GOP Judge Compares Trump to Slave-Catcher in Ruling

Summary

---

Legal AF by MeidasTouch

Episode: GOP Judge Compares Trump to Slave-Catcher in Ruling
Date: January 17, 2026
Host: Michael Popok (MeidasTouch Network, national trial lawyer strategist)

---

Episode Overview

This episode, hosted by Michael Popok, centers on a bombshell federal ruling in Massachusetts where Senior Status Judge William G. Young—an 85-year-old Reagan appointee—lambasted the Trump administration for orchestrating what the judge likened to slave-catching tactics in response to pro-Palestinian protestors. The ruling exposes unconstitutional conspiracies by high-level cabinet officials, specifically Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, targeting First Amendment protections of protestors—many on student visas or green cards—who spoke out against Trump administration's Israeli-Palestinian policies.

The episode explores the sweeping legal and historical implications, the judge’s scathing language, and the Trump administration’s brazen backlash, drawing parallels to the erosion of civil rights protections in America.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Massachusetts Federal Ruling and Judge Young’s Legacy

(01:39 - 07:00)

• Background:
  Judge Young, part of an esteemed group of "senior status" judges, delivered a landmark decision exposing coordinated constitutional violations by the Trump administration.
  • "Judge Young is a Part of a team of senior status judges...defending democracy every day." (02:25)
  • Popok describes Young as “an 85 year old Reagan appointee” who’s been unapologetically defiant, even when chastised by the Supreme Court.
• Comparisons to Historic Civil Rights Struggles:
  Popok draws links to other legendary rulings, referencing Judge Breyer in San Francisco and Judge Kofador in Seattle for rulings that protected constitutional norms.
• Judge Young’s Motivation and Defiance:
  • Quote: “He shrugged his shoulders and said, defiant? I'm an 85. He basically said, I'm an 85 year old senior status judge. It was not my intention to be defiant. I just didn't understand your ruling about Donald Trump cutting off funding to be such a precedent...” (03:10)

2. Details of the Trump Administration’s Actions

(03:50 - 06:00)

• Targeting Pro-Palestinian Protestors:
  The administration incarcerated protestors—primarily students and professors on visas—who were engaging in First Amendment-protected speech, effectively equating dissent with terrorism.
  • Protestors “were taken off the streets. They were disappeared into ICE detention facilities. Sound familiar? Without due process and held for months…” (05:11)
• Denial of Judicial Authority:
  Trump’s legal counsel told Judge Young he had no jurisdiction:
  • “The Trump administration even had the balls in court...to say, judge, you don't have any jurisdiction over us anyway.” (05:37)
  • The administration asserted only immigration courts could address these detentions, citing the Immigration and Naturalization Act.

3. Historic Rhetoric and Analogies: The “Slave-Catcher” Comparison

(02:15, 07:00 - 08:20)

• Judge Young’s Stinging Rebuke:
  • At a hearing on the eve of Martin Luther King Jr. Weekend, Judge Young analogized the cabinet’s conduct to the era when authorities paid bounties to “chase after newly freed slaves to re-enslave them and return them to their masters.” (02:15, 04:12)
• Critical Quotes:
  • "I find it breathtaking...that I have been compelled on the evidence to find the conduct of such high level officers of our government Cabinet secretaries conspired to infringe the First Amendment rights of people with such rights here in the United States..." —Judge Young, quoted by Popok (06:21)
  • "These Cabinet secretaries have failed in their sworn duty to uphold the Constitution.” (06:37)
  • Judge Young calls the Trump administration “authoritarian...that will abuse anyone who does not toe the line.” (07:28)

4. Legal Implications and Broader Context

(05:55 - 10:00)

