness
Call us up and you tell us what's on your mind. I have to tell you a couple times, Dr. Topol mentioned testing done on whales and I was so confused. Why are they testing this stuff on whales? Are whales similar to us? How do they catch the whales? And then I realized he was saying testing done in Wales.
Kim Holderness
Like W A L E S the.
Penn Holderness
Country right next to England. When I realized my mistake, I doubled over and laughed hard. I got strange looks from my fellow morning walkers. This happens frequently when I listen to you two. By the way, I honestly, I bet she wasn't the only one.
Kim Holderness
That is my favorite bug. My brain does that too. How would they catch the whales? Do they do this and they keep them in the water? Is there a tank? Like I would have done that too.
Penn Holderness
Real quick, Nancy, do you know that whales blood vessels are so big that a human being could swim through them?
Kim Holderness
Which is convenient because sometimes I'm like, what if I got eaten by a whale? I could just swim through the blood vessels Anyway. And we got this honest voicemail from Kathy. Hi, this is Kathy. I am from Texas and I have just discovered your conversations with Dr. Eric Topol. I would never expect that information from you guys because I come to you to laugh, but I love this topic and it's something of concern to me because I'm 60 in family history. So thanks for sharing that with us.
Penn Holderness
Oh, Kathy, Kathy, Kathy. Family history is the real deal. And we are planning on asking Dr. Topol more about this because we got quite a few additional questions, especially about like organ clocks and brain clocks. So stay tuned and thank you so much for what you said. I feel you and I'm with you.
Kim Holderness
Yeah, we try to make you laugh but also make you think a little bit. Right? Okay, we have to read Dr. Eric Topol's very impressive.
Penn Holderness
He fancy.
Kim Holderness
He's a world renowned cardiologist, scientist and the New York Times best selling author whose work is changing how we understand health, aging and the power of technology. He is the founder and director of the Scripps Research Translational Institute which where he leads groundbreaking research in genetics, digital health and artificial intelligence. In other words, Dr. Topol is not just studying the future of medicine, he is creating it.
Penn Holderness
Time magazine named him one of the most influential people in healthcare. We know one of the most influential people in he's so fancy you guys. And his insights have been featured in the New York Times, the Atlantic, The Washington Post, 60 Minutes, TED talks and laugh lines with Penn and Kim Holderness.
Kim Holderness
I'm sure he's putting that on him. Bio.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. Dr. Topol has authored several acclaimed books including Deep Medicine and Superagers that explore how innovation can help us live longer, healthier and more connected lives. Please welcome back to the show Dr. Eric Topol.
Dr. Eric Topol
Hello there. Great to be with you.
Kim Holderness
So excited. We after our first episode together we got hundreds of comments and questions from your interview. So thank you for coming back. We had several hot button issues and topics but first I want to I want to read some of our favorite comments we got. This is from Kelly. Tell Dr. Topol to stay persnickety.
Penn Holderness
Are you okay? Like I love that. First of all, I love that word yes and and he she means it in the nicest way possible. Like in this past podcast he gave us his real thoughts about some trends that maybe aren't as great as they're cracked up to be.
Kim Holderness
I know and I think that it's just so important that we cut through the BS and so keep at it.
Dr. Eric Topol
It's what I hear that chance to do that because if you go to a lot of other podcasts and platforms, it's hard to get what's really true out there.
Kim Holderness
And Lynn said just watch Dr. Tobel debunk several current health trends and I'm here to say please do more. So that's what we're doing. Should we get right to it? I mean there was two major sort of convers. Got a lot of feedback. Everything did. But the two kind of that stick out that I think we should attack first are the protein, the amount of protein and the weighted vest. Okay, so question, what is too much protein and what happens if you consume too much?
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, the first thing is when you consume too much, you just basically pee it out. You're basically taking in extra calories, maybe extra expense to get that. And you're not. Your body has no way to store it. Right. The second thing is if particular protein excess. And let's say you want to make the 0.8 grams per kilogram is the recommended daily allowance, so called RDA. And let's say you want to even double that, which is like that's red line. You could justify if you're lifting a lot of weight, resistance training, maybe there's something about aging that you could want to take in, maybe more protein to maintain muscle mass even that's a little fuzzy. But after you get beyond 1.5 grams per kilogram of protein, then you're getting into the red zone for promoting inflammation in your body. So not just that you can't store it, but now you can actually have an untoward effect. And that is especially the case if it's taking an animal protein like red meat protein and other sources. So too much protein is bad for you. And we're in this protein craze where people are taking ridiculous amounts of protein well above the one point. Let's say five. So let's say you're 70 kilo person.
Kim Holderness
Okay, just say it in pounds because math is hard. So let's say I weigh 150 pounds.
Penn Holderness
We as Americans refuse, choose to go by the more popular standards of weight, weight and systems and measurements, as Nate Bergazzi showed us on SNL. But yeah, sorry, yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
So let's say 70 pounds, 2.2 multiplied. Right again.
Kim Holderness
Math, Dr. Topol math.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. 150 ish. Right.
Kim Holderness
Say I weigh 150.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yes, yeah, 150. Okay. So if you want to have, if you're going to get one gram per kilogram of that, you know that's going to be at the most. You're talking about a hundred grams of protein a day. That's a lot.
Kim Holderness
So I will tell you that there's a lot of. This all came about because there's a lot out there that says that I should be having as a woman a gram per pound.
Dr. Eric Topol
Right, Right. Yeah, that's what Peter Attia espouses without data. So there are no data to support that. Even people think, oh, well, maybe if they're Olympiad weightlifters, they need to do that, like the Terminator, Schwarzenegger profile. But there's not even data for that that is justified. But no, you should not take in one gram per pound. What I was just saying is the maximum for you, if you're talking about 150, it's. It's 90 to 100 grams. That's plenty. Plenty.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
For that weight. So this is the problem of, of protein overdose. And by the way, a lot of these people that are pushing the protein are also selling it, right?
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
So you got these David bars. Like, you know, they're, they're really hot out there and they, you get two of those bars and you're probably going to have diarrhea. You know, this is ridiculous stuff because they use this plant extract like olestra.
Penn Holderness
Which we know that'll get you running.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, yeah. So maybe if you're constipated and you want to eat a lot of David bars. But no. And then the powders that we've seen have contamination. This is leading to all sorts of problems and expense. I mean, these extra protein sources are really an issue. So we've gotten absolutely crazy about this and there's no data to support it. I mean, even going to the, for the 150 pound person to go to 100 grams is a lot. I mean, it's perfectly fine to be at 80, which is what you probably would get normally in your diet.
Penn Holderness
All right, so the reason why animal fats, I imagine, are dangerous is because animal protein. Sorry? Well, animal protein is because of the animal fats, because you're taking all this protein in and you're not getting the protein, but you are getting the fat. You are getting all of that other stuff. It's staying there. So I understand what he's saying there.
Dr. Eric Topol
But also the, the protein itself, interestingly, when it's been put into animal models, it can directly. The lysine component, that protein amino acid, that can directly stimulate inflammation, which was a surprise and it's a concern. It hasn't been as well demonstrated in people, but the animal models are pretty impressive. So it's both, I would say. Penn.
Penn Holderness
Okay, I want to make sure, because I do work out, I take a little more protein than most because of that, especially on days that I do heavy lifting. I want to make sure that the condition of perimenopause and menopause does not require a ton more protein.
Dr. Eric Topol
No.
Penn Holderness
Okay.
Dr. Eric Topol
Let'S say if you want to accepted the minimum allowance. I mean the daily allowance, not minimum, but the recommended. If you want to go up from that to some extent, but not to what some of these folks are advocating for various reasons like you said. But yeah, we are in the midst of a craze. It will eventually settle down because it's unfounded. But in the meantime, people are making a lot of money and paying out a lot of profits.
