Loading summary
Aaron Manke
This episode of Lore is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Fiscally responsible financial geniuses.
Aaron Manke
Monetary magicians.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
These are things people say about drivers.
Aaron Manke
Who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.
Unknown
It's better over here.
ATT customers switching to T Mobile has never been easier. We'll pay off your existing phone and give you a new one free. All on America's largest 5G network. Visit t mobile.com CarrierFreedom to switch today.
Pay off up to $650 via virtual prepaid MasterCard in 15 days. Free phone up to $830 via 24 monthly bill credits plus tax qualifying port and trade in service on go 5G next and credit required. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance and required finance agreement is due.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
First came the Then the fever.
Aaron Manke
The boy struggled for air, and each breath was like a knife to the chest. After a visit from the doctor, there was no doubt it was pneumonia. And finally, on one icy Chicago Day.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In 1920, Robert Ruckheim passed away.
Aaron Manke
He was only seven years old. And yet his story wasn't over. Because, as it turns out, little Robert was destined for a strange sort of immortality. You see, Robert's grandfather, Frederick Ruckheim, was something of an entrepreneur, and in 1893, Frederick and his brother Louis had started.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Hawking a new snack product at the Chicago World's Fair. It was a hit, and the brothers began mass producing a packaged version of the treat. Now, of course, the product would need a flashy logo, something to signal wholesome.
Aaron Manke
Patriotic fun to consumers across the nation.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And in 1918, after a number of less inspired iterations, Frederick landed on a design that stuck.
Aaron Manke
He decided to honor his then five.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Year old grandson Robert by putting his face on the box, dressed in a.
Aaron Manke
Sailor suit with a dog at his feet.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Little did Frederick know that less than.
Aaron Manke
Two years later, that smiling little boy would be dead. The only thing left of him would.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Be that picture emblazoned like a memorial.
Aaron Manke
On thousands upon thousands of Cracker Jack boxes.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
That's right, Sailor Jack. The kid depicted on the classic baseball.
Aaron Manke
Game snack is actually a drawing of poor little Robert, a boy who never grew up.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But I'll be honest, when it comes to spooky baseball stories, that one is just the beginning. So today, we'll dig deep into America's.
Aaron Manke
Favorite pastime, emerging with prizes more strange and haunted than any Cracker Jack box could ever hold. I'm Aaron Manke, and this is Lore. It wasn't just a good game for Jim Davenport.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It was a great game. The Giants player had hit not one.
Aaron Manke
But two home runs. And now, back in the locker room, he was pondering his success.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
How had he played so well that night?
Aaron Manke
What had changed? After all, his skill hadn't grown between this game and the last.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
His opponents were no less formidable. But as he glanced down, he spotted.
Aaron Manke
The anomaly right there on his uniform.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It was a button. Or rather, the lack of a button. In his rush to get ready that.
Aaron Manke
Morning, he had accidentally missed a buttonhole while dressing. Yes, that empty buttonhole must be his lucky charm, his secret to success.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And so after that day, Jim would leave that buttonhole undone on purpose for the rest of his career. Now, it may sound absurd if you.
Aaron Manke
Aren'T a baseball fan, but for those.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Who do follow the sport, you'll know that superstitions like this are even more common than strikeouts. And as it turns out, there's a.
Aaron Manke
Pretty good reason for that.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Philosopher and baseball writer Dr. Amber Griffin describes it best. She writes, a poorly thrown fastball can result in a strikeout. An a perfectly executed slider can be.
Aaron Manke
Blooped into the outfield for a base hit.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
A ball popped up in the infield can be lost in the sun, and.
Aaron Manke
The wind can turn a would be home run into a foul ball. The best teams win only approximately 60% of their games.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In other words, despite requiring extreme talent.
Aaron Manke
And finesse, many of the outcomes in.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Baseball depend largely on chance or lucky. Now, if there's one thing that we.
Aaron Manke
Know about the human brain, it's that it hates leaving things to chance.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In fact, we'll do just about anything.
Aaron Manke
To manufacture a sense of control, even.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Convince ourselves of impossible, impractical cause and.
Aaron Manke
Effect relationships like, say, the ability for a single buttonhole to produce home runs.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Some baseball superstitions are learned as early.
Aaron Manke
As Little League, passed down from coach.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
To player, or whispered amongst peers in the dugouts. Things like never step on a white chalk foul line, or never speak to.
Aaron Manke
A pitcher who's in the midst of throwing a perfect game. Or the idea that a bat only contains a limited number of hits, and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
When those hits are used up, that's.
Aaron Manke
That the bat has to be retired.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
There are superstitions about how to wear your cap, how many times to swing.
Aaron Manke
The bat before stepping into the batter's box, and more.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In the 1920s and 30s, players who.
Aaron Manke
Tripped on the field would have to.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Retrace their steps Exactly. To undo the bad luck further back.
Aaron Manke
In the century, finding a lady's hairpin on the ground was considered lucky, as.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Was seeing a white horse before a game.
Aaron Manke
The hairpin and the horse, though, brought up another issue.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You had to be lucky enough to.
Aaron Manke
Organically stumble upon these things, which meant.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Once again, relying on chance. So sometimes managers would, well, let's just say, stack the deck. A manager might drop hairpins on the ground, hoping for players to find them. In 1904, a manager for the New York Giants even paid a carriage driver to casually bring his white horses past.