• Remedy and Impact:
  Judge Young is considering special protections for Palestinian protestors, cementing a precedent for First Amendment rights regardless of citizenship status, provided no violent incitement is involved.
  • "I will defend with my last dying breath their right to say it. As long as it's not inciting violence..." (08:22)
• Conflict with Supreme Court and Other Appellate Rulings:
  Popok mentions contrary findings from the Third Circuit (Philadelphia), questioning the power of federal judges to issue remedies in similar immigration-related constitutional cases.
• Erosion of Civil Rights Protections:
  Popok laments the degradation of the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division and the symbolic hypocrisy of the Trump administration referencing civil rights icons.
  • "Proud history [of the Civil Rights Division] up on their website as if they're protecting it. And we know that they're not because they've destroyed the Civil Rights division..." (09:25)

5. Trump Administration’s Response and Political Fallout

(10:24 - 12:00)

• Hostile Reaction:
  Trump’s spokespeople suggest expelling Judge Young and label dissenters as “terrorist sympathizers.”
  • "Tricia McLaughlin, the spokesperson for the Homeland Security...I don't think she was talking about the student activists. I think she was talking about a federal judge." (10:45)
  • White House spokesperson paints Judge Young as a “left wing activist judge sympathizer,” disregarding the principle of co-equal branches.
• The Stakes for Democracy:
  Popok closes by reminding listeners that the executive branch's contempt for checks and balances must be countered, invoking Martin Luther King Jr. weekend as a time to reflect on protecting American freedoms.

---

Notable Quotes and Memorable Moments

• Judge Young, on government misconduct:
  • "I find it breathtaking...that I have been compelled on the evidence to find the conduct of such high level officers of our government Cabinet secretaries conspired to infringe the First Amendment rights of people...” (06:21)
  • "[The Cabinet] have failed in their sworn duty to uphold the Constitution.” (06:37)
  • "The big problem in this case is that the cabinet secretaries and ostensibly the president are not honoring the First Amendment." (07:10)
• Michael Popok, on First Amendment values:
  • "I will defend with my last dying breath their right to say it. As long as it's not inciting violence...by God, I will defend their right to make me uncomfortable. That's what the First Amendment is all about." (08:22)
• Judge Young’s “slave-catcher” analogy:
  • “The actions of the Trump administration are akin to when people were paid bounties to chase after newly freed slaves to re-enslave them and return them to their masters.” (02:15 and paraphrased at 04:12)
• Popok, on historical context:
  • "The irony of the fact that on Martin Luther King Jr. Weekend, that's going to be completely ignored and disrespected by the Trump administration..." (09:05)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

| Segment | Timestamp | |--------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------| | Introduction of Judge Young and context | 01:39 - 03:00 | | Judge Young’s “slave-catcher” analogy and historic comparisons | 02:15, 04:12 | | Details of Trump administration’s actions and legal argument | 03:50 - 06:00 | | Judge Young’s most critical quotes and legal findings | 06:21 - 07:28 | | Discussion of remedies and First Amendment significance | 07:50 - 08:42 | | Broader implications and civil rights context | 09:05 - 10:16 | | Trump administration and White House backlash to ruling | 10:24 - 11:35 | | Closing thoughts on civil rights, democracy, and MLK, Jr. legacy | 11:30 - 12:00 |

---

Conclusion

This episode delivers a forceful legal analysis of a historic federal ruling denouncing the Trump administration’s campaign against First Amendment rights, with Judge Young’s analogy to slave-catcher tactics ringing especially powerful on Martin Luther King Jr. Weekend. Michael Popok weaves together legal precedent, civil rights history, and contemporary threats to democracy with both conviction and deep concern for America’s constitutional values.

Listeners are left with the warning that vigilance is needed to prevent the erosion of constitutional protections—and an affirmation that the judiciary, even in its oldest and most seasoned ranks, can stand as a bulwark for freedom.

---

Transcript

[Stiles Mackenzie]

We interrupt this program to bring you an important Wayfair message. Wayfair's got Style Tips for Every home. This is Stiles Mackenzie helping you make those rooms sing. Today's Style Tip when it comes to making a statement, treat bold patterns like neutrals. Go wild like an untamed animal. Print area rug under a rustic farmhouse table. From wayfair.com this has been your Wayfair style tip to keep those interiors superior.