Kim Holderness
Protein. Okay.
Penn Holderness
And getting diarrhea from alestra.
Kim Holderness
Okay, so hold on. So the RDA. Tell me, tell me the math of the RDA again. What is it? It's.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, it's 0.8 grams per kilogram, which if you take that divided by, you know, multiplied by 2.2. So that would be per pound I had made it.
Penn Holderness
That's even less than half. That would be less than half because the kilograms is 2.2 pounds. So. Sorry, I'm doing math right now.
Kim Holderness
Right now it's like A Beautiful Mind in my head.
Penn Holderness
So if Kim, if Kim weighs 150, you're. You're going to divide that by 2.2, which is about 70.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah.
Penn Holderness
Then point eight of 70 is more like 5.6. Like point. Yeah. So that's. You're like closer to 55 to 60 grams. Sorry for nerding out.
Kim Holderness
I know, but I just want a math equation that's easy. And right now I feel like I'm doing it. I'm doing physics.
Penn Holderness
I think it's about a third.
Kim Holderness
Okay, about a third.
Penn Holderness
Okay.
Kim Holderness
A third plus a little of pounds. So if I weigh at 150.
Dr. Eric Topol
That's right. That's exactly right. So you know, if you were taking in 50 grams at 150 pounds, that would be the RDA. And if you want to amp that up to 70, 80, that's fine.
Kim Holderness
But not. But no need to eat 150 grams of protein.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh my gosh. No.
Kim Holderness
Okay.
Dr. Eric Topol
This is crazy stuff.
Kim Holderness
And real quick, does it make a difference? Is it more desirable to have plant based protein? Should it be a mix? Tell me.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, the plant based protein is going to be protective against that potential of inflammation. Promoting inflammation.
Penn Holderness
That's. Yeah, nuts.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, nuts. I'm big on those and it's a great protein source. But no, the other problem is if you go after this protein and that's why they made the David bars, it's pretty hard to get a lot of protein extra if you're not bringing in a lot of calories and so that's a lot of people that are going to gain weight by this protein craze too, which doesn't help the body either. So. Yeah, that I think is something to keep an eye on as well is that you're taking in, you know, just excess of calories. But there's lots of good sources of animal. I mean a plant based protein and certainly nuts are high on the list.
Kim Holderness
Yeah. But issue with nuts, there's a lot of fat. So why don't you view nuts as a protein, personally, as a perimenopausal woman? I'm just saying this depends.
Penn Holderness
Fair.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Penn Holderness
I mean, you need some fat too. Yeah.
Kim Holderness
No, no, no, no. But I don't, I don't eat nuts for the protein.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. Do you eat tofu?
Sam Allen
I.
Kim Holderness
So Dr. Topol. I don't, I have like a texture thing with tofu. Like I just can't, I can't get. So I. The only plant based protein I will do are the powders, like the pea protein or whatever. I'll do a smoothie with that.
Dr. Eric Topol
I'm with you on the texture of tofu. If you doctor it up, you know.
Kim Holderness
Oh yeah. Like you have to doctor it up.
Dr. Eric Topol
By the way, there's other good sources of protein, you know, like salmon and.
Kim Holderness
You know, chicken and like a chicken breast, right? Yeah, yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
Low in fat or if the fat like in salmon, it's, it's good of high omega 3 fat. So it's, it's, it's another good source.
Kim Holderness
Okay.
Penn Holderness
Speaking of things that make money and are trendy, we talked about weighted vests last time.
Kim Holderness
People had feelings.
Penn Holderness
People had feelings. Now listen, you, you weren't saying weighted vests are going to kill you. You were saying that the benefits that a lot of people hocking them, the benefits that these people are promoting are for the most part inaccurate. And so let's start with this. How does weighted vests versus weightlifting differ in promoting bone density? Because that's a big part of what people are talking about.
Kim Holderness
Big buzzword.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. Well, first of all, talk about a buzz. This thing rucking.
Kim Holderness
Oh, yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
It's out of control. I mean, you go out there and you see all these people walking around their weight events. I mean, this is ridiculous. It's like a cult.
Penn Holderness
Yeah, I got one.
Kim Holderness
I love you so much.
Dr. Eric Topol
Is it bad for you? I'm not saying it's bad for you, but it's a craze, which is not. I mean, there's some small studies that show, like you said, Penn, that it's Good for promoting bone health. But you get that also from resistance training. Yeah, you can get that through many different ways. You don't have to go get a weighted vest and walk around with that. And by the way, you know some of the craze about checking your VO2 max.
Kim Holderness
Oh, yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
Which I feel is without basis. I mean, that is a stupid metric because you can't really get that. You know, like, for example, if you have an A iPhone, it'll give you a VO2 max based on your walking. Well, if you were rucking, your VO2 max will plummet because you can't walk at the same speed with this weight on your back. So if you think, oh, wow, my VO2 Max is my magical metric, well, you're going to ruin that one. But no, I mean, it's okay if people want to do this, but this idea that it's some unique. A way to promote bone health or get a core exercise, there's so much better ways that are without any expense. You know, things like planks, push ups, you know, push ups, sit ups, you know, bands. There's so many ways. I mean, you can get a set of bands for, you know, $9. How much does a weighted vest cost?
Kim Holderness
Right?
Penn Holderness
More. Way more. I mean, they're. They're depending on who's selling them. There was like, I did some research and there were some that are in the $400 range.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, my God. I knew it was high, but I didn't.
Kim Holderness
I think there are. I mean, listen, I can be influenced, Dr. Topol. So I did see some ads and I didn't. I did not buy them, but there was one. It kind of looked nice and it zipped up and so. So what I took from our initial conversation is it's not that it's like bad for you. It's just not going to get you the benefits that other things could. And like, what I love about how you communicate with people is like, just be curious about who's benefiting from this. And. And in your. So it. There is potential. We. We've heard a lot of people, they injure themselves with the way that I threw my back out because I was wearing it. I'm like, oh, I'll just wear it around the house while I'm doing something. I bent over to pick up laundry and I threw my back.
Dr. Eric Topol
So like, oh, yeah, yeah.
Kim Holderness
No, be aware.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, like, yeah, there is potential harm. I mean, it could do for your back, for your knees, Achilles tendons, you know, you can definitely take a hit from it. So it isn't like it's, you know, a perfectly safe means. And of course, if you're going to do it, you got to do it gradually. You can't just like take the big weights.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
And you know, got there. So. But I think that the, the net benefit here is questionable, particularly when you put in context the cost and also the fact that you can do this through so many other safer and inexpensive ways to do achieve the same benefit.
Penn Holderness
So, Dr. Topol, I got several pages of questions here and.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh good. I love, I love your question.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. I'm going to give you as much or as little time as you want to answer these, but know that there's a few, quite a few. So if we can answer these expeditiously, we can get to more of them.
Kim Holderness
More on this after these words. Okay, quick show of hands. Have you ever gone to the doctor with a very real concern and left thinking, cool. So I guess I just imagined all of that.
Penn Holderness
Oh yeah, you've told me about this, Kim. The, the classic medical shrug.
Kim Holderness
Yeah. And if you're in midlife and feeling dismissed, unheard or just completely, completely over the healthcare system, you're deeply not alone.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. For years, women dealing with perimenopause and menopause have basically been told to just deal with it, which feels unscientific.
Kim Holderness
Yeah. And frustrating and exhausting and honestly kind of rage inducing. So. Especially when you learn that 75% of women seeking care for menopause and perimenopause are still left totally untreated.
Penn Holderness
And that's not because women aren't advocating for themselves. It's because the system is, has not been built for them.
