Loading summary
Trevor Young
You're listening to an iHeart podcast.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and Safeway this spring. Stock up on all your personal care favorites and earn 4 times points. Now through June 17th. Shop in store online for deals on all your favorite personal care items like Pantene Shampoo, Native Body Spray, Deodorant, Secret Body Spray, Venus Razors, Always Pads, Head and Shoulder Shampoo and Native deodorant and earn 4 times points. Then use those points for discounts on groceries or fuel. You don't want to miss these deals. On offer ends June 17. Promotions may vary. Restrictions apply. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
California Psychics
At California Psychics we know that sometimes you can wake up thinking.
Matt Frederick
I don't know if I'm in the right career ew or the right relationship.
California Psychics
But whatever your life dilemma at California Psychics, we'll give you the guidance you need to feel certain about your life choices. And because we only connect you with the very best, we guarantee if your reading isn't life changing, we is free California psychics. Visit CaliforniaPsychics. Visit CaliforniaPsychics.com today for limited time offers.
Matt Frederick
Kick off summer with Memorial Day savings at Lowe's right now. Get five Scott's Naturescapes 1 1/2 cubic foot mulch bags for just $10. Plus get up to 40% off. Select major appliances and save an extra $50 on every $500 you spend on select major appliances. $396 or more. Lowe's we help you save valid through 500/28 mold shopper excludes Alaska and Hawaii. Selection varies by location while supplies last. See Lowes.com for more details. This season, let your shoes do the talking. Designer Shoe Warehouse is packed with fresh styles that speak to your whole vibe without saying a word. From cool sneakers that look good with everything to easy sandals you'll want to wear on repeat, DSW has you covered. Find a shoe for every heel from the brands you love like Birkenstock, Nike, Adidas, New Balance and more. Head to your DSW store or visit dsw.com today.
Laura
Hello everyone and welcome to this exclusive interview going inside the Monster franchise. It's yours only on True Crime. I'm Laura from the Tenderfoot TV team and today I'm sitting down with the producers behind the podcast, Matt Frederick and Trevor Young. Matt has been the lead executive producer at iheartmedia behind what has become an award winning six season true crime franchise known as the Monster series. And today we're gonna dig into the long road that he and his Team have taken over nearly a decade to bring you this hard hitting investigative journalism. Case after case and season after season. Quick heads up for everyone. Today it's pouring rain where I'm recording, so if you hear some thunder in the background, don't freak out. I'm just hoping it's gonna add a little bit to the mood as we dig into some of these gloomy topics. Hey, Matt, thank you for joining today.
Matt Frederick
Hey, thank you for having me. I'm quite excited to be here. This has been a huge part of my life and career.
Laura
Yeah, I can only imagine. Can you actually just start us off by sharing a little more about you and your background and how you got into podcasting in the first place?
Matt Frederick
Oh, sure. I'm a super nerdy actor, drummer kid that came out of high school, got a film degree, didn't think I was gonna get a job for a long time, but then I got an internship at this place called How Stuff Works. And I, you know, did everything there from logging videotape to doing metadata and all kinds of stuff like that, to then shooting videos to then editing videos, producing them. And eventually we pivoted to audio and I became an audio producer and then moved my way up there to supervising producer and then executive producer.
Laura
And. Okay, what brought you into working on the Monster series? Cause I was a big fan of How Stuff Works. I still am, but it's quite a different world and genre from where you've ended up. Can you talk a little bit about that journey?
Matt Frederick
Oh, yeah, for sure. I was making a show called Stuff They Don't Want yout To Know that I co created with my buddy Ben Bolen, a friend of mine that we've known each other since. We started basically at How Stuff Works. And we had covered a lot of true crime before in the past, but we had an opportunity to partnered with Tenderfoot, which had just created up and Vanished and happened to be in the same office building that we were in. And our boss at the time, Jason, had a meeting with them and I guess I was tapped along with my friend Alex Williams as the team on our side basically to partner with Tenderfoot to create a new show that was. It was going to be very different than anything we had created before. But we figured, hey, if we put our research background into this thing, into a true crime story that Tenderfoot's really good at making, clearly we can make something special. And that became Atlanta Monster. That time, man, was just so. Just to think back, like every that that was. Everybody was scared. It was always be Careful. You know, everywhere y' all go, go.
Dr. Patrick McGrath
In groups, you know what I'm saying?
Matt Frederick
It was like everybody was scared. And definitely the people from where we grew up, like, round from where we from, everybody over there was scared because that's where they was getting the kids from. It was crazy, man. Like, that time was like the Boogerman Kelf Club. It's literally somebody going around taking kids, and they would find them in Chattahoochee. They would find them behind buildings.
Laura
That was just our life.
Matt Frederick
When you living through something like that, it's kind of, like, different. It was just something we had to deal with. Watch for the Boogerman.
Laura
Can you talk a little bit more about how Atlanta Monster got off the ground initially? Like, did you have any sense at that point it would become a franchise, or was it really just this one off show that you all came together to start working on?
Matt Frederick
When we began making Atlanta Monster, it was a singular show. It was a huge historical story we wanted to tell about our city, Atlanta, and, you know, about some. It's a somewhat hidden story. Even though it's been told before in documentaries, it's not a thing. If you walk around and you ask the people of Atlanta about this story about the missing and murdered children, the child murders, Wayne Williams, a lot of people don't know much about it at that time. And we're talking 2018 when we're making the show, right? And we just thought, well, we can probably do this thing justice if we actually put in the work to go to the archives and find all of the old material that some of us remembered, like Monica Pearson going on the television and stating those words, it's nine o' clock. Do you know where your children are? That kind of thing. So as we're actually beginning that process of research, we're finding these archival materials that have never been digitized before. They're all just sitting on physical tape in this massive vault. So there's a team at the University of Georgia that is actually like, doing the metadata thing that I started doing, you know, as a kid working at this company as an internal. It was actually overwhelming the amount of archival material that we found to the point where we're going through it and on the cutting room floor. You've got, I would say, hundreds of hours of stuff that we didn't use in Atlanta.
Laura
Monster was a lot of that information that you found in the vault and on these tapes, like, new information to you. I mean, I imagine that since you grew up in Atlanta, you said people didn't really talk about the child murders, but it's something that you were familiar with from when you were younger, right? It's local history.
Matt Frederick
Well, let me be clear. I didn't know much about it. I was kind of in the same position that Payne was.
Laura
Okay.
Matt Frederick
Neither of us knew a ton about it, but we had people that we worked with, we had people around us that knew a lot about it, and we made connections with people like Kalinda Lee at the Atlanta History center, who told us the full story before we even really dove into this thing that much. And once you. Once you hear the story and you start to see the details of it, we realize that this is a. This is a at least 10 part series, like kind of following the rabbit holes that it creates. When you're going down the possibilities of who could have done this, who was blamed for doing this, you know, who was actually incarcerated for these things, and all of these children that were killed, it's just. It's an intense thing.
Laura
Okay. So you're looking through the vault, you're connecting with local historians, you're getting all of this information. How did you sort things out? Like, did you have it? Was you in pain and who else was on the team? How did you all approach, you know, distilling this down into a show?
Matt Frederick
Yeah, so on the creative side, you've got Payne, Lindsay, Meredith Stedman was huge. Donald Albright is working on it. Jamie, I think, was working a little bit on the show, but more on the periphery. And there were a few other people that were working on the Tenderfoot side that were really doing the putting the story together work. What Alex and I were primarily focused on, along with Jason, was sifting through that archival stuff, finding the snippets that would fit, you know, an empty space in the story we're trying to tell. Right. So in the end, other than doing that and then, you know, finding a way to negotiate how to license all of this material that we were finding, and then also doing the final passes, basically on files that we would get from pain. On every one of these shows, we work up until the last minute to perfect it as much as we possibly can. It's not like we lock the audio and then it's done for a month and then we just wait to release it.
Laura
Right.