[Jerry (Insurance Assistant)]

Wayfair Every Style, Every Home Tired of your car insurance rate going up? Even with a clean driving record, you're not alone. That's why there's Jerry, your proactive insurance assistant. Jerry compares rates side by side from over 50 top insurers and helps you switch with ease. Jerry even tracks market rates and alerts you when it's best to shop. No spam calls, no hidden fees. Drivers who save with Jerry could save over $1,300 a year. Switch with confidence. Download the Jerry app or visit Jerry AI Libsyn today. That's J E R R Y AI Libsyn from Lashes for days with the.

[Thrive Cosmetics Representative]

Viral Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara to lift and color from the brilliant eye brightener. Thrive Cosmetics is the go to for amplifying everyday looks. Plus every product is 100% vegan, cruelty free and made with clean skin loving ingredients that work with your skin. Amplify your everyday. Go to thrivecosmetics.com shine26 for an exclus of offer of 20% off your first order. That's Thrive Cosmetics. C A U S E M E t I c s.com/shine26 an unconstitutional conspiracy.

[Michael Popak]

At the highest levels of the Trump administration led by his Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has been called out and uncovered by a senior status federal judge, a Republican appointee at that. In Massachusetts coming off of bombshell hearing in which the Trump administration and its cabinet were scolded in public for one of the most audacious attempts to crush First Amendment expression in an 85 year old senior status judge's history. In fact, at one point irony not lost on me. During the lead in to Martin Luther King Jr. Weekend, Judge Young in Massachusetts said that the actions of the Trump administration are akin to when people were paid bounties to chase after newly freed slaves to re enslave them and return them to their masters. I'm Michael Popak. We've got your attention. You're on Midas Touch and on Legal af. Let's talk about Judge Young. Judge Young is a Part of a team of senior status judges who are in their late 70s and 80s who are defending democracy every day. Like Judge Breyer in San Francisco, who issued his ruling about Donald Trump's violation of the Posse Comitatus act, the National Guard in California stopping Donald Trump in his tracks. Or Judge Kofador up in Seattle, who issued the first birthright citizenship decision that kicked off the whole protection of our 14th Amendment rights to be born in this country and recognized as an American. And now Judge Young, who has been chastised by the United States Supreme Court, who said he was defiant because he didn't follow a prior order of theirs as precedent. He shrugged his shoulders and said, defiant? I'm an 85. He basically said, I'm an 85 year old senior status judge. It was not my intention to be defiant. I just didn't understand your ruling about Donald Trump cutting off funding to be such a precedent based on the emergency docket. And now he has in front of him students and professors who are here on student visas and or on green cards who are protesting Donald Trump's foreign policy and policy related to Israel and the Palestinian people. And so he was effectively jailing Palestinian protesters on college campuses. Not committing crimes, just committing First Amendment freedom of expression, which you enjoy even if you are not an American Citizen. Anyone on U.S. soil enjoys First Amendment and constitutional protections. They're not terrorist sympathizers that need to be expelled, if you can believe it, and I know you can. The Trump administration spokespeople even went so far as to call for the expulsion or deportation of Judge Young for having ruled against the democratically appointed president. Yeah, it's gotten that bad. Have a seat. Let me preach you from the. This is just a hearing now about what should the remedy be. This judge already found that the Trump administration committed serious conspiratorial acts of First Amendment abuse against the rights of these people to speak out freely. Instead, they were taken off the streets. They were disappeared into ICE detention facilities. Sound familiar? Without due process and held for months until they were bailed out at some point. And the Trump administration even had the balls in court, that's a legal term, even had the balls in court to look Judge Young in the eye in the middle of this barrage of criticism of the conspiracy being unmasked and say, judge, you don't have any jurisdiction over us anyway. The judge said, I have no jurisdiction to issue a remedy for a constitutional violation. They said, no, you have to go through immigration court. That's an immigration judge's policy. That's what he gets to do under the Immigration, National Immigration and Naturalization Act. You don't have the power here. Now there is some support for that argument. We just had a ruling that came out of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals sitting in Philadelphia about Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University professor, adjunct professor and protester. And they basically said something like federal judges under most circumstances don't have power to remedy constitutional violations. But I think this, the record developed by Judge Young certainly gave him the power to fashion the remedy. And that's what this hearing was about. Listen to the quotes and from those that were in the courtroom about what the judge observed. Here's what the judge said. I find it breathtaking. This is Judge Young now on Thursday that I have been compelled on the evidence to find the conduct of such high level officers of our government Cabinet secretaries conspired to infringe the First Amendment rights of people with such with such rights