Masters in Business: Influencing Capital Allocation with Karen Reece
Podcast Information:
- Title: Masters in Business
- Host: Barry Ritholtz, Bloomberg Radio
- Guest: Karen Reece, Former Vanguard Group Executive, Board Member at HarborVest Partners
- Release Date: May 9, 2025
Introduction
In this insightful episode of Masters in Business, Barry Ritholtz welcomes Karen Reece, a pivotal figure from the Vanguard Group, currently transitioning to HarborVest Partners. With nearly three decades at Vanguard, Karen has been instrumental in driving initiatives, growth, and the development of new products, including the Vanguard RIA—an internal advisory service managing approximately $350 billion. Her journey offers a deep dive into working within a rapidly expanding organization renowned for managing trillions in assets.
Karen Reece’s Career Journey at Vanguard
Early Career and Education: Karen Reece began her career with a Bachelor's in Finance and an MBA from Villanova. Initially contemplating art school, her path shifted towards finance after working at Sunoco and then joining Vanguard in 1997 as an investment analyst.
“I initially actually wanted to go to art school. Little known fact.”
— Karen Reece [02:37]
Growth Within Vanguard: Karen’s 28-year tenure at Vanguard saw her rise through various roles, thanks to the firm's strong rotational culture. She contributed to corporate strategy, institutional and retail divisions, and ultimately led strategy, product marketing, communications, and investment product development.
“Throughout the 27 years though, I had, as you know, a bunch of different roles at Vanguard. Really strong rotational culture at the firm.”
— Karen Reece [06:31]
Vanguard’s Corporate Culture and Leadership
Leadership Influence: Karen discusses the influence of Vanguard’s leaders, including Jack Brennan, Bill McNabb, and Tim Buckley. She highlights Jack Bogle’s lasting legacy on the firm's ethos and her direct work with Brennan and McNabb, which significantly shaped her career.
“Jack Bogle certainly was out in the industry and vocal, but at the firm level you're right, we didn't do a lot of advertising.”
— Karen Reece [07:26]
Headquarters Location: Vanguard’s decision to remain headquartered in Malvern, Pennsylvania, rather than relocating to financial hubs like New York or Boston, has fostered a culture more reflective of "Main Street" than "Wall Street." This strategic choice has influenced the firm’s culture and talent acquisition.
“Our culture is really reflection more of Main Street than Wall Street.”
— Karen Reece [13:48]
Investment Strategies and Capital Allocation
Active vs. Passive Management: Despite Vanguard’s reputation for broad indexing, Karen sheds light on the company’s substantial active equity management, overseeing nearly a trillion dollars in active equity. She explains the distinction between Vanguard’s in-house active fixed income management versus externally managed active equity funds.
“For Vanguard, it means investment product development. So I had oversight of our 420 Plus. The number's probably even greater now. First mutual funds and increasingly ETFs.”
— Karen Reece [08:54]
Collaborations and Partnerships: Karen details Vanguard's partnerships with firms like HarborVest, enhancing their private equity offerings and democratizing access to alternative investments for retail investors.
“Vanguard continues to work with HarborVest, and now I'm looking forward to working with them in a different capacity.”
— Karen Reece [23:35]
Vanguard’s Response to Financial Crises
Leadership During the Financial Crisis: Reflecting on the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), Karen praises CEO Bill McNabb for his calm and reassuring leadership, which emphasized maintaining strategic priorities and investing in long-term goals.
“There was an explicit assurance that we were going to keep calm and carry on and really importantly, continue investing in our strategic priorities.”
— Karen Reece [17:22]
Impact of Cost Focus: Karen discusses the "Vanguard Effect," wherein the firm's relentless focus on low costs has saved investors significant amounts, fostering a client-centric approach that prioritizes expense ratios as a key factor in portfolio construction.
“We counsel our investors and our clients to focus on the things they can control and expense ratios... keeping costs low is something that Vanguard feels obligated to do.”
— Karen Reece [19:12]
Evolution into Private Markets
Diversification into Private Equity and Credit: Karen elaborates on Vanguard’s strategic move to include private equity and private credit in their offerings, aiming to broaden investment opportunities for mainstream investors. She emphasizes the importance of selecting top-quality managers at fair prices to maintain Vanguard’s low-cost reputation.
“I think investors should expect to pay more for a private equity offer or private credit offer... getting a top quality manager at a fair price.”