Kim Holderness
Which is why I love the next part. This show is sponsored by MIDI Health. MIDI is a women's telehealth clinic focused specifically on midlife, founded and backed by world class leaders in women's health.
Penn Holderness
And here's the big deal. They're the only women's telehealth brand covered by major insurance. So this is expert care that's actually accessible.
Kim Holderness
You get one on one face to face virtual visits with clinicians who truly listen to no rushing, no minimizing, hormone.
Penn Holderness
Therapy, weight loss support, lifestyle coaching, preventative care. This isn't. Here's a pamphlet. Good luck. This is personalized care for your body.
Kim Holderness
Ready to feel your best and write your second act script. Visit joinmitty.com today to book your personalized insurance covered virtual Visit. That's join MIDI.com MIDI the Care Women deserve. All right, Penn, as you know, there Is no right time for better health. There's just now AG1 is the easiest and most impact impactful habit you can implement this year.
Penn Holderness
Sustainable health is about consistency, not perfection. Simplify your nutrition with AG1 multivitamin free and probiotics, superfoods and antioxidants in One Scoop.
Kim Holderness
AG1 is the opposite of complexity. 20 seconds. One Scoop 8 ounces of water. Done.
Penn Holderness
Drink it first thing before coffee before checking your phone. It will become a microhabit that anchors everything else you do that day.
Kim Holderness
And the new next gen formula. They've added more vitamins and minerals than ever clinically proven to fill common nutrient gaps.
Penn Holderness
Now I use this every single day. And by the way, AG1 now comes in original citrus berry and tropical. My favorite is citrus but you can experiment with the flavors. They are all delicious.
Kim Holderness
AG1 has over 50,000 verified five star reviews and comes with a 90 day money back guarantee.
Penn Holderness
So go to drink ag1.com laughlines to get their best offer. That's three free AG1 travel packs and three free AGZ travel packs plus free vitamin D3 plus K2 and AG1 welcome kit with your first AG1 subscription order.
Kim Holderness
That's drink ag1.com laughlines drink ag1.com laughlines.
Penn Holderness
From Wendy. Is there any real evidence that collagen based protein actually helps with hair, skin, nails and joint pain?
Dr. Eric Topol
That's a great one. High use, very little to no evidence.
Penn Holderness
Okay.
Kim Holderness
Really?
Penn Holderness
That's. There we go.
Kim Holderness
Dr. Topol, I'm sorry, I really thought I bought some supplements. They're going to get here soon because they told me it would push out my wrinkles.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, I'm going to laugh at all.
Penn Holderness
Of these I'm afraid. It's always fun when we find one that works though. Like last time it was the.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh yeah. No, they have real evidence. When you talk about evidence, you want randomized trials with a placebo collagen. Right. That looks everything like that. And those trials are. They. They don't exist. You know, unfortunately the use is so out of proportion to the tiny little supportive, questionable evidence.
Kim Holderness
So right now there's probably some anecdotes, anecdotal evidence that they're quoting is that. Yeah. So that I would. So somebody out there has benefited and has their wrinkles pushed out from collagen. I think that's enough for me. I'm kidding. But maybe not. Okay. Anyway, continue.
Penn Holderness
From Tricia. I'm in my 50s. I have a strong family history of Alzheimer's. So I'm feeling you, Tricia. I've been learning about what I can do for prevention. My blood work shows no inflammation markers, which is great. Right. We know this, but I am in pain. Is arthritis caused by inflammation or isn't it caused by inflammation? I'm trying to get more active, but I cannot. What can I do?
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, I guess the question is, is it specified to certain joints? Yeah, you know, that's because if it's an arthritic knee or hip or something like that, you know, that needs to be attended to. The problem is chronic inflammation of a joint isn't good for you. And if you're high risk for Alzheimer's, it's just not going to help that matter. And as we discussed previously, if you really are concerned about family history, it's good to check a P Tau 217. They're available. They have been for a while now, a couple of years. And that will, if that's really low, that'll give you extra confidence that in the next 15 years you're not going to have to worry about that. So I think the key here is getting to the root cause of the arthritis.
Penn Holderness
Okay. Yeah. And she did say she's showing no inflammation markers with her blood work. So she's looked. So that is good news because that's good.
Dr. Eric Topol
But it could be. It could be localized, not necessarily in the blood, you know, and that's the. So even localized, significant arthritis. Something to look into. Why.
Kim Holderness
So that brings up from Kelly. She says, I also have a lot of Alzheimer's and dementia, my family. But I've always been nervous to get the test to see if I have the markers. If I get a bad result, what could. Would you advise me to do right away to try to prevent it?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, that's a great one because we're in a new era now where that. Cassandra, I don't want to know because I can't do anything. Which was, of course, reasonable. Now you can do things.
Penn Holderness
That's right.
Dr. Eric Topol
So we are starting in the next few weeks the first prevent Alzheimer's trial. And in that trial, we're getting after a person's at high risk by family history, checking their APOE 4 to see if they have one or two copies. We're also doing a polygenic risk score because there's other genes besides ApoE4 that are implicated. And so people in the really high risk group then will check P Tau217. And then we put them randomized into a trial. And half of them are getting intensive continuous coaching for lifestyle factors, and the other half are just getting some Educational materials and we're going to have 1200 people enrolled starting in February and hopefully we'll get in the year. Whether we fix the brain clock which shows accelerated pace of aging in those people and the P Tau 217 and other markers bring them down. And if we can do that, then we've iced a lifestyle story. And this is not just more physical activity, you know, getting to the optimal weight, eating the right foods, sleep quality, you know, all the right things that we know are anti inflammatory that help prevent Alzheimer's. But then we start working with drugs that have a really good promise for helping to interfere with the process of brain inflammation like the GLP1 drugs and others. So it's exciting. We're going to do a big dentist in the years ahead to prevent Alzheimer's. I am confident this is going to emerge as a preventable disease. After decades of all these drugs that were tested that were failing, this is going to be turned around because we now have the new biomarkers, we've got the brain and immune system clocks that we never had before. And we've got these drugs, new drugs that are emerging that are potent brain anti inflammatory. So it's an exciting time to get on top of Alzheimer's.
Penn Holderness
If I can just jump in and add a personal answer to this question to Kelly. Kelly, I was you. I was you one year ago. I was terrified. I was pretty sure that I was going to have some evidence of at least one copy of Apoe 4 because both of my, my parents have Alzheimer's. I did not want to take the test. I had great people like Dr. Richard Isaacson and my wife basically pushed me into the doctor's office to get the blood test. I got it back and got what I thought was the worst possible news, that I have twin copies of Apoe 4. We're like 10x more likely historically to get Alzheimer's. Here's a couple of things I'm going to tell you. I'm sleeping better at night than I was before because of what I've learned. Since these markers not only are very real, you can reverse and improve these markers with some of the current medications. If you start looking at it like managing your cholesterol of the brain, it makes a huge difference. People like Dr. Topol are going to kick Alzheimer's ass over the next few years. But you're not gonna figure out how to do it until you take the test because they've gotta know what you're working with. You heard him say this trial that he's Doing is for people who have certain APOE4 genetic markers. I happen to qualify because I've got both, which sucks. But now I am on a different lifestyle train, I'm on a different medication train, and I guarantee you my odds are way better than 10x just because of that.
Dr. Eric Topol
Absolutely. No, you are the perfect spokesperson for this new movement. I mean, nobody can articulate it as well. And why people should know. I mean, you don't have to go out and do any of these tests if you don't have a family history, but if you have a family history of bonafide Alzheimer's, that would be a reason to check APOE 4, get a polygenic risk score, and if those are abnormal P tau. And Richard Isaacson is a great neurologist, you know, one of the country's treasures in this area, and he similarly agrees with this optimism that we've been discussing.