here in the United States, their Cabinet. These Cabinet secretaries have failed in their sworn duty to uphold the Constitution. Think of the language that this senior status 85 year old Reagan appointee used against the Trump administration conspiracy infringe. He in fact at one point said this is at the highest level that there hasn't been anybody higher than Marco Rubio and Kristi Noem to ever have gone after the First Amendment the way he's ruled that they have. I want to eat better. But I realized pretty quickly that after long days of recording, cooking healthy meals just wasn't going to happen for me. Factor doesn't ask you to meal prep or follow recipes. It just removes the entire problem. Two minutes, real food done. You're not failing at healthy eating. You're failing at having a three extra hours every night in your day. Factor is already made by chefs, designed by dietitians and delivered to your door. You heat it for two minutes and eat lean proteins, colorful vegetables, whole food ingredients, healthy fats, no refined sugars, no artificial sweeteners, no refined seed oils. My favorite has been grilled filet mignon and creamy Parmesan shrimp because it worked even when I was completely slammed. Factor fits your life, not someone else's plan. With around 100 rotating meals every week, including high protein calorie, smart Mediterranean, GLP1 support, ready to eat salads and the new Muscle Pro Collection. Always fresh, never frozen. No prep, no cleanup, no mental load. It's not motivation to eat better, it's elimination of the reason you don't. I use this and you should too. Head to FactorMeals.com LegalAF50OFF and use code LegalAF50OFF to get 50% off your first Factor box plus free breakfast for a year offer only valid for new factor customers with code and qualifying auto renewing subscription purchase. Make healthier eating easy with factor. But he continued, he said at the hearing, talking straight here. Judge Young again, the big problem in this case is that the cabinet secretaries and ostensibly the president are not honoring the First Amendment. He goes on to call the Trump administration authoritarian. That will abuse anyone who does not toe the line. Absolutely. And that top officials have a fearful approach to freedom of speech that would seek to, according to him, exclude from participation everyone who doesn't agree with him. It looks like he's going to fashion a remedy to give Palestinian protesters on college campuses a special protection for First Amendment non criminal expression. Look, I don't agree with everything a lot of protesters say, okay? But I will defend with my last dying breath their right to say it. As long as it's not inciting violence. As long as it's not inciting murderous or violent attacks. As long as it's not. As long as it doesn't violate what we say is outside First Amendment protection. I mean, as uncomfortable as certain First Amendment expression may be, and I may not be comfortable with a conversation with some of these protesters, but by God, I will defend their right to make me uncomfortable. That's what the First Amendment is all about. And that is exactly the type of speech in the marketplace of ideas that has to be protected. And that's what you're seeing from a judge like Judge Young now, the senior status judges, and we haven't gotten the ruling yet. And I will report back on it on Midas Touch Network. But I just think the irony of the fact that on Martin Luther King Jr. Weekend, that's going to be completely ignored and disrespected by the Trump administration, a Trump administration that continues to use the trappings of our patriotism, wrapping themselves in a flag they don't deserve. Wrapping themselves in the Constitution they don't deserve. I mean, still up on the website for the Department of Justice, once proud, now put out of its misery, our misery Civil rights division that had investigated the murder and the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. Of Medgar Evers. Of the three, you know, voting rights advocates down in Mississippi during the 19th, during the 1960s, they still have that proud history up on their website as if they're protecting it. And we know that they're not because they've destroyed the civil Rights division. They won't acknowledge what Martin Luther King Jr. And the Civil rights movement. And I have a dream meant I have a dream. It's to put us out of our misery and get rid of this administration and its Department of Justice. And I think I've got support for people like Judge Young. Now of course we've got two reactions from the Trump administration, one terrible and one horrible. We've got Tricia McLaughlin, the spokesperson for the Homeland Security, who said, you know, effectively, you know, the United States has no place for terrorist sympathizers. I don't think she was talking about the student activists. I think she was talking about a federal judge. And then you had another spokesperson for the White House say out loud a version of we've seen this before. A version of well, we got on one side the democratically elected President of the United States and on the other side a left wing activist judge sympathizer. I mean everybody's a sympathizer. Cuz they don't understand how our our three level system of government co equal branches of government work because they work in the executive branch. They don't care about the other two, but we do. And I'm glad you're here on Midas. Touch it on Legal af. I'll continue to follow this story. Help us continue to grow legal af the YouTube channel and come over and become a paid member. And our legal AF substack is growing as well with a special 25% discount all the way through the end of MLK junior weekend Monday at midnight. So until my next report, I'm Michael Popak.