— Karen Reece [26:25]
Democratizing Access: She underscores Vanguard’s mission to democratize access to private markets, making these traditionally exclusive investments available to a wider retail audience.
“I think there's a place for private assets in that, but that'll be up to the current team to decide.”
— Karen Reece [27:24]
Leadership and Diversity Initiatives
Vanguard Women’s Initiative for Leadership Success (WILLS): Karen co-founded WILLS, an employee resource group focused on empowering women within Vanguard. This initiative, supported from the top down, aims to foster leadership and support diversity across various specializations within the firm.
“The importance of encouraging women and helping them develop into leaders at Vanguard... developing into the highest potential leaders.”
— Karen Reece [38:07]
Advice for Aspiring Women Leaders: Karen advises young women to take risks, develop and share their viewpoints, and proactively seek leadership opportunities. She emphasizes overcoming confidence gaps and being explicit about aspirations within the organization.
“Don’t be afraid to take a risk... develop a point of view and be willing to share it.”
— Karen Reece [39:22]
Philanthropy and Board Roles
Involvement with Vanguard Foundation and HarborVest: Karen discusses her roles on various boards, including the Vanguard Foundation and Vanguard Charitable, highlighting her commitment to philanthropy and community engagement. She is set to join HarborVest Partners’ board, continuing her influence in the private equity space.
“I'm going to be joining their board, really getting to know the firm in a different capacity.”
— Karen Reece [23:03]
Personal Insights and Recommendations
Mentorship and Career Development: Karen credits numerous mentors at Vanguard who shaped her career, including Jeff Molitor, Martha King, Jack Brennan, Bill McNabb, and Tim Buckley. Their guidance and advocacy were pivotal in her professional growth.
“I had a small stable of funds and now we have 400 different options. And I think it also led to the genesis of our personal advisor offer.”
— Karen Reece [33:03]
Books and Continuous Learning: Karen shares her favorite reads, including A Random Walk Down Wall Street by Burton Malkiel and Genius Failed by Roger Lowenstein, which provided foundational knowledge in passive investing and hedge funds, respectively.
“A random walk down Wall Street... a required reading on the benefits of passive investing.”
— Karen Reece [44:55]
Advice for Recent Graduates: Karen advises new graduates to prioritize the company’s mission and culture over job titles or salaries, contribute beyond their job descriptions, and invest in understanding the company’s history and context.
“Pay attention to the company and the mission and purpose of that company. Be proud of the company you work for.”
— Karen Reece [47:45]
Reflections on Financial Planning: She emphasizes the importance of living below one’s means, investing early, and taking advantage of compounding—a principle she learned from Vanguard’s leadership.
“Live below your means... invest in the 401 and take advantage of the company match and build up an emergency fund.”
— Karen Reece [48:58]
Conclusion
Karen Reece’s extensive experience at Vanguard offers a comprehensive look into effective capital allocation, the importance of low-cost investment strategies, and the evolution of investment products to include private markets. Her insights into leadership, diversity, and strategic growth provide valuable lessons for professionals in wealth management and aspiring financial leaders.
Notable Quotes
- Karen Reece [02:37]: “I initially actually wanted to go to art school. Little known fact.”
- Karen Reece [06:31]: “Really strong rotational culture at the firm.”
- Karen Reece [07:26]: “Jack Bogle certainly was out in the industry and vocal, but at the firm level you're right, we didn't do a lot of advertising.”
- Karen Reece [13:48]: “Our culture is really reflection more of Main Street than Wall Street.”
- Karen Reece [17:22]: “There was an explicit assurance that we were going to keep calm and carry on and really importantly, continue investing in our strategic priorities.”
- Karen Reece [19:12]: “Keeping costs low is something that Vanguard feels obligated to do.”
- Karen Reece [23:35]: “Vanguard continues to work with HarborVest, and now I'm looking forward to working with them in a different capacity.”
- Karen Reece [26:25]: “I want to know that I'm getting a top quality manager at a fair price.”
- Karen Reece [38:07]: “The importance of encouraging women and helping them develop into leaders at Vanguard.”
- Karen Reece [39:22]: “Don’t be afraid to take a risk... develop a point of view and be willing to share it.”
- Karen Reece [47:45]: “Pay attention to the company and the mission and purpose of that company. Be proud of the company you work for.”
- Karen Reece [48:58]: “Live below your means... invest in the 401 and take advantage of the company match and build up an emergency fund.”
Listen to the full episode on iTunes, Spotify, YouTube, Bloomberg, or your favorite podcast platform.