Amber | Elon's Spies Ep3

Summary

Tortoise Investigates: "Amber | Elon’s Spies Ep3" Summary

Introduction

In the third episode of "Elon’s Spies," part of the Elon Spies series by Tortoise Investigates, host Alexey Mostros delves deeper into the intricate and shadowy dynamics surrounding Elon Musk’s surveillance activities. This episode focuses primarily on Elon Musk’s relationship with Amber Heard, allegations of surveillance, and the broader implications of Musk’s expansive influence. Through interviews and investigative reporting, the episode uncovers unsettling connections between Musk’s business ventures and his personal relationships.

---

The Amber Heard and Elon Musk Relationship

The episode begins by reintroducing the complex relationship between Elon Musk and actress Amber Heard. Sally Coates, a journalist from the Gold Coast Bulletin, provides firsthand insights into Heard's life in the Gold Coast, Australia, where she was filming Aquaman in 2017.

Notable Quote:

"When Amber Heard arrived in Australia, she was dating Elon Musk. [...] A few months later, she'd be at the centre of a bizarre mystery and she'd learn something about Musk."
— Alexey Mostros [03:49]

---

The Anonymous Tip and Possible Surveillance

Sally Coates recounts receiving an anonymous tip that Amber Heard’s private address had been compromised, revealing that a local football player was frequently visiting Heard’s residence. The metadata traced the message back to SpaceX in California, raising suspicions about potential surveillance.

Notable Quotes:

"The anonymous tip was suggesting that Amber had a frequent visitor who was a local football player..."
— Sally Coates [12:06]

"It quite clearly came up as SpaceX. California."
— Sally Coates [14:34]

---

Sally Coates' Encounter with Elon Musk and Amber Heard

Following the anonymous tip, Musk and Heard announce the end of their relationship. However, shortly after, both are spotted together at a cafe in the Gold Coast. Sally Coates seizes the opportunity to photograph them, leading to a public portrayal of reconciliation. Subsequently, Musk reaches out to Coates, implicitly acknowledging the involvement of someone from SpaceX in sending the anonymous tip.

Notable Quotes:

"Elon told her that the couple are working on their relationship and he's determined to defend Amber."
— Alexey Mostros [19:06]

"He did accept that someone working for him had sent the tip to the paper because it came from SpaceX."
— Sally Coates [20:02]

---

Unveiling of Musk's Surveillance of Amber Heard

Alexey Mostros reveals information from a source indicating that Elon Musk’s team employed an Australian private investigation firm to surveil Amber Heard extensively. The surveillance involved multiple operatives, cars, paparazzi tactics, and advanced technology like infrared cameras and drones, costing hundreds of thousands of Australian dollars.

Notable Quotes:

"The Australian company is said to have used six or seven operatives to spy on Amber every night, followed her in multiple cars and pretended to be paparazzi if they were caught."
— Alexey Mostros [21:05]

"He suspected her of being unfaithful."
— Mostros [22:15]

---

Christina Balan's Case and Allegations of Surveillance by Tesla

The episode introduces Christina Balan, a former Tesla engineer who alleges wrongful dismissal after raising safety concerns. Balan claims that Tesla not only accused her of theft but also subjected her to surveillance, including being followed and receiving threatening notes. Her case underscores the pattern of behavior where Musk’s enterprises intimidate and silence critics.

Notable Quotes:

"I had a very scary note taped on my door in which they said, if you care about your son. Will drop your lawsuit."
— Christina Balan [31:39]

"Musk and Tesla seem determined that [Christina] won't have a chance to clear her name in open court."
— Alexey Mostros [28:54]

---

Political Tensions with Hamza Yousaf and Musk's Influence

Hamza Yousaf, the former First Minister of Scotland, discusses his fraught interactions with Elon Musk. Accusing Musk of racism and manipulating private messages, Yousaf describes Musk as a "super racist" who uses his vast resources to silence opponents. This segment highlights Musk's influence extending into political arenas, where he leverages his power to target and intimidate public figures.

Notable Quotes:

"I don't doubt for a moment that he absolutely is a racist. Has racist sympathies, amplifies racists, believes in white supremacist conspiracy theories."
— Hamza Yousaf [36:05]

"I'm certain he absolutely does. [...] try to besmirch my reputation and they'll use any nefarious tactics."
— Hamza Yousaf [38:10]

---

Elon Musk's Influence and Power

Alexey Mostros concludes the episode by reflecting on the magnitude of Elon Musk’s influence across various sectors, including technology, space, and global communications. Musk’s control over entities like Starlink and SpaceX positions him as a pivotal figure in geopolitics and media. Mostros questions whether Musk’s unchecked power could undermine democratic institutions and free speech, especially given his alleged use of surveillance and intimidation tactics.

