Team Favorite At the Money: Valuation Is an Exercise in Faith

Summary

Masters in Business: Episode Summary Episode: Team Favorite At the Money: Valuation Is an Exercise in Faith
Release Date: February 19, 2025
Host: Bloomberg Radio's Barry Ritholtz
Guest: Professor Aswath Damodaran, NYU School of Business

---

Introduction

In the episode titled "Team Favorite At the Money: Valuation Is an Exercise in Faith," Bloomberg Radio host Barry Ritholtz engages in a profound discussion with Professor Aswath Damodaran, renowned as the Dean of Valuation. The conversation delves deep into the intricacies of equity valuation, distinguishing between intrinsic value and market price, and exploring the psychological facets underpinning investment decisions.

---

The Importance of Valuation in Equities

Barry Ritholtz opens the discussion by addressing the fundamental question: Why are valuations so important when it comes to equities? He succinctly differentiates between traders and investors, emphasizing that valuation is paramount for investors who seek to understand the true worth of their investments beyond mere price movements.

Ritholtz [03:17]: "Value matters if you're an investor. To me, the definition of an investor is you buy something for less than what it's worth."

Professor Damodaran underscores the criticality of identifying the intrinsic value of a company, which involves a comprehensive analysis of cash flows, growth prospects, and associated risks.

---

Intrinsic Value vs. Market Price

A significant portion of the conversation revolves around distinguishing intrinsic value from market price. Ritholtz argues that while market prices fluctuate based on supply and demand dynamics, intrinsic value is anchored in the company's fundamental financial metrics.

Ritholtz [10:21]: "Value is driven by changes in your earnings, cash flows, growth and risk... Price is driven by demand and supply, driven by mood and momentum."

Professor Damodaran adds that various valuation multiples like price-to-earnings (P/E), price-to-sales (P/S), and price-to-book (P/B) ratios are more reflective of market pricing rather than intrinsic value assessment.

Damodaran [06:46]: "When people look at stocks that way, they're looking at price and relative valuation, not intrinsic value."

---

Methods of Valuation

The duo delves into the methodologies employed in determining intrinsic value. Ritholtz emphasizes the age-old approach focusing on cash flows, growth, and risk.

Ritholtz [03:59]: "It's cash flows, growth and risk. That's the essence of value."

They discuss how intrinsic valuation requires a deep understanding of the business, including its revenue models and cost structures. Ritholtz illustrates this with his personal investment in Nvidia, highlighting the necessity of comprehending whether a company is merely manufacturing chips or designing them, as it significantly impacts cash flow estimations.

Ritholtz [07:10]: "I started with a presumption that was a computer chip company... But as I started digging deeper, I realized that they're not a Chip maker. They're a chip designer."

---

Investing vs. Trading

Ritholtz paints a clear distinction between investing and trading. For investors, understanding intrinsic value is crucial, whereas traders might prioritize technical indicators and market sentiment.

Ritholtz [13:21]: "If you're playing the trading game, don't lie to yourself about caring about fundamentals and earnings and cash flows. Just play the trading game."

He advocates for investors to do their homework, suggesting that even those without formal training in accounting should strive to understand financial statements to gauge a company's value effectively.

---

Behavioral Aspects and Market Dynamics

The conversation shifts to the psychological elements influencing market prices. Ritholtz references behavioral finance, explaining how mood and momentum can cause prices to deviate from intrinsic values for extended periods.

Ritholtz [10:21]: "Behavioral finance tries to explain why price can not only deviate from value but stay different for long periods."

He likens investing to an act of faith, acknowledging the uncertainty inherent in expecting market prices to align with intrinsic values.

Ritholtz [11:51]: "The essence of investing is faith. Faith that your estimated value is the right value and faith that the price will move to value."

---

Mean Reversion and Long-Term Expectations

Professor Damodaran introduces the concept of mean reversion, where overpriced assets eventually return to their fair values. However, he cautions that this process is neither guaranteed nor predictable in its timeline.

Damodaran [11:51]: "Does that mean reversion always occur? It's not just mean reversion, it's assumption that values what matters in the long term."

Ritholtz echoes this sentiment, emphasizing that intrinsic value is dynamic and subject to change based on evolving business fundamentals.

Ritholtz [10:21]: "Intrinsic value can change. Price is driven by demand and supply, driven by mood and momentum."