Kim Holderness
And I, I do get, I do get it. That before. And this. I mean, we've been married now for 20 years. I'm doing okay. Math is hard.
Dr. Eric Topol
Sorry, you started when you got married at age 16.
Kim Holderness
Exactly. I was 12. No. So for 20 years. I, I mean, they, they didn't have access to a lot of this stuff 20 years ago. But I've been asking him, like, to do the most, to find out the most. And in his defense, like, he didn't really want to know because the answer 20 years ago was like, well, what am I going to do about it? Like, yeah. And now. But now, even if it's just medications. Yes. And managing your cholesterol and the whole thing, but even lifestyle, to your point, I mean, there's so many lifestyle things you could do, and to feel like you're in control of is a different vibe in our house. And honestly, Dr. Topol, like, having conversations with you are a part of that because you've given family hope that we just really didn't have. So.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, yeah. I mean, I. I'm an Apoe 4 carrier and, you know, I've been concerned about that. I've known about that for years. But when I got a P Tau 217 and it was really low, you know, near close to zero, that gave me a whole new outlook that, you know, just because you, as, as Penn mentioned, just because you're at increased risk is not a fatalistic, deterministic thing. Brain, you have a lot of control on this. And if we now have these tests that are available, not just the P Tau markers, but soon, the brain clock this year, and it gives you a whole different outlook about your risk. It, it could actually be quite low even if you are, you know, carrying one of these markers.
Penn Holderness
Can we talk a little bit more about the brain clock? Like how is, how is the brain clock different from the P Tau tests?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, very different because there you're looking at a group of hundreds of plasma proteins out of 11,000 that can be measured with a couple of milliliters of blood. And they have been partitioned to track with each organ for the pace of aging. So people with Alzheimer's who are destined to get Alzheimer's in the years ahead, they have a more rapid pace of aging of their brain. And what's great, just like Penn mentioned about, you follow the, like the LDL cholesterol for the heart, we're going to be following not just making the diagnosis of risk, but following the benefit of lifestyle or drugs, other interventions because the brain clock goes into slowing mode when you are making the right interventions. And the P Tau 217 and other markers go way down. So we don't even have just markers now. We have tracking mechanisms through these measurements. So the brain clock, there's a couple of companies that are just getting out a Stanford spin out teal that we're working with in that trial that we're getting started very soon. But in the next year there'll be multiple ways to get accurate brain, immune system clocks, heart, artery and other organs, all with one simple blood test. Low expense too.
Kim Holderness
Okay, so this, this question's a good one because I have this question. Well, what is a functional medicine, doctor? Are they better than primary care? Also, blood tests were mentioned several times on the show and I've seen ads for several companies that do 50 to 100 plus markers. Are these worthwhile? So I, I think I know the difference between functional and, and just a general practitioner, but I want you to explain it. And they are more expensive. Do you think it's worth it? And then you talked a lot about markers and tests. If I walked into my regular doctor, they're going to say like, I don't know what the hell you're talking about. So talk us.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, no, really good question. I don't, you know, support overall the functional medicine movement because a lot of that is not evidence based. And it's unfortunate because a lot of things that are being pushed through that in general, there may be some specific exceptions are not, you know, with data. Now, with respect to, let's say this company function. All right, it's a popular company, it's.
Kim Holderness
Being pushed a lot.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, yeah. Mark Hyman, I know him. He's a friend. I used to be at Cleveland Clinic, and I was there many years ago. He wanted me to join the board of that company. I told him, sorry, I can't do that. And he's pushing Hunter. Hundreds of tests. Hundreds. And also even a total body mri. They acquired this company, Ezra, and this is, this is the wrong way to approach it because you're getting a lot of tests that you don't need and are going to cause false positives and get you all worried. And you're paying to get worried. It's crazy. What we're talking about, what we just were talking about, is very specific testing because of good rationale, not blitzkrieg of every test known to mankind, which is kind of what the function approach is. So I think, I'm not saying that function isn't trying to help people, but I think it's the wrong approach. It should be targeted testing based on the person's specific risk, not just testing everything under the sun and doing total body MRIs, which have no big basis. So that's, that's how I see it. And that's what I wrote about a lot in super agers.
Kim Holderness
A devil's advocate. So Trisha, who had asked about her, you know, the, the markers are not showing inflammation, but she's in pain. Wouldn't att if she went to Function Health and got, you know, just through every, all the spaghetti at the wall, maybe something comes back. So, like, in that case, I might be influenced and hit by on something like that. I might do a total body mri because there's a symptom that nobody can figure out.
Dr. Eric Topol
I think that's an exception that you're bringing up that is potentially worthwhile.
Kim Holderness
Okay.
Dr. Eric Topol
When it's a real mystery and you have just no good idea what's going on, and you kind of do a, a total body, total blood test. Exploration. Exploration, if you will. It's like exploratory surgery. Yeah. I mean, in rare cases, maybe that's reasonable. Yes.
Kim Holderness
Okay. And I would say the functional approach, as I've experienced it, I think it's more for me, what I've experienced is I, I, my levels and my blood, or they're like, they're on like the high end of average or low end of average. And a traditional doctor was like, like, oh, you're fine because you're one point from being high. Whereas, like a functional doctor, how I was interacting, it was like, okay, let's take this because my cholesterol is, like, high.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Kim Holderness
And so, like, a functional doctor paid more attention to it. So I think there's.
Penn Holderness
Yeah, I think you're describing two different types of healthcare. One that's governed and one that's not. Right. Like, yeah, there's. There's certain things that doctors like, they look, in order for them to do this, they have to have a barrier.
Kim Holderness
Because, yeah, you can't sit there for an hour with everybody under this, like, traditional insurance model, which is like, oh, my God free.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, God. Anyway, well, you're bringing up something important. The length of time physician spends with a patient is critical. And so functional medicine docs, I give them credit, they spend a lot more time.
Kim Holderness
You're paying for it. But, yeah, yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
And the same way if you get your own concierge doctor that, you know, in a program time, the gift of time with, you know, being able to discuss your concerns and all that, that is really important. And that's why, part of that popularity, the other thing, I would just say you are really touching on a key point about labs. But what you want to do is put your labs into OpenAI, ChatGPT, or Cloud or Gemini of Google. Because even if your labs are in the normal range, what you want to look at are trends. And you can have trends in the normal range that are going in the wrong direction and that, that, you know, you look at it, the doctor looks at it, everything looks fine. But it's the trends that are really important. You can pick up all sorts of things that AI can see that we don't in the medical community these days.
Kim Holderness
That is. That is a very good point and a part where you need to advocate for yourself in that way. I mean, it'd be great if the doctors had a model in which that was being triggered, but really, you need to know what your own numbers are.
Dr. Eric Topol
Put them all in there and you'll get for free. You know, you can do that and you get all sorts of useful information. You can even put your genome from ancestry, DNA.
Kim Holderness
Oh, really?
Dr. Eric Topol
I know. It'll give you all the analysis of your genome. I mean. Yeah.
Kim Holderness
Okay. Brooks asks, what do you think about detoxing for parasites? That's another thing that's.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, I don't know. That's out of my. Yeah, that's my range of.
Kim Holderness
There's. There's a. There's many people that are saying a lot of symptoms that are like, it's worms, it's parasites, it's. And there's a lot of things that are being sold to get rid of.
Penn Holderness
Like, you, like you, you can find them on a full moon, stuff like that. I've heard that before. I, someone at some point point in my life was like, a little worms will help you. Like, I've had people say that to me, but it can't be right.
Dr. Eric Topol
Right.
Penn Holderness
This was like the 80s, you know.
Kim Holderness
The 80s, if you ate Pop Rocks and coke, your stomach was gonna explode.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah.
