Mind of a Serial Killer: Episode 1 – Elizabeth Wettlaufer

Released on November 25, 2024, by Crime House Studios

Introduction

In the premiere episode of Mind of a Serial Killer, hosts Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels delve into the harrowing story of Elizabeth Wettlaufer, Canada's first convicted angel of death serial killer. Wettlaufer, a nurse in southwestern Ontario, systematically murdered eight elderly patients between 2007 and 2014 using her professional access to medications. This episode explores her early life, the psychological turmoil that led to her descent into murder, and the complex interplay of factors that made her capable of such heinous acts.

Early Life and Religious Upbringing

Elizabeth Wettlaufer was born in 1967 to Doug and Hazel, parents deeply embedded in the South Zorra Baptist Church in rural Woodstock, Ontario. Her upbringing was dominated by strict religious doctrines and a conservative fundamentalist environment. Dr. Tristan Engels explains:

"If she's being taught that only her community of people are good and everyone else in the world is bad, that's teaching her to view the world in dichotomous ways."
(05:42)

Wettlaufer's father, a lay pastor, enforced rigid rules that left little room for personal interpretation or deviation. This black-and-white worldview significantly impacted Elizabeth's ability to form nuanced relationships and understand the complexities of human emotions.

Struggles with Sexuality and Conversion Therapy

As Elizabeth entered her teenage years, she grappled with her emerging sexuality. Realizing she was attracted to women, she faced immense internal conflict due to her conservative upbringing. With limited outlets, she confided only in her friend Glenn Hart, who accepted her without judgment. However, her family and church adhered strictly to anti-LGBTQ+ sentiments, leading to profound cognitive dissonance.

“Elizabeth had to keep her secret hidden. She was terrified of what might happen.”
(08:43)

After pursuing a degree in religious counseling, Elizabeth faced severe repercussions when her excursion to a gay-friendly church was discovered. Her parents forced her into gay conversion therapy, a deeply harmful practice aimed at altering her sexual orientation. Dr. Engels emphasizes the detrimental effects of such therapy:

"It's not only degrading and it's shown to cause an increase in substance abuse, depression, anxiety and suicide."
(10:35)

Despite the therapy's intent to suppress her true identity, Elizabeth struggled to deny her inherent attractions, leading to further emotional and psychological strain.

Nursing Career and Substance Abuse

Elizabeth transitioned from religious studies to nursing, securing positions at a local hospital and an assisted living facility. Excelling academically, she initially appeared to thrive in her new roles. However, the internal conflict between her true self and imposed beliefs began to surface. To cope, she turned to alcohol, seeking solace in numbness rather than confronting her turmoil.

"Elizabeth was unable to act on her impulses. She tried bottling up her feelings and when that didn't work, she turned to alcohol to numb the pain."
(14:23)

Her substance abuse escalated, leading to the misuse of medications like Ativan and Valium. In September 1995, her excessive intake resulted in her being fired from her nursing position, though the Ontario Nurses Association facilitated her continuation in the field under strict sobriety conditions.

Onset of Criminal Behavior: Experimenting with Patients

Elizabeth's fragile mental state, compounded by isolation and unresolved sexual identity issues, culminated in her initial forays into criminality. Beginning with non-fatal experimentation on her patients, she administered high doses of insulin to observe their reactions. These actions marked the beginning of her transformation into a serial killer.

"She started stealing drugs from the hospital's medication room... and even opiates like morphine."
(15:35)

Her first fatal act occurred in August 2007 when she administered a lethal dose of insulin to James Silcox, an 84-year-old war veteran suffering from Alzheimer's and diabetes. This act was driven by intrusive thoughts and an internal voice compelling her to "make things right with God."

"Elizabeth knew what to do. She walked over to the fridge where the staff stored medications and picked up a box of insulin cartridges."
(32:57)

Following this, she continued her spree, targeting patients who were vulnerable and unlikely to resist, further entrenching her path of violence.

Psychological Analysis of Wettlaufer's Actions

Dr. Tristan Engels provides a comprehensive analysis of Wettlaufer's psychological state, highlighting the interplay of her religious indoctrination, identity conflicts, and mental health issues. Key factors include:

1. Cognitive Dissonance: Elizabeth's struggle to reconcile her true self with her religious teachings created immense internal conflict.

2. Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD): Diagnosed during a psychiatric stay, BPD contributed to her unstable relationships and emotional volatility.

3. Substance Abuse: Alcohol and drug misuse exacerbated her mental health issues, impairing her judgment and increasing impulsivity.

4. Intrusive Thoughts and Command Hallucinations: Elizabeth experienced voices urging her to commit acts of violence, blurring the lines between reality and delusion.

"She didn't have the emotional regulation skills that she needs, she doesn't have outlets, she's isolated."
(15:35)

These elements combined to create a volatile environment where her capacity for rational decision-making was severely compromised, making her susceptible to committing murder.

Confessions and Lack of Reporting

Elizabeth's pattern of confessing her crimes without facing consequences highlights systemic failures and her manipulative nature. She confessed to multiple individuals, including friends and her pastor, yet none took steps to report her to authorities. This lack of accountability allowed her to continue her killing spree unabated.

"Elizabeth felt free to kill again."
(40:44)

Her confessions served as a means to unburden herself emotionally while simultaneously absolving herself of guilt, further entrenching her in her destructive path.

Conclusion

Episode 1 of Mind of a Serial Killer offers a chilling exploration of Elizabeth Wettlaufer's journey from a constrained upbringing to a calculated murderer. Through detailed storytelling and expert psychological insights, Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels shed light on the complex factors that can drive an individual to commit serial murder. As the episode concludes, listeners are left contemplating the profound question: What makes a serial killer?

Stay tuned for Episode 2, where the hosts will continue to unravel the depths of Wettlaufer's descent into madness and the eventual culmination of her criminal activities.

Notable Quotes

• Dr. Tristan Engels [05:42]:
  "If she's being taught that only her community of people are good and everyone else in the world is bad, that's teaching her to view the world in dichotomous ways."

• Dr. Tristan Engels [10:35]:
  "It's not only degrading and it's shown to cause an increase in substance abuse, depression, anxiety and suicide."

• Dr. Tristan Engels [32:57]:
  "Elizabeth knew what to do. She walked over to the fridge where the staff stored medications and picked up a box of insulin cartridges."

• Dr. Tristan Engels [15:35]:
  "She didn't have the emotional regulation skills that she needs, she doesn't have outlets, she's isolated."

Connect with Us

For more true crime content and updates, follow Mind of a Serial Killer on Instagram and TikTok @crimehouse. Subscribe to Mind of a Serial Killer wherever you get your podcasts, and enhance your listening experience by subscribing to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts for ad-free episodes and exclusive bonus content.