Aaron Manke
The ballpark before a game.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Talk about making your own luck right now. Sure, these rituals seem pretty playful and.
Aaron Manke
Benign, but that wasn't always the case.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Some were downright, well, racist. Ty Cobb and many other players believed.
Aaron Manke
That rubbing the head of a black boy would bring them good luck.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Cobb even took a young black child.
Aaron Manke
With him on the road during the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
1908 season for just this reason. Others employed, and I quote, hunchbacks and.
Aaron Manke
People with dwarfism to work somewhere in.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The team's orbit, viewing these human beings.
Aaron Manke
As no more than lucky charms.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And I have to say, as a professional observer of history, I think that.
Aaron Manke
America's real favorite pastime has always been discrimination.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Speaking of lucky charms, though, many players have what are called fetishes. And, no, not that kind of fetish.
Aaron Manke
A fetish is another word for a talisman.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Players carry things like coins, poker chips, crucifixes, rabbit's feet, lucky socks, a special.
Aaron Manke
Glove and more for good luck and protection.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And honestly, all of this is just.
Aaron Manke
Scratching the surface because there is as.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Much baseball magic as there are, well, players. Because that's the most fascinating thing about.
Aaron Manke
This particular category of superstition.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
While some of the rituals are shared.
Aaron Manke
Most of them are, in fact, private and individual things made up by a.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Player himself and performed by him and him alone. Take, for example, the favorite lucky charm for 1960s player Julio Gotai. During every game, he carried a cheese sandwich in his back pocket. Part lucky charm, part snack.
Aaron Manke
Not a bad idea, right? And then there's left fielder Ricardo Cardi.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Who would prep by dunking five candles in the toilet and bathtub before bringing them to the game, at which point he would light them at the plate. Cardinals player Edward Mojica used to dig.
Aaron Manke
A hole at the front end of the bullpen mound into which he would.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Spit half a cup of red Gatorade.
Aaron Manke
And yes, it had to be red.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Powerhouse hitter Jason Giambi, who played in the major leagues from 1995, all the way through 2014 was prone to what are called slumps, which is when a.
Aaron Manke
Player gets stuck in a streak of poor performance.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Thankfully, though, Giambi had a trick for.
Aaron Manke
Getting his groove back.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The 6 foot 3, 240 pound heavy hitter would simply wear a shiny golden.
Aaron Manke
Thong under his uniform.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And hey, don't knock it till you've tried it. Because it gained such a reputation for success that Giambi's teammates, including Derek Jeter.
Aaron Manke
And Johnny Damon, admitted to borrowing it too.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Hopefully not borrowing the actual thong. 12 time All Star and Hall of Famer Wade Boggs had a rather famous superstitious routine. For one, he ate chicken before every.
Aaron Manke
Game, evidently earning him the nickname Chicken Man.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
He would wake at exactly the same time on game days, and for night.
Aaron Manke
Games he always left his home at exactly 1:47pm he would take batting practice.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
At exactly 5:17pm Run sprints at 7:17.
Aaron Manke
And field exactly 150 balls during warmups.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Quizzically, he also drew the Hebrew word for life, chai, in the dirt before coming to Batman. Despite not being even a little bit Jewish, pitcher Turk Wendell may take the cake, though.
Aaron Manke
Men's Journal magazine named him the most superstitious athlete not just in baseball, but in any sport, and called him, and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
I quote, an absolute maniac when it came to magical belief. Wendell would always chew four pieces of black licorice when he was pitching and.
Aaron Manke
Would spit them out and then brush his teeth after each inning.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Oh, and he'd always hop over the.
Aaron Manke
Baseline, making sure never to step on.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It when entering or exiting the field.
Aaron Manke
And at the start of each inning, refusing to pitch until his center fielder waved at him.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Oh, and then there was his lucky necklace, made from the teeth of wild.
Aaron Manke
Animals that he had hunted and killed. And that's just a small sample of his rituals. There is no denying it.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Baseball players have got to be some.
Aaron Manke
Of the most superstitious people on the planet. But all that belief also comes with a downside.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Because you see, you can't believe in.
Aaron Manke
Charms and luck without also believing in curses. The Chicago Cubs were on a roll. They had won two of their first three World Series games against the Detroit.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Tigers, which meant only two more wins.
Aaron Manke
Would cement their 1945 title. And to make matters better, for the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Next game, they'd have home field advantage. But hey, success was nothing new to the Cubs.
Aaron Manke
After all, they were one of the best teams in the country. No, really, ever since their founding in 1876, the team had broken record after.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Record for winning streaks.
Aaron Manke
World Series Appearances and more.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But little did they know that was.
Aaron Manke
All about to change.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
On October 6th of 1945, fans poured.
Aaron Manke
Into Wrigley Field, eager to watch their beloved team do what they did best win.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
One of these fans was a Greek.
Aaron Manke
Immigrant named William Sianis, owner of a local bar called the Billy Goat Tavern.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And clutched in his fist were two.
Aaron Manke
Tickets to the big game. One for him and one for his pal Murphy. A small detail I should mention, though.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Murphy just also happened to be a goat.