Notable Quotes:

"Musk has a force in him that lets him build companies and machines that no one thought possible. [...] But to me, it's this same force, this same desire to control the world around him."
— Alexey Mostros [42:40]

"His Starlink company gives him control over large swathes of the global Internet. [...] Whether you choose to engage with him or not, Musk is shaping your world and mine."
— Alexey Mostros [44:02]

---

Conclusion

"Amber | Elon’s Spies Ep3" meticulously unveils the depths of Elon Musk’s personal and professional endeavors to monitor and influence those around him. Through investigative journalism and compelling personal accounts, the episode paints a picture of a man whose ambitions extend beyond business into the realm of personal control and surveillance. The implications of Musk’s actions raise critical questions about privacy, power, and the boundaries of influence in the modern world.

Notable Quotes:

"How he controls information, how he seeks to shape his own reality behind the scenes when no one else is looking."
— Alexey Mostros [44:02]

---

Key Takeaways:

• Surveillance Practices: Elon Musk’s alleged use of private investigators and surveillance extends into his personal relationships, raising ethical concerns.

• Intimidation of Critics: High-profile individuals like Christina Balan and Hamza Yousaf highlight a pattern of using intimidation and legal maneuvering to silence opposition.

• Global Influence: Musk’s control over significant technological infrastructures underscores his capacity to influence global communications and geopolitics.

• Impact on Democracy: The episode questions the implications of one individual's unchecked power on democratic institutions and personal freedoms.

---

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the pivotal moments and revelations from "Amber | Elon’s Spies Ep3," providing a clear and detailed overview for those who have not listened to the episode.

Transcript

[Alexey Mostros]

Hello, I'm Chloe Hegemotheo. I'm a narrative editor at the observer and the host of the Tortoise Investigates podcast. Lucky boy. I'm popping up here to say thank you all for continuing to listen and to support Tortoise Investigates from the observer. If you like what you've heard already. The good news is there are more observer podcasts that you may not know about yet. There's the News meeting, where Tortoise journalists and special guests battle it out to see whose story will lead the news the Sense Maker, one story every weekday to make sense of the world and the Sloan Newscast, a weekly investigation into a story we think you should know about. We're proud to bring you our journalism in audio, so make sure you follow all our shows so you don't miss a single Observer Podcast episode.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

If you're an experienced pet owner, you already know that having a pet is 25% belly rubs, 25% yelling drop it. And 50% groaning at the bill from every vet visit. Which is why Lemonade Pet Insurance is tailor made for your pet and can save you up to 90% on vet bills. It can help cover checkups, emergencies, diagnostics, basically all the stuff that makes your bank account nervous. Claims are filed super easily through the Lemonade app and half get settled instantly. Get a'@lemonade.com pet and they'll help cover the vet bill for whatever your pet swallowed after you yelled drop it.

[Naomi Ekparigan]

Want a workout that actually works? Hydro delivers a full body workout that hits 86% of your muscles in just 20 minutes. Rowing with Hydro combines strength and cardio with thousands of workouts led by Olympians in breathtaking locations. No wonder nine out of ten members are still active one year later. Try Hydro risk [e-mail] and use code RO to save up to $475 off your Hydro Pro Rower. That's H Y-R-O-W.com Code Row.

[Alexey Mostros]

Hey, it's Alexei here. Thanks for listening to my new series Elon Spies. I really hope you enjoy the final episode. If you want to hear more of our investigations, you can listen to our previous series right here on Tortoise Investigates. To hear more from Tortoise's award winning newsroom. Just search for Tortoise wherever you get your podcasts. You can get early access and ad free listening to all Tortoise shows by subscribing to Tortoise plus on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or by downloading downloading the Tortoise app.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

Tortoise.

[Alexey Mostros]

Last time On Elon's spies, Musk now needs to reveal exactly what surveillance he used on me, which firms and what methods.

[Hamza Yousaf]

The pedo guy defamation still hangs over.

[Alexey Mostros]

Me six years later.

[Hamza Yousaf]

What was your.

[Naomi Ekparigan]

Were you involved in arranging for a.

[Alexey Mostros]

Personal investigator to follow Mr. Tripp? Yes. Do you think the investigation into Martin Tripp was normal? It's interesting. I, I, I looking at it now, knowing what I know about what they really did, that. No, it wasn't normal.

[Sally Coates]

It was nuts, like it was. It was one of the craziest periods of my life.

[Alexey Mostros]

It's 8am the rain is drizzling down, but the view from the balcony is so beautiful it doesn't matter. And the birds chirping away in the background, they don't seem to mind. From where I'm sitting on my sofa late one night, staring into a computer screen, it looks like another world. And it may as well be. The Gold coast of Australia is about as far away from London as you can get. It's also pretty much the last place I expected to find a story about Elon Musk.

[Sally Coates]

I'm Sally Coates. I grew up in the country in New South Wales, but moved to the bright lights of the Gold coast when I was 18 for uni, studied journalism.