Penn Holderness
So here's my favorite one. This is from Diana. I don't know how you're gonna answer this, but it's a very real question. I know sleep and exercise are both important, but for us parents who are still busy with young kids at home, if we have to pick one which is better, pick one.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, well, they're interactive. The more you exercise, usually the better sleep you're going to get. As long as you don't exercise too late in the day. Yeah, I mean they, you get two for one, you know, just by doing the exercise. I would say exercise is the one that has the absolute best data. Okay. Sleep is not far behind.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. And yeah, if you make it a point to try to work out like early in the day with kids, that might actually accidentally help your sleep.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, exactly.
Kim Holderness
But I do, especially with young kids at home. I remember having a two year old, a four year old, and there was not a, like we were working and there was not a consistent childcare situation with preschool. And it was literally, I could go to bed or I could sleep an extra hour in the morning, or I could wake up and like get on the treadmill in the basement. I mostly chose sleep.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. Yeah. Well, sleep is okay. You get really good sleep. You know, that's going to be helpful too, too. So if you, if you can't get the physical activity, then that's going to be a bonus too.
Kim Holderness
Okay. Nicole asked. This is another buzzword that is being said to a lot of women my age. Nicole asked. I think I have high cortisol, but I have no idea how to test for it. And if supplements that claim to help can any advice. So like a lot of my issues right now, according to the Internet, are being blamed on having high cortisol levels. Is this a thing and is there a way to test for it? Is there a way to help it?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, well, there's a way to test for it. Any doctor can order a cortisol test. You might even be able to get it direct to consumer. Has to be done, you know, fasting in the morning. I don't think it's worth much. I, I think this is just one more of these fads that are probably going to fade. I mean, we, we do know hormones. Cortisol is the adrenal gland hormone are really important and they play a big role in women's health with respect to premenopausal, perimenopausal, menopausal. But it isn't necessarily the cortisol that's the key. It's really much more related to index to estrogen. So this may be misplaced. I would much more favor interacting with a qualified gynecologist and primary care physician about whether it's worthwhile or not. But I, you know, what are you going to do with the abnormal cortisol? And especially it's only at one moment in time, that particular morning that you get an assay. So I, I'm not really thinking that, that in, in the vast majority of people that's going to be worthwhile.
Kim Holderness
They do sell a lot of supplements. I will let you know that. And I have not purchased them. I told you that.
Penn Holderness
What?
Kim Holderness
I know, it's huge, but I, Yeah, I just feel like. And moments are like, definitely my cortisol's high. Like my body's on high alert. Well, like big stuff was happening, so.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, that's of course a natural physiologic thing that, you know, fluctuations in cortisol with stress. But to take supplements. No, how about the things that really we know, work, exercise, physical activity, healthy diet, that kind of stuff and like.
Kim Holderness
Trying to reduce stress? Yes, doctor.
Penn Holderness
This guy has four questions. So I'm gonna, I'm gonna give you ten words or less for each question. I bet you can do it. If anyone can do it, it's Dr. Topol.
Kim Holderness
Oh my God.
Penn Holderness
So Dr. Topol, 10 words or less on autophagy.
Dr. Eric Topol
Autophagy.
Kim Holderness
Autophagy.
Penn Holderness
Oh, God, I don't even know what it is. Autophagy. Excuse me?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, no, that's just a biologic process of the cell getting rid of stuff. That's okay.
Kim Holderness
A lot of intermittent fasting talk. It promoted.
Penn Holderness
So.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah. And again, my view of intermittent fasting is eat your evening meal, you know, not late, and just don't eat anything after that till the following morning. That's a very good intermittent fasting.
Penn Holderness
Perfect. What about 36 hour fasting?
Dr. Eric Topol
There's no data to support it except the, the limited weight loss benefit. Okay. But there's lots of other ways to achieve weight loss besides that.
Penn Holderness
Okay. Olive oil, slash fish oil, slash MCT oil supplements.
Dr. Eric Topol
Olive oil is great and not as a supplement. You know, it should Be part of your diet. Really? Fish oil again? Part of your diet? You don't need to take fish oil and smell like a fish.
Penn Holderness
It does smell funny.
Kim Holderness
It does smell funny.
Penn Holderness
It smells so funny. Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
And then the other one, Forget it. That's alien. So. No, I mean the Mediterranean diet is what we have. The best randomized trial, all sorts of observational, huge supportive evidence. And that's of course centered on olive oil as being part of it. And omega 3 oil from food, not.
Kim Holderness
From supplement from a teacher. What about lion's mane supplements for cognitive support? I feel like I asked this.
Penn Holderness
Yeah, I know. I can't wait.
Dr. Eric Topol
There's no supplement that has help cognitive health, despite what you see on tv. All these things that are advertised that. You know, if I made a slide that summarizes their evidence, it would be a blank slide.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
Sorry.
Kim Holderness
Keep being persnickety. I'm gonna make you a T shirt.
Penn Holderness
I want to see that. I want to see his next keynote. He's gonna be. Can we bring up the cognitive slide?
Kim Holderness
The evidence?
Sam Allen
Yep.
Kim Holderness
It's blank.
Penn Holderness
Dr. Topol, the slide is blank.
Dr. Eric Topol
Comprehensive summary of supplements that improve cognitive health.
Penn Holderness
Well, Mr. Topol, that's a blank slide. And then he just. Eric just stares at him.
Kim Holderness
More on this after these words.
Penn Holderness
January is already in full swing and our schedule is quickly becoming booked and busy.
Kim Holderness
When I need a restful escape, but I don't have time to go anywhere, I turn to my trusty comfy bed.
Penn Holderness
You sure do, honey.
Kim Holderness
I love it.
Penn Holderness
You take to the bed when you need it. After upgrading to Bowen Branch's signature sheets, you have found a relaxing escape that you don't have to leave home for.
Kim Holderness
Exactly. I love it so much. And it's made even better by adding their coveted waffle bed blanket. With layers and layers of the finest organic cotton, our bed is now a deeply comforting retreat that's there anytime I need it.
Penn Holderness
Bolen Branch's signature sheets and waffle bed blanket are a must have bedding combination. They are both loved by millions of sleepers and woven by artisans with the finest 100% organic cotton and highest level of craftsmanship.
Kim Holderness
We can confirm these sheets get softer with every wash and with over 300 color combinations, they are designed to mix and match.
Penn Holderness
So discover a softness beyond your wildest dreams. With bowl and branch, get 15% off your first order plus free shipping at bowlandbranch.com Holderness with code holderness.
Kim Holderness
That's Boland Branch. B O L L a n d branch.com Holderness code Holderness to unlock 15% off exclusions apply. This episode is sponsored by GAB.
Penn Holderness
As we know, the youth mental health crisis is all over the news and we know that social media is a huge driving factor.
Kim Holderness
Did you know the US Surgeon General warns that kids who spend more than three hours a day online are twice as likely to have depression and anxiety?
Penn Holderness
Yeah, we are huge advocates for prioritizing mental health and that includes monitoring the time that we and our kids spend in front of devices.
Kim Holderness
I personally keep my phone out of the bedroom at night so I don't spend hours mindlessly scrolling rather than getting a good night's sleep.
Penn Holderness
Here's the good news though. A company called GAB has solved that problem by doing something no one else is doing. Their approach is tech and Steps.
Kim Holderness
Tech and Steps works by providing kids safe phones and watches tailored to every age, offering the right device place at the right time.
Penn Holderness
From GPS tracking enabled watches for young kids to increased features and parent enabled apps on the phones for tweens and teens, each device grows with your child.
Kim Holderness
Bottom line, you don't have to give your kids a device that was made for an adult. Get them Gab, which keeps them socially connected safely.