Aaron Manke
That's right.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Scientists brought a goat to a baseball game.
Aaron Manke
Why?
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Well, it's hard to say. Some claim that he was a superstitious.
Aaron Manke
Fellow and thought that the goat would be good luck. But my guess is that it was a publicity stunt for his Billy Goat Tavern. In fact, the guy had a track record for media gimmicks.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Like the time he asked the State.
Aaron Manke
Department to issue him a license for building a restaurant on the moon. Or another time, when, knowing the Republican National Convention was in town, he smacked.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
A We do not serve Republican sign.
Aaron Manke
On his pub door, ensuring, through Reverse.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Psychotic, a paying bar packed with them the next day. Whatever the motivation, Seanis and Murphy marched.
Aaron Manke
Toward the gate, determined to watch the game.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Seanis had even blinged Murphy out with a sign that read, we got Detroit's goat. Yeah, that pun is low, even for my standards. After some spirited arguing with the ushers, the dynamic duo were finally let into.
Aaron Manke
The stadium and led to their seats. So far, all was well and good.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The goat was in. The game was about to start.
Aaron Manke
Luck was on the Cub's side. But then it began to rain.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Now, I'm not sure if you've ever.
Aaron Manke
Smelled a rain soaked goat, but imagine a wet dog on steroids. This was pungent.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
So bad, in fact, that fans seated.
Aaron Manke
Nearby started to complain.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And eventually, Seanis and Murphy were kicked.
Aaron Manke
Out of the stadium. Now, according to the legend, as the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Furious Sianis and his wet, smelly goat.
Aaron Manke
Stood outside Wrigley Field, he tossed his.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Hands up and yelled a fateful proclamation. The Cubs, he said, ain't gonna win no more. The Cubs will never win a World Series so long as the goat is.
Aaron Manke
Not allowed in Wrigley Field. And that was that.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
From then on, the Chicago Cubs were cursed. They lost that game against the Detroit Tigers that day. Then they lost the World Series the following season. Their losing streak continued. And the season after.
Aaron Manke
And after that, years went by, and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Game after game, pitch after pitch, it seemed like all the Cubs could do was lose.
Aaron Manke
Once lauded as superstars, they had come.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
To earn the nickname the lovable losers.
Aaron Manke
Wait till next year became the team's rather pitiful motto. It seemed that Murphy the goat had taken his revenge. Now, if we've learned anything from fairy tales, it's that curses can be broken, right? And Lord knows that the Cubs supporters.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Tried to break this one.
Aaron Manke
Fans did all sorts of rites and rituals to turn the tide. Even the higher ups got involved.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In September of 1950, for example, P.K.
Aaron Manke
Wrigley himself wrote a letter to Sianis begging for mercy.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But nothing worked.
Aaron Manke
Decades passed. By 1972, both Sianis and Murphy had passed away. But the curse didn't die with its makers. Nor did the Billy Goat Tavern, for that matter, which had been passed down to Sianis nephew Sam.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And Sam, well, he figured enough was enough. Maybe, just maybe, that Sianus blood running in his veins could help him break.
Aaron Manke
The curse once and for all.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And so Sam climbed into a limo.
Aaron Manke
And headed to Wrigley Field with a special friend in tow. That's right, a goat. This time the sign on the animal.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Read, all is forgiven.
Aaron Manke
Let me lead you to the penant.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Your friend, Billy Goat. You know the old adage, those who forget history are doomed to repeat it.
Aaron Manke
Well, whoever was working the door at Wrigley that day must have forgotten history.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Because the ushers refused to let Sam.
Aaron Manke
And the goat through the gate. And once again, it seems the curse retaliated. The cubs lost a whopping 16 of.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Their next 20 games. Now, look, I'm an Illinois boy, and I can tell you firsthand, Chicago is.
Aaron Manke
Not a city that gives up without a fight.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
On two occasions, once in 1984 and again in 1994, the Cubs tried to right this wrong by inviting Sam and his goat BFF to attend games as honored guests. Their manager even told a reporter, and I quote, I've got to go down to that tavern and talk to that.
Aaron Manke
Guy about the goat.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
We'll let the goat run the bases.
Aaron Manke
And water the outfield. We'll let him eat some grass and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
I'll kiss him, whatever it takes. And it almost seemed to work. Both times, Sam Sianis and his goat.
Aaron Manke
Visited a game the Cubs won. But alas, the winning streaks never lasted. Not until 2016, when, at long last, the Cubs finally achieved the impossible. They won the World Series.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
For the first time in 108 years.
Aaron Manke
The curse of the Billy Goat has.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Gone down as one of, if not the most famous curses in sports history.
Aaron Manke
And it's easy to see why.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
After all, the tale is compelling.
Aaron Manke
To say the least. And okay, I'll admit most of the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Cubs players themselves never actually believed in.
Aaron Manke
The hex, just playing along for show. But maybe they should have believed. Because if you ask me, the team really was. Cursed, that is. The placebo effect is a powerful drug. The Cubs came to expect a loss, and if you believe you're going to lose, well, you probably will. Add to that years of poor management.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Poor trades, an unwillingness to pay for.
Aaron Manke
Top players, an overzealous desire to win.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The World Series, and a playful little superstition.
