Mind of a Serial Killer: Herbert Mullin Pt. 1 – Detailed Summary

Released on December 23, 2024 by Crime House

Introduction

In the premiere episode of "Mind of a Serial Killer," hosted by Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels, listeners are introduced to Herbert Mullin, a once well-regarded individual whose descent into madness led to the tragic deaths of 13 people in Santa Cruz during the early 1970s. This episode delves deep into Mullin's background, exploring the factors that contributed to his transformation from a promising young man to a notorious serial killer.

Early Life and Upbringing

Vanessa Richardson opens the discussion by painting a picture of Herbert Mullin's childhood:

"On April 18, 1947, Herbert Mullin was born into a typical suburban, post-war American family. Herb's family consisted of an older sister, a devout Catholic mother, and a father, William, who'd served in the Marines before becoming a salesman." ([06:12])

Herbert's family frequently relocated across Northern California due to his father's job, a factor Herbert later perceived as a means to destabilize his upbringing:

"He thought the constant relocation was unfair and viewed it as his parents' intentional move to hold him back." ([06:58])

Dr. Tristan Engels adds a psychological perspective on the impact of frequent moves during childhood:

"Children who move frequently during critical developmental years can have deficits in the acquisition of proper social skills as well as emotional development... It can make it more difficult for that child to find their own identity." ([06:58])

Despite these challenges, Herbert appeared to thrive during his teenage years after settling in Felton, excelling academically, socially, and in extracurricular activities like sports and marksmanship ([08:02]).

The Tragic Loss of Dean

Herbert's life took a dark turn in 1965 when his best friend, Dean, died in a car accident shortly after Herbert graduated high school. This loss profoundly affected him:

"Dean's death had a profound impact on Herb's emotional state. He cried for weeks and would spend hours in his room, assembling candles and photos of Dean in what some said looked like a shrine." ([08:02])

Dr. Engels explains the lack of coping mechanisms to deal with such a loss:

"At that age, not many of us have experienced a close loss like that, so he likely did not have the coping skills to manage that loss." ([09:38])

College Years and Onset of Mental Illness

Herbert continued his education, enrolling in community college as an engineering student and maintaining a solid academic record. However, his college years marked the beginning of his experimentation with illegal substances and a significant shift in his personality:

"He'd gone from studious and likable to unpredictable and moody." ([10:37])

In 1968, significant changes occurred:

• Dropping out of college
• Breaking off his engagement
• Being arrested for marijuana possession ([10:37])

These events were early signs of what Dr. Engels identifies as the first major indicators of Mullin's psychosis:

"He admitted himself to the Mendocino State Hospital... They diagnosed him with schizophrenic reaction, the former name for schizophrenia." ([13:23])

Herbert Mullin's Diagnosis and Treatment

Despite his diagnosis, Herbert only remained hospitalized for six weeks before voluntarily discharging himself. Post-discharge, his delusions intensified, leading him to engage in self-destructive behaviors and violent commands from perceived voices:

"The voices in Herb's head were giving him orders, dangerous ones. When he moved in with a friend... and he listened." ([16:27])

Dr. Engels clarifies misconceptions about schizophrenia and violence:

"Schizophrenia is a spectrum, and there's a very small percentage of individuals who have been diagnosed with schizophrenia who have been violent." ([14:46])

Herbert's non-compliance with treatment and the lack of accessible mental health resources further exacerbated his condition, leaving him vulnerable to deepening delusions ([18:05]).