Matt Frederick
The nature of the show is we are. We keep going and we keep giving notes, we keep making passes. And one of my primary jobs, along with Alex, was to get that final from Tenderfoot and then go through and just adjust the levels, mix it and master it just perfectly, at least to our. To what we thought was as perfect as it could get and. And then send it out into the world. And it was usually at like, between 10pm and midnight or something like that by the time we would get the files and then finish that work and then get them out. But it was such a fun thing. It felt like. Felt like college to me, working on a project late at night and, like, struggling to hit a deadline or something.
Laura
Right.
Matt Frederick
It was pretty glorious.
Laura
And what about that specific case and that story felt important to you? Like, what compelled you all to dig into it? Cause it was from, you know, the late 70s. So it's an older case. Why did it feel important to bring it back out of the shadows and out of these tapes in this vault in 2018, 2017, 2018?
Matt Frederick
Well, if you go through the vault, you will find interviews of parents of children who are victims. You will find some interviews with. They weren't law enforcement officers. They're like, maybe former law enforcement officers turned private investigators who had been working on the case back then. And they're giving interviews at that time saying, oh, we don't think Wayne Williams did these, or at least all of these. And we, you know, we think there's somebody else out there doing this stuff, and just because this guy's in jail, it doesn't mean they're going to stop. And then you go in 2017, 2018, and talk to people and they've got major doubts about Wayne Williams being the only person responsible for these things. And I think that for me personally and for us as a team, that was enough of a reason to expose as much of the truth as we can and explore it as deeply as we can to try and get to at least a closer truth than the one we were all faced with, which was blaming one man for 30 deaths and a man that, at least on the surface, didn't appear to be responsible for those things. Although, spoiler, if you haven't listened to Atlanta Monster, please do. Payne ends up talking to Wayne extensively. And I guess you'll have to just hear the show to see how his character gets illuminated over the course of, you know, months of communication.
Laura
Since you were reopening a case that had more or less been closed, even though people had a lot of doubts about who was convicted. Did you and the team hit any challenges or roadblocks or points of, I guess, contention or pushback since you were, you know, digging back into a, quote, unquote, closed file?
Matt Frederick
Oh, yeah, we are actually experiencing some of that Right now. Spoiler alert. There might be more Atlanta Monster coming to you in the future.
Laura
Hey, that's great news.
Matt Frederick
Yeah.
Laura
Yes, it is.
Matt Frederick
It is. Again, it deserves more and more attention, and the more you can give it. I think that's fantastic. From the law enforcement side. There was a lot of pressure at the time when the first arrest was made and when the investigation was hot and happening. There was a lot of pressure from the city itself to close the case and put somebody behind bars. Take a little bit of the pressure, the PR pressure off of the city itself, and, you know, the city was going through a couple of huge transformations, and just a lot of money was being pumped into the city, and it doesn't look good when you've got a serial killer out in the loose somewhere. And, gosh, I don't want to sound conspiratorial. If you analyze it, it appears that that pressure pushed some things, some mechanisms, some official mechanisms, like the police departments, some of the Justice Department here in Georgia to just get somebody behind bars, blame everything on that one person, and close it, and it's done. We don't have to think about it anymore. But as we're going through the case, you discover, oh, no, there is a pretty heavy Ku Klux Klan thing going on. There are some individual characters that made threats against specific children that died there. There is a child sex trafficking ring that was identified through the investigation that existed in a part of Atlanta, and we couldn't find where the. The end of that investigation went. Like, how did that end up? Who went to jail for that child sex thing that they'd uncovered? We couldn't find it, and those kinds of things, I think, need to be further delved into.
Laura
So then you all followed up pretty quickly, actually, with your next show, which was Zodiac Killer.
Matt Frederick
The next year.
Laura
The next year, yeah. So you really stayed in it. What compelled you and the team to build this monster concept into a franchise? And how did you decide on what would come next?
Matt Frederick
In podcasting you, you want to capitalize on something that works because, you know, if it was a rewarding experience to make it, then hopefully listening to it was also, you know, something somebody wants to do again. So you want to make something similar. But we didn't have another Atlanta story like this to tell. We didn't have something that was that close to home. So we were looking for a story that was big, legendary almost. And I think it was Pain that identified Zodiac, specifically, the image of this killer wearing this weird executioner's hood suit thing with a gun. And a knife. And just this. This image of that thing as a monster, whatever that was, I think it really resonated with the title and what we were trying to do in the show. Analyze what creates something like that out of a human being. Just somebody that was a child one time. You know, how did that thing get created? Like some kind of golem or tulpa or. You know, I'm using weird terminology here, but how do you. How does one become that? So we. We found the Zodiac Killer to be this subject, and we just immediately realized, oh, boy, we need more people to help us make this in this timeline. Because the show Atlanta Monster came out on New Year's 2018. Right. We wanted Zodiac Killer to come out on New Year's 2019. And we hadn't started research, we hadn't started interviews. And if you've listened to these shows, you know, we interview somewhere between 30 and 40 people. And when you talk to Trevor Young, who is an executive producer at iHeart Podcast now, who was working with us at that time, we've interviewed so many people, you forget how many people you talk to for one of these shows. And you should also ask him about the difficulty tracking somebody down, first of all, and then convincing them to talk to a bunch of nerdy podcasters. It's not easy. And Trevor could tell you exactly how not easy it is.
Laura
And the Zodiac Killer was also not a hometown show for you all. It was across the country, right? It was in San Francisco. So, yeah. Can you talk really quickly before I get Trevor on here? Just about the process of. Okay, you find this image, this show or this story is based in San Francisco. You all are in Atlanta. How did you move an entire group of people across the country essentially, to. Yeah. Find these interviews, start building the story. I imagine you had to go into physical archives in San Francisco as well for information. Like, can you talk a little bit about that process?
Matt Frederick
Oh, yeah, sure. We didn't relocate everybody immediately. What we did instead is take a couple of targeted trips out there. So we would pre produce while we're in Atlanta, arrange a bunch of interviews for this one big block of a week, and then we'd all travel out there and stay at an Airbnb or something and go out, get as many interviews as we can, come back to our little home base area and start cutting those interviews up. And I specifically remember a moment when Payne came out to visit during one of our trips, and we were attempting to create one of the first pieces that anybody would hear in the show. I think it was the cold open for episode one, and Payne came out, listened to all the tape that we had gathered, listen to some of the rough cutting that we had been doing, just, you know, trying to ideate on what this could sound like. This, this sound bite's going to work really well to set up this section. The first thing you hear in episode one of Zodiac Killer, the cold open there. Payne came in and just started throwing that thing together because he heard some of the tape and just saw something in there that was special. And goodness was it. I don't know if Trevor wants to talk to you about Tom. Tom's a special guy. He was a photographer who was on the first scene of the first Zodiac murders. And talking to Tom, specifically, the way that Payne cut that tape up, it's haunting and it makes me remember being there in San Francisco and it makes me remember how freaked out people were at the time. Christmas time, 1968. All was not calm, all was not bright. Sergeant, could you briefly describe what apparently happened last night? We had a double homicide that took place out on a county road sometime.
Laura
After 11 o' clock. 16 year old girl and a 17 year old boy. How did this incident occur?
Matt Frederick
Apparently?
Dr. Patrick McGrath
Well, they were shot.
Matt Frederick
Photographer Tom Ballmer arrived on the scene. The night of December 20th was an interesting one. Photographers back then were ambulance chasers. We had radios with the local police, police and fire frequencies and we followed what was going on. I remember a dispatch to Lake Herman Road in Benicia and they said that there were two victims there and they thought it was a murder suicide. The woman there that was shot was fairly small in size and they were thinking it was an adult and a child. That was what the original dispatch was, as I recall it. So I headed out that way.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and safeway now through June 17th. Shop in store or online for your favorite personal care Items and save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Stock up on items like Dove Body Wash, Degree Motion Scents Deodorant, Tresemme Hairspray, Dove Shampoo, Dove Bar Soap, Dove Men's Body and Face Wash and Dollar Shave Club blades, and save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Hurry in before these deals are gone. Offer ends June 17. Promotions may vary. Restrictions apply. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
California Psychics
What if I told you that right now millions of people are living with a debilitating condition that's so misunderstood, many of them don't even know that they have it? That condition is obsessive. Compulsive disorder or OCD. I'm Dr. Patrick McGrath, the chief clinical officer of NOCD. And in the 25 years I've been treating OCD, I. I've met so many people who are suffering from the condition in silence, unaware of just what it was. OCD can create overwhelming anxiety and fear around what you value most, make you question your identity, beliefs and morals, and drive you to perform mentally and physically draining compulsions or rituals. Over my career, I've seen just how devastating OCD can be when it's left untreated. But help is available. That's where NOCD comes in. NOCD is the world's largest virtual therapy provider for Obsessive Compulsive Disorder. Our licensed therapists are trained in exposure and response prevention therapy therapy, a specialized treatment proven to be incredibly effective for OCD. So visit NOCD.com to schedule a free 15 minute call with our team. That's N O C D.com at California.