Aaron Manke
It all became too real. But through it all, one winner always came out on top. The Billy Goat Tavern.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Its curse related fame led to franchising.
Aaron Manke
Merch lines and an influx of cash.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Unlike anything the pub ever would have.
Aaron Manke
Seen without such a legend behind it. Honestly, it seems that Seanis had been the real goat all along. Now, believing in barnyard curses is one.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Thing, but as this next story goes.
Aaron Manke
On to show us, it's another thing entirely.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
When a baseball team starts playing like.
Aaron Manke
It'S the end of the world.
Unknown
It'S.
Aaron Manke
The bottom of the fifth and the crowd is enraptured. This is it. The moment you've been waiting for.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The reason you've poured into the stands.
Aaron Manke
All 6,000 of you, eyes glued to the field. At last the innings end and the real show begins.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Instead of returning to the dugout, the visiting team starts to juggle. That's right, juggle. Baseballs soar through the air in elaborate loops.
Aaron Manke
One of the players performs a magical sleight of hand trick, a ball vanishing into thin only for him to pull it out of his long black beard. Suddenly there are donkeys on the pitch.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Players performing from their backs.
Aaron Manke
Yep, in a matter of minutes the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Park has been transformed into a full on circus.
Aaron Manke
At last comes the grand finale.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The visiting team sets down their gear, steps into the stands and invites you to join their doomsday cult. It's 1920s America and you have just witnessed the world famous semi pro baseball.
Aaron Manke
Team, the House of David in all their bizarre glory.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But before you dismiss this as some.
Aaron Manke
Kind of fever dream, let's rewind a few decades. It'll all make sense soon enough. If you're a regular listener of this show, you'll remember our recent episode on the self proclaimed prophet Joanna Southcott. Long story short, she was an English.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Apocalypse preacher during the late 18th and early 19th centuries and spent her life.
Aaron Manke
Warning of a second coming. While delivering terrifying and slightly wacky prophecies, she managed to recruit thousands of disciples her lifetime.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And after her death in 1814, numerous.
Aaron Manke
Cults continued to follow her teachings.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Cults like the House of David. It was founded by a man named.
Aaron Manke
Benjamin Purnell and his wife Mary.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The two were not wealthy nor well.
Aaron Manke
Educated, but Benjamin was a damn good preacher.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And they spent years traveling and teaching self Caudian principles.
Aaron Manke
Well, one night, Mary had an odd dream. As she slept, a voice vividly spoke.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The words Benton Harbor, Michigan, despite the.
Aaron Manke
Fact that she had never heard of a town by that name. When she awoke, she reported the dream to her husband, and they were in an agreement. It must be a divine message. And it could only mean one thing. Benton Harbor, Michigan would be the location of the new Garden of Eden. So the Purnells and a few disciples headed for Chicago. Once there, they founded a little compound.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Called, and I quote, the Israelite House of David, the new Eve, the Body of Christ. But that proved to be a bit.
Aaron Manke
Of a mouthful, so most people simply called it the House of David. They believed that once 12,000 disciples had gathered in Benton harbor, the old world would fall and a new era of peace and harmony would commence. And with that, the Purnell's real mission began. It was time to start recruiting.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Their followers grew to a few dozen.
Aaron Manke
And then to a hundred, then more.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
At its peak, shortly before World War.
Aaron Manke
I, members would number around 1,000, all living communally on their land. Like any good cult, there were rules and regulations to follow. They were celibate, for one, even among married couples. Alcohol, tobacco and profanity were also prohibited, as was eating meat. Personal property was not allowed. And lastly, haircuts and shaving were forbidden. Now, if you're imagining a bunch of.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Tent dwelling hippies, think again. The House of David was an urban planning powerhouse.
Aaron Manke
They cultivated their own grain and maintained over a dozen orchards.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The commune had its own cannery, its.
Aaron Manke
Own carpenter shop, its own tailor shop shop, and more. Heck, they even owned and operated their own electrical plant to provide the compound with lighting. Basically, this wasn't a commune, it was a city.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Of course, they had to fund all of this somehow.
Aaron Manke
And fund it they did. By the 1920s, the House of David was raking in millions and millions of dollars.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
How?
Aaron Manke
Well, they purchased 3,400 acres of agricultural.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Products, selling crops in massive quantities.
Aaron Manke
They dipped into the lumber industry too.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Get this.
Aaron Manke
They even ran a theme park next door to their compound called the Eden.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Springs Amusement park, complete with a miniature.
Aaron Manke
Railroad, a fish pond, a giant dollhouse, a zoo, and of course, an auditorium for performing biblical plays.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
I know, I'm right there. With you.
Aaron Manke
We all want to go to the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Doomsday cult Six Flags. And yet, none of their ventures were.
Aaron Manke
More famed and beloved than the House of David baseball team. It started simply enough. By buying some land. The cult built a baseball park on the purchase plot and began renting it out to semi pro teams for a little easy money. Every now and then, though, the members would jump in on a game themselves.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You know, just for fun.
Aaron Manke
And miraculously, they were holding their own against these semi pro teams. Actually, better than holding their own. They were winning. In fact, they soon realized that they.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Were talented enough to form a semi.
Aaron Manke
Pro team of their own. By 1915, the official House of David.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Baseball team started barnstorming, as it was.