---

Conclusions and Final Thoughts

As the episode concludes, both Ritholtz and Damodaran reaffirm the significance of valuation in investment decisions. They advise investors to be honest about their investment strategies, whether leaning towards trading or intrinsic value-based investing.

Damodaran [13:21]: "When we think about valuation, investors should be aware of the variations in valuations. The more you pay for something, the lower your future expected returns are."

Ritholtz encapsulates the essence of investing as an exercise that requires both analytical rigor and psychological resilience.

Ritholtz [14:15]: "The essence of investing is you got to be able to look through those financial statements and be able to gauge the value of a company."

---

Key Takeaways

1. Intrinsic Value vs. Market Price: Understanding the difference is crucial for making informed investment decisions.
2. Valuation Fundamentals: Focus on cash flows, growth prospects, and risk assessments to determine a company's true worth.
3. Investor vs. Trader Mindset: Align your investment strategy with your approach—whether it’s fundamental analysis or technical trading.
4. Behavioral Finance: Recognize how emotions and momentum can impact market prices, sometimes causing prolonged deviations from intrinsic value.
5. Faith in Investing: Accept the inherent uncertainties and the role of belief in expecting market prices to align with intrinsic values over time.

---

This episode provides a comprehensive exploration of valuation, offering listeners valuable insights into the art and science of assessing investment opportunities. Whether you're an aspiring investor or a seasoned trader, the discussion equips you with the knowledge to navigate the complex landscape of equity markets effectively.

Transcript

[Oracle Representative]

AI is rewriting the business playbook with productivity boosts and faster decision making coming to every industry. If you're not thinking about AI, you can bet your competition is. This is not where you want to drop the ball, but AI requires a lot of compute power and with most cloud platforms, the cost for your AI workloads can spiral. That is, unless you're running on oci. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure this was the cloud built for AI, a blazing, fast, enterprise grade platform for your infrastructure, database, apps and all your AI workloads. OCI costs 50% less than other major hyperscalers for compute, 70% less for storage and 80% less for networking. Thousands of businesses have already scored with oci, including Vodafone, Thomson Reuters and Suno AI. Now the ball's in your court.

[Barry Ritholtz]

Right now, Oracle can cut your current cloud bill in half if you move to OCI. Minimum financial commitment and other terms apply. Offer ends March 31st. See if your company qualifies for this special [e-mail] strategic that's oracle.com strategic this.

[Intuit Representative]

Is a message from sponsor Intuit. TurboTax Taxes was waiting to get your money back, which turned into worrying about getting your money back. Now Taxes is matching with a TurboTax expert who can do your taxes today and help you get up to a $4,000 refund advance loan fast. Get an expert on TurboTax.com only available with TurboTax Live. Full service refund advance has $0 loan fees and 0% APR. Refund advance loans may be issued by First Century Bank, NA or Web bank terms apply. Subject to approval. Bloomberg Audio Studios Podcasts Radio News Cause.

[Barry Ritholtz]

I gotta have faith, I gotta have fam. Because I got to grapple.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

Baby. Oscar Wilde once described a cynic as a man who knows the price of everything but the value of nothing. Nowhere is understanding value more important than in the stock market. Sure, prices get quoted every second every tick, but value? That's a much more challenging problem. Whether you're buying broad indices or purchasing specific stocks, it pays to not be a cynic and understand both price and value of your investments. Hi, I'm Barry Ritholtz and on today's edition of at the Money, we're going to explain how to become more savvy about understanding equity values. The value you pay for your investment has an outsized impact on your long term returns. To help us unpack all of this and what it means for your portfolio, let's bring in Professor Aswath Damadouran of NYU School of Business. He is often Referred to as the Dean of Valuation for his extensive work in the area. He's written numerous books on the subject, including Damadoran on Valuation Narrative and Numbers and the textbook Investment Valuation Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset. So, professor, let's just start with the basic question. Why are valuations so important when it comes to equities?

[Barry Ritholtz]

I'm going to give you a cynical answer. They're not important if you're a trader. Traders live on pricing. The essence of pricing is you buy at a low price, you sell at a high price, and it doesn't really matter why the price changes if you get the direction right. Value matters if you're an investor. To me, the definition of an investor is you buy something for less than what it's worth. And the essence of value is you're trying to estimate what something is worth. But most before, as I said, it depends on the philosophy you bring in. Are you an investor? Are you a trader? Because that's going to drive whether value matters to you.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So let's talk about identifying that intrinsic value of what something is worth with any specific company. How can you determine that valuation?