Psychics we know some people can't read the career warning signs. Like your boss. Still not knowing your name.
Cindy Crawford
You, Tina, Lisa, Sheila, whatever. Get that report to me by lunch, okay? It's Carrie, ma' am. Just get it done, Terry.
California Psychics
So talk to to California Psychics and receive the career guidance you need. We only connect you with the very best, so guarantee if your reading isn't life changing. It's free. California psychics. Visit CaliforniaPsychics. Visit CaliforniaPsychics.com today for limited time offers.
Cindy Crawford
Now I'd like to introduce you to Meaningful Beauty, the famed skincare brand created by iconic supermodel Cindy Crawford. It's her secret to absolutely gorgeous skin. Meaningful Beauty makes powerful and effective skin care simple and it's loved by millions of women. It's formulated for all ages and all skin tones and types. And it's designed to work as a complete skin care system, leaving your skin feeling soft, smooth and nourished. I recommend starting with Cindy's full regimen which contains all five of her best selling products including the Amazing Youth Activating Melon Serum. This next generation serum has the power of melon leaf stem cell technology. Its melon leaf stem cells and encapsulated for freshness and released onto the skin to support a visible reduction in the appearance of wrinkles. With thousands of glowing five star reviews, why not give it a try? Subscribe today and you can get the Amazing Meaningful Beauty system for just $49.95. That includes our introductory five piece system, free gifts, free shipping and a 60 day money back guarantee. All that available@meaningful beauty.com.
Laura
Let'S bring Trevor on. So you have this team. And off air, before we started talking, you called them the Monster Squad.
Matt Frederick
Yes.
Laura
Which I love.
Matt Frederick
That's still our name, I believe, right, Trevor?
Trevor Young
Yeah, it sure is.
Laura
Trevor, when did you join the Monster Squad, and what was your experience as a part of the San Francisco team, digging into this really grisly story of the Zodiac Killer? Because that was your first show you worked on.
Trevor Young
Yeah, so I came in. In, I guess it would have been 2018. So at this point, Atlanta Monster was wrapping up. And at some point, behind the scenes on that team, it was decided, hey, we're going to need, like, a bigger team if we're going to expand this, like, if. If we want to, you know, do this again with different cases, kind of replicate Atlanta Monster in, you know, San Francisco or wherever. We're going to need a bigger team. And that's when me and a handful of other people who became the Monster Squad, the first iteration of the Monster Squad, were brought on to work on Zodiac. So that would have been my first show, kind of again, at the tail end of Atlanta Monster before Zodiac started.
Laura
And what was your role at that point?
Trevor Young
So at that point, I was just a writer, producer. We had, I think, four of us who all had that same kind of role who were equally in charge of all things from booking guests to actually writing the show, to editing the show, to sound designing the show.
Laura
So can you talk a little bit about just that creative process? Because, you know, taking news and taking really heavy news and an older case and then bringing it into something that's engaging and kind of follows an arc throughout a show is a skill.
Trevor Young
I think anytime you're looking at a story or a case, you need to ask yourself, like, what is the best way to tell this story? Like, what are the elements of it? What are the beats of it? And, like, the reality is, like, we have to tell each of these stories differently based on the type of story it is. So the Zodiac was a much older case. Not much. I mean, it was, like, maybe 10 years older than Atlanta Monster. But that actually makes a big difference when you're thinking about availability of, like, who's still alive and what kind of archives were there, you know, from news stations and things like that. And it was also a little bit more of a. I don't want to say complex, but it was just like a bigger story. Right. Like, Atlanta was a little bit more of a grassroots type of story. It was a big deal. Right. Like, it was a big national story. But Zodiac is, like, one of the biggest serial killer cases known to humankind. Right. So we kind of had to approach it a little differently in the sense that we wanted to do it a little more chronologically. So we thought, like, we would tell that story by starting at the very beginning, like, starting you off at the very first murder and like, taking you through it as if you were living in San Francisco at the time and knew nothing about what was going on, so. As if you were just, like, a local person experiencing this in real time. And we kind of did something similar with DC Sniper later, but that was very different from Atlanta Monster. Cause Atlanta Monster was much more about, you know, here we are on the ground in Atlanta. You know, we're gonna knock on people's doors. And we didn't do that so much. We did. I mean, we went to San Francisco and we, like, interviewed people, but it was less like, we're gonna solve the murder, kind of like Atlanta was, and more like, we're going to uncover as much about this case as we can that maybe hasn't been explored yet and maybe, like, revive the case in a Shakes the Tree and gives people new ideas. So we just had to approach it a little differently because of the type of story it was.
Laura
Wow, that's really interesting. So you already mentioned DC Sniper a little bit, which was the next show that you worked on.
Trevor Young
Yeah.
Laura
How was that show, I guess, similar and different to Zodiac? And both of you can talk about how that one was chosen as the next case. I'm really curious about this process of evolution of the Monster franchise in general. And, okay, you do one story, go to San Francisco. This is a very big case. You wanted to really immerse people in the lifestyle as if they were experiencing it. And then show wraps, it's published, it's received in the public, and you're like, all right, we're gonna do another one.
Matt Frederick
Yeah.
Trevor Young
Yeah. It's an interesting question. Matt can speak to this, too. But I think after Zodiac, we were like, I think we want to do something a little bit more modern, something that felt a little bit more timely. And DC Sniper was early 2000s, right? Like, we were all alive and remember that time well, and there was just something about it. I think we were looking for, you know, stories that felt significant. And this was one that wasn't clear because it wasn't a serial killer. Right. It wasn't like your Zodiac or your Son of Sam. But what it did have was, like, that same sense of, like, terror, Right? This idea that, like, they were terrorizing this place and wreaking havoc and killing people, and nobody knew what was going on, and nobody knew who was gonna be next. And I think that, like, the same thing that was consistent in the previous two seasons, that felt like the same amount of fear, and that's why it felt like such a good case for us.
Matt Frederick
Well, yeah, In Atlanta Monster. There's an unknown monster stealing and killing children. Right. It's hard to think of anything much more terrifying. In season two with the Zodiac, there is this physical monster that might kill you if you are being amorous, you know, with your boyfriend or girlfriend in a car. Right there in this. This instance, there is a monster that nobody can see that is killing you. When you're pumping gas in Washington, D.C. you know, in Virginia, it's hard to describe that terror until you hear some of the interviews that we captured for Monster DC Sniper of people who were there pumping gas and a shot is fired, and you have no idea where it's coming from, and somebody gets hit and, you know, is bleeding out right next to you.
Trevor Young
Right. And it comes back to this idea that there's, like, some mysterious evil at work here, you know, embodied in one or sometimes two people who are the perpetrators of this. And in all of these stories, like navigating and kind of exploring that type of evil in a person in a monster is, like, the most interesting type of question we can ask. So we're always looking for that, like, is, you know, what can we say about these types of monsters who do this? And that one had a very particularly unique and interesting series of sub questions that came along with it based on the nature of who the killers were. I really enjoyed navigating, again, all of those questions that came along with the D.C. sniper case.
Matt Frederick
Yeah. And one of the main reasons for that we covered that one is because we had two members on the Monster Squad. Well, let's just name them all. Ben Kieverich, Miranda Hawkins and Josh Thain. I believe Trevor, Ben and Miranda both had experiences with DC and the DC Sniper, or at least Ben did.