Aaron Manke
Called, which was when teams would go.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
On tour playing exhibition games far from.
Aaron Manke
Their colony in rural Michigan. The team barnstormed through the US And.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Canada, Mexico and even Cuba. The more they played, the more money.
Aaron Manke
They were able to send home to Benton harbor, and the more opportunities they.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Had to proselytize the fans they met along the way.
Aaron Manke
After all, they were still going for that 12,000 member goal back at the compound. And what better way to recruit than by traveling the world? But they weren't just religious zealots posing as baseball players. These guys were good. They won 65 to 75% of their games, sometimes playing two or three games per day, and they were a blast to watch. They were aggressive and theatrical, never shying away from dramatic slides or stealing bases.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Not to mention their whole, well, look. Remember, one of the cult's rules was.
Aaron Manke
No haircuts or shaving.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
So imagine a bunch of Rasputin clones.
Aaron Manke
Running around in pristine uniforms. Oh, and due to their facial hair.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Sports journalists refer to the House of David players as, and I quote, Whiskerinos. Their image became so iconic that famous.
Aaron Manke
Major league players would don fake beards to impersonate them.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
There's even a photo of Babe Ruth.
Aaron Manke
With a Whiskerino beard strapped onto his stout, legendary chin.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But most exciting of all were the.
Aaron Manke
House of David's elaborate baseball stunts or pepper games. And this brings us back to what you witnessed at the start of the story.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The juggling, the vanishing trick in the.
Aaron Manke
Beard, the donkey riding, and more. Basically, think of them as the original Harlem Globetrotters. Gag after gag they performed to delighted.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Crowds for more than 40 years. And a lot happened in that time. But one thing that sure didn't was.
Aaron Manke
The second coming of Jesus Christ. But hey, at least they found a pretty good way to pass the time.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In the late 1920s scandal rocked the community.
Aaron Manke
Back in Benton harbor, the cult's leader, Benjamin Purnell, was accused of sexual assault and child abuse.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And while he was never found guilty on those counts, he was convicted of.
Aaron Manke
Fraud in 1927 and died shortly thereafter. The group splintered into a broken kaleidoscope of smaller factions, each one with their own House of David baseball team. Meanwhile, commune members were replaced one by.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
One with hired players until the teams.
Aaron Manke
Were barely related to the cult at all. And as the 1950s arrived and the age of barnstorming came to a close, so ended the House of David's exhibition teams once and for all.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And yet, while they reigned, they made.
Aaron Manke
An indelible mark on America. Amidst all their antics and beards and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Doomsday preaching, they were also setting the.
Aaron Manke
Stage for a new era of equity in baseball. You see, they played against other semi.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Pro teams, yes, even the occasional major.
Aaron Manke
League team, but they also played Negro league teams years before baseball became integrated. In fact, they even hired some major stars from the Negro league to play.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
For them, making them one of the.
Aaron Manke
First integrated teams in history. They even had a few female players on the team, including 19 year old Beatrice Mitchell, who allegedly struck out both.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig. Despite being a rigid Christian cult, they.
Aaron Manke
Were actually practicing progressive inclusivity far ahead of their time. At the end of the day, I can't help but wonder if the team's.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Success had something to do with their religious beliefs.
Aaron Manke
After all, what would make you play your heart out harder, lean more fully into the thing you love, than thinking that the world was about to end?
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It makes me reflect back on all those player superstitions. The cheese sandwich in the back pocket.
Aaron Manke
The hole full of red Gatorade, the undone button, and the five flickering candles on home plate. Because the thing about all these rituals is that according to the data, they actually worked.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Just as the assumption of failure was.
Aaron Manke
A self fulfilling prophecy for the Chicago.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Cubs, so too functioned these lucky rituals.
Aaron Manke
You see, by practicing these ceremonies, by.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Believing so deeply in their power, the players performed with more confidence, more certainty.
Aaron Manke
And ultimately, because of this, more skill.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In other words, it turns out that.
Aaron Manke
Golden Thong really was magic.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
I hope you enjoyed today's battle between two opposing teams. Common sense and superstition.
Aaron Manke
It's a wonderful slice of the past, right?
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But surprisingly, even to this day, a.
Aaron Manke
Few stray House of David disciples continue to keep up the cult's traditions right there in Benton harbor, still waiting for the second coming to arrive.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
They've waited a century for their final story. Our last tale, though, is coming right up. Stick around through this brief sponsor break.
Aaron Manke
To hear all about it. This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. This month is all about gratitude, and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Along with all the people in our lives we're very grateful for, there is.
Aaron Manke
One person we honestly don't thank ourselves.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It's sometimes hard to remind ourselves that.
Aaron Manke
We are trying our best to make sense of everything. And in this crazy world, that isn't easy.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
So consider this a little reminder to say thank you to the people in your life, including you need help finding the courage or strength to do that?
Aaron Manke
That's where therapy can be a big help. I know how important and helpful therapy.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Can be when it comes to helping.
Aaron Manke
Us see our lives with fresh eyes. And therapy isn't just for folks who have experienced major trauma. It can truly empower you to be.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The best version of yourself. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try.
Aaron Manke
It's entirely online, designed to be convenient.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Flexible and suited to your schedule. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with the licensed therapist and.