[Alexey Mostros]

Today, Sally works as a strategist, but in 2017, her job was a little different.

[Sally Coates]

A couple of years after I graduated, I got a job at the Gold Coast Bulletin, which is just the local newspaper.

[Alexey Mostros]

The Gold coast is a small city in eastern Australia, south of Brisbane. It's famous for its many beaches, including Surfer's Paradise.

[Sally Coates]

The Bulletin covered a lot of pretty regular local news stories, you know, local crime, local politics, a lot of council stories, you know, just.

[Alexey Mostros]

Yeah, like a proper local newspaper.

[Sally Coates]

Yeah, the usual.

[Alexey Mostros]

If you're a local newspaper reporter, whether on the Gold coast or in Bristol or in Memphis, it's the same sort of work. Local journalism is all about covering the community, planning applications, new restaurant openings, that sort of thing. Celebrity gossip usually doesn't play a big part, but on the Gold coast, things are a little different.

[Sally Coates]

There's been a bunch of movies filmed there.

[Alexey Mostros]

Now, it's not Hollywood, but the city has a reputation as a location for filming big movies. Films like Ticket to Paradise with George Clooney and Skull Island.

[Sally Coates]

I always think it's a little bit like a mini la.

[Alexey Mostros]

The crew and actors often stay locally.

[Sally Coates]

Like Tom Hiddleston, Michael Fassbender, like Matt Damon. Over the years, there'll be kind of a celebrity cameo on the Gold coast and everyone goes nuts.

[Alexey Mostros]

Manna from heaven for a local newspaper. And that's why when Amber Heard flew into town, Sally knew all about it.

[Sally Coates]

So Amber would have arrived around April 2017.

[Alexey Mostros]

Now, you know how I mentioned that sometimes stories have a way of coming back to you. You think you've finished with them and then something happens to drag you back in. Well, last year, I. I'd spent months looking into the trial between Amber Heard and Johnny Depp for a podcast called who Trolled Amber? Great podcast, by the way. I really recommend it. To be honest, I didn't expect Amber to cross my path again, but I'd forgotten one thing. A year after divorcing Johnny Depp, she'd started a new relationship.

[Sally Coates]

Is when all the Elon Musk Amber Heard madness started.

[Alexey Mostros]

Very briefly, when Amber Heard arrived in Australia, she was dating Elon Musk. Sally was in for a surprise too. She thought she'd write a few stories about Amber turning up at parties, getting spotted on the beach, that sort of thing. She didn't know it then, but a few months later, she'd be at the centre of a bizarre mystery and she'd learn something about Musk. That, together with evidence we've uncovered, reveals just how far one of the world's most powerful men might have been willing to go to keep tabs on his partner. I'm Alexey Mostros and this is elon spies. Episode 3Amber hey, this is Naomi Ekparigan, co host of the podcast Couples Therapy. I wanted to talk to you about Boost Mobile, the newest 5G network in the country. Boost Mobile's new network delivers customers the speed and service they'd expect from the Big three, Plus groundbreaking benefits you'd only get from a true challenger in the industry. Like letting people try the network risk free for 30 days and offering a $25 per month unlimited plan that's guaranteed to never go up in price. So visit your nearest Boost Mobile store.

[Naomi Ekparigan]

Or find them [e-mail] want a workout that actually works? Hydro delivers a full body workout that hits 86% of your muscles in just 20 minutes. Rowing with Hydro combines strength and cardio with thousands of workouts led by Olympians in breathtaking locations. No wonder nine out of ten members are still active one year later. Try Hydro risk free at hydrow.com and use code RO to save up to $475 off your Hydro Pro rower. That's H Y-R-O-W.com code row BetterHelp Online.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

Therapy bought this 30 second ad to remind you Right now, wherever you are, to unclench your jaw, relax your shoulders, take a deep breath in and out. Feels better, right? That's 15 seconds of self care. Imagine what you could do with more. Visit betterhelp.com randompodcast for 10% off your first month of therapy. No pressure, just help. But for now, just relax.

[Alexey Mostros]

In 2017, Amber Heard is about to start filming Aquaman. She's playing the character Meera. Was there paparazzi? Were people kind of interested in the fact that she was around?

[Sally Coates]

Yeah, people were interested, but she, she was pretty out and about. Like it was, it was kind of awesome. You know, she went out to a nightclub and, you know, just was kind of in with the rabble and it seemed like she was really enjoying herself. We don't really have like a huge kind of paparazzi detail here.

[Alexey Mostros]

Again, when she's not filming, she's spotted in town. There's photos of her at a luxury hotel, at a bar, at a party. Musk flies over From America, an 18 hour flight to see her. They're pictured visiting a bird sanctuary together. But when it comes to where Amber's living, no one knows the location until August 4, 2017, when someone blows up her privacy.