Trevor Young
Yeah, I know Ben did.
Laura
I don't remember personal connections to it.
Trevor Young
Yeah. Either lived in the area or had family that lived in the area. And then, of course, our host, Tony Harris, was a Baltimore native and, you know, kind of came up in the news world in Baltimore, so he was actively covering it. There was a lot of, like, personal connection to the story, for sure.
Laura
Right.
Matt Frederick
Well, I would say that's another evolution in the Monster series. The first season is hosted by Payne exclusively The second season, Payne is doing, you know, part of the hosting, part of the storytelling, and then my voice is officially hosting it. Now we're moving to a journalist who is helping us tell the story, use that voice and just. It was a big step up, I think.
Trevor Young
I think that was the first time we pivoted into trying to do something that was like, more akin to like a serial. Right. Or like where we had like a journalism presence that was like the focal point in a very robust way. Right. And it was just different. It was just a different type of show. But I think that served us well for that particular case.
Laura
Yeah. So did Tony help craft the storytelling element of it then, since he was so familiar with the case and had been reporting on it for a long time? He sounds like he was very involved in that process as well.
Trevor Young
Oh, yeah. Surely he went with us to everything. We went to DC Tonight we have.
Matt Frederick
The creators of the third iteration. It is called Monster DC Snipers.
Trevor Young
He was there for all the interviews.
Matt Frederick
Host Tony Harris. And we have two of the premieres producers, Trevor Young and Benjamin Kiebrick. And guys, if you'd like, without Tony.
Trevor Young
Like, that show wouldn't have been what it was. He was absolutely integral to the fabric of that show.
Dr. Patrick McGrath
I feel blessed to have this opportunity to tell this story that I have kind of intimate knowledge of. You remember this story, right? I mean, you remember this. I just need to feel some energy back from the audience. You do remember the story, right? This is 2002 and. Wow. I was working in Baltimore as a news anchor for the Fox affiliate there. And on the second, I remember us getting a call in our newsroom about a shooting in Montgomery county, which was odd and weird because, you know, as was mentioned, Montgomery county is kind of this pristine community, high net worth county in Maryland, that would have led our newscast that night. And the next day, all hell broke loose. Five people killed on the third. And at that point, as my news brain was working at that time, I knew we had a massive story and not enough people. I'm thinking resources to cover the story. I'm thinking about how do we get the information to people. We weren't getting anything from police. So you're just conflicted and you're wondering if you're doing a service to the public. But we have people, viewers who are clamoring to know everything there is to know about this case. And so you're feeling conflicted in everything else. And I'm still thinking as an anchor, as a reporter trying to get information at some point, And I don't know when at some point I started to think like a human being and I started to think about the people who had been killed, their lives, their families. And then it must have been around the time when Iron Brown, 13 year old kid at Tasker Middle School shot. Yeah, that's right. He survived. That's right, survived at Tasker Middle School. And I think it was shortly or certainly in that moment I began to stop thinking about this purely as a story, with all the adrenaline that goes along with being a reporter or anchor on a huge story with national and international interest. And I started to think about myself as a father of two young children. And the story kind of changes for me at that point.
Laura
What particularly stood out to you about DC Sniper? Were there any themes or moments that really hit home for the two of you since it was something that happened during your lifetime?
Matt Frederick
Oh, yeah. One of the biggest things that drew us to this story, it's kind of spoilery. So here you go. Listen to Monster DC Sniper, please. There were two human beings involved in those killings, at least when it comes to the trial. Right. And to the official findings of the investigation. One of those people was quite a bit older than the other one and appeared to be a mentor, almost father figure to the other. That was a kid, basically. At least a very, very young man. And that very, very young man, Lee Boyd Malvo, was at the time that we were making the show, the legality of his sentence was being looked at, basically. Can you sentence this kid to his life in prison forever without parole? Was it legal to even sentence him to that?
Laura
He was 17, right?
Matt Frederick
Yep. So he's like, right. He's right on that line of what the law says. Okay, you're, you're a man now, or, oh, you were just a boy and he is potentially killing, murdering people in cold blood. Or is he. Which was all part of the trial, trying to figure out who actually is pulling the trigger on each one of these deaths.
Trevor Young
I think that sort of moral gray question was one of the most fundamental paradigms of what we tried to dig into in the show and try and explore. It's funny. I can't help but go back and look at reviews of shows and people are, it's funny. You'll go and read reviews and they're gonna be like, oh, they ended up saying that he was far right opinion, or they ended up saying he was far left opinion on that particular topic of the death penalty and all that. And like, in my memory, like, we were pretty center on it. Like, I think our goal was purely to ask the question and then present all the different viewpoints and let listeners kind of come to their own conclusion on it. But really, like, there is no answer. It's like, one of the most interesting questions to me about whether or not, you know, someone who's a minor, when they do a terrible deed was fully aware of what they were doing. Like, if their brain was fully developed enough to the point where they should be held responsible the same way an adult should.
Laura
Right.
Trevor Young
You know, especially right on that cusp, as Matt was saying, Right. At 17. Or if we can look at brain science and say, no, they really weren't developed. And he was entirely impressionable to this older man. And so much of it comes down to, I think, gut or instinct feeling for people when they look at interviews with the young man and listen to the things he said on the way he acts. You just kind of have to feel it out sometimes, and it's just so open to interpretation. I found that very fascinating.
Matt Frederick
Well, yeah. And just the concept of exactly what you hit on there, Trevor. How much can you, as an individual be influenced by a mentor, Right. Or someone you view as a mentor and do the actions that you take directed by this mentor, are they your. Are you 100% responsible, or is that mentor responsible? It is the Charles Manson kind of thing.
Laura
It is, right?
Trevor Young
Yeah.
Laura
It is a really fascinating conundrum. And I have not spent as much time as you both have thinking about this, focusing on it, trying to, you know, find a way to then share that externally with millions of people? I would love to hear a little bit about your experience getting in touch with John Muhammad's wife. We haven't said his name yet, but the older mentor, you know, potentially the primary culpable person in this whole situation. Can you share about the experience of talking with Mildred and how she helped untangle this case for you all and what it was like to work with her?
Trevor Young
That was all Matt. I think I had found Mildred first. Like, found, yes, her number in contact and reached out, but she and her folks did not want to talk to me. So at some point, I just. I turned to Matt and I said, can you do anything here? Like, Matt just has, like, a charm with people and especially people of Mildred's caliber. So all the credit should go to Matt because he took a crack at it, reached out to Mildred, and she was just on board after that.
Matt Frederick
I know that I had an immediate connection with Mildred when we talked, because she was just. She was so open and giving, just As a human being, Just like she wants to help people, she's a survivor. You know, all the work she's done since a lot of the stuff went down is to teach other people about what it looks like when you're in a relationship with somebody who begins to act this way. When you are being abused and you're in that situation, how do you get out of it? How do you even recognize that you're in that situation if you're used to that situation? I honestly have no idea. There were several people that we talked to for the show that required convincing. Just like being able. Getting somebody to come and hang out with you and tell you about the worst moment, worst hour, worst day, worst year, worst relationship. Like, imagine. Imagine your worst relationship right now. Now imagine somebody says, hey, come on over and talk to me for five hours about that relationship. I'm going to record it, and I'm going to make it into a podcast. That's a scary thing. Unless you're somebody like Mildred who wants to use that to teach other people what she has learned.
Trevor Young
Yeah, that's true. I mean, you know, one of the things about the Monster series generally is just that thing of needing and wanting to convince people to talk about this is one of the biggest challenges to making any of these shows right, because, like, in order for the show to exist, those people have to be willing to talk. But as Matt alluded to, they oftentimes really don't want to. You know, I mean, and why would they? Right. Like, so I think going into this as a producer, you have to come into it with, like, a large bank of empathy and understanding for where these people are coming from and not do this, not reach out to them and try and convince them from a point of, like, you know, hey, I need this for my project. Right. Like, you know, come on, this is my job. But, like, try and befriend them. Like, try and, you know, meet them on their level and understand where they're coming from and explain to them, like, the importance of what you're trying to do and why it would be important for them to be a part of it. Right. Again, not demand it, but just try and build a relationship there that would make them want to talk to you about it.