[Barry Ritholtz]

It's as old as time. That Venetian glassmaker who sold his business in the Middle Ages, probably sold it to somebody, bought it because of the cash flows he generated, the risk in those cash flows, and how much those cash flows are going to grow. It's cash flows, growth and risk. That's the essence of value. That's always been true. We act like we invented valuation in the last century in finance because we came up with all these neat little models and metrics to measure risk and bring it into what you need to make. But value has always been driven by cash flows, growth and risk. And how you get to that value can come from different pathways. I use intrinsic valuation in that sense as capturing anybody who thinks about those fundamentals.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So let's dive into that intrinsic valuation based on cash flow, growth and risk. What different ways are there to measure the fundamental value of a company? And how do these different valuations reveal intrinsic value?

[Barry Ritholtz]

I mean, ultimately, cash flows, growth and risk are not going to be different for different people. The way we think about risk, though, can differ depending on who you are as an investor and what you think matters. I mean, I'll give you an example. In traditional finance, we think about risk by looking at how prices move for a stock relative to the market. But there are intrinsic value. People argue the true measure of risk is what happens to your earnings, your revenues, your operating metrics. Even within people who believe in intrinsic value, we can have disagreements about how to measure risk, what is the right cash flow to look at, and what's a growth rate that you think about over what period. So while we might have 20 people in a room, all of whom buy into intrinsic value, we can come up with 20 different estimates of intrinsic value for the same company at the same point in time.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So we always hear about price to sales, price to book, price to earnings. Are these all that different? They're just variations on fundamentals or are they very different ways of looking at the same company?

[Barry Ritholtz]

Philosophically, they're very different. Because when you compute the price earnings or the EV to EBITDA price to book for a company, what you do is you compare to other companies out there and you make a judgment and saying, hey, this company trades at 10 times earnings, other companies like it, and I'm going to put quotes on like it traded 15 times earnings, therefore it's cheap. That's a pricing judgment. There's nothing value in here. There's no intrinsic value judgment. That's why all of sell side equity research, I would argue, is all about pricing, it's not about valuation. Nothing wrong with it, but we should be honest about what we're doing. So when you use ratios, it's because you want to find something cheap by comparing it to other things out there that are being traded right now. And you're looking at what other people.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

Are paying, so you're looking at price. When people look at stocks that way, they're looking at price and relative valuation, not intrinsic value. Let's talk about some of the things you've explained in your books. Valuation requires a deeper understanding of the business, including how it makes money and its future prospects. Give us a little more detail on that.

[Barry Ritholtz]

I'll give you an example, and it's a personal example. I bought Nvidia purely by luck in 2018. I didn't see AI coming. None of this stuff. So sometimes your best investments happen by accident. So last year I had to revalue Nvidia for a simple reason. I mean, I bought it at $27 per share. The stock was trading at $800 per share. And I had to decide, is it time to leave? So as I sat down to value Nvidia, I started with a presumption that was a computer chip company that had made chips and sold them. And I had to estimate cash flows based on that. It's only as I started digging a little deeper that I realized that they're not a Chip maker. They're a chip designer. Every Nvidia chip is made by tsmc, which basically changes the way you think about the business. If you're doing pricing, you might be able to gloss over it. It doesn't matter that they do it. But if you're doing intrinsic valuation, because I have to estimate cash flows, I have to think about what is it that they spend to create these revenues. And that requires an understanding of how they conduct their business. I mean, Warren Buffett, a famous saying that he doesn't buy stocks, he buys shares of businesses. That, to me, in essence, is what you're doing in intrinsic valuation. You're not buying a share of Apple or a share of Amazon. You're buying a slice of those businesses. And if that's what you're doing, you better understand what you're buying before you pay a price.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So can we apply the same theory of valuation to broad indices as opposed to just individual stocks?

[Barry Ritholtz]

Absolutely. I mean, it's cash flows, growth and risk drive the value of Nvidia Cash flows, growth and risk is what drives the value of the S&P 500 of the NASDAQ. In fact, that's the process I use at the start of every month to come up with an estimate of what investors are pricing in the S&P 500 and what they can expect to earn given the cash flows. The very intrinsic value view of what can you expect to make as a rate of return on an index?

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So that raises the real important question, what do these measures of valuations mean for future expected returns?

