Podcast Summary: "Trump Screws Himself as He Picks Fight with Wrong Judge"
Legal AF by MeidasTouch
Release Date: March 21, 2025

Introduction

In the March 21, 2025 episode of Legal AF by MeidasTouch, hosts Ben Meiselas, Michael Popok, and Karen Friedman Agnifilo delve into the contentious interactions between former President Donald Trump and the federal judiciary. The episode, titled "Trump Screws Himself as He Picks Fight with Wrong Judge," offers a critical analysis of Trump's recent public attacks on judges, particularly focusing on Judge Chief Judge Boasberg of the D.C. Circuit Court. The discussion highlights the implications of these confrontations on the independence of the judiciary and the broader constitutional crisis emerging from these actions.

Trump's Attack on the Judiciary

Michael Popok initiates the conversation by addressing the prevalent theme of forced resignations within Trump's administration, emphasizing the recent and reckless attacks on the judiciary.

• Popok (01:18): "Resignations and people being forced to resign or asked to resign are in the common parlance these days. It's in the water, it's in the air."

He criticizes Carolyn Levette, Trump's press secretary, for her aggressive rhetoric against Judge Boasberg, labeling her as unqualified and unfit to comment on legal matters.

• Popok (01:35): "Carolyn Levette... took to her bully pulpit today during a press conference to attack by name a Republican appointed judge, Judge Chief Judge Boasberg of the D.C. Circuit Court."

Popok underscores Trump's apparent shift in strategy, suggesting that while Trump may be reluctant to continue his personal assaults on judges, he permits his administration officials to carry out these attacks.

• Popok (02:15): "Donald Trump believes that he may not be able to continue to attack judges, but he's going to let those in his administration do it."

Carolyn Levette's Press Conference and Attack on Judge Boasberg

The episode provides a detailed account of the press conference where Carolyn Levette directly attacked Judge Boasberg, questioning his integrity and decisions.

• Levette (05:30): "We will continue with the mass deportations... This judge cannot, does not have that authority. It is an egregious abuse of the bench."

Popok challenges Levette's portrayal of Boasberg, highlighting the judge's bipartisan appointments and moderate reputation.

• Popok (05:40): "Boasberg was originally appointed by George W. Bush and then elevated by Barack Obama. He’s a moderate, middle-of-the-road Democrat."

Levette attempts to discredit Boasberg by attributing his decisions to partisan bias, which Popok refutes by pointing out Boasberg's established reputation for moderation.

• Levette (06:00): "Judge Boasberg is a Democrat activist... his wife has donated more than $10,000 to Democrats."

• Popok (06:15): "67% of all of the injunctions in this century have come against which President? Donald J. Trump... 92% of those have been from Democrat appointed judges."

Implications for the Judiciary and Constitutional Crisis

Popok delves into the broader ramifications of these attacks, suggesting that Trump's actions are precipitating a constitutional crisis by undermining the judiciary's independence.

• Popok (08:23): "This goes beyond them drawing a line in the sand to try to battle the federal judges into submission. We've now reached a whole new level, a whole new turning point of a constitutional crisis created by Donald Trump and his administration."

He expresses concern over Chief Justice John Roberts' response to these attacks and the potential for further erosion of judicial independence.

• Popok (10:17): "John Roberts, in his State of the Judiciary address, just this year, said that one of the greatest threats was the attacks on the judiciary... And now you've got Carolyn Levette deciding to do exactly that."

Popok underscores the personal toll these attacks may be taking on Chief Justice Roberts and other members of the judiciary, likening their intertwined struggles to a failing marriage.

• Popok (12:00): "This has been a terrible two weeks for John Roberts and Trump. You'd send them to marriage counseling if they were a married couple."

He warns of the potential long-term consequences, including increased protection measures for judges and heightened tensions between the executive branch and the judiciary.

• Popok (13:50): "We've now reached a whole new level... What is Chief Justice Roberts going to do next? And what is Kavanaugh going to do next?"

Conclusion: The Path Forward

In wrapping up the discussion, Popok stresses the necessity for the Supreme Court and judiciary members to uphold their independence against political pressures. He cautions that continued attacks may force the judicial branch to take more drastic measures to protect its integrity.

• Popok (14:12): "We're going to follow everything that comes out of Carolyn Levette's mouth and we're going to shove it right back at her in court filings... We're going to follow it here on the Midas Touch network and on Legal AF."

He reiterates the importance of maintaining a clear separation between the branches of government to prevent further constitutional turmoil.

• Popok (14:57): "This goes beyond them drawing a line in the sand... We're going to follow everything that comes out of Carolyn Levette's mouth."

Notable Quotes

1. Michael Popok (01:35): "Carolyn Levette... took to her bully pulpit today during a press conference to attack by name a Republican appointed judge, Judge Chief Judge Boasberg of the D.C. Circuit Court."

2. Carolyn Levette (05:30): "Judge Boasberg is a Democrat activist... his wife has donated more than $10,000 to Democrats."

3. Michael Popok (06:15): "67% of all of the injunctions in this century have come against which President? Donald J. Trump... 92% of those have been from Democrat appointed judges."

4. Michael Popok (10:17): "John Roberts, in his State of the Judiciary address, just this year, said that one of the greatest threats was the attacks on the judiciary."

5. Michael Popok (14:12): "We're going to follow everything that comes out of Carolyn Levette's mouth and we're going to shove it right back at her in court filings."

Final Thoughts

The episode "Trump Screws Himself as He Picks Fight with Wrong Judge" offers a critical examination of the escalating conflict between Donald Trump and the federal judiciary. Through incisive analysis and strong rhetoric, Legal AF underscores the potential dangers posed by political interference in judicial matters. The hosts advocate for the preservation of judicial independence as a cornerstone of the American legal system, warning of the precarious path the nation treads as these tensions intensify.

Listeners are left contemplating the long-term effects of such political maneuvers on the integrity of the judiciary and the balance of power within the U.S. government.

Connect with Legal AF:

For those interested in staying updated on the intersection of law and politics, Legal AF is available on YouTube at Legal AFMTN. Subscribe for more in-depth analyses and discussions on critical legal developments.