[Sally Coates]

One day when Amber was still here, we got an anonymous tip that said essentially there's a young football player who's been spotted leaving Amber Heard's rented accommodation. And I'll never forget this, it said, looking like the cat that got the cream. But we were like, where the heck is this come from?

[Alexey Mostros]

Sally's newspaper, the Gold Coast Bulletin, receives a mysterious anonymous message.

[Sally Coates]

And so we were like, whaaaat? You know, you get tips, but it's usually like, my neighbour built a fence on my land because, like, we're still a regional newspaper like this now, at.

[Alexey Mostros]

Every news company I've worked for, there's always been a way for readers, listeners, whoever to get in touch with journalists if they have a story. To be honest, a lot of these tips are garbage, but occasionally you get a nugget that becomes the start of, of something bigger. This is a nugget. Just to be clear, what was the message suggesting?

[Sally Coates]

The anonymous tip was suggesting that Amber had a frequent visitor who was a local football player and he was leaving her house looking like the cat that got the cream.

[Alexey Mostros]

And the message revealed her private address?

[Sally Coates]

Yes. Yeah, it did. And we didn't have that previously.

[Alexey Mostros]

The message says, spending many nights a week at Amber Heard's house on. On the. And leaving early in the morning looking like the cat that swallowed the can. Basically it's a tip that Amber is seeing an Aussie rules football player and that he's been spotted leaving her place on a number of occasions. Sally says that the message immediately stood out to her because Amber's address was previously secret information. No one knew where she was staying. Whoever sent the tip not only knew that information, but had apparently been at the address in the morning and in the evening and on multiple days too, if the message was to be believed. They were also close enough to see the look on the face of the footballer as he left the house.

[Sally Coates]

So it had to be someone who had eyes on him.

[Alexey Mostros]

And when you first got this message, who did you think may have been behind it?

[Sally Coates]

We thought it potentially could have just been a neighbour. It did cross my mind that potentially it could have been him sending it in for a bit of attention.

[Alexey Mostros]

Sally thinks maybe the footballer has leaked the information to the newspaper himself to boost his own profile, but he strongly denies it. Maybe it's a neighbor, but that doesn't really seem to fit. So Sally and her colleagues get technical.

[Sally Coates]

Like they are anonymous, but you can track the IP address, which we usually wouldn't bother doing because, you know, a tip's a tip. But we were like, where the heck has this come from?

[Alexey Mostros]

The reporters look into the metadata behind the message. That's the underlying code that can tell you things like where the message was sent from.

[Sally Coates]

So we trace your IP address and it quite clearly came up as SpaceX. California.

[Alexey Mostros]

Never underestimate the tenacity of journalists at a local paper. It's quite a twist, isn't it? Everything points to the message originating from inside one of Elon Musk's own companies. And the experts on IP the newspapers speak to, they agree. So the Gold Coast Bulletin writes up the story. It reports just the facts. The anonymous tip, the tracing to SpaceX, the fact that Musk declines to comment. The paper doesn't really try to answer the question at the centre of my mind, which is, if someone at SpaceX was responsible for sending the tip to the newspaper, then they must have placed Amber under surveillance, because how else could they have got that information without sitting outside her house day after day, night after night? And if that's right, what are the implications of that? But instead, the paper reports the story and then moves on. Fair enough. Local reporters have to write several stories a day. They can't spend months thinking about just one of them. And it stays like this until Sally gets a call out of the blue from Elon a day after someone from SpaceX sends the anonymous tip to the Gold Coast Bulletin. Amber and Musk announce that their relationship is over.

[Sally Coates]

And then the very next day after it was announced globally that they had split up, I went to a cafe and I was having a meeting just with a totally other source about other stories. And in walk Amber and Elon, side by side. It was kind of mid morning on a weekday, cafe was pretty empty. And I just said to the person I've seen, I was like, I'm really sorry. I could pretend to listen to you, but I'm not listening to you. I have to like do this. They are really broken up. And now they are here.

[Alexey Mostros]

Now Elon Musk is not known for taking holidays. In fact, he told his biographer, vacations will kill you. But here he is back on the Gold coast seeing Amber for the second time in four months. And as a complete coincidence, Sally happens to be in exactly the same cafe. Like any good reporter, she's not going to let a chance like that slip by.

[Sally Coates]

They are rarely broken up. And now they are here. And so I went up to them and just said like, hey guys. Oh my God, I can't believe you're here. Can I get a photo of you too? And they both gave each other this like awkward look and were like, maybe not. We can take photos of you. And so Amber took a photo of me and Elon, and Elon took a photo of me and Amber like separately, like clearly in the same backdrop.

[Alexey Mostros]

Sally gets the photos and writes up the story. Elon and Amber's relationship seems to be back on. They run it.

[Sally Coates]

My bosses at the paper very lamely labeled it an intergalactic exclusive. It was on the front page of like the Gold Coast Bullet. I know, first of its kind.

[Alexey Mostros]

But then she panics because she receives an email from Sam Teller at SpaceX. Teller is Musk's chief of staff. He says he wants to connect her to Musk, but he doesn't say what it's about. Her colleagues joke that it was nice knowing her. She waits anxiously, like the number on.

[Sally Coates]

My phone is like this like American mobile number. And I was like, hi, how'd you go? It was like, sally, it's Elon. And I was like, what the hell?

[Alexey Mostros]

Elon is calling Sally to tell her that the couple are working on their relationship and he's determined to defend Amber. He says all relationships have their ups and downs, especially ones in the public eye. Fair enough. But Sally wants to know about the anonymous tip. Was it sent by someone in SpaceX as the IP address? Suggested. Musk says that he doesn't know about the message himself and that sometimes other agendas are at work. Sally asks him the obvious question. What other agendas?

[Sally Coates]

He said that there were people acting on his behalf that were trying to look out for him.

[Alexey Mostros]

You mean people working for him?

[Sally Coates]

Yeah, yeah, because it came from. It came out of SpaceX. So that was like. That was the explanation for that.

[Alexey Mostros]

So. But he. He accept. Sorry to butt in, but. But he. He accepted that someone working for him had sent the tip to the paper and Musk confirmed that. Musk tells her that he's not going to discipline anyone for sending the tip because, quote, I don't know exactly which team member it was. People sometimes act on my behalf, he says, sometimes with my interests in mind, sometimes not. What Musk is telling her is pretty extraordinary. He's not denying that a member of his team sent the anonymous tip. In fact, he's saying they did, just without his knowledge. And to me, that comes close to an admission that someone on Musk's team spied on Amber Heard. It makes sense to conclude that someone working on behalf of Elon Musk procured that information and passed it back to him.

[Sally Coates]

I can't say for sure, like, from my experience, but if you lay out the pieces and, you know, form a logical conclusion, all signs point to either someone was watching and feeding information back or there was some sort of surveillance.

[Alexey Mostros]

When the call ends, Sally has formed her own opinion about who sent the tip.

[Sally Coates]

My personal belief is he definitely sent it. And I think with the, you know, knowing how sort of fast and loose he can be with online communication, I think it wouldn't be hugely out of character. I think at the time it just seemed a bit more out of character. I mean, you know, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck. I just can't really see anyone, any of his members of staff, caring enough to or knowing, like, how would they know? How does anyone know?

[Alexey Mostros]

When Sally agreed to speak to us, I hadn't realized that she'd had a personal call with Musk. I thought she was going to help us bring the Gold coast to life and add some color to another part of the investigation. Part of the investigation we'd already been working on. A couple of months ago, I got on a call with a source, someone who suggested that if I was looking into Musk and the way he uses private investigators, I might want to look at what happened on the Gold Coast. This source told me that Amber Heard was placed under surveillance when she was filming Aquaman between April and October 2017. The source said that Musk's team, acting through one of his security officers, a guy called Andrew Lannu, contracted with an Australian firm of private investigators who specialized in exposing marital infidelities. The source said that the surveillance on Amber was extensive, that it went on for weeks, if not months, at a cost that ran into hundreds of thousands of Australian dollars. The Australian company is said to have used six or seven operatives to spy on Amber every night, followed her in multiple cars and pretended to be paparazzi if they were caught. They even used infrared cameras and drones. And all because apparently Musk wanted to keep an eye or several eyes on Amber. He suspected her of being unfaithful. When I put this to Musk and to Amber, both declined to comment. So did the firm of investigators in question. But taken together with Sally's story, a disturbing picture was beginning to emerge. An insight into how Musk thinks and acts. Musk and Herd's relationship broke down in December 2017. When he spoke to his biographer, Walter Isaacson about this period, Musk described it as one of unrelenting insanity. It was mind bogglingly painful, the most concentrated pain I've ever had. And it is noticeable that many of the incidents we've covered in this podcast happened during this time frame between 2017 and 2018. It was a time when Musk was going through months of unrelenting stress. This is what he wrote on Twitter in 2017. The reality is great highs, terrible lows. What I do is just take the pain. So I'm thinking, is this whole investigation essentially historic? Is the Elon Musk of 2024 a changed man? The Musk of today is more certain of his position, even richer and more powerful. Would Musk 2.0 have spied on Amber, heard, or employed a fraudster to dig into Vernon Unsworthy? Or set private investigators on Martin Tripp? As we were writing this episode, Musk posted a tweet. It was a picture of Jim from the Office, the US Comedy holding up two boards. How do you know who's telling the truth? One board said. The second board gave the answer. The ones trying to silence other people are the ones lying. If we take Musk's post at face value, he's setting his face against anyone trying to silence another person, against anyone trying to stem the free flow of information. Except it could be argued, that's exactly what he's done himself. Not just in 2017 and 2018, but right up until the present day.

[Christina Balan]

I'm Christina Balan I'm well known worldwide as the stubborn women engineer who dared to stand up against the almighty Elon Musk.

[Alexey Mostros]

Christina Balan has been fighting with Elon Musk for more than a decade. She used to work as an engineer for Tesla. She was such a star that her initials were engraved on the batteries inside thousands of their electric cars. But after raising a safety concern about a design flaw, she claims she was pushed out. Christina won a wrongful dismissal case against Tesla, but was then publicly accused by the company of theft and embezzlement. So she took them to court again. She wanted to clear her name, and she didn't know how long she had to do it.

[Christina Balan]

My biggest concern during cancer was, my God, my little one will always have. Sorry, I'm being emotional. My little one, who for him, I'm the hero. I'm the mommy who designs airplanes and cars. His. My memory of me for him will be always questioned. Was he or was not a thief at the criminal. And even if he knows the truth, even if I have the evidence, I couldn't have had a chance to show the world how disgusting Elon Musk really is, how disgusting a company like Tesla really is, and what a bunch of hypocrites they are to know that they are lying and stealing. Didn't not have a heart, not have a decency to say she can die. She's fighting the most aggressive type of cancer. It's time for us to just say, I'm sorry she didn't do any of those crimes.

[Alexey Mostros]

Despite battling an aggressive form of cancer, Cristina wanted to fight her case in open court. But Musk and Tesla seem determined that that won't happen. Like other Tesla employees, including Carl Hanson and Sean Guthrow, the two security guys from episode two, Christina has been forced to defend herself against Tesla in private arbitration proceedings, proceedings which might never be made public even if she wins.

[Christina Balan]

So what Tesla did a few months later, they went an appeal to have my case public. And the court of appeal told them that they are right and every single person who ever signed an arbitration agreement, they are bound for life in going to arbitration.

[Alexey Mostros]

So they reversed the decision of the first judge. Correct. And so that put you back into this private arbitration?

[Christina Balan]

Correct.

[Alexey Mostros]

To me, this is hard to justify. Why should Tesla be allowed to accuse Cristina of a crime in public and then compel her to defend herself behind closed doors? Particularly when Musk, Tesla's boss, publicly states that he's against anyone trying to silence anyone else. In May 2023, a group of US senators wrote to Musk saying that they were incredibly troubled by Tesla' use of forced arbitration clauses. The politicians accused the company of ignoring reportedly deplorable and discriminatory conditions and of using arbitration agreements to limit regulatory authorities ability to protect Tesla customers and employees. Far from fighting against those who seek to silence information in his corporate life, at least Musk continues to to do the opposite. By the way, during this period that she was battling Tesla, Christina also alleges that she was subject to surveillance. During either of the legal battles that you had with Tesla, did you see evidence of private investigators or unlawful surveillance?

[Christina Balan]

Yes. From the time that I, I filed my lawsuit in January 2019, I encountered quite a few vehicles that was following me around.

[Alexey Mostros]

People following you?

[Christina Balan]

Yeah.

[Alexey Mostros]

A note was even pinned to her door.

[Christina Balan]

I had a very scary note taped on my door in which they said, if you care about your son.

[Alexey Mostros]

You.

[Christina Balan]

Will drop your lawsuit. And sadly I don't have the evidence of that because my, let's say my reptilian brain of a mother, when I saw that, I just went and pick it up and rip it to pieces because my little one was behind me.

[Alexey Mostros]

I can't say that Musk or his investigators had any anything to do with the note. I've spoken to Christina's ex partner who remembers her seeing it, but it might have been put there by an ardent Tesla fan, of which there are many, or by someone else entirely. Still, it leaves a chill.

[Naomi Ekparigan]

Want a workout that actually works? Hydro delivers a full body workout that hits 86% of your muscles in just 20 minutes. Rowing with Hydro combines strength and cardio with thousands of workouts led by Olympians in breathtaking locations. No wonder nine out of ten members are still active one year later. Try Hydrow risk free at hydrow.com and use code row to save up to $475 off your Hydrow Pro Rower. That's H Y-R-O-W.com code row this Mother's.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

Day show the moms in your life just how much they mean to you with a stunning bouquet from 1-800-flowers.com for almost 50 years, 1-800-flowers has set the standard for high quality bouquets. Right now, order early from 1-800-FLOWERS and save up to 40% on gorgeous bouquets and one of a kind arrangements guaranteed to make her day. Save up to 40% today at 1-800-flowers.com acast. That's 1-800-flowers. Com acasth, the official florist of Mother's Day.

[Hamza Yousaf]

Hi guys.

[Alexey Mostros]

Hey. How's your name? Holman. Yes, all good.

[Hamza Yousaf]

Just very, very busy as parliamentary days happen to be, but less busy than if I was in the front bench having to answer lots of questions. So small mercies.

[Alexey Mostros]

This summer, SpaceX helped make history when four private citizens who had orbited Earth in a SpaceX capsule went on to complete the first all civilian spacewalk. Another impressive feat for Elon Musk. But earlier this summer, his attention on social media was elsewhere. After the murders of three young girls at a Taylor Swift themed dance class, riots broke out in parts of the uk. Misinformation swirled on social media. Elements of the far right became convinced, incorrectly, that the killer was a Muslim refugee. Musk predicted that civil war would break out in the uk and he criticized the Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, saying Britain was turned turning into the Soviet Union. He also rekindled an old spat with the former First Minister of Scotland, Hamza Yousef. How did your relationship, if I can characterize that, with Elon Musk all begin? How did it all start and when?

[Hamza Yousaf]

Well, to be honest, I can't say I have a relationship with Elon Musk. I've never met the individual, but we've of course had interactions and really it took me by surprise.

[Alexey Mostros]

Back in 2020, Humza made a speech to the Scottish Parliament. At the time, he was Justice Secretary and he told his fellow politicians that Scotland had a clear issue with structural racism. When Elon Musk saw an edited video of that speech, he took to Twitter to brand the politician as a blatant racist. Humza hit back, accusing Musk of racism, something he stands by. Would you go so far as to say he's racist?

[Hamza Yousaf]

I don't doubt for a moment that he absolutely is a racist. Has racist sympathies, amplifies racists, believes in white supremacist conspiracy theories. I mean, I think there can be little doubt on that given the various interventions he's made over the years.

[Alexey Mostros]

Tension between the pair has bubbled away for years, but it was during the riots, when they boiled over, Hamza called Musk one of the most dangerous men on the planet, prompting Musk to describe the politician as a super racist. But this time, just as he's done in the past, Musk took it a step further. The tweets that he sent you that really caught my eye, included ones that said, I dare that scumbag to sue me. Go ahead, make my day. And then this is the important one. Legal discovery will show that however big a racist he's been in public communications, he is vastly worse in private communications.

[Hamza Yousaf]

It's an attempt to threaten and intimidate me. And let me be clear. Elon Musk could have trillions, let alone billions, and he wouldn't be able to shut me up. And we're going to continue to call out his racist, far right white supremacist tendencies. But that caught me by surprise and I started to wonder what it was he was possibly talking about and thought, well, okay, this is somebody who obviously has access to Twitter DMs or XDM's, by the way, that should ring alarm bells for people. Those private conversations you have in your DMs, how secure are they or will they be used by this multimillionaire sociopath megalomaniac who is aligned to the far right?

[Alexey Mostros]

Musk's tweet about Humza's private communications could be interpreted in a few ways. It could be purely speculative, but it has a sinister feel to it. But do you suspect that he might have accessed your messages on Twitter?

[Hamza Yousaf]

Oh, I'm certain. Oh, I'm certain he absolutely does. And I'm certain he scours anybody who he scours the private messages of those that he sees as a threat. In fact, certainly as a whole team of people who are now looking at any information that they can gather on me and try to use it to try to besmirch, as I say, my reputation and they'll use any nefarious tactics in order to do that.

[Alexey Mostros]

You said that in a kind of blase way that you went back and you looked through your private messages to see if there was anything kind of incriminating. But if you look at, I mean, if I look at it, I find it absolutely extraordinary that you felt worried enough to do that.

[Hamza Yousaf]

Yeah, yeah. And again, it was more out of just complete and utter confusion about what the heck he was talking about, like what kind of a very pointed accusation that he's trying to make. And most people, you know, who commented underneath it are saying the same thing. Well, you know, go on. Elon releases Twitter DMs. And, and I'm thinking, what is that? I mean, I've been on Twitter for a long time and have I made an off color joke? Have I said something in a private communication? So I thought I better do the belt and braces thing. And as I said, there was nothing there. And unsurprisingly so. But here is somebody who's basically saying to me, by the way, you better watch out. I'm going to release stuff on you and it's going to make your life hell.

[Alexey Mostros]

Hamza is concerned enough to spend time scrolling through his old messages. Was there anything he could have said that Musk could use against him? As I was listening to Hamza talk about this, I kept thinking, this is not a great look for democracy. Hamza was the first minister of Scotland. He was a powerful guy, a democratically elected leader. And yet here he is searching through his private messages on Twitter because he. He's concerned that the platform's owner could gain access to them. Do you think that his reference to private communications might refer to messages outside Twitter?

[Hamza Yousaf]

That's the fear. That is genuinely the fear is that here is somebody with almost unlimited amounts of wealth. I mean, I saw a report a couple of days ago that he could be the world's first trillionaire in the next few years. And I have no doubt that he would use that wealth in the most nefarious ways possible if he thought somebody was a threat or took a dislike to them, as he has to me. And what I noticed from when you reached out to me is that there is a pattern of behavior. Look, I'm very concerned about Elon Musk. I've described him, and I repeat this charge that he's one of the most dangerous men on the planet. He's unaccountable, one of the wealthiest, by some accounts the wealthiest man, an individual on the planet. He does what he wants, says what he wants, and does not care about the consequences.

[Alexey Mostros]

There is no evidence to suggest that Musk has accessed Humes messages or any of his other private communications. I asked Musk about this, but he didn't respond to requests for comment. We understand he denies ever accessing private messages on Twitter. When Walter Isaacson's book on Musk came out last year, it was reviewed by the Guardian. The headline, which still makes me laugh a bit, was, Elon Musk Pillock Genius or both? Having spent a few months looking into Musk's life, it's clear to me that the answer is both. Musk is a man with the geopolitical power to sway wars, to swing public opinion behind one politician or another, to put humans on Mars, to save us from a fossil fuel future. He's a man who can transform reality simply through the force of his own will. It makes me think back to what Jim Cantrell, Musk's old SpaceX buddy, told us.

[Hamza Yousaf]

I would have to say he's the most brilliant man I've ever met, the most ambitious man I've ever met, and the one person that you don't ever want to fight with or underestimate.

[Alexey Mostros]

Musk has a force in him that lets him build companies and machines that no one thought possible. That's admirable. But to me, it's this same force, this same desire to control the world around him rather than let it control him. That explains why he targets whistleblowers, why he spies on his critics, and why, allegedly, he put his then partner under surveillance. When I started this investigation, I had three main questions. Does Musk use private investigators in both his public and his private life? Does that show a pattern of behavior that tells us something about his character? And finally, is there evidence that Musk, or people acting foolish him, were willing to push the boundaries when it came to how that information was obtained? Speaking with Vernon, digging through the documents from Martin Tripp's case and hearing about what happened with Amber heard, I can say that the answer to these questions is yes. The thing that lingered from Bash's investigation last year was it was the start of something bigger. As I write this, we're almost exactly a month out from the US Presidential election. A moment of global consequence. The more I think about it, the importance of this investigation doesn't hinge on whether Donald Trump or Kamala Harris wins. Musk has grown so big he doesn't need the ear of a president to expand his power and influence over how we all live. His Starlink company gives him control over large swathes of the global Internet. More than half the satellites in space belong to him. That alone embeds Musk in the fabric of geopolitics and global communication. And that's not counting SpaceX and its contracts with NASA. It's not counting Tesla or X or companies like Neuralink. Whether you choose to engage with him or not, Musk is shaping your world and mine. So it matters how he does that, how he controls information, how he seeks to shape his own reality behind the scenes when no one else is looking. Elon Spies is presented by me, Alexey Mostros. It's co written by me and Gary Marshall, who is also the series producer. Original composition and sound design by Tom Kinsella. Podcast artwork is by John Hill. This episode was fact checked by Chloe Hajimatheo. The executive producer is Kerry Thomas.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

Tortoise.

[Naomi Ekparigan]

Want a workout that actually works? Hydro delivers a full body workout that hits 86% of your muscles in just 20 minutes. Rowing with Hydro combines strength and cardio with thousands of workouts led by Olympians in breathtaking locations. No wonder nine out of ten members are still active one year later. Try Hydro risk free at hydrow.com and use code row to save up to $475 off your Hydrow Pro Rower. That's H Y-R-O-W.com code row this Mother's.

[Chloe Hegemotheo]

Day show the moms in your life just how much they mean to you with a stunning bouquet from 1-800-flowers.com for almost 50 years, 1-800-flowers has set the standard for high quality bouquets. Right now, order early from 1-800-FLOWERS and save up to 40% on gorgeous bouquets and one of a kind arrangements guaranteed to make her day. Save up to 40% today at 1800-flowers.com acast that's 1-800-flowers.com acast, the official florist of Mother's Day. Support for this podcast and the following message is brought to you by E Trade for Morgan Stanley. With E Trade, you can dive into the market with easy to use tools, $0 commissions and a wide range of investments. And now there's even more to love. Get access to industry leading research and insights from Morgan Stanley to help guide your decisions. Open an account and get up to $1,000 or more with a qualifying deposit. Get started [e-mail] terms and other fees apply. Investing involves risks. Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC Member SIPIC etrade is a business of Morgan Stanley. Every idea starts with a problem. Warby Parker's was glasses are too expensive. So they set out to change that. By designing glasses in house and selling directly to customers, they're able to offer prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Warby Parker glasses are made from premium materials like impact resistant polycarbonate and custom acetate, and they start at just $95, including prescription lenses. Get glasses made from the good stuff. Stop by a Warby Parker store near.