[Barry Ritholtz]

The more you pay for something. Let's cut away from all of the noise in this process. The more you pay for something upfront, the lower your expected returns are going to be. Because if you pay more upfront, and that's just common sense, so when you buy the S&P 500 at 5300, you can expect to earn a lower return than if you bought it at 5100. So if you bought it last week, your expected return was lower than if you bought it today. And that's at the basis of intrinsic value. It's about paying the right price for something upfront is the most critical decision you make.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So you consistently, in all your books, emphasize that that value is not price. So how should investors think about the difference between the quoted fluctuated price we see every day, the quoted fluctuating price that we see every moment on the market, and that deep intrinsic value?

[Barry Ritholtz]

Recognize there are two different processes. Nothing makes one better than the other different processes. Value is driven by changes in your earnings, cash flows, growth and risk, and that that's captured by changing value over time. So I'm not saying intrinsic value is somehow a stable, stagnant number. The intrinsic value of Nvidia doubled because of its entry into AI. Intrinsic value can change. Price is driven by demand and supply, driven by mood and momentum. And I think one of the best indicators you can take of mood and momentum is when the momentum is good. All news is good news. In fact, there's a whole segment of finance called behavioral finance. And behavioral finance tries to explain why price can not only deviate from value, but stay different for long periods. There's this inherent belief that value investors have that price will move towards value and it'll happen quickly. That's not true. Price can deviate from value. It can stay separated from value for long periods. Which means if you're an intrinsic value investor, you're going to get incredibly frustrated because you think you got it right, but you keep losing money.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So you're referring to mean reversion. The expectation is that pricey things eventually come back down to fair value and inexpensive things will eventually be recognized and returned to fair value. How long does this process take? Is it guaranteed to happen? Does that mean reversion always occur?

[Barry Ritholtz]

It's not just mean reversion, it's assumption that values what matters in the long term. That. I mean, that's almost. I mean, when I start my valuation class, I started the question, do you have faith? My students look at me, say, it's a valuation class. What are you talking about? I said, the essence of investing is faith. Faith that your estimated value is the right value and faith that the price will move to value. And the essence of faith is if you asked me to prove it and if you told me, tell me what will cause it to happen, my answer is, I don't know. It's a mystery. I mean, it's like going to church and going up to your pastor or your rabbi and saying, can you give me some proof that God exists? I keep coming every, you know, every week because I. And if that rabbi or priest or, you know, is telling you the truth, they should say, look, you know, I can't give you that proof. It's faith. And I think that's what makes investing so difficult, is it's driven by faith rather than by proof. So if you ask me, you know, if I bought something undervalued, am I guaranteed to make money in the long term? Absolutely not. And you have to be okay with it. If you're not okay with it, buy an index fund, don't invest, or be a trader. The essence of investing is you can do everything right and have nothing to show for it. And you have to be okay with that.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

Wow. So, professor, bottom line it for us. When we think about valuation, when investors look at equities, what should be foremost in their mind before deploying capital?

[Barry Ritholtz]

Let's be honest with yourself now. What what is the game you're playing? If you're playing the trading game, don't lie to yourself about caring about fundamentals and earnings and cash flows. Just play the trading game. Look at charts, look at technical indicators, look at mood and momentum, because that's what you play. If you want to be an investor, you need to do your homework. You can't hide behind the fact of I've never done an accounting or evaluation class. I don't understand these financial statements. The essence of investing is you got to be able to look through those financial statements and be able to gauge the value of a company. You might not want to use the full technology of intrinsic valuation, but you need to start thinking about businesses and value in a much more, in a much deeper way than you're doing right now. If that's not your thing, that's fine. There are lots of people who get rich as traders and there's nothing wrong with trading. Just play that game well.

[Professor Aswath Damodaran]

So to wrap up, investors who have a long term time horizon should be very aware of the variations in valuations. The more you pay for a given stock or a given market index, the lower your future expected returns are. Understand that there are no guarantees in the market and merely buying cheap stocks is no guarantee that you're going to outperform or even market perform in the future. I'm Barry Ritholtz and this is Bloomberg's at the Money.

[Barry Ritholtz]

Join Bloomberg in Chicago or via livestream on March 11th for the Future Investor Finding the Opportunities. This 2020 event series will examine how companies are investing in their businesses to create efficiencies, innovating their products and services and improving the customer experience. This series is proudly sponsored by Invesco. Q. Q. Q. [e-mail] FutureInvestorChicago that's Bloomberglive.com FutureInvestorChicago.