Modern Wisdom Podcast Episode #962: Lyman Stone - The Real Reason Birth Rates Are Falling

Host: Chris Williamson
Guest: Lyman Stone
Release Date: July 3, 2025
Podcast: Modern Wisdom

1. Introduction to the Declining Birth Rates

In Episode #962 of Modern Wisdom, host Chris Williamson engages in a profound discussion with Lyman Stone from the Institute for Family Studies. The conversation delves into the multifaceted reasons behind the global decline in birth rates, exploring demographic trends, societal influences, and policy implications.

2. Population Density and Fertility: Correlation vs. Causation

Lyman Stone begins by addressing the intuitive correlation between population density and fertility rates. He explains that denser areas tend to have lower fertility rates, a trend observed across almost all industrialized countries.

Lyman Stone [04:55]:
"Population density predicts everything... one of the things it proxies for is fertility."

However, Stone emphasizes that the simplistic view of density directly causing lower fertility is misleading. He points out that factors like crowded living spaces and small households play a more significant role than mere population numbers.

Lyman Stone [07:46]:
"It's actually tricky when you start looking below the correlational level... crowded living space, like small houses, is what's actually doing the work here."

3. Housing Design and Family-Friendliness

The conversation transitions to how housing design impacts fertility. Stone advocates for dense single-family neighborhoods, such as townhouses with tree-lined sidewalks, which balance high density with family-friendly amenities.

Lyman Stone [08:19]:
"If you want people to have kids, you should go for the less height and the less empty space on the ground. That is townhouses with tree-lined sidewalks are what everyone wants anyways."

Stone argues that these designs make it easier for families to access parks, schools, and neighborly interactions, fostering environments conducive to raising children.

4. Societal and Cultural Factors Influencing Fertility

Stone delves into broader societal influences, citing "developmental idealism"—a framework that views life and civilization as progressing linearly rather than cyclically. This ideology promotes delaying family formation to invest in personal and professional development early in life.

Lyman Stone [24:31]:
"Developmental idealism introduces the idea that there actually is a long run trend that your life progresses linearly, not cyclically."

He links this shift to modern societal expectations, where achieving career milestones often takes precedence over starting a family, thereby contributing to lower fertility rates.

5. The Role of Social Networks and Media in Shaping Fertility Preferences

Exploring the impact of technology, Stone discusses how mobile phones and the internet have "concretized" fertility preferences, making individuals more likely to set specific goals for the number of children they intend to have. However, this also leads to a discrepancy between desired and actual fertility due to perceived or real constraints.

Lyman Stone [27:08]:
"Social exposure to people with big families makes you want big families... but cell phones make intentions more rigid."

Stone also highlights the "contagion effect," where the fertility choices of peers influence an individual's own decisions, further impacting overall birth rates.

6. Case Study: Georgia's Religious Initiative and Birth Rates

A pivotal example discussed is Georgia's intervention by a state church leader who incentivized having a third child by personally baptizing and godparenting those families. This initiative successfully increased the fertility rate from 1.6 to 2.2 within 18 months.

Lyman Stone [34:20]:
"He announced this, and in 18 months, the fertility of Georgia rose from 1.6 to 2.2."

This case illustrates how altering social and status hierarchies can directly influence fertility behaviors without reverting to traditional gender roles or economic dependency structures.

7. Male Socioeconomic Status and Its Impact on Fertility

Stone addresses the critical role of male earnings in family formation, arguing that young men's stagnant incomes relative to older generations hinder their marriage and fertility prospects. Women often compare potential partners' earnings to their fathers', creating a situation where young men struggle to meet these historical benchmarks.

Lyman Stone [53:32]:
"Women match to husbands that share their father's socioeconomic status... a bigger gender gap in incomes does not actually predict a higher rate of entrance into marriage."

This dynamic contributes to fewer marriages and, consequently, lower fertility rates, especially among younger men who feel they cannot provide the "insurance" women seek.

8. Gender Roles and Household Labor: Debunking the Double Shift Myth

Contrary to popular belief, Stone presents evidence that married mothers and fathers in industrialized societies share household and unpaid labor more equally than stereotypes suggest.

Lyman Stone [89:08]:
"Married moms and dads report virtually identical combined hours of household and non-household work."

However, he acknowledges that while averages show parity, individual experiences can vary, with some women facing a "double shift" of paid and unpaid labor. This nuanced understanding challenges societal narratives about gender roles within the household.

9. Cultural Case Study: South Korea and Fertility Expectations

Stone examines South Korea as a case where intense educational pressures and restrictive workplace norms for women have led to exceptionally low fertility rates. The rise of K-Pop culture, promoting childless lifestyles among its stars, further influences societal attitudes towards family formation.

Lyman Stone [80:46]:
"They systematically created a culture of childless celebrities and role models."

This cultural shift, combined with limited opportunities for women despite high educational attainment, fosters frustration and contributes to declining birth rates.

10. Conclusion: Addressing Fertility Decline Through Cultural and Policy Shifts

Lyman Stone emphasizes that reversing fertility decline requires comprehensive cultural and policy interventions. These include designing family-friendly housing, redefining social norms around family and work, and leveraging influential role models to promote positive fertility behaviors.

Lyman Stone [107:28]:
"We have to build the kinds of houses that people want and create narratives that give long-term meaning to family life."

By addressing both the structural and cultural barriers to family formation, societies can create environments that support higher fertility rates without compromising individual freedoms or economic participation.

Notable Quotes

• Lyman Stone [04:55]:
  "Population density predicts everything... one of the things it proxies for is fertility."

• Lyman Stone [08:19]:
  "Townhouses with tree-lined sidewalks are what everyone wants anyways."

• Lyman Stone [24:31]:
  "Developmental idealism introduces the idea that there actually is a long run trend that your life progresses linearly, not cyclically."

• Lyman Stone [27:08]:
  "Social exposure to people with big families makes you want big families... but cell phones make intentions more rigid."

• Lyman Stone [34:20]:
  "He announced this, and in 18 months, the fertility of Georgia rose from 1.6 to 2.2."

• Lyman Stone [53:32]:
  "Women match to husbands that share their father's socioeconomic status... a bigger gender gap in incomes does not actually predict a higher rate of entrance into marriage."

• Lyman Stone [89:08]:
  "Married moms and dads report virtually identical combined hours of household and non-household work."

• Lyman Stone [80:46]:
  "They systematically created a culture of childless celebrities and role models."

• Lyman Stone [107:28]:
  "We have to build the kinds of houses that people want and create narratives that give long-term meaning to family life."

Further Resources

For more insights and research on fertility rates and family studies, visit the Institute for Family Studies' Pronatalism Initiative or follow Lyman Stone on Twitter @manstoneky.

Note: Advertisements and non-content sections from the transcript have been omitted in accordance with the summary guidelines.