Letters from an American – January 5, 2026

Host: Heather Cox Richardson
Episode Theme:
Reflections on the fifth anniversary of the January 6th attack on the U.S. Capitol—tracing the historical, political, and legal forces leading to that day, reviewing its aftermath, and contemplating the meaning of recent developments for American democracy in 2026.

Main Theme and Purpose

Heather Cox Richardson uses the five-year anniversary of the January 6, 2021, Capitol insurrection to examine the ideological currents, historical trends, and political developments that led to that pivotal moment. She connects it to patterns of minority rule and elite power in American history and reflects on their contemporary manifestation—particularly in Trump’s return to power and the ongoing erosion of democratic norms.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Roots of January 6th

• Comparison to the Civil War Era (00:07–02:25):
  Richardson draws parallels between January 6, 2021, and 1861, arguing that the insurrectionists sought minority rule, akin to Confederates trying to break up the U.S. for elite white men’s benefit.

  • Quote: “In fact, it was not 1776, but 1861, the year insurrectionists who had tried to overthrow the government in order to establish minority rule, tried to break the U.S.” (00:47)
  • The presence of Confederate battle flags and the rhetoric of Republican leaders are portrayed as not accidental.

• Republican Shift Toward Anti-Government Individualism (01:15–03:15):
  Tracing back to the 1980s, Richardson notes the party's growing antagonism toward federal power, social safety nets, and civil rights—framing federal government action as existential threats to American individualism.

Election Manipulation Narratives and Paramilitary Violence

• Voter Fraud Myths and Paramilitary Support (03:16–05:23):
  As demographic changes threatened Republican power, allegations of Democratic “cheating” grew, often tied to racially-coded language and paranoia about “undeserving” Americans.
  • Example: The 2014 standoff over Cliven Bundy's grazing fees, hailed as patriotism by Republican Senator Dean Heller.
  • The incitement of individual men and paramilitary groups to “reclaim” America becomes a party undercurrent.

The Trump Ascendancy and the Breakdown of Oversight

• Trump’s Rise & GOP Acquiescence (05:24–08:10):
  Despite initial hesitance, GOP leaders embraced Trump for his appeal to disaffected voters, the promise of sweeping tax cuts, and the appointment of conservative judges—including three Supreme Court justices.

  • “But the idea that Trump could be kept in check fell apart in September 2019, when it appeared he was trying to rig the 2020 election.” (07:05)

• Ukraine Scandal and GOP Enabling (08:11–09:49):
  Trump’s 2019 attempt to coerce President Zelensky for political dirt on Biden is highlighted as a flagrant abuse of power—with Richardson noting, “Republicans in 1974 had turned against President Richard Nixon for far less.” (08:35)
  Nevertheless, almost all Republican senators remained loyal, seeing the battle as about maintaining Senate control rather than addressing presidential wrongdoing.

The 2020 Election and January 6

• Pre-Election Planning and Rhetoric (09:50–13:40):
  Steve Bannon’s foresight on contesting late-counted ballots and declaring victory preemptively is cited:

  • Quote: “He’s going to declare himself a winner ... After then, Trump never has to go to a voter again. He’s going to say, f you. How about that?” (11:16)

  Trump’s messaging after losing key states on election night set the stage for post-election chaos.

• Legal and Political Maneuvers (13:41–17:15):
  Trump’s campaign pursued baseless litigation and pressured officials, such as the infamous request to Georgia’s Secretary of State:

  • Quote: “find 11,780 votes, which is one more than we have to win the state of Georgia.” (14:37) The plot to submit fake electors in several battleground states is detailed, aiming to throw the election to the GOP-controlled House.

Incitement and the Capitol Attack

• Trump’s Rhetoric at the Ellipse and Consequences (17:16–19:05):
  Trump’s encouragement of the crowd to “fight like hell,” with explicit knowledge many were armed, and to “march to the Capitol,” is recounted verbatim:

  • Quote: “You’ll never take back our country with weakness. You have to show strength and you have to be strong.” (17:44) As violence erupted, Trump “did nothing for more than three hours,” delaying intervention until the outcome was apparent.