Aaron Manke
Switch therapists anytime for no additional charge. Let the gratitude flow with BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com lore today to get 10% off your first month.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
That's BetterHelp.
Aaron Manke
H E L p.com lore this episode was also made possible by Acorns.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Acorns makes it easy to start automatically saving and investing for you, your kids, your retirement, even during the holidays. You don't need to be an expert.
Aaron Manke
Acorns will recommend a diversified portfolio that matches you.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You don't need a ton of time.
Aaron Manke
You can create your Acorns account and start automatically investing your money in just five minutes.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You don't need to be rich. Acorns lets you get started with the.
Aaron Manke
Spare money you've got right now. That could be $5 a day, or even just your spare change. That's right. Acorns can round every purchase you make up to the dollar and automatically invest.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Your spare change for you. And you can get bonus investments just for buying the stuff you need from.
Aaron Manke
The brands you love. I know how confusing and intimidating the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Investment world can be, but I also.
Aaron Manke
Know it's important for our future. Which is why I love how easy Acorns makes it to jump in and get started.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It didn't require me to become an.
Aaron Manke
Expert or learn a bunch of lingo.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It's really that simple.
Aaron Manke
Head to acorns.com lore or download the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future paid client endorsement compensation.
Aaron Manke
Provides incentive to positively promote Acorns Investing involves risk Acorns Advisors, LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
View important disclosures@acorns.com lore it's better over.
Unknown
Here ATT customers Switching to T Mobile has never been easier. We'll pay off your existing phone and give you a new one free. All on America's largest 5G network. Visit t mobile.com carrierfreedom to switch today.
Pay off up to $650 via virtual prepaid MasterCard in 15 days. Free phone up to $830 via 24 monthly bill credits plus tax qualifying port in trade and service on go 5G next and credit required. Contact us before canceling entire account to continue bill credits or credit stop and balance and required finance agreement is due.
Aaron Manke
I know this is going to sound obvious, but boxing is a violent sport.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
From concussions to fractures, brain damage to.
Aaron Manke
Muscle tears, fighters face a myriad of dangers when they step into the ring. But one threat they usually don't have to worry about is black magic.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Unfortunately, though, for light heavyweight boxer Tiger Jack Fox, that was exactly what would take him down. The fight took place on February 3rd.
Aaron Manke
Of 1939 beneath the glamorous lights of Madison Square Gardens, and by this point, Tiger Jack was no stranger to the sport. He'd been boxing for over a decade and had achieved nearly 100 career wins, although he'd taken a break for the.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Last couple of months after a woman he'd brought back to his hotel room had stabbed him in the chest.
Aaron Manke
Story for another time.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Anyway, tonight he would make his way to the final bouts in a tournament to determine the new light heavyweight champion. And to be honest, it looked like Tiger Jack had this one in the bag. He was up against a fellow boxer named Melio Bettina, who had a reputation for being kind of a naive farm boy. Even having been stabbed two months prior, Tiger Jack was still favored to win 3 1. But little did he know Bettina had a secret weapon. And that secret weapon was his manager, a guy named Jimmy Grippo. And if you think that sounds like a cartoon character, just wait. Because old Jimmy Grippo really lived up to his name. You see, Jimmy wasn't actually best known.
Aaron Manke
As a boxing manager. He was most famous as a magician.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The Las Vegas sun would later describe him as an expert in, and I quote, clairaudience, clairvoyance, dream interpretation, extrasensory perception, handwriting analysis, magic and sleight of hand, palmistry, precognition, pupilmetrics, telekinesis, and telepathy. But his Real specialty? Oh, that would be hypnosis. In fact, Jimmy Grippo became famous for partnering with well respected doctors to use.
Aaron Manke
Hypnosis as an alternative to anesthetics. He was a huge proponent of hypnosis.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Ability to help women through childbirth, and was even hired to perform hypnosis on.
Aaron Manke
The King of Siam to calm the nervous monarch before an eye surgery.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Oh, and by the way, if you're.
Aaron Manke
Envisioning a mysterious showman with a flowing.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Black cape, you may want to amend that mental image. This fella basically looked like Captain Kangaroo, with dark hair, dark glasses and a suit and tie, of course. The real question though, is how did.
Aaron Manke
A magician end up as Milio Bettina's boxing manager?
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Well, he'd actually known Bettina since the.
Aaron Manke
Fighter was a boy.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The boxer had been a meek, scrawny kid who got picked on in school.
Aaron Manke
And so his mom enrolled him in.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
A local boxing gym and also hired their neighbor, Jimmy Grippo to help bolster.
Aaron Manke
The boy's confidence using hypnosis.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Of course, in Grippo's own words, I'd drill into his subconscious mind that he.
Aaron Manke
Was going to retain the knowledge he.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Would pick up in the gym, that he would have good reflexes, that he would be able to absorb punishment, that he was going to win in a wakeful state.
Aaron Manke
He now had greater confidence.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It was the power of suggestion at work.
Aaron Manke
And that hypnotic power of suggestion wouldn't.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Just influence Bettina though.
Aaron Manke
Nope.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In the championship bout on February 3, it was about to come for Tiger Jack Fox. Suffice to say, word got out about.
