Legacy Podcast Episode Summary: "Stalin | Fighting Hitler | 3"

Released May 14, 2025 | Host/Author: Wondery

1. Introduction to Stalin's Leadership During WWII

In the third episode of the Legacy series, titled "Stalin | Fighting Hitler | 3," hosts Afua Hash and Peter Frankopan delve deep into Joseph Stalin's pivotal role during World War II. They explore Stalin's transformation from a feared dictator to a wartime leader, examining his strategies, decisions, and the immense sacrifices made by the Soviet Union.

2. The Shock of the German Invasion ([00:44] - [08:49])

The episode begins in the summer of 1941, a period marked by the rapid fall of France and the harrowing realization that Hitler's ambitions had turned eastward towards the Soviet Union. On June 22, 1941, Soviet border guards detected the ominous sound of German tanks, signaling the commencement of Operation Barbarossa.

At [05:50], Frankopan narrates Stalin's initial disbelief upon learning of the invasion:

"Stalin feels the air rush out of the room...He can't look up, because that would mean accepting that Hitler...has betrayed him." ([08:49])

Stalin's delayed response—waiting four hours before issuing any orders—indicates his state of shock and inability to process the dire situation immediately.

3. Stalin's Initial Paralysis and Beria's Intervention ([08:49] - [09:52])

Afua Hash raises a critical question about Stalin's delayed reaction:

"Only four hours after the invasion begins... what is going on with him at this point?" ([08:49])

Frankopan responds, suggesting Stalin experienced a profound breakdown, struggling to comprehend the magnitude of the threat:

"He has some form of breakdown...He can't believe that he's exposed the Soviet Union to these kinds of risks." ([09:03])

As German forces swiftly advance, Stalin retreats to his dacha, leaving his subordinates, led by Beria of the NKVD, to manage the crisis. This absence creates uncertainty about leadership during a moment when decisive action is most needed.

4. Stalin's Rallying Speech and Mobilization ([10:41] - [16:47])

Despite initial paralysis, Stalin regains composure and delivers a rousing speech on July 3, 1941, appealing to Soviet citizens and soldiers to resist the invaders:

"Comrades, citizens, brothers and sisters...History shows that invincible armies don't exist." ([11:08])

This speech marks a shift in Stalin's image from a feared tyrant to a wartime leader galvanizing the Soviet Union's vast resources. Hash notes the significance of the war being termed the "Great Patriotic War" in Russia, highlighting Stalin's crafted image as a heroic figure:

"He is enjoying his finest hour." ([12:29])

Frankopan underscores Stalin's organizational prowess, emphasizing the relocation of factories east of the Urals and the staggering industrial output achieved:

"Soviet industrial output during this era reaches astonishing levels...15,000 aircraft and 13,000 tanks." ([15:41])

5. The Battle of Stalingrad: A Turning Point ([17:45] - [21:31])

The narrative shifts to the Battle of Stalingrad, one of WWII's most brutal confrontations. Hash describes the onset of Operation Uranus on November 1942, which encircles the German Sixth Army:

"An entire German army is surrounded...the tide is really turning now." ([21:03])

Frankopan highlights the immense casualties suffered by both sides and the strategic importance of halting German advances toward vital resources like the oil fields in Baku:

"The key thing was keeping the Germans away from oil fields in Baku." ([24:29])

The battle not only signifies a military victory but also cements Stalin's role in altering the course of the war, albeit at an unimaginable human cost.

6. The Human Cost and Stalin's Personal Struggles ([25:54] - [29:08])

Hash confronts the paradox of millions willing to fight under Stalin's oppressive regime:

"They might be wondering why they were willing to make such a huge sacrifice under Stalin's leadership." ([25:54])

Frankopan attributes this resilience to a combination of fear, propaganda, and the brutal realities of Nazi aggression:

"Propaganda...exaggerating it, but in lots of cases not needing to, because...the ways that the Germans behaved...were absolutely grotesque." ([26:28])

The episode also touches upon Stalin's personal turmoil, particularly the capture of his son, Yakov, by the Germans. Despite his public stoicism, Yakov's capture visibly affects Stalin, hinting at cracks in his formidable exterior:

"He is visibly upset by his son's capture...he goes grey during the war." ([27:26])

7. Stalin's Diplomatic Maneuvers: Tehran and Yalta Conferences ([30:24] - [36:01])

As the war progresses, Stalin engages in crucial diplomatic negotiations with Allied leaders. The Tehran Conference (1943) and the Yalta Conference (1945) become focal points of discussion.