• Aftermath—Impeachment and Accountability (19:06–21:22):
  Trump’s tepid video response and tweet—“We love you. You’re very special”—is quoted as evidence of continued support for insurrectionists. During impeachment, only a small minority of Republicans in Congress voted to convict:

  • Quote (McConnell): “There is no question that President Trump is practically and morally responsible for provoking the events of that day, but said he must answer for his actions in court.” (20:35)

Judicial Impunity and Erosion of Norms

• Legal Proceedings and Supreme Court Ruling (21:23–23:00):
  Special counsel Jack Smith’s investigation and Trump’s argument for presidential immunity culminate in a Supreme Court decision on July 1, 2024:
  • Quote: “Presidents have absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for crimes committed as part of the official acts at the core of presidential powers, Trump himself had appointed three of the justices in the majority.” (22:50) The belated and narrow new indictment is rendered moot when Trump is re-elected, as DOJ custom discourages indictments of a sitting president.

Trump’s Second Term—A New Rubicon

• Unchecked Power and Democratic Backsliding (23:01–25:40):
  As of this episode in early 2026, Trump is depicted as acting with impunity:

  • Disregarding congressional laws like the Impoundment Control Act
  • Deploying troops in Democratic-led cities
  • Stonewalling on transparency (the “Epstein files”)
  • Seizing people off the streets, prosecuting enemies, and assuming unilateral war powers
  • Quote (Stephen Miller, 24:40): “We live in a world in the real world, Jake, that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power... These are the iron laws of the world since the beginning of time.”

  Richardson contrasts this worldview with the “rules-based international order” and American traditions of checks and balances.

Historical Framing—1863 and Lincoln’s Charge

• Evocation of Lincoln and the Meaning of Democracy (25:41–26:36):
  Richardson recalls Abraham Lincoln’s 1863 Gettysburg address as a call to remember those who sacrificed for a “nation conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal” and closes with Lincoln’s injunction:
  • Quote (Lincoln): “...that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” (26:23)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments With Timestamps

• “It was no accident that the rioters carried a Confederate battle flag.” (01:23)
• “Republicans pushed the idea that the country's problems came from greedy minorities and women who wanted to work outside the home.” (02:15)
• “After then, Trump never has to go to a voter again. He’s going to say, f you. How about that? Because he's done his last election.” (11:27, paraphrasing Steve Bannon)
• “We fight like hell. And if you don’t fight like hell, you’re not going to have a country anymore.” (18:10, quoting Trump)
• “Remember this day forever.” (19:29, quoting Trump’s tweet after the Capitol attack)
• “Presidents have absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for crimes committed as part of the official acts at the core of presidential powers…” (22:50, summarizing the Supreme Court ruling)
• “We live in a world…that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power.” (24:40, Stephen Miller)
• “That government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” (26:23, quoting Lincoln)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Opening and framing historical context – 00:07–03:15
• Rise of right-wing antigovernment sentiment – 03:16–05:23
• Trump’s rise, the GOP, and courts – 05:24–09:49
• Election 2020, plotting to overturn – 13:41–17:15
• January 6th rally and insurrection – 17:16–19:05
• Aftermath, impeachment, and legal impunity – 19:06–23:00
• Second Trump term authoritarian actions – 23:01–25:40
• Lincoln and the legacy of democracy – 25:41–end

Conclusion: Tone and Closing Message

Richardson’s narrative is urgent, analytical, and somber, warning listeners that the events of January 6, 2021, were not merely a fluke, but rooted in long-standing tensions over power and democracy. Her citation of Lincoln’s words frames the present crisis as a test of the nation’s commitment to government “of the people, by the people, for the people.”

For more episodes or to read the newsletter, visit heathercoxrichardson.substack.com.