[Legal AF Substack Host]

Can't get your fill of Legal af.

[Michael Popak]

Me neither.

[Legal AF Substack Host]

That's why we formed the Legal AF substack. Every time we mention something in a hot take, whether it's a court filing or a oral argument, come over to the substack. You'll find the court filing in the oral argument there, including a daily roundup that I do called Wait for it Morning af. What else? All the other contributors from Legal AOF.

[Michael Popak]

Are there as well.

[Legal AF Substack Host]

We got some new reporting, we got interviews, we got ad free versions of the podcast and hot takes where Legal AF on Substack. Come over now to free subscribe.

[Michael Popak]

How many discounts does USAA Auto Insurance offer? Too many to say here. Multi vehicle discount, Safe driver discount, New vehicle discount, Storage discount.

[Thrive Cosmetics Representative]

How many discounts will you stack up?

[Stiles Mackenzie]

Tap the banner or visit usaa.com autodiscounts restrictions apply.

[LifeLock Representative]

The new year brings new health goals and wealth goals. Protecting your identity is an important step. Your info is in endless places that could expose you to identity theft leading to lost funds. LifeLock monitors millions of data points per second. If your identity is stolen, our restoration specialists will fix it, guaranteed or your money back. Resolve to make identity, health and wealth part of your New year's goals with LifeLock, save up to 40% your first year. Visit LifeLock.com podcast Terms apply Weight Watchers.

[Stiles Mackenzie]

Now offers access to affordable GLP1s Weight Watchers has everything I need from weight loss medications to nutrition support and help.

[Thrive Cosmetics Representative]

With my side effects.

[Stiles Mackenzie]

With our program, our members are losing more weight with expert nutrition and side effect support.

[Michael Popak]

Weight watchers prescribing GLP1 medications. It's been life changing.

[Stiles Mackenzie]

Better results, expert support, lose more weight, make it last. Get started today for as low as $25 at weightw.

[T Mobile Representative]

Everyone deserves to be connected. That's why T Mobile and US Cellular are joining forces. Switch to T Mobile and save up to 20 versus Verizon by getting built in benefits they leave out. Check the math@t mobile.com switch and now T mobile is in US cellular stores.

[T Mobile/US Cellular Disclaimer Voice]

Savings versus Comparable Verizon plans plus the cost of optional benefits. Plan features in taxes and fees vary. Savings with three plus lines include third line free via monthly bill credits. Credit stop if you cancel any lines. Qualifying credit required.