At Yalta, Stalin negotiates aggressively for territorial gains in Poland and Eastern Europe, showcasing his strategic acumen:

"Stalin tugs the stopper from a bottle of vodka... 'When Hitler is defeated, my country expects reparations...$20 billion would suffice.'" ([30:40])

Frankopan critiques the ethical implications of these negotiations, highlighting how decisions made in Viennese drawing rooms determined the fate of millions:

"Fate can get decided by a very small number of people who decide that they have the right to carve the world up." ([35:40])

Hash emphasizes the resulting Iron Curtain, symbolizing the deep divisions in post-war Europe:

"On the 5th of March 1946, Churchill gives a speech...talking of an iron curtain being drawn across the center of Europe." ([38:41])

8. The Aftermath of WWII and the Onset of the Cold War ([36:01] - [44:55])

Post-war Europe is depicted as exhausted and in desperate need of rebuilding. The United States' Marshall Plan injects significant funds into Western Europe, contrasting with Stalin's tightening grip over Eastern Europe through oppressive measures and the establishment of puppet governments.

Frankopan discusses the Berlin Blockade (1948-1949), where Stalin's attempt to cut off Western access to Berlin fails due to the successful Allied Airlift:

"The Soviets cut off road and canal links into the city...the Americans respond with a huge airlift." ([40:10])

This event marks a significant Cold War victory for the West, reinforcing the division between East and West.

Hash and Frankopan also touch upon Stalin's continued paranoia and the tightening of his regime, leading up to his eventual decline:

"He is unpredictable, volatile...his levels of suspicion and paranoia have reached new levels." ([43:57])

9. Stalin's Legacy and the Soviet Superpower ([43:57] - [45:31])

The episode concludes by assessing Stalin's transformation of the Soviet Union into an industrial superpower capable of rivaling the West. Despite immense human suffering and oppressive rule, Stalin's leadership ensured the Soviet Union's significant role in shaping the post-war geopolitical landscape.

Afua Hash reflects on Stalin's relentless pursuit of power and control, setting the stage for the subsequent Cold War tensions:

"As 1953 approaches, Stalin decides it's time to turn back the clock...return to the terror." ([44:55])

Peter Frankopan underscores the long-lasting impact of Stalin's decisions, which continue to influence contemporary geopolitical dynamics:

"The legacy of a divided Korean peninsula is still with us here and today." ([41:43])

10. Conclusion: The Duality of Stalin's Impact

Throughout the episode, Hash and Frankopan present a nuanced portrayal of Stalin—both as a ruthless leader responsible for immense suffering and as a strategic mastermind who steered the Soviet Union to victory against Nazi Germany. This duality forms the crux of Stalin's complex legacy, questioning whether his contributions to defeating Hitler overshadow the atrocities committed under his regime.

Notable Quotes:

• Peter Frankopan ([09:03]):
  "If you deal with the devil, the devil comes and takes your soul from you."

• Afua Hash ([12:29]):
  "He's suddenly stepping into this role as a hero..."

• Peter Frankopan ([35:40]):
  "Fate can get decided by a very small number of people who decide that they have the right to carve the world up."

Final Thoughts

This episode of Legacy expertly navigates the intricate and often contradictory facets of Joseph Stalin's leadership during one of history's most tumultuous periods. By balancing military strategy, political maneuvering, and personal narratives, Hash and Frankopan offer listeners a comprehensive understanding of Stalin's enduring impact on the 20th century and beyond.

Follow Legacy

Stay updated with the Legacy podcast by Wondery on the Wondery App, Amazon Music, or your preferred podcast platform. For early and ad-free access, consider joining Wondery+.