Aaron Manke
Grippo and Bettina's unconventional training methods and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Rumors started to fly. Some journalists claim that Grippo was using his powers to put Bettina into a.
Aaron Manke
Trance, making him unable to feel pain. And not only that, reports speculated that.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
If he was able to meet Fox's.
Aaron Manke
Eyes before the match, Grippo would put a hex on him too.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And it seems that Fox took the.
Aaron Manke
Threat of a hypnotic hex seriously.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
At the pre fight weigh in, he.
Aaron Manke
Wore sunglasses to protect himself from Grippo's power.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
It was a snowy night in New.
Aaron Manke
York, and as nearly 8,000 fans convened.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
In Madison Square Garden, Grippo leaned into.
Aaron Manke
His pride fighter and gave him his final instruction. You will be courageous, he said.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You will not quail. You will feel no pain and you will conquer.
Aaron Manke
He will not hurt you.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
You will attack, attack, attack.
Aaron Manke
And you shall prevail.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
And all the while, Tiger Jack was.
Aaron Manke
Doing everything he could to avoid making eye contact with the magician. Grippo, however, was determined just before the initial bell rang. Jimmy shouted out a distraction and foolishly Tiger Jack looked up.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The two men locked eyes and Tiger Jack moaned. That was it.
Aaron Manke
He was doomed. The bout started out slow and for a while it seemed that the fighters were evenly matched. But as the eighth round neared its end, Tiger Jack began to flag.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
By the ninth, Bettina had Tiger Jack.
Aaron Manke
Up against the ropes almost immediately and.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Was landing hit after hit. Somehow, Tiger Jack Fox, a quick fisted veteran, was being pummeled by a young farm boy. Finally, at the 122 mark, referee Eddie Josephs called the match Bettina had won.
Aaron Manke
Years later, a journalist would write of.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Jimmy Grippo, he can put people under a hypnotic spell.
Aaron Manke
Grippo is the name. Jimmy Grippo.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But whenever the scholars assemble in Leatherfist.
Aaron Manke
Lane to discuss such erudite subjects as.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
The supernatural and hypnotism, they refer to him in hushed voices as Grippo the Great. Tiger Jack and Bettina would both continue.
Aaron Manke
Fighting, the former eventually honored in Ring magazine's 100 Greatest Pound for pound punchers of all time.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
But for the most part, the two fighters were forgotten. It seems that despite the boxer's prowess.
Aaron Manke
In the ring, it was the magician who won the real championship, that of being remembered by history. And even now, we are still left wondering on that day back in 1939, did Jimmy Grippo really put a hypnotic.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Hex on Tiger Jack or did he.
Aaron Manke
Just really, really psych him out? This episode of Lore was produced by me, Erin Manke with writing by Jenna.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Rose Nethercott, research by Sam Alberty, and.
Aaron Manke
Music by Chad Lawson. Don't like hearing the ads? I've got a solution for you. There is a paid version of Lore on Apple Podcasts and patreon that is 100% ad free.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Plus subscribers also get weekly mini episodes that we call Lore Bytes.
Aaron Manke
It's a bargain for all of that ad free storytelling and a great way.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
To support this show and the team behind it.
Aaron Manke
Of course, Lore is much more than just a podcast. There's the book series available in bookstores and online, and two seasons of the television show on Amazon Prime Video. Information about all of that and more is available over@lorepodcast.com and you can also follow this show on YouTube, Threads, Instagram and Facebook.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
Just search for Lore Podcast all one word and then click that follow button.
Aaron Manke
And when you do, say hi. I like it when people say hi. And as always, thanks for listening. This episode of Lore is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, Monetary Magicians.
Jenna Rose Nethercott
These are things people say about drivers.
Aaron Manke
Who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.
Unknown
After investing billions to light up our network, T Mobile is America's largest 5G network. Plus right now you can switch Keep your phone and we'll pay it off up to $800. See how you can save on every plan versus Verizon and at and t@tmobile.com.
KeepAndSwitch up to four lines via virtual prepaid card. Allow 15 days qualifying unlocked device, credit service ported 90 plus days with device and eligible carrier and timely redemption required Card has no cash access and expires in six months.
Lore Episode 267: Curveball – A Detailed Summary
Host: Aaron Mahnke
Co-Host: Jenna Rose Nethercott
Release Date: November 18, 2024
In Episode 267 of the award-winning podcast Lore, hosts Aaron Mahnke and Jenna Rose Nethercott delve into the intriguing world of baseball superstition and dark sports legends. Titled "Curveball," this episode unravels the mysterious tales behind America's favorite pastime, exploring how belief, luck, and curses have shaped the history of baseball.
Robert Ruckheim and the Making of Sailor Jack
The episode begins with the poignant story of young Robert Ruckheim, whose tragic death at the age of seven in 1920 inadvertently immortalized him as Sailor Jack, the emblematic figure on Cracker Jack boxes. Aaron Mahnke narrates:
"Little Robert was destined for a strange sort of immortality. ... The only thing left of him would be that picture emblazoned like a memorial on thousands upon thousands of Cracker Jack boxes." [02:21]
Baseball Superstitions: A Deep-Rooted Tradition
Jenna Rose Nethercott and Aaron Mahnke explore various baseball superstitions that players adopt to edge out luck in a game governed largely by chance. They discuss how even minor rituals, like leaving a buttonhole undone or carrying lucky charms, can significantly impact a player's performance by fostering confidence.
"Players carry things like coins, poker chips, crucifixes, rabbit's feet, lucky socks, a special glove and more for good luck and protection." [07:00]
Dr. Amber Griffin, a philosopher and baseball writer featured in the episode, elaborates on the randomness of the game:
"A poorly thrown fastball can result in a strikeout. A perfectly executed slider can be blooped into the outfield for a base hit." [04:14]
The Curse of the Billy Goat: A Legendary Hex
The centerpiece of the episode is the infamous Curse of the Billy Goat, which supposedly doomed the Chicago Cubs for over a century. The story recounts how William Sianis, owner of the Billy Goat Tavern, brought his pet goat, Murphy, to a Cubs game on October 6, 1945. Due to Murphy's disruptive presence, Sianis was ejected, leading him to curse the team:
"The Cubs will never win a World Series so long as the goat is not allowed in Wrigley Field." [13:00]
This curse is credited with the Cubs' prolonged championship drought, their affectionate moniker "lovable losers," and a series of unfortunate seasons. Despite numerous attempts by fans and team management to lift the curse—such as inviting Sianis and Murphy back to games—the Cubs remained beleaguered until their historic World Series win in 2016, ending a 108-year hiatus.
"I can't help but wonder if the team's success had something to do with their religious beliefs. ... Golden Thong really was magic." [25:44]
The Power of Belief and the Placebo Effect
The hosts discuss how superstitions and rituals can create a placebo effect, enhancing player performance through increased confidence and reduced anxiety. This psychological boost often translates into better on-field results, suggesting that belief itself can be a powerful tool in the competitive landscape of sports.
"The placebo effect is a powerful drug. The Cubs came to expect a loss, and if you believe you're going to lose, well, you probably will." [16:00]
Transitioning from the supernatural to theatrical exhibitions, Mahnke and Nethercott explore the House of David, a religious commune that formed one of the first integrated baseball teams. Founded by Benjamin and Mary Purnell in Benton Harbor, Michigan, the House of David team was known for their remarkable skills and unique appearance, adorned with immaculate beards.
Integration and Inclusivity Ahead of Their Time
Notably, the House of David team was among the first to integrate by hiring stars from the Negro leagues and even including female players, such as Beatrice Mitchell, who famously struck out legends Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig.
"They were actually practicing progressive inclusivity far ahead of their time." [24:58]
Exhibition Games and Theatrical Performance
Their barnstorming tours across the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Cuba were not just competitive but also highly entertaining, featuring tricks akin to those of the Harlem Globetrotters. These performances captivated audiences for over four decades, blending athletic prowess with showmanship.
"House of David players as, and I quote, Whiskerinos. Their image became so iconic that famous Major League players would don fake beards to impersonate them." [23:07]
Despite internal scandals, including accusations against their leader Benjamin Purnell and the eventual decline of the group, the House of David left an indelible mark on baseball, promoting early forms of equity and integration within the sport.
In the second major segment of the episode, Mahnke and Nethercott shift focus to the world of boxing, telling the tale of Tiger Jack Fox and his enigmatic manager, Jimmy Grippo.
Jimmy Grippo: The Magician Manager
Jimmy Grippo was not your typical boxing manager. Renowned for his expertise in hypnosis and various forms of magic, Grippo believed in harnessing supernatural powers to enhance his fighters' performance. His unconventional methods included:
"Grippo would put people under a hypnotic spell." [35:14]
The Championship Bout: A Dark Turn
The pivotal moment in this story occurred on February 3, 1939, at Madison Square Gardens. Tiger Jack Fox, a seasoned boxer with nearly 100 career wins, faced Melio Bettina, a seemingly naive farm boy under Grippo's mystical guidance. Despite Fox being the favorite, Bettina emerged victorious in a shocking upset.
"Years later, ... Grippo the Great." [35:18]
The outcome left many speculating whether Grippo's supposed magical interventions were responsible for Fox's unexpected defeat or if it was merely a psychological edge.
Legacy of the Match
While both fighters continued their careers, it was Jimmy Grippo who etched his name into sports lore through the rumors of his magical prowess. The true extent of his influence remains a topic of fascination and mystery among historians and sports enthusiasts alike.
"Even now, we are still left wondering on that day back in 1939, did Jimmy Grippo really put a hypnotic hex on Tiger Jack or did he just really, really psych him out?" [35:59]
Episode 267 of Lore masterfully intertwines stories of superstition and dark rituals within the realms of baseball and boxing. From the legendary Curse of the Billy Goat that plagued the Chicago Cubs to the enigmatic tales of Jimmy Grippo's magical influence in boxing, the episode underscores how belief and ritual can significantly impact athletic performance and team fortunes.
"If you're a regular listener of this show, you'll remember our recent episode on the self proclaimed prophet Joanna Southcott." [18:18]
Ultimately, Lore highlights that whether through the placebo effect, psychological confidence, or the allure of the supernatural, the human propensity to seek control and meaning in sports continues to shape narratives and destinies within the athletic world.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of "Lore" Episode 267: Curveball, providing listeners—and those who missed the episode—with an engaging overview of the fascinating interplay between superstition, belief, and sports history.