Penn Holderness
Use our code to get the best deal on something that'll make parenting easier and give you some peace of mind. Visit gab.com holderness and use that code. Hold Holderness for a special offer that's.
Kim Holderness
G a b b.com holderness new year same kid chaos. But what if your pantry could actually make life easier this year?
Penn Holderness
It's all about progress over perfection. Yes, less stress, more yes. Thrive Market is the pantry Peacekeeper helping parents feed their families well without the fights.
Kim Holderness
Running a home is already enough. You shouldn't also have to be the ingredient Detective.
Penn Holderness
Thrive Market does the vetting for you. With 1,000 plus restricted ingredients, vetted brands and trusted staples, Thrive's app makes it.
Kim Holderness
Easy to shop for your family's needs without endless label reading. Use their 90 plus filters that include high protein, low sugar, gluten free and plant based.
Penn Holderness
Thrive Market makes it easy with thousands of healthier swaps of the things your kids love like Google's Mac and cheese, Collie Puffs, Olipops or other low sugar swaps and fruit snacks with simple ingredients.
Kim Holderness
Now I can say goodbye to the mean mom syndrome when I say yes to more nutritious versions of my kids favorite foods.
Penn Holderness
Join Thrive Market with our link thrive market.com holderness for 30% off your first order plus a free $60 gift.
Kim Holderness
We got some other questions that they just people want you to weigh in on. So I can answer this for you. The neuro branded supplements that are said to help with brain health and function, I'm guessing you're a no on.
Dr. Eric Topol
I'm a no on that.
Kim Holderness
Are you? No on that.
Dr. Eric Topol
Okay, bring me the data. Yeah, yeah.
Penn Holderness
These are all health trends by the way. All of these zone to cardio. You ever hear of zone two cardio?
Kim Holderness
No. That's what I'm trying to do. Moderate intensity that you're supposed to be working in Zone two. Moderate intensity, that's going to be low and slow. I'm not supposed to be doing that.
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, you can. I mean it's better than nothing. But every activity plot, you know, physical activity for benefit. If you go, you know, from moderate to more rigorous, it shows more benefit. Doesn't mean you have to go to, you know, crazy level. But going to zone two, which is just a minimal level heart rate increase, you know, if you want to do that, that's fine, it's still beneficial. But to say that that's more beneficial than more activity, that's. There's just nothing to substantiate that. But there are people out there hawking it, that's for sure.
Kim Holderness
Okay. This, they're saying, calling it fiber maxing with like.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Kim Holderness
What, what do you think? And this is eating high fiber foods and taking fiber supplements by eating high.
Dr. Eric Topol
Fiber foods is really important. It's. It's the one thing that people don't get enough of like 25 grams a day of fiber. So yeah, that would be good. Taking a fiber supplement of. If you're going to put in the list of supplements something that has some value. If you're not getting enough fiber in your diet, that's something to consider. But I would first go with trying to find ways to get better fiber in your diet, which you're going to get a lot more when you have a largely planted plant based diet.
Penn Holderness
All right, here's one I've never heard of. The hard 75.
Kim Holderness
Wait, you've never heard about this?
Penn Holderness
Nope.
Kim Holderness
This is what I don't.
Penn Holderness
I'm not on the same TikTok channels that you're on, babe. Like I'm not. Two 45 minute workouts, one outside drink, one gallon of water, read 10 pages of a nonfiction book and take a daily progress photo. Failing any task means starting over.
Kim Holderness
And it's for 75.
Penn Holderness
For 75 straight days.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh my God. Came up with this one according to.
Penn Holderness
Kim, a man, but I have never heard of it.
Kim Holderness
Before, I'm assuming it was a man. Is it a man? Sam? Hold on. She. She's looking.
Penn Holderness
Why you all got excused.
Kim Holderness
Like, oh, it is such a man. Yeah, it's a dude, so. Okay. All right. Okay, Doc, I want your input, and then I have opinions. Okay. So what. What do you think of something like this?
Dr. Eric Topol
I mean, it's just, you know, just make it up. It's like, you know, this is a Looney Tunes. I. I don't know. I mean, if it. Show me data that. That is better than a lot of other things that we've talked about. Yeah.
Kim Holderness
You know what I appreciate about this? I've not done it, and I'm not gonna do it. I love a soft 75, maybe, but I do. See, I used to be like this. If I had a very specific goal and, like, very specific rules, and so then I would. I would be more down to follow them. So I would do this as opposed to nothing. So I don't think it's. I've. I've seen a lot of people go through this on social media. I don't think it's hurt anybody. I just think that for me, if I messed up. I'm using air quotes here. And, like, didn't get a workout in, I would feel immense shame, and it would feel very punishing. But for some people, it was a huge transformation.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, I get that. I mean, if it gets you moving.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
I mean, if it's a motivational thing. But all I'm just saying is why that versus, you know, all the other things that we would advocate for. For that. So. Yeah, but if it. If it inspires people to do more activity, all the power to them.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. I like the gamifying of things. I will say that for it. So it depends on each person. Like, maybe like that sort of record. That's part of it. I joined a gym where they have a leaderboard, and that's, like, completely changed my life for the better. And I'm not. I'm very rarely in zone two. I'm like. I'm in zone whatever. The ones are above zone two.
Kim Holderness
That's where he told me, yeah, you.
Dr. Eric Topol
Won'T be in any leaderboard in zone two.
Kim Holderness
Yeah, yeah. He told me about his gym. I'm like, maybe I'll go. I need to really work on, you know, building muscle. And he told me about the leaderboard. I'm so competitive knowing I wouldn't be on the leaderboard. I'm like, I can't go. I can't go because I'M not going to be on the leaderboard.
Penn Holderness
You'll be on the leaderboard. You just.
Kim Holderness
It'll be at the bottom of it. Screw that. Okay. The sober, curious movement, drinking less or drinking more non alcoholic beverages, that's probably a good movement.
Dr. Eric Topol
And the reason for that is, as you know, the data that's come out for alcohol, it isn't, you know, positive for the most part. It is scary that people who have moderate drinking, a couple of drinks a week, there's nothing to really worry about there. But the more you drink alcohol, then you start to see some risk, at least by certain careful analyses. Now we're seeing less people drink alcohol and more people taking marijuana, right?
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
I don't know if that's a good trade off. But at any rate, having some limits on alcohol, for one, it does interrupt deep sleep, quality of sleep, for sure. We know that in most people and otherwise, if you are at high risk for things like Alzheimer's, it's not good to be drinking excessively. And other diseases as well, like atrial fibrillation, a condition which is very common. You don't want to be a big drinker and be at high risk for atrial fibrillation because that's not going to help you to get in that rhythm and all the things that can happen with that rhythm. So overall, it's a pretty good thing that we consume less. That's the country's trend right now.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
But we're consuming less from being excess high excess. So, yeah, I wouldn't stop drinking some alcohol. I just think that keeping it on the lower end is better.
Kim Holderness
I will say we were at Total Wine, like the holidays, and we were hosting, so we, you know, we got a. Like a case of something. The lovely woman at the checkout said that I think like 30% of their business now. Are those CBD THC drinks?
Penn Holderness
Yep. Oh, wow.
Kim Holderness
So would you if. If both things are on the table, do you prefer one or are you. Do you have an opinion?
Dr. Eric Topol
I've never tried a THC drink, so I don't. I don't know what to tell you.
Kim Holderness
It makes me go night night. Dr. Chapel, I have one.
Penn Holderness
I don't think. It does not appear to interrupt your sleep the way that a glass of wine does.
Kim Holderness
Right. If I. Yeah, if I love a. I love a glass of wine, but I can't really drink them anymore because I can't sleep.
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, that's a common story for people trying to prioritize their sleep. It interrupts it. And so, you know, if that that might be reasonable. I, I don't know enough about that to give you a good solid answer.
