Lore Legends 68: Erupt

Host: Aaron Mahnke
Date: December 8, 2025

Overview

This episode of Lore explores humanity’s encounters with volcanoes—how these cataclysmic forces have shaped human history, folklore, and belief. Aaron Mahnke weaves together modern tragedy, ancient legend, and dark humor to show that no matter our technological advancements, nature—and sometimes our own sense of doom—remains untamable.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Nature’s Wrath: Why We’re Still Powerless

[01:43]

• Mahnke opens by describing the 2023 North Carolina hurricane, highlighting how even today, modern civilization is vulnerable to extreme weather. This sets the stage for his exploration of volcano legends as manifestations of nature’s ultimate power over humans.
• Quote:

  “Despite all our advances, we have nothing in our arsenal to fight cataclysmic weather events. All we can do is try to weather the storm.” (Aaron Mahnke, 02:54)

2. The White Island Tragedy

[03:54]

• Mahnke recounts the 2019 eruption on New Zealand’s White Island, where 22 of 47 people were killed.
• Emphasizes that volcanoes, like quicksand, become “forgotten” threats until catastrophe strikes.
• Quote:

  “It might be easy to think that volcanoes are ancient history... but the Earth is still spinning and tectonic plates are still shifting. As long as those two things continue, volcanoes will always be erupting.” (05:55)

3. Volcanoes as Moral and Divine Punishment

[06:30]

• Across cultures and centuries, volcanoes have symbolized retribution or divine will:
  • Aztecs: Volcano Momo Tombo as resistance against conquistadors.
  • New Zealand: The shaman Nagatoro and fire demons punishing broken vows.
  • Italy: Mount Vesuvius “appeased” via religious relic parades.
  • Hawaii: King Kamehameha offers his own hair to halt Mount Hualalai’s eruption.
• Communities developed rituals to appease or communicate with volcanoes, indicating the deep intertwinement of natural forces with spiritual beliefs.

4. Volcanoes as Messengers and Creators

[09:41]

• Eruptions interpreted by clergy as warnings or punishment from God, e.g., Mount St. Helens (1980), Mount Habakabak (Philippines, 1951).
• Not all views are negative:
  • Tanzania’s Maasai: Ol Donyo Lengai’s eruption celebrated as a blessing (new mothers pour milk on the earth).
  • Hawaii: Goddess Pele’s eruptions seen as creation (“the lava represents the blood leaving her body... to form the building blocks of life,” 11:03).
  • Indigenous and Pacific worldviews often see volcanoes as both destroyers and creators.
• Quote:

  “It’s the cycle of death and rebirth playing out again and again.” (11:16)

5. The Bridge of the Gods (Puyallup Creation Myth)

[12:14]

• Mahnke tells the myth of Lewit, the “Lady of Fire,” whose love triangle with two gods sparks destruction and transformation.
• The aftermath: the three lovers become the Cascade Mountains (Mount Hood, Adams, and St. Helens).
• Myths explain landscape features as remnants of divine events, connecting emotional drama to geological phenomena.

6. The Tragedy of Mount Tarawera

[14:55]

• The 1886 eruption destroyed the famed pink and white terraces—once called the “eighth wonder of the world”—and devastated Maori communities.
• Eleven days before, tourists witnessed a phantom canoe, a well-known Maori omen of disaster, believed to carry souls to the volcano.
  • Their guide Sophia conceals her unease but later shares with her tribe’s spiritual leader.
• Tehoto, the tribe’s chief, interprets the eruption as punishment for selling out to tourists and betraying sacred grounds.
• The legend underscores how modern actions (tourism) are woven into ancient understandings of guilt and divine justice.

7. Tehoto: The Ancient Wizard Who Defied Death

[20:45]

• Local spiritual leader Tehoto is both revered and seen as curmudgeonly.
• According to legend, he had cursed a being imprisoned in Mount Tarawera—possibly triggering the eruption as vengeance against him.
• Tehoto is buried alive in the landslide but is found alive days later (“he was shouting at them to go away and leave him alone,” 22:28), surviving only to willingly die soon after.
• Quote:

  “All Tehoto really wanted, it seems, was to be in control. And honestly, I can’t blame him.” (23:46)

Featured Folklore: Katla, the Icelandic Witch and Her Volcano

[29:40]

• The episode’s last “explosive” tale is that of Katla, a ruthless Icelandic monastery caretaker and suspected witch.
• Katla possesses bewitched pants that grant endless energy. A shepherd named Barai steals them; Katla murders him in rage and hides his body in a skyr cistern.
• Fearing discovery, she flees and leaps into a glacier crevice—immediately, the volcano above erupts, destroying the monastery and removing evidence of her crime.
  • The volcano is named “Katla”; since then, it’s erupted regularly.
• The story suggests that powerful women, dark secrets, and the landscape are forever linked in Icelandic myth.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “For a lot of us, volcanoes probably fall into the same category as quicksand, something that you learned about as a child and that you thought would be a much bigger problem in your than it really is.” (05:12)
• “They had no way of knowing that the phantom canoe was trying to warn them about a volcano instead of an oncoming war.” (18:15)
• “With a snap of his fingers, he destroyed the bridge. And the fire fell into the river below, making the water boil.” (12:54 - Bridge of the Gods myth)
• “Her favorite belonging, by the way, was a pair of bewitched pants that gave the wearer a never ending supply of energy. I would very much like that pair of pants.” (30:15)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 01:43 – Opening: The limits of technological advancement against nature
• 03:54 – The 2019 White Island tragedy
• 06:30 – Volcanoes as divine retribution in multiple cultures
• 09:41 – Divine messengers and creative volcano myths
• 12:14 – The Bridge of the Gods creation story
• 14:55 – The eruption of Mount Tarawera and the omen of the phantom canoe
• 20:45 – The fate and legend of Tehoto, Maori wizard
• 29:40 – The tale of Katla, Icelandic witch and namesake volcano

Conclusion

Aaron Mahnke closes on the persistent theme: humanity’s urge to control nature is thwarted by deep, elemental forces—sometimes personified as gods, witches, or omens, but always present. Through folklore and history alike, volcanoes remain reminders of our powerlessness and humility before the earth.

For full transcripts, supporting materials, or to listen ad-free, visit lorepodcast.com