Matt Frederick
Yeah. And when you finally do get to speak to somebody like Mildred, one of the reasons why she was such a big deal for us in the show is you start to see a completely different perspective of a story that we all read in the news that, you know, a lot of us grew up experiencing and then you realize this huge thing about this. This guy or this group of people that was using a sniper rifle in a vehicle to shoot people and cause terror. And that's really what you remember in your mind. You remember the terror part. You remember a couple of the headlines. You remember seeing it on TV maybe, but you don't hear or know the story about his spouse and their children and the potential custody battle and the abuse and all this other stuff. And why maybe was he in that car using a sniper rifle to kill people and what could have actually been going on in his head? And Mildred just gives you that context.
Laura
So when you're doing these kinds of interviews, especially with her and with people who've been through these really traumatic experiences. Experiences. Do you. I mean, I've talked to Neil, the host of To Die for, and he talked about doing, like, trauma informed interview training and work around that so that he could make sure that he was, you know, conducting interviews in a way that was not causing more harm. I'm curious if you guys have ever done anything like that or if you've learned along the way and what kinds of tools you've learned to open up those conversations for people in a way that is, you know, it sounds like you have a lot of natural empathy to begin with, Trevor, but, like, how do you approach those sensitive conversations and build trust and can you just talk a little bit about that, that sort of side of things?
Trevor Young
Yeah. I mean, the short answer is that it's something you kind of learn. Right. Like, I think it's just like a skill you develop the more you do it. And the way you, I think, approach it is just with a. You know, it sounds kind of maybe silly, but you, like, you just approach it with like, a degree of, like, softness and like, being unthreatening. Right. Like, I think the.
Laura
It's not silly at all.
Trevor Young
It's just. It's such a simple thing. And I think that's just how you, like, approach anybody in life that you want to, you know, have a. Build a relationship with or, you know, just have, like, a successful interaction with. Right. Is like, hi. Like, you know, how are you? Like, ask them about themselves. Like, don't don't make it all about you. Right. You know, like, the, the softness approach is, you know, coming into it with just like an overwhelming friendliness that puts people at ease. You know, there's just kind of all these interpersonal ways that I think we all should talk to people anyways.
Matt Frederick
Yeah. So I think, I think part of that is exactly as you're saying, on the job training, and you see when, oh, I'm being a little too cold and just asking questions right now because I can read on the face of the person I'm talking to that that's happening. Yeah, there's something about the skill of specifically being in a physical room with somebody and just feeling their presence and knowing when you're going in the wrong direction. And you can feel it. You can literally feel it. We had a moment on Monster the Zodiac Killer, and we were interviewing Dean Farren, who was the husband of Darlene Farron, who was part of the second shooting that occurred in the Zodiac killings. And that man had such a complicated life and relationship with his wife and his daughter and a new family and all this other stuff going on in his world. I could see that specifically I was stepping on toes and taking him to really uncomfortable places as I was talking to him. And ultimately I did the thing where you kind of just let him talk a little bit about what he wants to talk about and then you just pull back the layers, you know, that are this list of questions that you're going in with, which we're kind of doing on this, this interview session right now. It's what happens organically. Right. You're like, oh, we don't actually need to go that route right now. Let's just talk.
Trevor Young
Yeah, Having that in the moment. Sensitivity is crucial. And as you said, I think one of the biggest things we could ever do to convince people that we're worth talking to is explaining to them that we don't have an agenda. We literally just want you to tell us your story unfiltered. No way that we're trying to manipulate this. We just want you to express your honest feelings and recollections and nothing more. We're not asking you to subscribe to any ideology or, you know, that's always a big, you know, issue with some people is like, how is this going to be used? Like, how am I going to be manipulated in some way? And, and I think we always just have to, like, let people know. Like, no, like you're going to start your story, you're going to end your story and we're going to put that in there. That's all it is.
Matt Frederick
A lot of the individuals that we end up talking to are used to going on episodic true crime show on like true TV or one of these places or Oxygen, and they just go on, they tell their story, a 30 minute episode, right? And often a producer is behind a camera in those tapings saying, could you. Could you say that again? But just really, like, angle in on the fact that your daughter was this, this, this. And that's not at all the energy we're coming at anybody with.
Laura
Yeah, right. I mean, that's really unique and I think important. And it's. It's a service to people. Right. Like, to me, if I'd been through something like that, I think it would be a relief to be able to just talk.
Matt Frederick
Yeah.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and safeway now through June 17th. Shop in store or online for your favorite personal care Items and save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Stock up on items like Dove Body Wash, Degree Motion Sense Deodorant, Tresemme Hairspray, Dove Shampoo, Dove Bar Soap, Dove Men's Body and Face Wash, and Dollar Shave Club blades. And save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Hurry in before these deals are gone. Offer ends June 17. Promotions may vary. Restrictions apply. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
California Psychics
What if I told you that right now millions of people are living with a debilitating condition that's so misunderstood, many of them don't even know that they have it? That condition is obsessive compulsive disorder, or OCD. I'm Dr. Patrick McGrath, the chief clinical officer of NOCD. And in the 25 years I've been treating OCD, I've met so many people who are suffering from the condition in silence, unaware of just what it was. OCD can create overwhelming anxiety and fear around what you value most, make you question your identity, beliefs and morals, and drive you to perform mentally and physically draining compulsions or rituals. Over my career, I've seen just how devastating OCD can be when it's left untreated. But help is available. That's where NOCD comes in. NOCD is the world's largest virtual therapy provider for obsessive compulsive disorder. Our licensed therapists are trained in exposure and response prevention therapy, a specialized treatment proven to be incredibly effective for OCD. So visit NOCD.com to schedule a free 15 minute call with our team. That's N O C D.com at California Psychics.
We know some people can't read the career warning signs like your boss. Still not knowing your name.
Cindy Crawford
You, Tina, Lisa, Sheila, whatever. Get that report to me by lunch, okay? It's Carrie, ma' am. Just get it done, Terry.
California Psychics
So talk to California psychics and receive the career guidance you need. We only connect you with the very best. So guarantee if your reading isn't life changing, it's free. California psychics call 1-800-PREDICT today and get 20 minutes for just $20.
Cindy Crawford
Now I'd like to introduce you to Meaningful Beauty, the famed skincare brand created by iconic supermodel Cindy Crawford. It's her secret to absolutely gorgeous skin. Meaningful Beauty makes powerful and effective skin care simple and it's loved by millions of women. It's formulated for all ages and all skin tones and types. And it's designed to work as a complete skin care system, leaving your skin feeling soft, smooth and nourished. I recommend starting with Cindy's full regimen which contains all five of her best selling products including the amazing youth activating Melon Serum. This next generation serum has the power of melon leaf stem cell technology. Its melon leaf stealth stem cells encapsulated for freshness and released onto the skin to support a visible reduction in the appearance of wrinkles. With thousands of glowing five star reviews, why not give it a try? Subscribe today and you can get the amazing Meaningful beauty system for just $49.95. That includes our introductory five piece system, free gifts, free shipping, and a 60 day money back guarantee. All that available@meaningfulbeauty.com.
Laura
So I'm gonna pull us back into the world of the monster franchise and kind of the journey that it's taken. So after dc, this big national story, you all went abroad for the first time. And how did that happen? How did you go from all these U.S. stories and you know, starting with a very local story in Atlanta, to Belgium?
Matt Frederick
On June 24, 1995, two young girls went missing in the province of Liege in belgium. It was 25 years ago, right here on this overpass, that they disappeared. A local man explains that eight year olds, Julie Lejeune and Melissa Russo lived less than 500 meters away. They came to this overpass to wave at the cars passing on the highway below and were never seen again alive.