Kim Holderness
Good answer.
Dr. Eric Topol
Maybe, you know, at individual level it's a good way to titrate.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Penn Holderness
Dr. Topol, you are awesome. And like we always feel better after talking to you because you bring us back down to, in this world that is trying so desperately to have us leave Earth for like whatever their supplement is. So thank you for, thank you for keeping it real. Just so you know, you found a following here. They love you. They will continue to ask questions. What, what's the most, what's the most important thing to you right now? What's the most important message to you or place that we should go to to learn more?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, well, I really appreciate that. And the problem we have right now is we're in this predatory environment where we have people who are highly influential who are hawking things, selling things and they're not usually, you know, not backed up by adequate or any evidence and even some with potential harm. It's a bad time because these folks have just overriding influence and they're very successful in selling these things. So there aren't limited credible sources, unfortunately. And you have to tell you, and I think you know this, the credible sources don't get the same traction. And the reason for that is that people like to think that there's all these secrets that their doctors won't tell them and that they, these, these soothsayers know, you know, like peptides and all the things that we've been discussing and that the real doctors are they, they just don't know what they're talking about. We have this real serious question of the medical establishment. Is it real, is it truthful? So we're at a tough time right now. And I get that. I mean, look, when I put the superageous book together, you know, it had almost 2,000 citations and I really tried, tried to stick with evidence and it's done very well. But it's not going to compare to books like Outlived by Atia or Casey Means Book, which is full of all kinds of stuff that is not backed up by evidence. They're selling millions of copies, right? So you know, people are more interested in this fringe stuff. It doesn't backed up by evidence. And I understand that. And that's kind of the world we live in right now.
Kim Holderness
And the world we live in right now at the time of this recording. There's just been been news that now the United States is changing its recommended for just their recommendations for childhood vaccines and vaccines in general. Do you have any opinion on that?
Dr. Eric Topol
It's really unfortunate, the data there. I mean, the vaccines have been the biggest positive impact in public health in history, saving immense number of lives. And they've taken off lots of. They dropped several vaccines from the recommended schedule. That's RFK Jr. And his colleagues. It's really unfortunate because some of those vaccines are really important. We've had, you know, many children with flu deaths this season. That's one of the ones that have been dropped and several others that obviously the hepatitis vaccines are big because if you don't, if you get hepatitis when you're a child, you could go on to, you know, liver disease, chronic and liver cancer. And we're going to see more of that as a result of these changes and many others. So it's really unfortunate and that's part of this anti science movement. And you know, the people that are running HHS are very much in alignment with a lot of these influencers.
Kim Holderness
I mean, personal note. So my aunt contracted polio a year before the vaccine came out and then died. And not she, she had double master's degree. She was paralyzed from the waist down. She lived a big life and she impacted so many people. She was a principal, she was an educator. She just, I mean, she was just, I mean she lived five lives in her, her life but then died of post polio virus.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh yeah, because.
Kim Holderness
And knowing that the rest of our family is protected because we have this vaccine and then you hear people talk. So I just, I get, get very prickly about it. But I'm glad to have a very calm, you know, person, not neutral, but a person who's actually knows what they're talking about.
Dr. Eric Topol
So yeah, the post polio thing, you know, that's, it's awful. It's a big deal and we still don't understand the mechanism, but it can occur, you know, decades later.
Kim Holderness
Yeah. 50 years later. Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
And it's just incredibly, I mean all the muscles can atrophy. It just, it's a horrible syndrome that is not so rare after polio. But just think about all those kids that are not getting even a measles vaccine now that can be deadly and it can wipe out your immune system. So each of these conditions, polio, measles, you know, down the whole list, diphtheria, they all have very serious sequelae in people. And at large, where we've already seen from the pandemic a drop in childhood vaccination. And now, now we're even taking more away this is really a serious breach. I am assuming that in the years ahead, when we get back on track, that we'll get these all restored, but we've got a lapse here for a stretch and hopefully it's going to be a limited one.
Kim Holderness
It makes me so sad. Anyway, thank you for going down that road with me, Dr. Topol, and we love to have you on. I'm sure we're going to get more questions. Is there anything exciting? I know you have this clinical trial starting. Anything else you, you, you want the folks to know about that you're working on?
Dr. Eric Topol
Well, we just enrolled over a thousand people with Long Covid for Tirzepatide, Zeppbound, really, or placebo. And this is the largest trial ever of Long Covid. And we enrolled all the thousand plus people in a month. Less than a month.
Sam Allen
Wow.
Dr. Eric Topol
So they're currently on the drug every week. We'll know in a year whether Zepbound works. The trial's going really well and it's exciting. And finally a really large trial. And we're so proud that we're able to get the Long Covid community at least a start, because there's not been any large trials yet. And we do this remotely, like the Alez Harmon trial, where anybody can join. And the interest in that was phenomenal.
Penn Holderness
So Tirzepatide has been. It was diabetes, it's now weight loss. People are microdosing it for brain health and for Alzheimer's possibilities. How does it help with Long Covid? Is it just all this anti. Inflammation or like, what is it?
Dr. Eric Topol
Yeah, it knocks out inflammation in the brain and the, and the body as good as any drug we've ever seen. And as you know, the immune system is terribly dysregulated in people with Long Covid. Yeah, that's why you get this inflammation everywhere. It's really bad. So this is as good a drug as we know to take that on. And we've already had some testimonials from some of the participants that they never felt better. But of course, we don't know what they could be getting. Placebo. You know, we have to wrap this up. It'll. It'll take a year to get all the. The data finalized from the enrollees. But it's a. It's the number one candidate drug where. And of course, it's not going to be a cure for everyone. We're hoping even 20, 25% it helps. But then we'll go on to testing other drugs. But along Covid, we've left These poor folks behind, and so many of them are terribly disabled. And I'm glad we could get on it. And we are committed to staying with it as long as it takes.
Kim Holderness
We're so happy you exist in the world, Dr. Topol. And thank you for doing this and answering our questions. Yeah.
Dr. Eric Topol
And laugh lines.
Kim Holderness
Yeah. Well, I. I want my new ringtone to be Dr. Topple. Going like this.
Penn Holderness
Oh, my God.
Kim Holderness
Like, that's what I want. My ring tone.
Penn Holderness
Oh, collagen. Thanks again. We will obviously schedule you for another one of these soon, because we just keep getting calls and, like, when. Emails, and when we do, we'll send them to you.
Kim Holderness
Okay. Okay, that's terrific.
Dr. Eric Topol
I'll look forward to the next time we convene.
Kim Holderness
Thank you so much. I love Dr. Eric Topol because he's not trying to sell you something. And if he were selling something, I would go buy it.
Penn Holderness
Yeah, he.
Kim Holderness
If he told me, he's like, actually, Kim, the thigh master will change everything. I'd be like, okay, let's go. Let's get on ebay. Let's do it.
Penn Holderness
Also, like, he told me how old he is. It is. He looks so good. I. Like, I. I don't.
Kim Holderness
I don't. I can't even, like, put an age on him, Right?
Penn Holderness
So, like, if you put him up in his age, up next to, like, superstars, like, actors of the same age, you will say, wow, this guy is walking proof of, like, being healthy. And I know that he practices a lot of what he preaches, so that's, like, a pretty good marketing tool, keeping it toy. Yeah. Yep, he sure is. So I guess it's time for. For Pen's nugs.
Kim Holderness
The first nugs of the new year. And if you're listening to us and not watching on us on YouTube, this is where Sam painstakingly turns Pen into some nuggets. We're waiting for that Nug sponsor into a chicken nugget.
Penn Holderness
But really, it's just the three nuggets. Nuggets that really kind of stuck out from. From the show today. And this one is gonna be a little different. I'm gonna say a word, and then I'm gonna make a noise. All right, ready? Number one, collagen.
