Legal AF by MeidasTouch – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Trump Pick Caught in Unearthed Footage That Could Sink Plan
Air Date: August 17, 2025
Host: Michael Popok (on behalf of MeidasTouch Network)

Episode Overview

This episode of Legal AF is a hard-hitting, in-depth analysis of the Trump Administration's controversial nominee for head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), E.J. Antoni. The show explores the implications of Antoni's lack of credentials, his deep partisan ties, and—crucially—his previously unearthed participation in the January 6th Capitol insurrection. The episode offers detailed insights into the dangers posed by installing unqualified, partisan actors in key government statistical agencies, and examines the broader efforts to politicize and manipulate official economic data.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Shocking Finding: E.J. Antoni Linked to Jan 6 Insurrection

• Main Point: NBC News discovered unearthed footage showing E.J. Antoni, Trump's pick for BLS, participating in the January 6th Capitol attack.

• Antoni wasn’t charged, but is easily identifiable, described as “a tall, lanky fellow that’s prone to wearing three-piece suits.”

• Quote:

  "NBC News has found EJ Antoni, insurrectionist roaming the grounds during that beautiful non-violent attack on our Capitol."
  (Michael Popok, 02:49)

• Implication: Even if not criminally charged, Antoni's mere presence and participation call into question his fitness to head a supposedly nonpartisan, gold-standard federal statistical bureau.

2. Antoni’s Lack of Qualifications & Partisan Agenda

• Main Point: Antoni is described as blatantly unqualified by both conservative economists and major business media (e.g., the Wall Street Journal).

• Antoni’s credentials: Recently obtained degree and PhD, former “Chief Economist” for Heritage Foundation and a Texas “freedom foundation” he may have invented himself.

• Paper trail shows no experience in labor statistics, no background in statistics or relevant labor economics.

• Tone: Scathing; Popok lampoons Antoni’s resume and partisan television appearances.

• Quote:

  "He's just a drive-by TV economist who puts on a three-piece suit and a big fat tie because he's trying to look older than he really is."
  (Michael Popok, 05:00)

• Comparison to Predecessor: Previous BLS head was highly credentialed, bipartisan, and respected across political lines.

• Quote:

  "Everybody that's ever had that role has been bipartisan, has been nonpartisan. E.J. Antoni just went on Fox News…said…that William Beach, who had been the commissioner that Trump had appointed, had been fired by a Joe Biden. And that's false. His term expired."
  (Michael Popok, 06:35)

3. Impact on BLS and Data Integrity

• Main Point: The BLS job reports are foundational for government, financial markets, and the global economy. The Trump team intends to “cook the books” by installing political loyalists.

• Quote:

  "There's a reason we don't trust the numbers coming out of the Chinese government—because they're not reliable. And the same thing is going to happen with Antoni running the Bureau of Labor Statistics."
  (Michael Popok, 08:05)

• Internal resistance: Strong suggestion that the agency’s 2,000 career economists will not simply go along with partisan directives.

4. Ongoing MAGA Attacks on Economic Data & Federal Agencies

• Main Point: Broader strategy to discredit, defund, or control federal statistical agencies.

• Popok details how the Department of Commerce leadership moved to change economic measurement methodologies, defunded agencies, and shuttered advisory committees.

• Quote:

  "Commerce Department…defunded all of the economic statistical modeling agencies…put a Gone fishing sign on the door of an advisory committee that supervised all of these statistical agencies…as of February 28th."
  (Michael Popok, 10:50)

• Contextualizes the current efforts as a public, open attempt to manipulate official statistics for political gain.

5. Economic Consequences: Winners and Losers

• Main Point: Examines recent Congressional Budget Office data showing the effect of Trump-era policies:
  • Bottom 10% of Americans: lose $1,200/household under Trump cuts to Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security.
  • Top 10%: gain $14,000/household via tax cuts.
• Argument: Disguising these trends by manipulating statistics would further disadvantage vulnerable populations.

6. Explainer: What the Jobs Report Actually Is

• Main Point: Popok demystifies the jobs report, countering Trump claims about the report's accuracy or “rigging”.

• Key facts:

  • Collected by voluntary surveys (households and businesses).
  • Only ~43-45% response rate since COVID.
  • Data are refined and updated with better returns and over time.
  • Every administration uses the same methodology; it’s not a census or headcount.

• Quote:

  "The job report is a compilation of voluntary surveys...it is a sample, it is like a poll. I think Donald Trump believes that the job report is actually like a census."
  (Michael Popok, 14:20)

• Warning: Attempts to “change the model” or force compliance would be unprecedented and dangerous.

7. The Dangers of Politicizing Economic Data

• Main Point: Drawing analogies to authoritarian states (China, Russia, North Korea), Popok warns that control of economic data by the executive branch enables disastrous “pump-and-dump” tactics and post-election crashes.
• Quote:

  "They cook the books. They lower their interest rates on Federal Reserve to increase spending in order to pump up artificially the economy...now the elections happen, midterms happen, boom, we crash."
  (Michael Popok, 16:10)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Antoni’s lack of experience:

  "The guy just got his college degree about eight or nine years ago. He just got his PhD like four years ago...he’s not that kind of economist."
  (Michael Popok, 05:25)

• On the Trump Administration’s approach to statistics:

  "We're going to back out the government's involvement in the economy. I like...What a pinhead. Seriously."
  (Michael Popok, 10:34)

• On the integrity of data:

  "There's a reason we don't want the executive branch in charge—the presidency in charge—of the Federal Reserve, the central bank and its numbers because they'll cook the books for their own election success."
  (Michael Popok, 15:53)

Important Timestamps

• 02:09 – Introduction to the Antoni controversy and Jan 6 footage
• 05:00 – Detailed critique of Antoni’s resume and non-qualifications
• 08:05 – On the dangers of having a partisan loyalist at BLS
• 10:50 – Trump administration’s history of defunding/adjusting government data agencies
• 14:20 – Explanation of how the jobs report is actually compiled
• 16:10 – Comparison to authoritarian economic manipulations

Conclusion

This episode provides a rigorous, sometimes acerbic critique of Trump’s attempt to place E.J. Antoni—a partisan, underqualified loyalist implicated in the January 6th events—at the helm of the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The analysis connects this maneuver to a larger pattern of attempts to control, suppress, or falsify crucial economic data for political advantage. Listeners come away with both a specific understanding of the Antoni scandal and a broader warning: politicizing statistical agencies is corrosive to the core functioning of a free democracy.

For more Legal AF analysis, follow their podcast feed and Substack for court filings, daily roundups, and ad-free reporting.