Trevor Young
We can't really take credit for La Monstre. Le Monstre was something that was the brainchild of Matt Graves, who's the host of that show. And so it's less that, you know, we had some burning desire to make an international monster show as it is that some very talented person came to us and said, I have a monster show for you. But here's the catch. It takes place in Belgium. And you know, I don't think we were expecting this or planning on this, but you know, the more we talked with Matt Graves about that case. And the more we looked into it, we were like, it's such a compelling case, you know. And so from that point on, it was as simple as saying, yeah, do this, you know, like, let's see what you got. And he came back to us essentially with all of the research, all the writing, basically did it himself as a one man band. And, you know, we guided him somewhat along the way, but, you know, really it was, it was his baby. And, you know, again, we can't take credit for that, but we think he made something really compelling and we're so glad it's part of the monster family.
Laura
Do you think that there's a future in the monster franchise that goes abroad again? Like, is that something that you all have been considering doing a little more proactively or not so much?
Trevor Young
Yeah, I don't want to give anything away, but we are working on a sort of ongoing monster series that would explore cases in different countries.
Laura
Interesting.
Trevor Young
I'll leave it at that.
Laura
I have so many follow up questions and I won't ask them until a later time. So when a show isn't brought to you like Matt did, how do you find a host that's the right fit? We talked a little bit about this with DC Sniper, with Tony. Can you just share a little bit more about bringing a host on board, finding the right person? I'm thinking about, you know, the next show in the monster series after you all came back, which is Freeway Phantom, which also takes place in D.C. and we had Celeste Headley as the host for that show, and she was an excellent host, but not really the same relationship that Tony had to D.C. sniper. So can you talk about that process of bringing a host into a show and how really their role within the makeup of everything?
Trevor Young
Yeah. So, I mean, just to be honest, part of it is like, who's in your Rolodex? Right. Like, I had known Tony going back years because we had worked together on other things and I'd also known Celeste. Celeste was the host of a show I had worked on at npr and I was her producer for many years. And so it's a few things. Who's close to this story? Right. So in Tony's case, he was close to the DC Sniper story. In Celeste's case, she is a DC person. And, you know, the Freeway Phantom case takes place in the D.C. area. She lived in D.C.
Matt Frederick
Between April 1971 and September 1972. Six young black girls were snatched off the streets in Washington, D.C. it took four murders before the police finally realized.
Laura
That One person was responsible. I will admit the others when you.
Matt Frederick
Catch me, if you can. Signed Freeway Phantom. This child was laying on the side of the road. It appeared that she was probably either dragged out of the car or thrown out of the car.
Trevor Young
The person said, I murdered your daughter.
Matt Frederick
The killer believed that he may have been seen by the mother.
Laura
Did my mother see me?
Matt Frederick
That guy is. He's out of sync with even the worst people. I thought that they would catch him. I thought it was just a matter of time.
Laura
Is it possible that the killer is still alive? Did she have a memory of that happening? Because that was the 80s, wasn't it?
Trevor Young
Yes, mostly 70s.
Laura
Okay. It was before her.
Trevor Young
Yeah. She didn't grow up there, but she is kind of a DC transplant, so she knows DC very well and has lived there for a long time. That was a big piece of it. And then, you know, just certain, you know, resume pieces that are important. You know, both of them are fantastic journalists with really great voices. You know, people who are very good at interviewing, good at telling stories, who are writers who know how to tell a coherent story, either in video or audio, and who are lovely to listen to, of which both of them are in so many ways. They were such no brainers for those stories. Like, they just checked off all the boxes. And so you're always looking for that person, Right. Who just matches all these things in the right ways.
Laura
Well, and coming back to where we are now, which is Monster btk, the host for that show, Susan Peters, is. She also fits into that category. Right. She's very familiar with the case. How did she get involved in Monster btk? And how did you all get involved in Monster btk?
Trevor Young
Yeah. So I guess we'll go back to the origins of the BTK series in a sec, but just about Susan, for anybody who hasn't listened yet, Susan is a TV journalist local to Wichita, who's been there for decades. And so she actually was covering the BTK story in real time, was directly involved, had communications with Dennis Rader, you know, just very, like, probably the closest to the story that we've ever had. A host on one of these. Right. Was like, knew everybody involved in the case very intimately. Right. So we had actually interviewed Susan just as an interview guest. When we were first starting out this series, when we didn't know who was hosting what the story was gonna be yet, we were just reaching out to people close to the story and talking to them. And at some point we interviewed Susan and we were like, wow, she's an incredible story. Also, she has a long history of both journalism and speaking on air and storytelling. Right. I think it just occurred to us that Susan would make a fantastic host for that show and bring a kind of fresh perspective that we hadn't had on a Monster yet. But the story of how we started BTK is something I can let Matt talk about.
Matt Frederick
So one of the incredible things that happens when you make a hit true crime show the way Payne and Donald did and they made up and vanished, is that people want to talk to you. They reach out to you, and they want to tell you their story. And sometimes it's just a, you know, a casual connection. Sometimes it's a, hey, let's get started on a project. In this particular case, Payne just hit it off with Carrie Rawson, the daughter of Dennis Rader. And they were just talking a bit and realized, hey, let's. Let's do an interview, and let's try and make a monster series about your dad. And so we had Carrie come down to Atlanta. We went into a studio. Trevor, was it like four or five hours, maybe? It was at least a break in between.
Trevor Young
It was a long, long interview. Yeah.
Matt Frederick
And we captured everything.
Laura
She was just telling her story that time. Like, that whole time.
Matt Frederick
Yeah, yeah. She sat with pain and just. They just talked. And again, Payne is one of the best interviewers I've ever seen. He just puts everybody at ease and just sits there and will just chat with you for a while. And it can jump around because Payne thinks about stuff like an editor, so he might get a chunk here that he knows. He's like, oh, man, we can use that to tell this story later. And you can see him editing in real time. It's kind of awesome.
Trevor Young
It was a spectacular starting place for this story. Right. That became the groundwork for what became Monster btk. Right. Even though that was actually over two years ago at this point that we did that interview, it was the starting point from which we spawned the rest of the series and built it around, really.
Matt Frederick
Yeah. Then we talked with John Douglas after that, and he was an integral piece of just understanding, wrapping our heads around Dennis Raider a bit.
Trevor Young
Yeah. And then we just dug deeper and, you know, Sue. And then, you know, we, as I said, we talked to Susan. Susan, you know, at some point, you know, became our host and became very helpful in tracking down the family members of victims in the BTK story. And we could not have done that without Susan because Susan had very personal connections with all of those people. As, you know, Raider was being captured in 2005. Susan was the first person to reach out to those people and interview them and get to know them and has maintained those relationships over the years. Yeah. Again, we wouldn't have had that kind of access without Susan's involvement.
Laura
What is different about Monster BTK than some of the other stories like this one? This case was closed in 2005, you said, right?
Trevor Young
Essentially, yeah.
Laura
Why do you feel like it's important, significant to cover now? And what does it bring to the story? What does this series bring to the story that people haven't heard before?
Trevor Young
Yeah. I'll say one thing that's particularly different about this series. And we went back and forth on how to do this, but this is the first time in a monster show where we give you who the monster is pretty early in the series. And rather than keep their identity a mystery throughout most of the series, we instead kind of put you in their shoes and you walk through the story alongside the killer, which is kind of an uncomfortable place to be. But this is, again, you have to approach each story differently based on the type of story it is. And this one just made more sense to do it that way because there's so much out there about exactly how he did everything he did, down to, like, the minute detail. And so it made the most sense to have, as we're telling you, the things that happened do it from almost his perspective.
Matt Frederick
I thought I could control it. I soon realized I was in over my head and I was too embarrassed to ask for help. I quickly was into sexual fantasies beyond my control. I had set my goals to be a white hat high, but the lifeboat drifted away from my reach until the deep water became my coping. I had trusted myself to steer the right course. But when I studied books about past serial killers, the more I learned, the closer I came to believe I could someday become one. I was on a powerful train and could not get off. The track was set. Superman could stop it, but I was not Superman. To cope with what I was doing, I cubed like I would do as a kid. The only way we know most of that stuff is because he said it out loud.
