Morning Joe 11/22/24

Summary

Morning Joe Summary: November 22, 2024

Podcast Information:

• Title: Morning Joe
• Hosts: Joe Scarborough, Mika Brzezinski, Willie Geist
• Episode: Morning Joe 11/22/24
• Release Date: November 22, 2024

---

1. Attorney General Nomination: Matt Gaetz's Withdrawal and Pam Bondi's Nomination

Timestamp: 01:03 - 15:35

Overview: The episode delves into the recent withdrawal of Congressman Matt Gaetz as President Elect Donald Trump's nominee for Attorney General. Gaetz's exit places heightened pressure on Trump to secure a suitable replacement swiftly. Amidst Gaetz's scandals, including allegations of sexual misconduct and illicit drug use—which he vehemently denies—Trump has nominated Pam Bondi as the new Attorney General candidate.

Key Points:

• Gaetz's Withdrawal: Gaetz stepped down citing that his confirmation was becoming a distraction from the critical work of the Trump-Vance transition. His withdrawal was influenced by mounting pressure from Senate Republicans and pending ethics reports.

• Pam Bondi’s Nomination: Bondi, the former Florida Attorney General, is presented as a more qualified and less controversial candidate compared to Gaetz. She brings extensive prosecutorial experience, having handled major cases, including death penalty cases, and has strong ties with Trump, having endorsed him in 2016.

Notable Quotes:

• Joe Scarborough [01:16]: “This puts a lot of pressure on Trump because now there's not much time to find somebody worse.”

• Al Sharpton [07:11]: “Pam Bondi is certainly on the right, but she is one who's qualified to become attorney general in terms of she's handled cases, she's managed offices.”

• Mika Brzezinski [12:01]: “Pam Bondi was a career prosecutor down there in Hillsborough County for many, many years before she was elected Florida's first female attorney general.”

• John Avalon [15:35]: “It was better for Trump, not that I'm a Trump person at all, but it was better for him and certainly better for the American public to get Gaetz off the scene as soon as possible.”

---

2. Sports Segment: Browns vs Steelers NFL Game Recap

Timestamp: 01:43 - 05:01

Overview: The hosts and guests shift gears to discuss a thrilling NFL matchup between the Cleveland Browns and Pittsburgh Steelers, played under intense snow conditions. The game mirrored classic AFC Central confrontations from the '70s and '80s, showcasing the unpredictability and excitement of football.

Key Points:

• Game Highlights: Despite the Steelers' strong 8-2 record against the Browns' 2-8 standing, the Browns clinched the win with a late touchdown by Nick Chubb and a crucial field goal by Jameis Winston in the snowy conditions of Cleveland.

• Player Performance: Jameis Winston's ability to lead the team effectively under adverse weather contrasted with the Steelers' inability to score in the final drive.

Notable Quotes:

• Richard Haas [03:02]: “Whenever you have to plow the yard lines, Joe, you know you're in for a good game.”

• Joe Scarborough [04:25]: “Jameis Winston came in and did what Deshaun Watson with all his money and all the baggage could not do.”

• Richard Haas [04:48]: “Jameis Winston's been bouncing around the league. Just a hugely talented player...maybe finding a new home in Cleveland.”

---

3. Senate Races and Implications: Bob Casey Concedes to Dave McCormick

Timestamp: 32:55 - 36:23

Overview: The podcast covers the significant political development in Pennsylvania, where incumbent Democratic Senator Bob Casey conceded to Republican Dave McCormick after a narrow victory. This shift has substantial implications for the Democratic Party, particularly concerning the Senate's balance of power.

Key Points:

• Election Results: Dave McCormick won the Senate race by a margin of just over 16,000 votes, triggering an automatic recount. The GOP now holds the majority in the Senate with a 53-40 split.

• Implications for Democrats: This loss signals mounting challenges for Democrats in appealing to working-class voters, especially in traditionally secure states like Pennsylvania.

Notable Quotes:

• Bob Casey [32:55]: “Pennsylvanians can move forward with the knowledge that their voices were heard.”

• Dave McCormick [Friend’s Statement]: “Senator Bob Casey dedicated his career to bettering our Commonwealth...”

• Joe Scarborough [34:54]: “Dave McCormick is the type of Republican candidate that can win a state like Pennsylvania...”

---

4. Democratic Strategy and Voter Outreach

Timestamp: 34:54 - 42:44

Overview: The hosts and guests discuss the Democratic Party's evolving strategy in light of recent electoral setbacks. Emphasis is placed on addressing critical issues such as personal safety, economic security, and effective voter outreach to regain support among working-class voters.

Key Points:

• Addressing Core Issues: Democrats need to prioritize personal safety and economic security to resonate with voters who prioritize these concerns over other issues like reproductive rights.

• Voter Outreach: Enhanced engagement with black communities and working-class voters is essential. The current approach has been perceived as focusing too much on identity politics and not enough on broader economic and safety issues.

• Party Positioning: Moving from a defensive to an offensive strategy is crucial. Democrats must present themselves as proactive leaders rather than defenders of the status quo.

Notable Quotes:

• Mika Brzezinski [37:10]: “People will vote for strong and wrong every time... Democrats gotta get off defense and playing offense.”

• John Avalon [37:20]: “Pam Bondi's nomination should give Democrats some relief.”

• Mika Brzezinski [41:49]: “If people don't feel safe and they don't feel economically secure, yeah, everything else is secondary.”

---

5. Social Media Platforms: BlueSky vs Threads vs X

Timestamp: 53:29 - 61:51

Overview: The conversation shifts to the evolving landscape of social media platforms, particularly focusing on the rise of BlueSky as an alternative to Elon Musk's X (formerly Twitter) and Meta's Threads. The hosts analyze the challenges and potential of these platforms in fostering meaningful dialogue free from manipulation and algorithm-driven content.

Key Points:

• BlueSky's Growth: BlueSky has experienced a surge in user adoption, with traffic increasing over 500% since November 5, attributed to dissatisfaction with existing platforms like X and Threads.

• Challenges with Threads: Unlike BlueSky, Threads failed to replicate the dynamic newsfeed and direct engagement that made platforms like Twitter valuable. Issues with fake accounts and lack of meaningful interaction contributed to its shortcomings.

• BlueSky's Potential: Free from Elon Musk's content curation policies and monetization strategies that encouraged trolling and misinformation, BlueSky is positioned as a platform for genuine conversation and diverse viewpoints.

Notable Quotes:

• Willie Geist [54:05]: “This was Mastodon, this is BlueSky, this is Threads. And so it's an attempt to siphon off the...”

• Willie Geist [57:07]: “BlueSky has a chance. Because without Elon's thumb on the scale, I'm getting the sense that I can actually maybe talk to people.”

• Joe Scarborough [56:11]: “What happens periodically is that... attempts to form the equivalent of a spring football league of social media.”

---

6. Foreign Policy Briefing: Ukraine Conflict and Russia's Posturing

Timestamp: 50:33 - 52:10

Overview: Mika Brzezinski provides insight into the ongoing Ukraine conflict, interpreting Russia's recent missile threats as posturing aimed at influencing negotiations rather than direct military aggression.

Key Points:

• Russian Actions: The firing of a medium-range ballistic missile by Russia is seen as a strategic move to set the stage for potential negotiations on the battlefield.

• Ukrainian Defense: Increased support for Ukraine from the U.S. is prompting retaliatory actions from Russia, which are ultimately aimed at gaining leverage in future talks.

Notable Quotes:

• Mika Brzezinski [50:54]: “I seriously put my money. This is a prelude to negotiations.”

• Joe Scarborough [51:16]: “We allow Ukraine to fire missiles deeper into Russia. Russia fires a missile that can go deeper and they start talking about going after bases in Poland...”