The Descent into Violence

Back with his parents in Felton in the fall of 1972, Herbert's mental state deteriorated further. He developed a fixation on preventing an impending earthquake through human sacrifices, a belief compounded by perceived telepathic commands from his father:

"He believed he had to, quote, make a sacrifice to prevent a repeat of the earthquake that had occurred on his birthday that was predicted for a few months hence." ([23:03])

First Murders: Lawrence White and Mary Guilfoyle

On October 13, 1972, Herbert's descent into violence began. While running an errand, he encountered Lawrence White, a homeless man, and attacked him:

"Herb attacked Lawrence, bludgeoning him to death. Then he hid the body in the dense brush along the road." ([25:33])

Eleven days later, Herbert picked up Mary Guilfoyle, a student hitchhiker, and brutally murdered her:

"Herb pulled Mary's body from the car and proceeded to cut her open, examining her organs in a horrific kind of autopsy." ([27:13])

Dr. Engels analyzes these actions, noting the ritualistic nature of Mary's murder compared to the more spontaneous killing of Lawrence:

"Mary's killing seemed much more intentional and less spontaneous." ([27:13])

Killing Father Henri Thome

On November 2, 1972, Herbert targeted Father Henri Thome at St. Mary's Catholic Church on All Souls Day. Armed with a knife, he attempted to make a sacred space the scene of another sacrifice but was confronted by the priest:

"Father Tomei managed to fight back. He landed a kick to Herb's head, stunning him. But it didn't buy him enough time to get away. Herb stabbed Father Tomei until he lay dead in the confessional." ([29:49])

Despite the violent nature of these killings, Herbert's actions were primarily driven by his delusional beliefs rather than inherent malice or psychopathy.

Escalation and Final Murders

By December 1972, Herbert had acquired a .22 caliber pistol, enhancing his capacity for violence. Despite earthquake predictions being publicly refuted by Reuben Greenspan, Herbert remained steadfast in his belief that his sacrifices were necessary, leading him to attempt rejoining the Marines—a move that was ultimately rejected and intensified his delusional state:

"This is very common with delusions. No matter what evidence is presented to the individual that challenges that delusion, they will find Something that confirms or strengthens it." ([35:34])

Herbert's rejection from the Marines led to familial conflict, resulting in him moving into his own apartment where his resentment toward former friends culminated in a final, tragic act of violence against Kathy Francis and her young sons:

"He shot and killed her. Tragically, Kathy's sons were at the house too. Two boys under the age of 10. Herb killed them, too." ([42:09])

Investigation and Conclusion of Part 1

The murders of Jim and Joan Genera, along with Kathy Francis and her sons, marked a turning point in the investigation. Ballistic evidence linked these crimes, prompting authorities to connect the dots and pursue Herbert Mullin as a suspect.

Dr. Engels emphasizes the complexity of treating individuals like Herbert:

"Individuals with schizophrenia are more susceptible to developing illusory correlations... It takes a lot of time and trust for clinicians to treat delusions in patients with psychotic disorders." ([44:22])

As the episode concludes, Herbert Mullin remains at large, leaving listeners eager for the continuation of his story in Part 2, where his final victims and the eventual resolution of his killing spree will be explored.

Notable Quotes

• Vanessa Richardson ([06:58]):

  "Research has shown us that children who move frequently during critical developmental years can have deficits in the acquisition of proper social skills as well as emotional development."

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([14:46]):

  "No, that is a myth. That is a huge myth. Schizophrenia is a spectrum, and there's a very small percentage of individuals who have been diagnosed with schizophrenia who have been violent."

• Dr. Tristan Engels ([35:34]):

  "This is very common with delusions. No matter what evidence is presented to the individual that challenges that delusion, they will find something that confirms or strengthens it."

Conclusion

This first part of the Herbert Mullin series provides a comprehensive look into the early life, psychological struggles, and initial acts of violence that defined Mullin's tragic path. By combining true crime storytelling with expert psychological analysis, Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristan Engels offer listeners a nuanced understanding of how Herbert Mullin's delusions and untreated mental illness culminated in a devastating murder spree.

Stay tuned for Part 2, where the final victims and the culmination of Mullin's terror will be dissected, providing answers to the haunting question: What makes a serial killer?

For more true crime content, follow Crime House on Instagram and TikTok. To enhance your listening experience, consider subscribing to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts for ad-free episodes and exclusive bonus content.