Laura
Right.
Matt Frederick
Whether in court, like on live television, or to Katherine Ramslin, the person who wrote the book with him, or, you know, several other people that he's spoken to over the years. But most of it are words directly from his mouth.
Trevor Young
Yeah.
Matt Frederick
So you kind of have to say who this guy is and then let people go into his mind.
Trevor Young
Yeah.
Matt Frederick
And it's my voice, by the way, so sorry about that.
Trevor Young
Yeah. Matt is the Voice actor for Dennis Rader in the series for anybody who doesn't know. Fun little nugget there. And I'll just say, I think that's important to the series for a number of reasons. But, you know, I think the biggest thing is understanding the mind of a killer, essentially. Right. I think this is the first time we've kind of intimately put you deep into the psych of these people in this kind of way. And I think through that, hopefully we have a deeper and darker understanding of who these types of people are. And with that sort of insight, we know how to catch this stuff much sooner. Right. Like, the whole second episode of the series is like, understanding the upbringing and childhood of this person. And, you know, if they knew the things then that we know now, maybe this wouldn't have happened. Right.
Laura
Trevor, do you have any processes that you go through when you're deep in a case and you're investigating these, you know, really dark.
Trevor Young
You mean for, like, how to. Stories, how to manage it mentally?
Laura
Yeah. How you manage it. I think I. I think mental health is a big question that a lot of True crime listeners have, and I think it's really valuable to share, like, how you separate yourself while you're, you know, all in on a story like this.
Trevor Young
Hmm. I mean, this is probably not the answer you want to hear or that you want to, like, replicate or share to people, but to be honest, while I'm in the middle of something, I intentionally don't. I intentionally like to go all in and let it kind of consume me for however many months that it's part of my life. And then what I do after it's over is I have, like, a long, like, detox period, essentially.
Matt Frederick
Right.
Trevor Young
So, like, I almost feel like it's necessary to, like, like, really throw myself into it to, like, get the best product. And then once it's over, then I just go through, like, a sort of, like, tearing apart away from it and then, like, kind of refinding myself, you know, and that is very much like a producer thing to do. And that's why I don't recommend people do that. Like, it's like a. I don't know. I don't even know what to think.
Matt Frederick
You're such a musician, Trevor.
Laura
Gosh, man.
Matt Frederick
You're so, like, whatever.
Trevor Young
I don't know.
Matt Frederick
Trevor's an incredible musician by.
Laura
I can't wait to ask about that after we stop rolling. Did you do any music on the show?
Trevor Young
No. No. So the person who does all the music for all these shows is a Makeup and vanity set, Matt. And he is phenomenal. He's like, one of the best composers I've ever met and even really just listened to in general. He's amazing. So, no, he scores everything for all these monster shows. Lovely guy.
Laura
So in a broader sense, who do you hope listens to shows like this, to the monster franchise shows, and what do you hope they gain from them?
Matt Frederick
Well, first of all, I hope everybody listens. That's over the age of, let's say, 17, maybe. Let's just. Let's be safe. I hope everybody listens because these shows. Well, I'm so biased. They're important to me because I do think there are stories in here you're not gonna hear anywhere else about things that we can all learn from. And most of it is just how our. Our minds work. And, you know, there's this weird thing. I don't know if you ever have this, but sometimes I feel really weird about just being either so nerdy or into the hobbies I'm into or just the way I think sometimes, like, oh, man, people are going to think I'm a weirdo for thinking that way. But when you listen to these shows about the actual, real horrifying things that could be going on in your mind, that the actions you could be taking because you. You can see images, you can see the terrible stuff that exists out there that monsters do, your weird little thing playing video games all the time makes you. Makes me feel really good about it. I know that's a weird answer, but really, like this. Sometimes you. When you see the darkness, like the true darkness, it makes you appreciate whatever little spark of light you've got going on, especially if you're in a. I've been in a couple of dark mental places in my life, and I would say this show has helped me realize that, man, it is never as bad as. As it could be.
Trevor Young
Yeah. I don't know if I have an answer to the question of, you know, who I would want to listen to this, just because I don't know if I really think about that necessarily when I go into it. You know, I think my approach to telling these stories is first and foremost a responsibility to the people in the stories. Right. And, you know, getting what they have to say out into the world in a way that feels responsible and important. And in my mind, there's, like, nobody on this planet who wouldn't benefit from telling what are some of the most significant, most harrowing and emotional stories that we've ever faced as a modern society. I Can't think of anybody who shouldn't be exposed to, you know, what it's like to lose someone close to you or the kind of effect that violence has on our lives. You know, I think it's too important to limit it to any one demographic or type of person.
Laura
I really like the tidbit that you had of by seeing the dark, it allows us to acknowledge the light. I hear what you're saying and that it did resonate with me. Last question that I will ask you all is whether there's any updates on past cases that we can expect. Because some of these cases are, well, closed, but quite a few of them you all reopened. A lot of kind of new light within them. So I'm curious if there's been any new information that's released in any of the monster series stories or that you all are planning to release release in the future. If you go back and revisit any of these.
Trevor Young
I'll just say real quick. I think we generally try and pick cases that aren't open and shut as much as possible. I think we like to leave people with a feeling of there's still more to be discovered here. Finding stories that are, you know, finished already. Just what's the point? You know, to some degree, obviously there is some point, right, in re examining something, but I think we always want to touch on something that feels like it's ongoing somehow. So Matt alluded to this already, but, like, there are more developments in the Atlanta child murders case that will likely be explored by us sometime in the future. D.C. sniper. You know, we touched on this at the end of the podcast, but it's going to be going on for years. Lee Boyd Malvo's the young boy in that case. His initiative to try and get parole essentially is going to be an ongoing legal battle that will have a lot of huge implications for the legal system as it develops. And again, that'll probably go on for the rest of his life. So that's something to always keep an eye on. And then the BTK case, I will just say I don't want to spoil anything for the end of the series, but anybody who pays attention to the news will see that it's very likely that the murders we knew about during that run were not the only ones. And this is all very new developing information that there are probably other BTK murders that we don't know about or we're learning about in real time as we speak. So, yeah, all of these things have developments, and we're always trying to keep our finger on the pulse and you know, update things as we go. But you know, I'll let Matt speak to the rest of it.
Matt Frederick
Yes, there's more coming and more shows and more Monster.
Laura
I love it. Thank you both so much for this conversation. I had a great time, which is kind of an odd thing to say, I guess, given the content. But it's really been fascinating to hear more about all the work, all of the intention, all of the research and empathy and everything that goes into these shows. And thank you for the work that you do. I'm excited to finish Monster btk. I have not listened to the whole series yet. I'm with everybody else week by week with waiting for it to come out. So thank you all so much. Any final words or sign offs?
Matt Frederick
Well, you can visit monster-podcast.com and check out every season. If you don't know a lot about each one, you can learn more about each one. Like I think Zodiac has some really cool art and some cool behind the scenes stuff. I think we did the same thing, at least a little bit with DC Sniper and La Monstro the Turtro Affair. Yeah, there's all, there's video, all kinds of stuff. Go check it out.
Laura
Thank you guys so much.
Trevor Young
Yeah, thank you so much. Appreciate it.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and safeway now through June 17th. Shop in store or online for your favorite personal care Items and save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Stock up on items like like Dove Body Wash, Degree Motion Sense Deodorant, Tresemme Hairspray, Dove Shampoo, Dove Bar Soap, Dove Men's Body and face Wash and Dollar Shave Club blades. And save $5 when you spend $15 or more. Hurry in before these deals are gone. Offer ends June 17. Promotions may vary. Restrictions apply. Visit albertsons or safeway.com for more details.
California Psychics
At California Psychics, we know that sometimes you can wake up thinking.
Matt Frederick
I don't know if I'm in the right career ew or the right relationship.
California Psychics
But whatever your life dilemma at California Psychics, we'll give you the guidance you need to feel certain about your life choices. And because we only connect you with the very best, we guarantee if your reading isn't life changing, it's free. California psychics. Call 1-800-PREDICT today and get 20 minutes for just $20.