---

Closing Remarks

The episode wraps up with light-hearted banter about the discussed NFL game and advertisements for various products and services. The hosts emphasize the importance of addressing critical issues to ensure voter confidence and the future trajectory of the Democratic Party.

---

Conclusion: This episode of Morning Joe provides a comprehensive analysis of significant political developments, including the Attorney General nomination shift, Senate race outcomes, Democratic strategy recalibrations, and the evolving social media landscape. Additionally, it offers a brief but insightful look into foreign policy dynamics regarding the Ukraine conflict. The discussion underscores the interconnectedness of political maneuvering, voter engagement, and media influence in shaping the current and future political climate.

Transcript

[Joe Scarborough]

The kind of burgers you get today.

[Willie Geist]

Tells you a lot about yourself. You're either someone who settles for sad.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Same old, same old burgers or you're Edit Carl's Jr obsessed with a tangy OG Western bacon cheeseburger demanding a house made guacamole, loaded guac bacon fired up.

[Joe Scarborough]

For the insanely hot El Diablo or.

[Willie Geist]

Craving a classic Charbold Famous Star.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Give in to your flavored cravings.

[Joe Scarborough]

Do your mouth to Carl's Jr Big Burger good Burger.

[Al Sharpton]

Have you met All Modern? All Modern brings you the best of modern furniture and right now through November 30, you'll score up to 70% off during their Black Friday sale. Prep your space for holiday hosting with deals on plush sofas, modern tabletop essentials, and more. All on sale at All Modern. Then get them delivered for free in days. You heard that right.

[Joe Scarborough]

Days.

[Al Sharpton]

That's modern made simple. Shop All Modern's Black Friday sale now through November 30th at allmodern.com.

[Joe Scarborough]

Former Florida.

[Willie Geist]

Congressman Matt Gaetz withdrew today as President Elect Trump's nominee for Attorney General.

[Joe Scarborough]

This puts a lot of pressure on Trump because now there's not much time to find somebody worse.

[Willie Geist]

He dropped out on social media posting.

[Joe Scarborough]

While the momentum was strong. It is clear that my confirmation was unfairly becoming a distraction to the critical work of the Trump Vance transition.

[Mika Brzezinski]

That is true.

[Willie Geist]

All of this attention on this sex criminal was unfairly distracting from the critical work of all the other sex criminals.

[Joe Scarborough]

Who have been nominated. This was a shocking announcement from the.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Trump team and as you can say.

[Joe Scarborough]

No one was more surprised than Matt Gay. Late Night show reactions really the and we're going to go through the headlines, but I think, you know, as a football fan, what I really want to be talking about right now. But here's the New York Times. Gates Withdraws Wall Street Journal Gates is out. Bondi is picked at doj.

[Sam Stein]

Interesting.

[Joe Scarborough]

And the New York Post still the official newspaper record for Morning Joe. Shut the Gates. I don't know if you have a laugh. We've been saying that for a year.

[Sam Stein]

But Willie, I think they like the picture.

[Joe Scarborough]

Oh, okay. Shut the Gates. Growing up for five years in upstate New York, our dream was going out, running out just like you in New Jersey. And when it started snowing, you know, we'd get the Nerf football, which by the way had the consistency of a rock after about three minutes outside in the freezing weather. And we would dream of being like the Browns and the Steelers, literally the Browns and the Steelers or the Vikings and whatever the bingo. And in. In the snow. Man, and last night, what a dream for the black. And. Yeah, that was unbelievable.

[Richard Haas]

Whenever you have to plow the yard lines, Joe, you know you're in for a good game. So the players can see him this game. Last night, Thursday nighter, in Cleveland in the snow. Browns, Steelers, Cleveland, Pittsburgh. All that was missing was John Fascenda's voice on NFL Films. Jameis Winston diving into the end zone here. It was a mismatch on paper. The Steelers came in 8 and 2, the Browns 2 and 8. But it was in Cleveland. It was in the snow. What a catch there. And the Browns get the job done. Nick Chubb scored a late touchdown. The Steelers couldn't score on their final drive. Browns get the win at home in the snow. That is just a thing of beauty.

[Joe Scarborough]

I mean, you'll remember the old black and blue division and the nfc. Was that the NFC Central? No. Yeah, yeah, I think NFC Central and then the AFC Central. Now they, you know, we have, like, 87 divisions, so I guess this is the AFC North. But, yeah, these are like the classic, classic games. And really the story here also, Steelers, you know, gonna end up in the playoffs. They're such an incredibly balanced team. But Jameis Winston, man, he came in and did what Deshaun Watson with all his money and all the baggage could not do. And there's Nick Chubb. So good to see him running again.

[Richard Haas]

Yeah, Jameis Winston's been bouncing around the league. Just. Hugely talented player. Had some good early years in Tampa, but sort of become an NFL journeyman and now maybe, maybe finding a new home in Cleveland. He looked. He looked good last night as the Browns, and of course, the dog pound, the fans, the stadium stays filled despite the weather. It's exactly the kind of game those fans like.

[Joe Scarborough]

And, Mika, do you know how they celebrated the victory?

[Sam Stein]

Celebrate. That looks cool.

[Joe Scarborough]

I promise. They went out and they made snow angels.

[Al Sharpton]

No, they didn't.

[Joe Scarborough]

Yes, they did. And they even got some of the announcers to come out, and they all made snow there, you see?

[Sam Stein]

You know what we need? A reason to smile. Along with Joe, Willie and me, we have the president of the National Action Network and host of MSNBC's Politics Nation, Reverend Al Sharpton. Managing editor at the Bulwark, Sam Stein. Doing way too early for us this morning, President emeritus of the Council on Foreign Relations, Richard Haas. He's the author of the weekly newsletter Home and Away, available on Substack. And former congressional candidate in New York's First District, our friend John Avlon. Joins us this morning. Good to have you, Sam.

[Joe Scarborough]

Wasn't there a Patriots game where a snow plow was strategically used, employed at the end before they kicked a field goal to win?

[Mika Brzezinski]

Yes, I think so.

[Richard Haas]

And was it a real snowplow or one like baby snowplows and they had to get the little marker. And then of course there was the famous Vinitari field go after the. Yeah, why am I blanking on the tuck rule game?

[Joe Scarborough]

Exactly so much. Our sports correspondent.

[Sam Stein]

We have a lot of news.

[Joe Scarborough]

Sam Stein. That is news, Nika.

[Mika Brzezinski]

This is news.

[Sam Stein]

That's not news. Here's news for you. Donald Trump has announced a new attorney general pick. The name is Pam Bondi. Bondi served as the state attorney general in Florida from 2011 to 2019. Before that, she spent more than 18 years as a prosecutor. Currently a partner at a lobbying firm, Bondi has long ties with the president elect. Back in 2016, on the eve of the Republican primary in Florida, Bondi endorsed Trump, picking him over the candidate from her own state. Senator Marco Rubio, 59 year old, later joined Trump's legal team defending the then president in his first impeachment trial. When Trump's first attorney attorney general, Jeff Sessions, was ousted in 2018, Bondi's name was floated then as a possible replacement. In a statement announcing his new AG pick, President elect Trump called Bondi an America first fighter, saying she will, quote, refocus the DOJ to its intended purpose of fighting crime and making America safe again.

[Joe Scarborough]

And Willie, very interesting. Dave Ehrenberg, of course, right now, Palm Beach Counties state attorney ran against PAM BONDI In 2010 for State Attorney general in Florida. And we're going to have him later on in the show to talk about the new AG Peg.

[Richard Haas]

Yeah, and we'll have more on who she is and what she might bring to the job if she's confirmed in just a minute. But Pam Bondi's name came about very quickly yesterday because Matt Gaetz withdrew his name from consideration for Attorney general. Gates explained his decision, writing on social media, it is clear that my confirmation was unfairly becoming a distraction to the crit work of the Trump Vance transition. Gaetz, of course, embroiled in his own scandals, facing allegations of sexual misconduct and illicit drug use. The former congressman denies those claims. Sources tell NBC News at least five Senate Republicans were planning to vote against Gates and had communicated to other senators and those close to Trump they are unlikely to be swayed on gaetz. At least 20 senators were uncomfortable with having to vote for Gaetz for attorney general. The former congressman could only afford, of course, to lose the support of three Republicans to be confirmed, assuming no Democrats would have voted for him. So what happened here? Joining us now, congressional reporter for the Hill, Michael Schnell, NBC News justice and intelligence correspondent Ken Delanian as well. Good morning to you both. Michael, let me start with you and how this fell apart so quickly. We had heard privately and then publicly from some senators in the last 24 hours or so that they just couldn't get to. Yes. On Matt Gaetz, that this was the one perhaps nominee that they were willing to take down. So how did this happen in the end and why did he walk away?

[Al Sharpton]

Yeah, well, Willie, we know that, excuse me, former Congressman Matt Gates was on Capitol Hill two days ago. The day before he dropped out, he withdrew his name from, from consideration and he had these meetings with senators. And senators seem to be keeping an open mind, saying that the president elect deserved to pick who he wants in these positions and let them have their say and defend their nomination. But we were also hearing from those same senators that they wanted to see the ethics report into Matt Gaetz. They wanted to see the allegations and the information that had been gathered over roughly three and a half years by the House Ethics Committee. Now, the panel had been debating and weighing whether or not to release that report this week. They declined to release the report. The vote to release the report had failed. But I spoke to a source familiar with the situation who told me that members left that meeting with the understanding that the report would be, quote, ready by the time of their next meeting on December 5, indicating that another vote could potentially happen then and a vote could be successful on releasing this report. So I think that with the skepticism among senators having this real possibility of an ethics report coming out, whether it be through a formal vote of a committee, whether it be through a leak from the committee, or right now there are even House Democrats who are pushing to have a floor vote on forcing this ethics committee to release its report into Matt Gaetz. There seemed to be this concern that at the end of the day he wasn't going to be able to wrangle enough votes that his confirmation hearing would potentially be a spectacle. On the Senate side, there were some senators saying that it would be Kavanaugh on steroids, of course, referring to that very that confirmation hearing for Brett Kavanaugh that grabbed a lot of headlines, headlines. So at the end of the day, it's clear that the Trump campaign, well, rather the Trump transition team and former congressman, that case, decided that it wouldn't be Worth putting him through the next few weeks of this confirmation process, having these incessant headlines instead, have him step aside and put somebody else up for the job.

[Richard Haas]

And now questions about what happens to Matt Gaetz. Does he go back to his congressional seat? Was he promised something by President Trump to step aside, like perhaps filling the Senate seat in Florida that will be vacated by Marco Rubio? We'll see in time. So, Ken, let's look at the new choice from Donald Trump, Pam Bondi, attorney general in the state of Florida, the first female attorney general in that state, a defender of Donald Trump during impeachment, both as an attorney and on television. What else do we know about her and how justice is feeling about this choice? Well, one reaction I got from inside the Justice Department last night was this is Matt Gaetz with a better legal resume. But the legal resume is significant, Willie.

[Mika Brzezinski]

And guys, because Pam Bondi was a career prosecutor down there in Hillsborough county for many, many years before she was.

[Richard Haas]

Elected Florida's first female attorney general.

[Mika Brzezinski]

So she's prosecuted major cases, murders, death penalty cases. She understands how that works. Matt Gaetz had never really been much of a lawyer before he was elected to the Florida legislature.

[Richard Haas]

So that's a big difference.

[Mika Brzezinski]

And, you know, at the same time.

[Richard Haas]

Though, she is, you know, an extreme.

[Mika Brzezinski]

MAGA activist and has tainted her legal.

[Richard Haas]

Career with very strong stands in favor.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Of some questionable things. There was a famous incident back in.

[Richard Haas]

Around 10 years ago when, if you.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Remember, Trump University, that for profit university.

[Richard Haas]

That Donald Trump ran, was getting a.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Lot of consumer complaints about being a scam and her office was asked to join a multistate lawsuit.

[Richard Haas]

And Donald Trump's foundation contributed $25,000 to.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Her campaign and she opted not to join that lawsuit.

[Richard Haas]

And his foundation was later fined for making an illegal contribution.

[Mika Brzezinski]

So, look, she served her tenure eight.

[Richard Haas]

Years as Florida attorney general. She later went on to be one of Donald Trump's impeachment defense lawyers in the Ukraine. Impeachment in 2020, made a speech on.

[Mika Brzezinski]

The House floor during the trial arguing that there was a Biden corruption scandal.

[Richard Haas]

In Ukraine and that that's why that phone call was okay. And she's also raised questions about fraud in the 2020 election, which people think were baseless.

[Mika Brzezinski]

So it's a bit of a mixed.

[Richard Haas]

Bag, but people are breathing a little.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Bit of a sigh of relief at.

[Richard Haas]

The Justice Department that at least she's.

[Mika Brzezinski]

A real lawyer and that her deputy.

[Richard Haas]

Todd Blanche, Donald Trump's defense attorney, does have a lot of experience with the Justice Department and is also well regarded over there.

[Mika Brzezinski]

So net net people are thinking this.

[Richard Haas]

Is a much better situation than Matt Gaetz. But she is certainly a Donald Trump loyalist who has also raised questions about weaponization at the Justice Department and may really cause some trouble over there from.

[Mika Brzezinski]

The perspective of some of the career folks guys.

[Joe Scarborough]

All right, NBC's Candy Lanian, thanks so much. REV. Let's look at the headline. Obviously yesterday, you know, we had been saying on this show that it's like the old Midas commercials about when the ethics report and all the bad information came out on Matt Gaetz. You need to pay us now or you can pay us later. And the later it is, the closer it is to, you know, the more that it's actually in the middle of the new presidency. And I think that's the last thing they obviously they didn't want see this scandal in the Senate probably in January and February.

[John Avalon]

Absolutely. I think it was the wise thing for the Trump people and for President Elect Trump to withdraw him now because a long term spectacle of days and weeks would only damage them even more. Take your losses short. Let him walk away because he was never qualified and he could not give any reasonable argument as to why he'd be attorney general. I talked to people that I know in Florida last night that on the civil rights side, we have a chapter in the action network there. Bondi is certainly on the right, but she is one who's qualified to become attorney general in terms of she's handled cases, she's managed offices. And yes, we can raise questions about what she did with Trump University, but there's no glaring things in terms of her values and morals. You're talking about Gates with underage sex. You're talking about money that has been documented that was sent around and to put him in charge of the Justice Department made a mockery of the system. So I think it was better for Trump, not that I'm a Trump person at all, but it was better for him and certainly better for the American public to get Gates off the scene as soon as possible.

[Joe Scarborough]

And one of the things that Dave Ehrenberg said was he ran against or ran a tough campaign in 2010. He's coming on later and said right after she defeated him, she hired him and actually spoke out to Republicans who said, who didn't like it, saying she's good, he's good at what he does. We need him in our which shows.

[John Avalon]

Maturity, which Gates certainly lacked.

[Sam Stein]

Yeah. All right. And then there's dod, Republican senators on Capitol Hill offering mixed reactions to Pete. Hegseth's police report that revealed new and graphic details about a sexual assault allegation against the former Fox News host back in 2017. Some defended Donald Trump's pick for defense secretary, while others voiced concern.

[Joe Scarborough]

Pete is going to be a shining.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Star, inspiring young men and women not.

[Joe Scarborough]

Only to stay in the military.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Pete shared with me texts and messages that he's received from his friends who are thinking of retiring, who are now happy that he's there and are inspired to stay. Young men and women who are thinking about serving will be inspired to join. It's a disgrace that those allegations are.

[Joe Scarborough]

Nothing but what you said.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Allegations that are, he said, she said. This is a case that has been dismissed. This is just dredging up something to try to smear and discredit a candidate. It reminds me of what happened to Brett Kavanaugh. It's disgrace.

[Richard Haas]

It's a pretty big problem given that.

[Mika Brzezinski]

We have, you know, we have.

[Richard Haas]

We have a sexual assault problem in our military.

[Mika Brzezinski]

This is why you have background checks. This is why you have hearings.

[Richard Haas]

This is why you have that go through the scrutiny. I'm not gonna prejudge them, but, yeah, it's a pretty concerning accusation.

[Sam Stein]

Okay, so we're gonna note here that the police did not give a reason, but they did not charge Hegseth, and he denies any wrongdoing. Michael, back to your reporting on this one. I think the issue at hand would be perhaps that Pete Hegseth did not raise this so that transition team members and others were caught off guard. That that's. I think that's a hard issue because perhaps raising that this police report exists and this situation happened might have given them a heads up. I think what happens now, and you let me know what you're hearing in terms of reaction is, okay, what else is there? I mean, what else haven't you warned us about?

[Al Sharpton]

Yeah, Mika, it's that question of what else is here, because typically when you have these nominees and decisions to make, you have a conversation with the individual and say, okay, what skeletons in the closet do I have to know about? What do we have to be prepared to potentially respond to? But going ahead now, you mentioned, you know, there are questions of, are there any other details that can drop out from this story? But also with Matt Gaetz now out of the question and him withdrawing his name from consideration, a lot of folks, reporters and also lawmakers up on Capitol Hill are expecting that that scrutiny and that attention is now going to shift to Hegseth. In a lot of ways, Matt Gaetz was taking up the oxygen in the room with his allegations and with his nomination. Also, just the fact that he is a very polarizing figure, somebody who, it's no secret in Washington is not beloved by his colleagues. So now with Matt Gaetz out of the conversation, a lot of folks are expecting the scrutiny to increase on Pete Hegseth. And I'll say one more thing. You know, there was this big question in the Capitol of how many of these senators up on Capitol Hill who aren't the biggest fans of Donald Trump, people like Lisa Murkowski, Tom Tillis, Susan Collins and others, how many of the nominees would they actually be will willing to tank? How many times would they be willing to vote no? Because remember, assuming all Democrats vote against these controversial figures, it only takes four to kill one of these nominations. Now, with Matt Gaetz out of the question, who was very likely on his way to a failed confirmation vote because of all the controversy surrounding him, that scrutiny could shift to Hegseth and that key group of senators who were not the president's biggest fans. They could now decide, this is where I'm putting my political capital. This is where I'm going to decide to be a maverick of the Senate. And this is the nominee who I'm going to take. So, you know, good, you know, Matt Gates coming out of the spotlight. But somebody has to fill that void. It could be Pete Hegseth. It could be RFK Jr. It could be Tulsi Gabbard. But right now, it seems like Hegseth is starting to get that oxygen, the hills.

[Joe Scarborough]

Michael Chanel, thank you so much for your reporting. Greatly appreciated. A couple of things going on here, actually, and Mika alluded to it. I mean, what you're hearing, according to the New York Times is the Trump transition team is saying, okay, the police report says they're not going to press charges, but he didn't tell us about this. And then they were blindsided a second time when they found out about the police report and that he'd had the police report since 2021. And the new York Times is reporting, and I think the Washington Post as well is that that's what's really right now. Got them going again. What else is out there? I think, Richard, what's so interesting is first of all, I read the Washington Post this morning. One of the lessons from, from the Gates withdrawal was that the Senate was actually doing its job, asking the tough questions. This is what's fascinating to me as we look at this. You have people who've, and I've said that They've spent their entire adult life focusing on strengthening the military and what happens at the DOD and who runs the DOD means the world to them, just like you. There are also people who've committed their entire adult lives to strengthening the intelligence community, the intel community. So I'm just gonna say I think you can count Murkowski and I'm guessing Murkowski and Collins out on voting for either of these two candidates. For many of those reasons, that means they're two Republicans. The question is somebody in the Intel Committee. Break. Because as we know, the Intel Committee is like that last committee. They stand shoulder to shoulder. Marco Rubio, Mark Warner. You know, Intel Committee famously works together in most cases. Are there going to be two Republicans from that committee? They'd say, no. I can't put somebody who's an apologist for Assad gassing citizens, you know, in charge of intelligence. Or is it going to be two people saying we can't have somebody that has no managerial experience running the most complicated bureaucracy in Washington, D.C. that's really the question for Republican senators right now, 100%.

[Mika Brzezinski]

The issue is not or not only whether the skeleton's the closet. It's what's in the closet. These are big, important jobs at a critical time. You've got nearly 3 million people to oversee civilian and military. When you run the Pentagon, when you run the Department of Defense, we're involved or could be involved in multiple conflicts, in multiple geographies. We don't have an adequate defense industrial base and we can go on and on. That ought to be the focus of the hearings. In addition to any skeletons is what in this person's background remotely prepares him for one of the critical jobs in the United States at a turning point in history. Same thing you could ask about Tulsi Gabbard. Again, beyond does she have the judgment, does she have the managerial experience to coordinate, what is it, 17 plus agencies? And to present the President of the United States with a realistic.

[Joe Scarborough]

And again, even without Matt Gaetz's scandals, all of these questions also apply to an inexperienced ag. Pam Bondi has been an Attorney General for the third largest state in America for eight years. Okay, Matt Gaetz barely ever practiced law. So again, you've got the Justice Department. It's just you have to have somebody that has experience. Same with the dod, same with the intel agencies. But when it comes to the DoD and bureaucracies, I know somebody that, you know, somebody who worked for Dr. Brzezinski, somebody that Dr. Brzezinski considered just the best. The Best in Washington. Bob Gates. I remember reading one of Bob Gates books and Bob Gates knew, as you know, he knew how to work Washington better than anybody else. He said about 75% of his time was spent trying to stay one step ahead of the bureaucracy. Here's a genius. And he said it was constant. He goes, these people with good intentions, they have their agenda and there are hundreds of thousands of them. And even if you go into the morning at 8am and say, I'm going to change this policy or I'm going to change that policy, he's like, it's 4:00 in the afternoon and you're still trying to keep up with all the work that, by the way, you have to do. Our soldiers don't get food and you know, all of that stuff. And so here you have the best at this, saying, I may be the most experienced person in the world. This was my greatest challenge. That's why you put somebody inexperienced there, they will be running in circles.

[Mika Brzezinski]

For four years, I worked in the Pentagon. It was one of my first jobs in 1979 under the Carter administration. At one point I was pressing for something to get civilian oversight over our contingency planning. The military wasn't comfortable with it. So a colonel sat me down. He said, Mr. Haas, you're a pretty smart guy, but from where I sit, you're Christmas help. You're here for a while. You're going to be gone after the next election. I'm, however, going to be here. This is my career. No way am I going to let you and other civilians get involved in the intricacies of our defense club.

[Sam Stein]

Great story.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Has the virtue of being true, but that's what the Pentagon is like.

[Joe Scarborough]

John Avalon, by the way, I want to tell everybody we're going to be talking about the fact that the Republicans added another seat. Dave McCormick in Pennsylvania, let me tell you, a Herculean task to be a Casey, a guy that used to win by 17 points. We're going to be talking to you about, in the next segment about that win, how tough it was for Democrats. You knocked on doors, you were out there, you ran a great campaign. It was still an uphill battle. But I remember, I'm much older than you, when Ronald Reagan's people got in and they were saying a lot of things that were very similar to what the Trump people are saying now, which is, we're going to completely remake the bureaucracy. We're going to wipe these places out. And about six months into it, they're like, why did we Even come here again. It's a herculean task. And if you want to change a bureaucracy, you better have somebody in place who knows how to fight the bureaucracy.

[Mika Brzezinski]

To state the obvious, experience matters, having the ability to understand this. But I'll say this. When you have a chief executive who wants to set up panels to fire generals, that's where having a loyalist becomes incredibly dangerous. If the number one criteria is just loyalty to an executive who wants to do things that smack of authoritarian instincts, that becomes more dangerous.

[Joe Scarborough]

And John, you know what else, and we've talked about this, how short sighted it is. Do you know what happens when you fire a general? You create a legend. And when you create a legend, you start lawsuits. You start about a three year war against this general or that general. It all sounds great. Everybody's got a plan until. What does Tyson say? Everybody got a plan until you get punched in the face the first time. And all of these things that people are flexing about. I'm going to go in and I'm going to fire this. You know, you do that, you create a legend, you create a political opponent that has the entire country behind them and it makes things tougher.

[Sam Stein]

Yeah, for sure. Stay with us. Still ahead on Morning Joe, Democratic Senator Bob Casey of Pennsylvania has conceded to Republican Dave McCormick. We'll go through those results and what this means for the Democratic Party moving forward. And as we go to break, here's a look at the snowplow game Joe was talking about at the top of the show. I didn't believe you.

[Joe Scarborough]

Okay, thank you. 1982. The Patriots had a most unusual solution to a snowy problem. In the closing minutes of a scoreless.

[Richard Haas]

Tie, rookie head coach Ron Meyer called.

[Joe Scarborough]

For a masked man. A snowplow driver. Mark Henderson responded.

[Richard Haas]

A convicted burglar employed at Foxborough Stadium.

[Joe Scarborough]

On a weekend work release program, Henderson cleared the path for the decisive field goal that propelled the Patriots into the playoffs.

[Al Sharpton]

Every day, thousands of Comcast engineers and technologists put people at the heart of everything they create. Like Kunle, a Comcast engineer who began to approach work differently after becoming a father with two teenage boys at home, Kunle thinks about the generation that he is building technology for. This continues to inspire him and his team to build a fast and reliable in home wi fi solution for millions of families like his so everyone can work, learn and play together under one roof. Learn [e-mail] this podcast is supported by.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Planned Parenthood Federation of America. Planned Parenthood Federation of America exists so.

[Willie Geist]

All people can get access to the sexual and reproductive care and education they need.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Planned Parenthood organizations advocate for health equity.

[Willie Geist]

And policies that allow people the freedom.

[Mika Brzezinski]

To control their own bodies, lives and futures. More than 2 million patients a year rely on Planned Parenthood health Center services like STI testing and treatment, birth control, gender affirming care, abortion, cancer screenings and more. Reproductive health care and rights are under attack from public officials who are out of step with the will of the.

[Joe Scarborough]

Vast majority of Americans.

[Mika Brzezinski]

The constitutional right to abortion has been stolen and politicians in 47 states have introduced bills that would block people from getting the sexual and reproductive care they need. Planned Parenthood knows that equitable access to.

[Willie Geist]

Healthcare, including safe, legal abortion, is a human right.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Right now, Planned Parenthood needs your help.

[Richard Haas]

To protect access to healthcare.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Donate today by visiting plannedparenthood.org protect it had to be you.

[Al Sharpton]

Dang, you're not supposed to sound that good at karaoke.

[Mika Brzezinski]

You've just only heard me sing all stuffed up with nasal polyps. But now I'm on this medicine and.

[Joe Scarborough]

Breathing better, so this is me with less congestion.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Dupixent Dupilumab is an add on prescription maintenance treatment for uncontrolled chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps in adults and children 12 years and it can help shrink your nasal polyps so you can breathe better with less congestion. Plus, it's an alternative to surgery. Oh, this is your song.

[Al Sharpton]

Wish I was singing after congested you.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Severe allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for face, mouth, tongue or throat swelling, wheezing or trouble breathing. Tell your doctor right away of signs of inflamed blood vessels like rash, chest pain, worsening shortness of breath, tingling or numbness in limbs. Tell your doctor of new or worsening eye problems like eye pain or vision changes, joint aches and pain, or a parasitic infection or asthma. Don't change or stop steroid asthma or other treatments without talking to your doctor.

[Joe Scarborough]

Do more with less nasal polyps.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Ask your doctor about DUPIXENT. Learn more at DUPIXENT.com or call 1844 DUPIXENT.

[Richard Haas]

Beautiful live picture of the library in Philadelphia as we come up at 6:30 in the morning on a Friday, incumbent Democratic Senator Bob Casey Casey of Pennsylvania now officially has conceded his race to Republican Dave McCormick. In a video posted to social media, Senator Casey said, quote, as the first count of ballot is completed, Pennsylvanians can move forward with the knowledge that their voices were heard, whether their vote was the first to be counted or the last. In response to Casey's concession, McCormick released a statement that reads in part, Senator Bob Casey dedicated his career to bettering our Commonwealth. Deena McCormick's wife and I want to extend our sincere gratitude to Senator Casey, Therese and their family for their decades of service, hard work and personal sacrifice. With 99.8% of the vote in, McCormick won the race by just over 16,000 votes. The small margin of victory triggered an automatic recount with the results expected out next Wednesday. Barring any unexpected changes, Republicans will hold the majority in the United States Senate 53 to 40. So, Joe, we can talk about that balance of power and what it means for the incoming Trump administration. But in these times, we have to say this is what it looks like to wait out a close race. He lost by only 16,000 votes. Automatic recount. He concedes graciously. Dave McCormick gives a gracious statement thanking him for his service in a big win for Republicans in the state of Pennsylvania. But this is how it's supposed to work.

[Joe Scarborough]

Okay, this sounds shockingly normal, like this is how it used to be. And I will say, and Willie, we talked about it back in. What year are we in now? What's in 2022? You know, you put Dave McCormick and if Dave McCormick had had won the primary, he could have won against Fetterman, who's very strong statewide candidate. But make no mistake about it, Dave McCormick winning here. First of all, he is the type of Republican candidate that can win a state like Pennsylvania, a West Point guy and ran a tough campaign. So give Dave McCormick his due. A great Republican candidate. But I want to talk about what this means for the Democrats because we had Sherrod Brown on and I got to say I knew that a lot of Democrats are going to have trouble this year. Didn't think Sherrod would in Ohio because he was so connected with working class voters throughout his entire career and got beat. Yeah. Here is the second shot across the bow for Democrats and working class voters. As you know, the Casey family legend in Pennsylvania, Casey would win. He won his last race by 17 points. Yeah. White working class voters in Pennsylvania loved him, loved his father, stayed with the case. He's through thick and thin and, and there weren't ever any close races. He has lost now. And let's look at Ohio, let's look at Pennsylvania and ask what does this mean for the Democratic Party? And we wanted you on to talk about this because everybody I talked to that followed your race said you ran just about pitch perfect race and yet the headwinds for you, for Casey, for Brown, just too hard to get past.

[Mika Brzezinski]

The headwinds were tough this cycle, I think particularly, you know, you can run ahead of the ticket, but there's only so much you can do that. And in the case of Ohio, Brown and Casey, that's a, you know, that's an Allegheny region problem. That's a white working class problem that a lot of folks are having in the Democratic Party. For me, I think the headwinds fundamentally. I kept thinking about one of my favorite quotes from Bill Clinton. He said people will vote for strong and wrong every time. And I think the Democratic Party has a strength problem on the issues that matter most, personal safety and economic security. I think those are the fundamentals. And Democrats gotta get off defense and playing offense. They can't be the default party of the status quo. I think that's the most dangerous place to be. And I think right now they are seen that way. And so people will take a chance if they seem like their bold solutions on the other side, even if it flies in the face of facts. And so here's where I think just Democrats, particularly in blue states need to actually, you know, you need to have a stronger center left standing up against the far right and the far left, I think you need to make sure you're dealing with things like the middle class squeeze, which is one of the biggest drivers of dissatisfaction going on for decades, that the affordability crisis because of inflation kicked even to higher gear. And then make sure you're actually dealing with issues of civic disorder, the border crime. If you have a well intentioned bill that has unintended consequences, fix it. But if people feel that the civic decline is going on, Democrats have to be taking that on and being the leaders of that reform otherwise they're going to get caught up in a wave.

[John Avalon]

But at the same time, John, I think that you're correct. We've got to see the Democrats deal with those issues and go after the working class white, but also the working class black community. I think that a lot of them played a lot of Democratic candidates, their consultants played to the edges and the younger vote and ignored black churches, ignored black fraternities, didn't invest in who are your solid voters who may be more conservative and concerned about immigration, crime and other things in a different way. And I think they over engaged some of the things that became trendy. But their base was not energized because you could have won enough votes in Philly to make this different for Gates.

[Mika Brzezinski]

And that's a profound point that actually, you know, what happened in Philly, what happened in Milwaukee, what happened in Cleveland. I made a point of going to black churches because I think that's really important.

[John Avalon]

It's rid of voters.

[Mika Brzezinski]

It's also nourishing.

[John Avalon]

Right.

[Mika Brzezinski]

But I do think you make the right point, which is, look, people gotta get past the identity politics of this, right? And so actually you shouldn't just talk about the white world. My mother's from Youngstown, Ohio, so I think about, you know, that region. But it really is just making sure folks feel like the American dream's accessible again. Making sure that the middle class feels like if they work hard and play by the rules, they can get ahead. And right now they don't. And that's where being the default party that seems to represent the status quo is unsustainable.

[Richard Haas]

Hey, John, Sam Stein here.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Hey, man.

[Richard Haas]

Good to see you, bud.

[Mika Brzezinski]

You too, buddy.

[Richard Haas]

John and I work together in a past lifetime. I was talking with Chris Murphy yesterday about this exact situation. And one of the things that we were talking about, and I'm curious what your thoughts are on how Democrats should maneuver around this, is that you talked about they're perceived as the defenders of the status quo. He agreed with that. That can be an issue. But I think part of the issue here is that Trump kind of forces that happen. By that, I mean, yes, you defend democracy when you feel like it's completely under attack and under assault. You defend immigrants when you feel like they're being scapegoated. You defend the pharmaceutical industry when you feel like an anti vax person is set to host hhs. It's his actions that cause that type.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Of reaction where you end up being.

[Richard Haas]

The defenders of the status quo.

[Mika Brzezinski]

How do you maneuver around that?

[Richard Haas]

Because those things are worth defending, even.

[Mika Brzezinski]

If you have a reformist mindset. It's a great point. First of all, I don't think you can let your opponent determine the tune that you dance to, Right. I think you need to play offense and get off defense. And I do think that the contrast is with the chaos and extremism that Donald Trump represents. The contrast is, look, we're going to be bold and put forward common sense solutions to the problems of everyday people. We're going to focus on rebuilding the middle, the middle of our politics, the middle of our economy. We're going to actually take a note, look at what that ballot prop that passed in California did, right? People pushed back on a 2 to 1 margin on the idea that we were decriminalizing low level crime because that created a sense of civic disorder. So I think it's actually Pushing it back against civic decline is also defending Democratic norms. It's actually building a big tent. But you gotta be strong on the stuff that people care most about. And I think a lot about something that Hakeem Jeffries said but could have said, you know, even more. And I'd take it as a mantra. It's a four Fs. You know, Democrats need to be back on reclaiming the values of freedom, which Kamala Harris did on reproductive freedom, fairness, which cuts both ways in some ways that Democrats don't want to deal with on the border. The flag and faith, Right? Reclaiming patriotism, reclaiming the social gospel, those traditions that I think can reanimate a new Democratic Party and not have it just responding to Donald Trump. That's no way to live. There's no way to win.

[Joe Scarborough]

All right, let's get specific here. I want to get specific. So we. I'll just talk about myself. I talked a lot over two years about fascist rhetoric, threats of retribution. Mika talked a lot about women's reproductive rights, women's reproductive health care, freedom for women to decide what they do with their bodies. And we talked about that a lot. And after the election, 75 million voters or so said, well, okay, we're focused on the price of gas, price of groceries, whatever. So how do you run a campaign where, when you hear rhetoric that you don't want to call it fascist, let's just say authoritarian, right? Whatever you want to call it. No, I'm saying whatever. However, you wanted to find that the definitions don't matter. There were threats of retribution. There was the issue of women's reproductive choices and health rubbing up against, pounding up against the price of groceries, the price of gasoline. How do you balance that when obviously what voters said was, we care more about the price of gas and we care more about the price of groceries.

[Mika Brzezinski]

How do you do that at that moment? Look, I think life is a struggle between the urgent and the important, right? And I think for a lot of people, the urgent issues they face are about affordability, right? And here's where Democrats. And about feelings of personal safety. Here's where Democrats got to get the big things, right? If people don't feel safe, if they don't feel economically secure, everything else is secondary, right? So that's why Democrats got to get stronger on these issues that count most well.

[Joe Scarborough]

And by the way, how condescending is it when people say, oh, no, you know, things are safe and da, da, da, da. The Southern border doesn't. It's something Willie and I have been talking about for four years now. Don't let people steal $999 worth of clothes from a store and say, oh, that shouldn't be a felony.

[Mika Brzezinski]

No quality of life policing works.

[Joe Scarborough]

Let's stop.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Like, you know, it's got nothing to do with plainclothes divisions or stop and frisk, frankly. It's just about saying that, look, if, if you let a broken window not get fixed, it encourages more broken windows. When you decriminalize low level crime, you get more of it. Then people push back and they elect extremes. So there's a responsibility for the center left in particular, in particular in blue states to stand up, get strong, push back against the liberalism on the left or the right and make sure we're not falling into that trap. Because if people don't feel safe and they don't feel economically secure, yeah, everything else is secondary.

[Sam Stein]

John Avalon, thank you very much. Come back.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Thanks, guys. Any time. Pleasure.

[Sam Stein]

Okay, coming up, traffic on the platform Blue sky is on the rise following the election as many people look for an alternative to X. We'll take a look at that substantial shift on social media. And also earlier this week, Joe and I told you that we went to Mar a Lago to meet personally with President Elect Donald Trump to reopen lines of communication. We heard from many of you wanting to let us know that it was the right thing to do our jobs. We've also faced a lot of criticism about the meeting, largely from folks online. I want to explain our thought process a bit more. So this week I went on the Daily Beast podcast with Joanna Coles and Samantha Bee to talk more about that meeting. Here's part of the interview, which is also this week's Morning Mika. The way I look at it is people are really scared. It's one of the reasons we went in there is people are really scared about Donald Trump's comments about political adversaries. A lot of people are scared because of what has happened with abortion. These are all issues that are important to me and in some ways personal to me, but definitely personal to the people I really care about. And I don't regret anything I've said during the campaign and I stand by it. But I'm also looking at how to do things differently. And I would never turn down an opportunity to gain insight or information. Never. So you can listen to the whole interview on the Daily Beast podcast. It's also available on morning Mika via YouTube and Peacock. It's a long, in depth conversation, really exploring all the contours of this because a lot of people have really strong opinions, and that's fair, too.

[Joe Scarborough]

Do they?

[Sam Stein]

Morning, Joe.

[Joe Scarborough]

Really?

[Sam Stein]

Right back.

[Joe Scarborough]

I didn't know that. Next.

[Al Sharpton]

Hey, it smells so good in here.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Yep, that'd be the coffee.

[Willie Geist]

I know.

[Joe Scarborough]

It's just I've had nasal polyps for.

[Al Sharpton]

So long now I'm on this medicine and my congestion and breathing are much better.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Dupixent Dupilumab is an add on prescription maintenance treatment for uncontrolled chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps in adults and children 12 years and up. It can help shrink your nasal polyps so you can breathe better with less congestion.

[Al Sharpton]

I'm pretty jazzed about it. Plus, I don't want another surgery. And now I might not need one.

[Mika Brzezinski]

So what can I get you?

[Al Sharpton]

Medium coffee, please.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Severe allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for face, mouth, tongue or throat swelling, wheezing or trouble breathing. Tell your doctor right away of signs of inflamed blood vessels like rash, chest pain, worsening shortness of breath, tingling or numbness in limbs. Tell your doctor of new or worsening eye problems like eye pain or vision changes, joint aches and pain, or a parasitic infection or asthma. Don't change or stop steroid asthma or other treatments without talking to your doctor.

[Al Sharpton]

Do more with less nasal polyps. Ask your doctor about Dupixent.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Learn [e-mail] or call 1-844dupixent.

[Al Sharpton]

Have you met All Modern? Allmodern brings you the best of modern furniture. And right now, through November 30th, you'll score up to 70% off during their Black Friday sale. Prep your space for holiday hosting with deals on plush sofas, modern tabletop essentials and more. All on sale at All Modern. Then get them delivered for free in days. You heard that right. Days. That's modern made simple. Shop All Modern's Black Friday sale, now through November 30th at allmodern.com first and.

[Joe Scarborough]

Foremost, the thing that powers your business is power. And when it comes to power, Ford Pro has options that scream, scratch that, we've got every option. Diesel, gas, hybrid, and all electric. Plus, they're all connected, so you're always in the driver's seat. The power is yours.

[John Avalon]

Visit fordpro.com today to learn more.

[Joe Scarborough]

Hey, welcome back to Morning Joe. David Bowie, Young American, waking you up on Friday morning. So Rev. John Avalon talked about something that you and I have been talking about and Willie have been talking about since 2020. And that is the idea that Americans have to feel safe if you don't get past that issue. You don't win elections. And I remember a conversation we had in 2020, the summer of George Floyd. We went back this far and we were talking about the stupidity, and let me say the stupidity as you and Willie and I said, of defund the police, that movement. And you and I were talking about a New York times article in 2020 where city council people in New York City representing the most diverse and in some cases, some of the most dangerous neighborhoods in New York go going, defund the police. Now we need more police on the streets. We need more police in our children's schools. And you always talk about the woke, and you've been doing it for four years. You know, people still come and going, oh, Reverend Nell was going against the woke. Is this something new? After the election, I'm like, dude, where have you been? He's been talking about this forever because he hears it from his parishioners.

[John Avalon]

That's right. I hear it from parishioners. I hear it at rallies. Don't forget, we did the George Floyd movement. I preached his funerals. And here comes some people outside that comes with this far radical, mostly, quote, white super progressives because they're not progressive, talking about defund the police. That was not what the George Floyd movement was about. It was about reforming the police and making it work. We fought to get a black attorney general to be the prosecutor in that case. So. So when I go to a rally and a black woman raising kids middle age says to me, rev, why are you running with people that want to defund the police? And I'm seeing my apartment building broken into, I'm having to explain this to her. And that's what I think John was talking about, is the candidates need to have enough backbone to not only stand up to the far right, but to the far left and say, wait a minute, you're not speaking for us. You're speaking for people that you don't speak to. We do not want crime. We do not want to see the gas that high. And I think that a lot of people become wimpish when it comes to the people on the far left that are speaking on issues that are not speaking to us. We have black police chiefs now. I remember when we had the disturbances in Ferguson after Michael Brown was killed. I preached this funeral, we marches and I went in and I said to some of the young people, you can't ride and burn down the city. It's not going to solve our problems. I understand your rage. I'm as Angry as you are. And one of them said to me, but Reverend Al, we can't talk to the man. We can't turn nothing over to the man. I said, have you seen the Attorney general? His name is Eric Holder. We are the man. We fought to become the man. Now we're going to undo what the man can do. You can't have the man after the police and not also police where we want to be safe in our community. That's not selling out, that's building up.

[Joe Scarborough]

Well, this conversation to be continued, thank you so much for that. And let's talk about talking about safety. Let's talk about Ukrainians, how they're feeling right now. This war keeps ramping up. Threats against the United States, threats against Poland. It seems. I'm not so sure if this isn't just again, the prelude to either a much wider war or to negotiations where Vladimir Putin is flexing his muscles going, oh, you're going to fire deeper in, you know, you think this is going to be a move that's going to help you at the negotiating tables. Here's my counter move.

[Mika Brzezinski]

I would put my money on. This is posturing. He shot one medium range ballistic missile. So what? And wasn't a big deal. This is posturing. I seriously put my money. This is a prelude to negotiations. We've upped our support for Ukraine and what we're providing. We've removed some of the constraints on what we're providing. Putin didn't like it, so he reacted.

[Joe Scarborough]

So put this in perspective. We allow Ukraine to fire missiles deeper into Russia. Russia fires a missile that can go deeper and they start talking about going after bases in Poland, which again, unless I'm talking totally misreading it, he is not going to do that at this point with as many losses as his army's already had.

[Mika Brzezinski]

That's complete posturing. The one serious escalation Putin has done, because these exchanges haven't transformed anything, Joe, is bringing the North Koreans in. That, by the way, was a serious escalation. But again, nothing's transforming the battlefield. It kind of was what it was. And I think we're looking after this winter, I think we're, we're quite possibly going to have, yes, we'll continue to have a battlefield, but I think we're finally going to have a negotiating table. I think we're moving that way. It's not going to be easy. We're not going to get to peace, we're not going to get to treaties, but could we get to a ceasefire to frozen conflicts that would save lives and allow Ukraine to begin to rebuild. Yes, I think that is finally going to be on the agenda.

[Sam Stein]

All right, Richard Haass, thank you very much. We also have Radek Sikorsky coming up to talk about this.

[Joe Scarborough]

Foreign minister, Poland. And if you can come back on Monday, I mean, we're going to be talking about Ukraine, we're going to be talking about the Middle east every day. Yeah, it's really, this is a danger.

[Sam Stein]

Thank you.

[Mika Brzezinski]

I'm in the neighborhood.

[Joe Scarborough]

All right.

[Sam Stein]

We hear that. We'll dive into Susan Glosser's piece for the New York Times about the lessons of Matt Gates withdrawal and what we and the Trump world can learn from it. Plus, we'll speak with someone who has worked with Pam Bonding, Florida State Attorney David Arenberg, and why he says her nomination should give Democrats some relief. Also ahead, the lieutenant governor of New York, Antonio Delgado, will be our guest as he urges Democrats to let a new generation lead. MORNING JOE will be right back, a few minutes before the top of the hour. The social media platform Blue Sky, a competitor to X, has gained millions of followers in the weeks following the presidential election. According to Blue sky, its traffic is up over 500% since November 5, a trend due in part to dissatisfied liberals leaving the Elon Musk owned X platform. Let's bring in MSNBC contributor Pablo Torre, who is discussing Blue Sky. Anna latest episode of his podcast, Pablo Torre finds out on Meadowlark Media.

[Joe Scarborough]

Explain something to me.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Yes.

[Joe Scarborough]

So why is it somebody made a.

[Sam Stein]

Fake account, so Threads.

[Joe Scarborough]

Yeah, there are a lot of fake accounts going on around. Threads was supposed to be the replacement for X.

[Willie Geist]

Sure.

[Joe Scarborough]

And I don't really understand, even though I went on Threads, tried it, and for some reason I wasn't getting the newsfeed. This was a year ago that I was still getting on X, a year I've since given up on X. But why didn't Threads work? And why is bluesky now necessary? Because threads didn't work.

[Willie Geist]

So, Joe, first off, I am available for tech support 24 hours a day, seven days a month. Just let me know if for some reason the settings are off. I'm here to help. But seriously, what happens periodically is that now you know you're familiar with spring football leagues, xfl, usfl. Periodically there are attempts to form the equivalent of a spring football league of social media.

[Joe Scarborough]

Right.

[Willie Geist]

And so this was Mastodon, this is Blue sky, this is Threads. And so it's an attempt to siphon off the.

[Joe Scarborough]

But I'm asking you specifically, though, so why didn't Threads. Why was Threads the USFL of online media?

[Willie Geist]

So Twitter's or it story is fascinating to me because it involves a saturation of media and celebrity that created this impression that if you get into your phone and log onto this platform, you can talk to Shaquille O'Neal, you can talk to the president. And Threads never replicated that idea of the world's grandest cocktail party, where you had access directly to people that you were otherwise always very far away from. But the media component of it, to me, is also incredibly crucial here. And it leads me to why I've been experimenting with Blue sky, frankly, despite knowing that it has some XFL vibes. It's because Twitter became the place where you got your news right. So the RSS feed as a concept, you know, I used to subscribe to something called Google Reader, and God bless anybody who remembers Google Reader, right? But it was a place where you could get the New York Times and cnn, the Washington Post and the New Republic, and go on and on, on across the political spectrum. And that's what Twitter's promise was. It was the place where you could get information.

[Joe Scarborough]

Can we just say, really, I mean, as far as information goes, Twitter always has been a very, very rough place, right? That said, you get your newsfeed right, and I, we. Willie and I have talked about this. Megan, I've talked about that. If you got it right, let's say five, six years ago, I can go in there and in 10 minutes, I knew what was going on. And then I'd go to the Times and read all the other stuff they got.

[John Avalon]

It was.

[Joe Scarborough]

It was pretty remarkable. Even though it's always been, oh, people are like, oh, it's.

[Willie Geist]

It's always been.

[Joe Scarborough]

It's always been.

[Willie Geist]

It's always been variously miserable. And I loved it, of course, because I watched sports with the world. It was live. It was a place to talk about the games I cover. But the thing that Elon did, this is an Elon story. To me, this is not a story as much as it is framed as liberals don't want to talk to conservatives anymore. There is certainly some of that on Blue sky, certainly. And the Exodus. But to me, it's because Elon Musk has put his thumb on the scale of curating what we're all seeing. And so to the point of clicking on links, what Elon did was he suppressed any post that had a URL, a hyperlink that left, so any article got demoted.

[Joe Scarborough]

So the very thing that made Twitter so valuable. Now, let's talk about BlueSky. Does Blue sky have a chance to be what threads wanted to be? And that is the alternative, the Pepsi decode.

[Willie Geist]

So it is free of the incentive structure that Elon has instituted. And so it's not merely the suppression of links. It's also the fact that Elon did something crucial. He installed the ability to monetize individual tweets based on engagement. And so what this was was a siren, a lamp for every scammer, moth to come into Twitter and say, hey, my way of making actual literal money is to troll, is to spread misinformation in a literal sense, to create anonymous accounts that would actually psychologically provoke response.

[Sam Stein]

This is very.

[Joe Scarborough]

By the way, though.

[Willie Geist]

It's a money story.

[Joe Scarborough]

Let's talk about by the way. It's horrible.

[Willie Geist]

This guy doesn't have that.

[Joe Scarborough]

It's horrible there. I know. He needs some money. It's horrible there. But I will say also Instagram, the algorithms also are to provoke. It's all to provoke. People want to know why social media depresses. Why social media? Because algorithms are meant to make you angry, to provoke, to get you clicking. And that's how they make their money.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Yes.

[Richard Haas]

Right.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Yes.

[Willie Geist]

Oh, there is a bit of a tilting at a windmill phenomenon. We're trying to find the best. We're trying to make a safer cigarette, in a sense.

[Joe Scarborough]

So does Blue sky have a shot of succeeding?

[Willie Geist]

It has a shot. Because without Elon's thumb on the scale, I'm getting the sense that I can actually maybe talk to people.

[Joe Scarborough]

Right.

[Willie Geist]

Talk to my conservative friends, read the thoughts of people, as opposed to reading.

[Sam Stein]

And get realistic feedback.

[Willie Geist]

They're clickbait farming. They're engagement farming over on Twitter.

[Joe Scarborough]

You know what I love so much about feedback about Twitter? Even though, again, it's always been a rough place.

[Willie Geist]

Oh, sure.

[Joe Scarborough]

So let's not pretend we go into a cage.

[Willie Geist]

Like we're not underneath the olive tree.

[Joe Scarborough]

Exactly. That said, though, I could watch a Red Sox game and I could tweet out, oh, my God, what a great double play. And I could look at responses and people that love the Red Sox would be there.

[Willie Geist]

Humans.

[Joe Scarborough]

If I talked about, hey, I listened to Pitt, Frampton Comes Alive front to back for the first time in 30 years. Here's my take. Thirty years later could get a response. I mean, we need a place like that where people can talk and just have great dialogue.

[Willie Geist]

Look, to me, Twitter would be perfect, given the alternatives. I would still use as much as I used to if Elon just wasn't there. It's like, he moved into my phone and now I have to leave.

[Joe Scarborough]

Joe, I wish.

[Willie Geist]

I wish we could have discourse. It's just not a place for feedback and discussion anymore. It's a place to be fooled into thinking that, oh, I clicked on an account that's actually a parody, and I've been scammed. It's scammers now.

[John Avalon]

Yeah.

[Joe Scarborough]

So before we let you go.

[Sam Stein]

Yeah, very interesting.

[Joe Scarborough]

We have to talk about, like, the NFL game of, like, of NFL games this year. I mean, shocking. The Browns beat the Steelers, but, man, the setup, it was so incredible. Reminded me of the old AFC Central Games from the 70s and 80s.

[Willie Geist]

Yeah, there's nothing more American than a shanked punk in the snow, Truly, just.

[Joe Scarborough]

Like, oh, I saw Thomas Jefferson said that.

[Willie Geist]

That's right. That's right. Somewhere on a piece of parchment, it said that Americans must, at some point in November, get a game that's a total mess. And this was a mess. And Joe, I always talk to you about how the NFL is a case study in mediocrity. These are teams that we like to think are so much better than the other. And of course, I appraise the Steelers to you. When the Browns come in and Nick Chubb is back from injury and he runs into the end zone and Jameis Winston can pilot a team through the snow, you're reminded that, truly, this is a game of randomness. An oblong ball in weather conditions that no other sport would subject itself to. And the flip of the coin is the glory of the sport. Anything can happen. And the week I say to you, the Steelers look like the most complete team in the NFL, I am completely disproven by the Cleveland Browns. So, yes, this is also true.

[Joe Scarborough]

They lose to one of the worst teams. And then, truly, we. We need more of this, though.

[Sam Stein]

This is. You can hear, by the way, the blue sky story and more on today's episode of Pablo Torre Finds out on Mental Arc Media. Do you explain why threads didn't work on the podcast?

[Willie Geist]

We talked. There are so many people on there. But it's Instagram. It's. It's a. It's a different purpose that Instagram people are.

[Sam Stein]

This guy better. What's one line?

[Willie Geist]

It is Elon free and actually about conversation.

[Sam Stein]

Okay, Pablo Torre, thank you very much. We appreciate it.

[Mika Brzezinski]

Honestly, we should have used a condom, but we got distracted.

[Richard Haas]

Honestly, there are things that everyone can do to help protect their sexual health. Talk to a healthcare provider to find out how you can take action. And find out [e-mail] sponsored by Gilead.