Episode Overview

Podcast: Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer
Episode: NEW: High Strange S2 - From Tenderfoot TV
Date: February 19, 2026
Host Network: iHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV

This episode presents a featured segment from the new season of High Strange, a podcast exploring UFOs and unexplained phenomena, hosted by true crime investigative journalist Payne Lindsay. The episode delves into the chilling account of an alleged alien abduction, with firsthand narration from the experiencer and an investigator's perspective, capturing both the psychological and visceral impacts of the event. Notably, the excerpt also discusses the use of forensic hypnosis in recovering lost memories.

Main Theme and Purpose

• Introduction of "High Strange" Season 2: The episode introduces listeners to the expanded investigative scope of Payne Lindsay, moving from true crime to UFOs and the mysteries of intelligent extraterrestrial life.
• Exploration of a Notable Abduction Case: A firsthand narrative of a 1985 alien abduction experience serves as the centerpiece, focusing on terror, confusion, and attempts to recall repressed memories through hypnosis.
• Questioning Official Narratives: The show challenges listeners to reconsider what authorities reveal about extraterrestrial life and unexplained events.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. High Strange – A New Investigative Angle

• Payne Lindsay’s Credibility: The episode sets up Payne Lindsay as a persistent investigator who applies his true crime skills to UFO phenomena.
• Continued Curiosity: The show’s tone encourages skepticism and curiosity regarding government transparency about intelligent life (“How confident are you that the government is telling us the whole truth about intelligent life beyond our planet?” [00:03], Speaker A).

2. The Abduction Experience Recounted

• Setting and Incident:

  • Date: December 26, 1985.
  • Experiencer described a peaceful day with family, leading to a night of terror:
    “It was me, my wife and our son, who was then six. Beautiful afternoon right after Christmas…Went to bed and in the middle of the night became aware of the fact that there were noises around me, movement.” [01:16], Speaker C

• Initial Disorientation and Fear:

  • Realization of being somewhere other than his bedroom; description of a strange room (“arched door and a little black window in was really weird.” [01:55], Speaker C).
  • Sensation of presence: “Felt like I was in a room full of people and I was supposed to be in my bedroom alone with my wife.” [01:30], Speaker C

• Encounter with Entities:

  • First sight: “I saw these big black eyes peering at me from about two feet away.” [02:41], Speaker C
  • Creature description: “Found myself in a room full of what looked like gigantic insects. It was horrifying.” [02:59], Speaker C
  • Movement: “They would move very slowly and then very quickly. They were not of this world at all.” [04:24], Speaker C

3. Hypnosis and Memory Recovery

• Engagement with a Forensic Hypnotist:

  • Dr. Donald Klein, famed for solving criminal cases with hypnosis, is called in to help recover repressed memories ([03:33], Speaker C).
  • Describes the trance experience and gradual return of suppressed details.

• Recovered Memories:

  • Scenes of paralysis, inability to escape or even imagine returning to his bed ("I couldn't get off of it. I couldn't move it. I kept trying to imagine my bed. I couldn't do that either." [04:44], Speaker C).
  • Vividness and terror: “It was so vivid. It was like real life. I remembered those faces. And they weren’t human.” [04:44], Speaker C

4. Communication with the Entities

• Mechanical Voice:

  • Experiencer hears a “mechanical voice” repeating:
    • “What can we do to help you?” [05:18], Speaker C
    • “Stop screaming. Why don't you like me?” [05:30], Speaker B

• Fear and Confusion:

  • The interviewer and subject both react with visceral fear and disbelief (e.g., “Jesus.” [05:37], Speaker B; “Holy shit. I'm sorry.” [05:41], Speaker B).

5. Alien Procedures and Psychological Trauma

• Descriptions of Alien Physiology and Behavior:

  • Comparison to real-world insects: “You ever, when you were a kid, maybe watch a praying mantis?...That’s how they moved.” [05:53], Speaker C
  • Size: “One of them was about 5ft tall. The others were all very small.” [06:19], Speaker C

• Details of the Encounter:

  • Encountering a medical device: “They showed me a needle. They’re gonna put it in the side of my head.” [06:25], Speaker C
  • Physical sensations: “He touches my head with this thing. I realized then this was physical.” [06:32], Speaker B & C

• Lingering Panic:

  • Attempts to calm down, both by experiencer and others (“Relax. Please.” [07:00], Speaker A; “Stop it. And second largest. Relax.” [07:03], Speaker B)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “How confident are you that the government is telling us the whole truth about intelligent life beyond our planet?”
  — Speaker A, [00:03]
• “I saw these big black eyes peering at me from about two feet away.”
  — Speaker C, [02:41]
• “Found myself in a room full of what looked like gigantic insects. It was horrifying.”
  — Speaker C, [02:59]
• “What can we do to help you?”
  — Repeated mechanical voice, Speaker C, [05:18]
• “You ever, when you were a kid, maybe watch a praying mantis?...That's how they moved.”
  — Speaker C, [05:53]
• “One of them was about 5ft tall. The others were all very small. They showed me a needle. They're gonna put it in the side of my head.”
  — Speaker C, [06:19]
• “I realized then this was physical.”
  — Speaker C, [06:43]
• Emotional reactions:
  • “Jesus.” [05:37], Speaker B
  • “Holy shit. I'm sorry.” [05:41], Speaker B

Important Timestamps

• 00:03: Introduction to the new season of High Strange
• 01:16: Narrative of the night of the alleged abduction begins
• 02:41: First visual description of the extraterrestrial beings
• 03:33: Introduction of Dr. Donald Klein and the hypnosis process
• 04:24: Entities’ movement and otherworldly nature described
• 05:18: Disturbing communication with the beings
• 05:53: Description of the beings’ size, behavior, and medical procedure
• 06:43: Confrontation with the reality of physical interaction
• 07:00–07:18: Emotional climax and attempts at reassurance

Tone and Style

The episode maintains a tense, investigative mood, with immersive storytelling by the abductee interspersed with authentic, emotionally charged dialogue. Listeners are made to feel the terror and confusion of the event, while also being subtly pushed to think about broader questions of official secrecy and unexplained phenomena.

Summary

This episode serves as both an introduction to the new season of High Strange and a prime example of its investigative, experiential storytelling. Listeners are drawn into a raw, unsettling account of alien abduction, amplified by forensic detail and vulnerability. The focus on memory, trauma, and the search for truth aligns with both Monster’s and High Strange’s investigative spirits, making this excerpt a compelling bridge between true crime and the hunt for high strangeness.