Cindy Crawford
Add dry eye relief to your routine with refresh Optave Mega 3, a lubricating eye drop with a moisture rich, preservative free formula enhanced with inactive ingredients like flaxseed oil and antioxidants. This formula supports all three tear film layers and provides advanced hydration to instantly moisturize and soothe dry eyes. Refresh Optiv Mega 3 is safe to use as often as needed so you can make it part of your wellness routine. Find Refresh online or in the Eye Drop section the of at all major retailers. FSA and HSA Eligible. Does Friendly have a taste? If it does, it's probably like hello's.
Laura
Peppermint Flavored Anti Plaque and Whitening Toothpaste.
Cindy Crawford
Brush away plaque, show tartar who's boss and remove surface stains to naturally whiten.
Laura
Hello's thoughtful and Flavor Forward products make brushing your teeth feel like a confetti.
Cindy Crawford
Filled bathroom dance party. So say hello to hello with the.
Laura
Always cruelty Free Be Never Tested on Animals toothpaste that's made to spread smiles.
Cindy Crawford
Visit helloproducts. Com and let hello add some everyday Yay into your life.
Trevor Young
You're listening to an iHeart podcast.
Podcast Information:
Release Date: May 21, 2025
In this special bonus episode of the "Monster" series, host Laura from Tenderfoot TV engages in an in-depth conversation with Matt Frederick and Trevor Young, the executive producers behind the acclaimed "Monster" podcast franchise. The discussion delves into the evolution of the series, the meticulous research and production processes, and the emotional and ethical considerations involved in recounting real-life horror stories.
Timestamp: [02:15] – [06:09]
Laura introduces Matt Frederick and Trevor Young, highlighting Matt's role as the lead executive producer at iHeartMedia and the significant contributions both have made to the "Monster" series over nearly a decade. Matt shares his journey from a film graduate and intern at How Stuff Works to becoming an executive producer, emphasizing his passion for investigative journalism and true crime storytelling.
Notable Quote:
Matt Frederick [03:23]: "I'm a super nerdy actor, drummer kid that came out of high school... pivoted to audio and became an executive producer."
Timestamp: [04:00] – [09:06]
Matt discusses the inception of "Atlanta Monster," a pivotal series that set the foundation for the "Monster" franchise. Initially intended as a one-off project, the show focused on the Atlanta child murders and the controversial conviction of Wayne Williams. Collaboration with Tenderfoot TV allowed Matt and his team to harness their research expertise, leading to a richly detailed narrative that unearthed archival materials previously unseen.
Notable Quote:
Matt Frederick [07:56]: "We were going through archives that had never been digitized before... hundreds of hours of material."
Timestamp: [09:27] – [13:30]
Reopening the Atlanta child murders case posed significant challenges. Matt explains the complexities of navigating public skepticism, historical biases, and uncovering new evidence that suggested Wayne Williams might not be solely responsible for the murders. The team grappled with the ethical implications of questioning a long-standing conviction and the potential impact on the victims' families and the community.
Notable Quote:
Matt Frederick [10:30]: "We keep going and we keep giving notes, we keep making passes to perfect it as much as we possibly can."
Timestamp: [15:28] – [32:39]
Following the success of "Atlanta Monster," the team swiftly moved to the "Zodiac Killer" series, marking their first exploration outside of Atlanta. Matt and Trevor outline the logistical and creative adjustments required to tackle a case set in San Francisco, including extensive travel for interviews and deep archival research. The inclusion of seasoned journalist Tony Harris brought an authentic perspective, enhancing the storytelling with his firsthand experience covering the case.
Notable Quote:
Trevor Young [25:18]: "We needed a bigger team if we're going to expand this... that's when me and a handful of others were brought on."
Timestamp: [33:11] – [48:38]
Laura probes into the methodologies the producers employ when dealing with traumatic and sensitive subjects. Matt and Trevor emphasize the importance of empathy, building trust with interviewees, and allowing survivors to narrate their stories without manipulation. They discuss the balance between thorough investigative journalism and respectful storytelling, highlighting their commitment to avoiding retraumatization of those involved.
Notable Quote:
Trevor Young [44:29]: "Approach it with a degree of softness and being unthreatening... an overwhelming friendliness that puts people at ease."
Timestamp: [51:43] – [54:15]
The conversation shifts to the franchise's expansion beyond the United States, with Matt recounting the addition of "La Monstre" based in Belgium. While acknowledging that Matt Graves spearheaded this international addition, both Matt and Trevor express enthusiasm for exploring global cases, hinting at future projects that will delve into monster cases from various countries.
Notable Quote:
Trevor Young [52:46]: "We are working on a sort of ongoing monster series that would explore cases in different countries."
Timestamp: [55:35] – [60:08]
The episode highlights the selection of Susan Peters, a seasoned TV journalist from Wichita, as the host for the "Monster: BTK" series. Trevor and Matt discuss how Susan's deep connections to the BTK case and her extensive journalism background made her the ideal host. Her firsthand experience and relationships with key individuals, including the family of victims and investigators, provide the series with unparalleled depth and authenticity.
Notable Quote:
Matt Frederick [60:29]: "We wouldn't have had that kind of access without Susan's involvement."
Timestamp: [61:21] – [63:53]
Matt and Trevor elaborate on the innovative narrative structure of "Monster: BTK." Unlike previous series that maintained the mystery of the killer’s identity throughout, "Monster: BTK" reveals Dennis Rader's identity early on. This approach allows listeners to delve deep into his psyche, exploring the motivations and circumstances that shaped his monstrous actions. Matt shares excerpts from Rader’s own words, providing chilling insights directly from the culprit.
Notable Quotes:
Matt Frederick [62:31]: "The only way we know most of that stuff is because he said it out loud."
Trevor Young [63:44]: "Understanding the mind of a killer, essentially... a deeper and darker understanding of who these types of people are."
Timestamp: [64:54] – [66:08]
Laura addresses the emotional impact of working on such dark and disturbing cases. Trevor candidly shares his personal coping mechanisms, including immersing himself fully in the project and subsequently undergoing a "detox period" to reclaim his mental well-being post-production. Matt emphasizes the importance of balancing intense investigative work with personal mental health practices.
Notable Quote:
Trevor Young [65:35]: "I throw myself into it to get the best product, and then I go through a tearing apart away from it to refind myself."
Timestamp: [66:14] – [69:56]
Matt expresses his hope that a wide audience engages with the "Monster" series, highlighting its educational and psychological value. He believes that understanding the darkest aspects of human behavior can foster greater empathy and awareness among listeners. Trevor underscores the responsibility they hold in conveying these stories responsibly, aiming to inform and enlighten without sensationalizing the tragedies.
Notable Quotes:
Matt Frederick [66:42]: "Sometimes when you see the darkness, it makes you appreciate whatever little spark of light you've got going on."
Trevor Young [68:14]: "Nobody on this planet who wouldn't benefit from telling what are some of the most significant, most harrowing and emotional stories."
Timestamp: [70:00] – [72:53]
The duo discusses upcoming projects and ongoing developments within existing cases. Matt hints at more episodes and expansions of the franchise, while Trevor touches on the continuous nature of certain cases like the Atlanta child murders and BTK, suggesting that new findings will be incorporated into future series releases.
Notable Quote:
Trevor Young [71:35]: "There are probably other BTK murders that we don't know about or we're learning about in real time as we speak."
Timestamp: [72:15] – [75:01]
As the episode wraps up, Matt directs listeners to monster-podcast.com for more information on all seasons, including behind-the-scenes content and artwork. Both Matt and Trevor express gratitude for the opportunity to share their work and encourage listeners to engage with the series for a deeper understanding of these complex and haunting cases.
Notable Quote:
Matt Frederick [72:15]: "They're important to me because I do think there are stories in here you're not gonna hear anywhere else about things that we can all learn from."
For More Information: Visit monster-podcast.com to explore all seasons, including "Atlanta Monster," "Zodiac Killer," "DC Sniper," and the upcoming "Monster: BTK."