Kim Holderness
No, it was more like.
Penn Holderness
Sorry, collagen.
Kim Holderness
The noises that our persnickety doctor makes.
Penn Holderness
Number two, brain clock.
Kim Holderness
Right.
Penn Holderness
Like, so there's now a test that they're working on. The brain clock sounded pretty cool.
Kim Holderness
Yeah.
Penn Holderness
If you heard that. Just, like, thousands of markers that basically all work together to let you know if you're aging at the correct rate or at the incorrect rate. He said the last thing he said. Don't know if you heard it. It's not going to be prohibitively expensive. It's not going to be like a full body MRI scan, and it's going to give you, like, a good snapshot of whether your brain is aging the right way. That's really valuable.
Kim Holderness
It's very valuable. And also, I just went. Even describing it, I get, like, a little confused about how that would even happen. And I know it's a blood test and the whole thing, but then the fact that, like, doing math to calculate how much protein I need just, like, spent my brain. I'm so glad there's such smart people out there.
Sam Allen
Yeah.
Kim Holderness
Okay.
Penn Holderness
And finally, full body MRI.
Kim Holderness
Dr. Topol's not a fan.
Penn Holderness
He. Although, like, I want to go back to this because he finished by saying if there's something really particularly like an undiagnosed noticeable condition, that's a good example. Like, especially if it's affecting multiple parts of your body, then it might work. But I think he's. He doesn't feel super strongly about just going and spending a bunch of money to get your whole body looked at.
Kim Holderness
I think that's exactly it for the general population. If nothing is really wrong with you spending a. A ton of money on something just to get your alarm bells up. And it's. It's not worth it. It. I love to spend a ton of money on just random shit, so.
Penn Holderness
And for that one, a bonus lion's mane. Poor lions. When Dr. Toble gets a hold of lion's mane.
Kim Holderness
That being said, if there's a study that said lion's mane is amazing beyond just anecdotal evidence, I think he'd be the first one out to say, hey, you should take this stuff.
Penn Holderness
Yeah.
Kim Holderness
But he is just very against. And this is where he and I went toe to toe before, because, like, science moves good, science moves slowly, right? Like, these studies take years and they're expensive to do. So, like, if. If I. If a guy on Instagram says, like, yeah, maybe lion's made. Is it gonna hurt me? Turns out, maybe.
Penn Holderness
So we'll see. Anyway, Anyway, so those nugs were inspired by Eric Topol, who, a lot of times when you first ask him about something, he makes some sort of grunty noise.
Kim Holderness
I love it.
Penn Holderness
And we do a super cut of that, maybe. It's wonderful. It makes me very, very happy.
Kim Holderness
Supercut of Dr. Topol's noises.
Dr. Eric Topol
Oh, gosh. Oh, my God, this is a looney tune.
Kim Holderness
Thank you for joining us. We love you. Time for some credits.
Penn Holderness
Laugh Lines is written and produced by Kim Holderness, Pen Holderness and Anne Marie Tapke with original music by Pen Holderness. It is filmed, edited and live produced by Sam Allen, who would had extra credit today because we had two podcasts and she had to run around like a crazy person turn off the cameras on and on because they're overheating. Anyway, we're also hosted by acast. As always, we love to hear from you. So please write to us on the email podcast theholdernessfamily.com or leave us a voicemail at 323-364-3929. Y', all. We love the voicemails because it gives you guys a chance to really bring your personality out and we will play you on the Laugh Lines and we'll see you next time on Laugh Lines.
Kim Holderness
Okay, bye. Love you.
Penn Holderness
This episode is brought to you by Pura.
Kim Holderness
If well, being means feeling grounded in your space, start with the easiest switch the air around you.
Penn Holderness
Yeah. Pura is a premium smart diffuser that makes home fragrance effortless. Control it from your phone, set it to match your day and breathe out the chaos.
Kim Holderness
Pura lets you personalize your environment with scents that match your mood, lifestyle and design aesthetic.
Penn Holderness
Plus, you can completely customize your scenting experience from intensity levels to scent schedules.
Kim Holderness
Whether it's for your home, your car or a thoughtful gift, Pura brings scent design to life.
Penn Holderness
And for a limited time, you get a free Pura plus home diffuser when you subscribe to your favorite fragrances for 12 months.
Kim Holderness
This is restoration, not reinvention. Grab your free diffuser at Pura. This episode is brought to you by Balance of Nature looking for a supplement.
Penn Holderness
That'S based on years of research and development and filled with ingredients you can actually pronounce.
Kim Holderness
Balance of Nature's whole health system supplements include 47 ingredients of fruits, vegetables, spices and fibers.
Penn Holderness
You know, even with the best routine, it can be hard to stay on track. More than 90% of Americans do not meet the recommended intake of dietary fiber.
Kim Holderness
Balance of Nature has you covered with supplements that are vegan, kosher and and gluten free.
Penn Holderness
And you can take their supplements with water. You can chew them or you can open them up and mix the powder into your food or drinks.
Kim Holderness
I personally take the fruits and vegetables supplement, mix the powder into my morning smoothie and start the day off on the right foot.
Penn Holderness
Plus, they have auto shipping, which means your order is delivered every 28 days with free shipping included. Pause, reschedule or cancel anytime you want. You are in control.
Kim Holderness
We know that what you put into your body matters. Balance of Nature's goal is to deliver the goodness from natural ingredients just as nature intended.
Penn Holderness
So go to balanceofnature.com and use code holderness to get 35% off your first order as a preferred customer. Plus get a free bottle of fiber and Spice.
Kim Holderness
That's balanceofnature.com and use code Holderness.
Penn Holderness
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you can could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
Sam Allen
The youth mental health crisis is growing and social media is a major driver. Kids are spending up to nine hours a day on screens, often unsupervised, and studies show a direct link to anxiety, depression and even suicidal thoughts. That's where Gab comes in. Gab offers safe phones and watches with no Internet or social media. Just the right tech at the right time. From SM watches for young kids to advanced parent managed phones for teens, GAB keeps kids connected safely. Visit gab.com getgab and use code getgab for a special offer that's G-A B-B.com getgab Gab Tech in steps Independence for them, Peace of mind for parents.
Release Date: January 20, 2026
Guests: Dr. Eric Topol (world-renowned cardiologist and researcher)
In this episode, Kim and Penn Holderness bring back the ever-popular Dr. Eric Topol to cut through the noise and debunk the latest viral health trends. Known for his no-nonsense, evidence-based, and occasionally “persnickety” approach, Dr. Topol answers listener questions about everything from protein fads, weighted vests, and collagen to the prevention of Alzheimer’s, the role of functional medicine, new blood-based health tests (including “brain clocks”), and whether popular supplements and routines are worth your time or money.
The tone is light, humorous, and relatable—true to the Holderness style—with Dr. Topol offering both reassurance and tough love about trendy advice flooding our feeds and supermarket shelves.
Q: “How much protein is too much, and what happens if you consume too much?”
Q: Are weighted vests really better for bone density?
Q: “Does collagen protein really help with hair, skin, nails, or joints?”
Personal Story ([32:22]):
This episode blends science and sanity with Holderness-style humor, ultimately advocating for curiosity, skepticism, and evidence over hype—“cutting through the BS,” as Kim puts it. Listeners are reminded to question who benefits from the latest trend, to look for data not anecdotes, and to focus on proven pillars of healthy aging: sleep, exercise, (mostly plant-based) diet, and managing true risk factors with expert help. And to laugh at ourselves—because, as Penn says, “when we age, life is like a comedy stage… and that’s why we got laugh lines.”
Have a question for Dr. Topol or the show?
Full episodes and bonus content: