Loading summary
Microsoft 365 Copilot Advertiser
The world moves fast. Your workday even faster. Pitching products, drafting reports, analyzing data Microsoft 365 Copilot is your AI assistant for work built into Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and other Microsoft 365 apps you use, helping you quickly write, analyze, create and summarize so you can cut through clutter and clear a path to your best work. Learn more@Microsoft.com M365 copilot this holiday Discover.
Kay Jewelers Advertiser
Meaningful gifts for everyone on your list at Kay. Not sure where to start? Our jewelry experts are here to help you find or create the perfect gift in store or online. Book your appointment today and unwrap Love this season only at Kay.
SoFi Personal Loan Advertiser
High interest debt is one of the toughest opponents you'll face unless you power up with a Sofi personal loan. A Sofi personal loan could repackage your bad debt into one low fixed rate monthly payment. It's even got super super speed since you could get the funds as soon as the same day you sign. Visit sofi.compower to learn more. That's sofi.com p o w E R Loans originated By SoFi Bank NA Member FDIC Terms and Conditions apply. NMLS 696891 oh hey.
Gift Wrapping Assistant
Welcome to gift wrapping.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
Whoa.
T-Mobile Salesperson
So we Saldana hey, can you wrap these please?
Legal Analyst / Host
Wow. IPhone 17s.
T-Mobile Salesperson
You splurged at T Mobile. You can get four iPhone 17s on them. The new center stage front camera is amazing for group selfies. It's the perfect gift for everyone.
Legal Analyst / Host
I'm the worst.
Gift Wrapping Assistant
I only got my mom a robe.
T-Mobile Salesperson
Well it's better than socks.
Legal Analyst / Host
So I have to trade in my old phone right?
T-Mobile Salesperson
No AT T Mobile. There's no trade ins needed when you switch. Keep your old phone or give it as a gift.
Gift Wrapping Assistant
Incredible.
T-Mobile Salesperson
In fact, wrap up my old phone too for my Aunt Rosa. Forget that. Aunt Liz will be jealous.
Gift Wrapping Assistant
Sounds like my family drama.
T-Mobile Salesperson
Oh I got it. I'll give it to my abuela. I'll take reindeer paper with hey where are you going?
Gift Wrapping Assistant
To T Mobile. The holidays are better. AT T Mobile get four iPhone 17s on us. No trade in needed when you switch plus four lines for just 25 bucks a line. And now T Mobile is available. Available in US cellular stores with 24 monthly bill credits and 4 eligible board inside essentials for well qualified customers. Bought on paperless taxi fees and 35 device connection charge credits and imbalance due if you pay off earlier. Cancel contact US Finance Agreement 256 gigabytes 830 required.
Kay Jewelers Advertiser
Visit t mobile.com Ever notice how ads always pop up at the worst moments when the killer's identity is about to be revealed during that perfect meditation flow. On Amazon Music, we believe in keeping you in the moment. That's why we've got millions of ad free podcast episodes, so you can stay completely immersed in every story, every reveal, every breath. Download the Amazon music app and start listening to your favorite podcasts. Ad free included with Prime.
Legal Analyst / Host
No, Judge Curry never bought what the Attorney General Pam Bondi was selling, never picked up what she was laying down, that she was able to ratify what Lindsey Halligan did as a U.S. attorney or a special attorney because she was able to look at a transcript that didn't exist. No, Judge Curry said, among other things and for other reasons, I'm going to dismiss the indictments of both James Comey and Letitia James. And I'm going to bounce Lindsey Halligan as having been improperly, unconstitutionally and illegally appointed in violation of the appointments clause, in violation of 28 USC section 546, and therefore everything that she did was what we call ultra vares or against the law and void bye bye indictments. Now, it means something different for James Comey, former FBI Director, than it means for Letitia James. Let me tell you up front what's gonna happen now besides the inevitable emergency appeal by Donald Trump, besides the inevitable, you know, you know, attempt to overturn what Judge Curry just did and to see if the United States Supreme Court decides to weigh in as well after the fourth Circuit. Besides, Judge Curry has declared that there is a vacancy in the Eastern District of Virginia, U.S. attorney's office. And step back. Pam Bondi and Donald Trump, you're not able to fill it because she has said in her order it can only be filled at present the vacancy by the district court judges of the Eastern District of Virginia. Now, that's one of the reasons they brought her up from South Carolina, because they didn't want her to have a conflict. So now the Eastern District of Virginia judges, if they're smart, and they are, they're gonna get together and they're going to appoint a U.S. attorney in lieu of Lindsey Halligan, which puts Judge Nachman off and Judge Walker in a weird position because even though the indictments have been dismissed, the criminal cases have not technically been closed yet. Nakmanoff has the case he's presiding over with James Comey and Judge Walker with Letitia James. I'm going to talk about that procedural twist in a minute, but you got the headline. Now, that was the ruling by Judge Curry not to Be confused by the ruling that we're waiting on by Judge Nachmanoff in the Comey case as to whether he's going to dismiss the indictment and close the criminal prosecution with prejudice once and for all because of an invalid. Because of sorry, vindictive prosecution by an abuse of power by Lindsey Allegan when she was acting as if she was the U.S. attorney when she is not. Now you know why Judge Curry kept calling Lindsey Halligan the indictment signer. The indictment signer or the government counsel never called her by her title. That's going to be decided by Nakmanoff sometime around between now, Thanksgiving or just after. And it all has a major implication for Comey because he's. His prosecution is out of time. The statute of limitations has run. Judge Curry has already ruled that Lindsey Halligan was invalidly appointed, so she was never able to obtain that indictment. So there was no indictment, defective or otherwise obtained within the statute of limitations of five years for a perjury charge against James Comey. And we're now almost two months after that. There's no time. You cannot bring new charges with a new grand jury and a new prosecutor, even if that one's validly appointed or confirmed because the statute of limitations on the perjury charge for James Comey has run. Letitia James is in a different boat. I'm glad you're here on Midas Touch Network for me to kind of give you this drill down. After you got the top line of the headline. I want to give you the more information. Right. Letitia James case is different. Letitia James was indicted for mortgage fraud. It's a bullshit case. We all know it. There were two grand juries. The head of the Major Crimes Unit, Liz Urie, was fired because she issued a memo that said you can't indict her. There's no mortgage fraud here, which is automatically reasonable doubt. You had a grand jury in Norfolk, Virginia that didn't indict you. Got a grand jury in Alexandria that did. It's a mess. But that's for another day because there's no statute of limitations issue. But at least we got rid of Lindsey Halligan, Donald Trump's hand chosen prosecutor. Right. Let me read to you from the pages that I think are the most powerful within Judge Curry's orders. There's actually two orders, but they're almost identical, except one is in the Comey case and one is in the Letitia James case. Let's go to page. Let's go to page 17. She's gone through one particular statute decides this. 28 USC section 546. She says it's clear on its face, the President or the Department of Justice gets one pick for an interim U.S. attorney. After that there's a split of. There's a split of power. President gets one pick. After that, he gets to keep going and try to get his confirmed nominee through the Senate, which he hasn't even put up anybody in the Eastern district of Virginia. There's nobody in the pipeline. But until then, the district court Judges pick the U.S. attorney. And they tried to do a series of interim U.S. attorneys. They had a U.S. attorney, she resigned on the day of the inauguration. Eric Siebert was picked by Pam Bondi, conservative Republican, but they fired him or forced him out cuz he refused to indict Comey and Letitia James. But that's. It's a single use ticket like at Disney. You don't get to come back the next day.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
So he's gone.
Legal Analyst / Host
So they try to do it again. Oh, another one. Lindsey Allegan. Another 120 days. Another120 days. Another120 days. And the judge says, no, you can't do that. You're doing an end run around the appointment clause. The appointment clause says you gotta, you get to nominate, but the Senate gets to confirm on advice of consent, you're a nominee. You can't do an end run around it. Go, you know, do a. Go in the back door and just keep appointing every 90 days somebody else. Oh, Lindsey Halligan didn't get it. Well, how is Lindsey Halligan even gonna get the U.S. attorney position? She, she hasn't even been put up for it. So the judge says, no, you can't do it that way. So you. She went through the history. She says on page 19, when an appointment violates the appointments clause from the jump, the actor has exercised power that she did not possess, citing to Justice Gorsuch and citing to Justice Thomas, an unconstitutionally appointed person, the government action taken by that erroneous erroneously claiming the mantle of executive power and thus has taken no authority at all. That's how she characterizes it. She says on page 20 of her order. In light of these principles, I conclude that all actions flowing from Ms. Halligan's defective appointment, including securing and signing Mr. Comey's indictment, constitute unlawful exercises of executive power. It must be set aside. There is simply no alternative course to cure the unconstitutional problem. She says on page 21, after citing a. A decision by the Office of Legal Counsel back in the Reagan days, led by Sam Alito on the Supreme Court siding with her position. She said that the that her appointment Halligan being appointed by Pam Bondi was not a clerical error and she can't use another statute to fix her problem. Now I got a secret. I'm obsessed with my Lola blanket.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
From the moment I pulled it out of the box, I could tell that this wasn't your average throw. The faux fur is unbelievably soft, like luxury level soft and it just makes my space feel calm, inviting and put together. Even here in Miami. I love wrapping up with it at the end of a day, watching a show with my family, answering emails or just relaxing. It's become part of my daily wind down ritual. Honestly, I'm already thinking about replacing every other blanket I own with a Lola. It's no surprise. Lola is the world's number one blanket. Made with ultra soft vegan faux fur and a signature four way stretch, it's machine washable, no pilling, no shedding, and it stays flawless after every wash. It's the perfect gift. Personal, beautiful and something people actually use every day. Give the gift of softness this holiday season with Lola Blankets. For a limited time, our listeners are getting a huge 40% off their entire order at Lola Blankets.com by using code.
Legal Analyst / Host
LEGAL AF at checkout.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
Just head to lolablankets.com and use code LEGALAF for 40% off. After you purchase, they'll ask you where.
Legal Analyst / Host
You heard about them.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
Please support our show and tell them.
Legal Analyst / Host
That we sent you, she says on page 25 I've already concluded that Ms. Halligan's original appointment was invalid and that the attorney's attempt to retroactively bestow special attorney status on her was also ineffective. She could not have authorized Ms. Halligan Bondi, who is not an attorney for the government. At the time. She wasn't even an attorney for the government to present Mr. Comey's indictment to the grand jury. You can't retroactively say somebody invalid is now valid, she said. It would mean if the if the implications of a contrary conclusion are extraordinary, it would mean the government would send any private citizen off the street. That's what Lindsey Halligan's been reduced to. A private citizen off the street who's not an attorney to secure an indictment as long as the Attorney General gives her approval after the fact that she also concludes that the position is open. There is no U.S. attorney. They should now shut off her badge and her security badge at the door of the Department of Justice and not let her in. There is a vacancy and that vacancy can only be filled by the district court Judges Until a U.S. attorney is nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate under 28 USC section 541. It is so ordered. Cameron McGowan Curry, senior United States District Judge, she, she signed it from her chambers in Columbia, South Carolina, November 24, 2025. What's going to happen next? It's going to happen next. Trump's going to take a Department of justice, is going to take an emergence besides the social media post. Oh, a liberal crazy judge in South Carolina who wasn't elected by a popular vote of the people just, you know, ruled against our ability to the President's ability to appoint a U.S. attorney. Okay, then enough of that. Then they'll file an emergency application to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals that sits over Virginia. I think that gets denied 3,02 to 1. Then they'll take an emergency shadow docket appeal. I think it goes through Chief Justice Roberts up to the United States Supreme Court. And then, you know, we're on the clock with the Supreme Court at that point. Are they gonna do an administrative stay for a couple of days while they do some briefing schedule like they just did about the maps, the congressional maps? Probably, or they just reject it because they think it's very clear that under 5:46, the president doesn't have that power. And seeing unlike other times when the Supreme Court sided with Donald Trump, we're not talking about foreign affairs, we're not talking about taxes and tariffs, we're not talking about commander in chief powers. We're talking about a statute and the separation of powers related to that. Now, could they argue that that statute passed by Congress, which has been used for the last 30 years, 40 years, is somehow a violation of the separation of powers because it lets the judicial branch pick an executive branch officer? Maybe, maybe. And we'll see. But that's what's going to happen next. We're going to see a major, a major crisis show up again at the doorstep of the United States Supreme Court. This time it'll go through a Chief Justice Roberts. So until my next report here and on Legal AF, the YouTube channel on this fast breaking story, there's so much that's going to happen over the next 72 hours, I assure you. Judge Nachmanoff is trying to decide whether the indictment should be dismissed for a vindictive prosecution in the Comey case. Judge Walker, the same thing in the Letitia James case. Judge Nakmanoff already said he's gonna make a ruling soon on that. There's also a Motion pending before Judge Nakhmedoff to get rid of the indictment because of the grand jury defects. The way that Lindsey Halligan, who is obviously illegally appointed, also screwed up her presentation and violated Comey's Fourth Amendment, fifth Amendment and Sixth Amendment rights. Question is, will Nakhmedoff say it's now moot because this, there's already been a prior ruling that the Lindsey Halligan was improperly appointed and everything that flowed from her appointment is invalid. I think he goes in that direction. So we got that going on.
Lola Blankets Advertiser
Right.
Legal Analyst / Host
And I think hopefully I'll be able to report soon that the district court judges get together and they appoint somebody and get a new U.S. attorney. And hopefully that U.S. attorney has some credibility, has some ethics, has some professionalism and doesn't try to indict Letitia James and James Comey again. I think until he ended this way. My opinion, my professional opinion is that James Comey's indictment and criminal case is closed, that he's out of time, that the Department of Justice is out of time on the statute of limitations on perjury. And the fact that there was an invalid indictment does not stop the clock. It doesn't let them fix their problem with a new, a new prosecutor and a new grand jury. Letitia James, though, I think if they get another, another MAGA prosecutor in there and it's getting harder and harder for Donald Trump to make anything like that happen with his slip on power, you know, slipping from his grip, then they might be able to re indict her on mortgage fraud. But there's already bad evidence for the Department of Justice and great evidence for Letitia James about a prior grand jury in Norfolk, Virginia that wouldn't indict her and a major career prosecutor head of the Major Crimes Division who said she shouldn't be prosecuted, which is going to be part of the presentation to the jury. Reasonable doubt, anyone? I'm glad you're here. Hit the Free subscribe button on Midas Touch. Do the same thing on Legal af. I'll see you at my next report to update you on this fast moving story. Can't get your fill of Legal af? Me neither. That's why we formed the Legal AF substack. Every time we mention something in a hot take, whether it's a court filing or a oral argument, come over to the substack. You'll find the court filing and the oral argument there, including a daily roundup that I do call. Wait for it. Morning af. What else? All the other contributors from Legal AF are there as well. We got some new reporting, we got interviews, we got ad free versions of the podcast and hot takes where legal AF on substack. Come over now to free subscribe.
Date: November 24, 2025
Host: Ben Meiselas (MeidasTouch founder & civil rights lawyer)
This episode delivers an in-depth analysis of a stunning legal defeat for Donald Trump’s attempts to prosecute key Democratic figures—James Comey and Letitia James—via controversial federal indictments. Host Ben Meiselas breaks down a landmark ruling by Judge Cameron McGowan Curry, who found that Trump’s handpicked special prosecutor, Lindsey Halligan, was illegally and unconstitutionally appointed, invalidating all her actions—including the high-profile indictments. The discussion also explores the broader implications for the Department of Justice, the potential for appeals, and next steps for the cases and the individuals involved.
Quote (Ben Meiselas, 02:49):
“Judge Curry has declared that there is a vacancy in the Eastern District of Virginia, U.S. attorney's office. And step back. Pam Bondi and Donald Trump, you're not able to fill it because she has said in her order it can only be filled...by the district court judges.”
Quote (Ben Meiselas, 08:24):
“They try to do it again. Oh, another one. Lindsey Halligan. Another 120 days. Another 120 days...The judge says, no, you can't do that. You're doing an end run around the appointment clause.”
Quote (Ben Meiselas, reading Judge Curry, 09:43):
“When an appointment violates the appointments clause from the jump, the actor has exercised power that she did not possess…an unconstitutionally appointed person...has taken no authority at all.”
Quote (Ben Meiselas, reading Judge Curry, 11:35):
“There is a vacancy and that vacancy can only be filled by the district court Judges until a U.S. attorney is nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate...It is so ordered.”
Quote (Ben Meiselas, 15:37):
"My professional opinion is that James Comey's indictment and criminal case is closed, that he's out of time, that the Department of Justice is out of time on the statute of limitations for perjury. And the fact that there was an invalid indictment does not stop the clock.”
Quote (Ben Meiselas, 13:12):
“They're going to file an emergency application to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals...then they'll take an emergency shadow docket appeal...Are they gonna do an administrative stay?...Probably, or they just reject it because they think it's very clear that under §546, the president doesn't have that power.”
On the larger meaning of the ruling:
(Ben Meiselas, 09:43)
“When an appointment violates the appointments clause from the jump, the actor has exercised power that she did not possess...has taken no authority at all.”
On the naked abuse of the appointment process:
(Ben Meiselas, 08:24)
“You can’t do an end run around it...Just keep appointing every 90 days somebody else.”
On DOJ’s limitations:
(Ben Meiselas, 15:37)
“My professional opinion is that James Comey's indictment and criminal case is closed...the fact that there was an invalid indictment does not stop the clock.”
On the future for Letitia James:
(Ben Meiselas, 15:57)
“If they get another MAGA prosecutor in there…it’s getting harder and harder for Donald Trump to make anything like that happen with his slip on power, you know, slipping from his grip…”
This episode chronicles a major legal collapse for Donald Trump’s efforts to prosecute political adversaries, with Judge Curry’s powerful ruling nullifying actions by an improperly appointed U.S. attorney. The result is almost-certain vindication for James Comey, while Letitia James still faces some—but diminished—legal risk. Ben Meiselas masterfully unpacks the weeds of appointment law, the strategic blunders by Trump’s DOJ, and what comes next, offering a crucial and clear update at the intersection of law and politics.