Most Valuable Agent with Matt Hannaford

Episode: The Dad Effect: How Travel Ball Parenting Limits Future Big Leaguers
Date: September 3, 2025
Host: Matt Hannaford
Guest: Johan (“Joe”) Martinez Gili

Brief Overview

In this episode, Matt Hannaford sits down with Johan Martinez Gili (also known as Joe), a recurring guest with deep experience in performance coaching for professional athletes. Together, they explore “The Dad Effect”: the lasting, often limiting influence of intense travel ball and youth sports parenting, particularly by fathers, on future big leaguers. The conversation delves into generational styles of parenting, personal stories, common pitfalls, and how parents – especially dads – can self-reflect and adopt healthier, more supportive approaches that benefit their children not only in sports, but in life.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Enduring Influence of Fathers in Athletes’ Lives

Timestamps: [00:52] – [03:09]

• The episode opens with Matt referencing a recent conversation with Joe about how the effects of a dad’s approach to parenting persist even after a player reaches the professional ranks.
• Joe’s Insight: Even high-level athletes often have “shady at best” relationships with their fathers, marked more by distance, criticism, or shame than support.
• Dads often remain a psychological influence via texts and expectations:

  “If the performance isn’t there...the dad checks in and just connects to their son...instead of blasting into him from a distance.” – Joe [02:01]

2. The Generational Pattern of Shame vs. Acceptance

Timestamps: [05:03] – [07:14]

• Many dads parent with the tools they were given – tough love, criticism, shaming for motivation. The logic: “I need to get a performance out of my kid.”
• Joe proposes, and Matt agrees, that what works better is curiosity, acceptance, and space for growth, not shame.
• Joe: “There’s something that's actually more powerful than shame and it’s acceptance, it’s curiosity...it actually creates a safer environment so people can grow and be their best.” [05:36]

3. How Father-Son Dynamics Evolve Over Time

Timestamps: [07:14] – [08:17]

• Young athletes feel unable to confront their dads directly, often opting for passive-aggressive avoidance.
• Parental approaches rarely change without intentional reflection and feedback.
• Positive example: a father at a top showcase event recognizes this, steps back, and lets the professionals guide his son, experiencing relief in doing so.

4. The Unintended Costs of Parental Control and Living Through Kids

Timestamps: [11:34] – [16:18]

• Joe shares his poignant story about his father—who sacrificed a professional soccer career, then imposed dreams on young Joe, eventually making the game joyless.
• The lesson: letting kids have their own dreams, not reliving a parent’s failed ambitions through them.
• Joe: “Instead of living your unlived dreams through your kids, let them have their own dreams.” [16:19]

5. Performance-based Love: The Car Ride Home Effect

Timestamps: [19:20] – [23:08]

• Joe and Matt discuss how athletic performance becomes tied to fatherly affection, most notably in “the car ride home.”
• Matt: "That's the car ride home thing that everybody talks about... I've disappointed the one person in the world that I don't ever want to disappoint.” [19:47]
• Result: Athletes internalize their worth as based on results, fueling insecurity and identity crises even at elite levels.

6. The Myth that Tough Parenting “Works”

Timestamps: [22:00] – [23:35]

• Many parents claim “my son’s in the big leagues because I was hard on him,” but Joe challenges this – “what if he did that in spite of you? What if he would actually gotten farther if you had a different approach?” [22:32]
• Focusing solely on results often leaves pro athletes coping with turmoil, self-doubt, and a distorted sense of self-worth.

7. Agency and Autonomy – Building Strong, Independent Athletes

Timestamps: [27:59] – [35:13]

• The highest-achieving athletes own their choices and vision. Parents who foster autonomy (rather than rigid direction and control) set the stage for deep growth and lasting confidence.
• Joe: “One of the first things that I have to help athletes reclaim is their agency...because for most...it has been stripped from them and they don’t know it.” [33:41]

8. The Role of Awareness and Emotional Intelligence

Timestamps: [36:51] – [50:30]

• Parental awareness—being able to pause, reflect, and communicate thoughtfully—is a powerful tool, sometimes “the tool.”
• Joe breaks down the difference between emotions (physiological, transient) and feelings (attached to beliefs), and how athletes struggle to process both if not modeled by parents.
• Joe: "Sometimes all we need is to notice what we're feeling. If we could just express it, if we could just get it out of our system, and then we can kind of move on to the next thing.” [48:46]

9. When and How to Pivot – It’s Never Too Late

Timestamps: [53:24] – [57:53]

• Many high-performing families feel it's "too late" to change, but Joe and Matt stress that it's never too late for parents to self-reflect, apologize, and improve the relationship.
• Joe: “One of the greatest things that you can do is adapt. And you gotta admit when you’re wrong... I want to show you that first as a parent.” [56:52]

10. Athlete Responsibility – Empowering the Child

Timestamps: [61:03] – [62:11]

• While much is placed on parents, athletes themselves, especially as they get older, can initiate honest dialogue and change the family dynamic for the better.
• Matt: “Why can't you be the one...maybe your parent...can't get themselves to have this conversation with you. It could actually come from...why not the kid?” [61:55]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the generational trap:
  “A lot of these dads, this is what they were taught. Some of it is unlearning... What if you took the feedback from your son and redesigned your relationship?” – Joe [06:04]

• On agency:
  “If we can build [identity], man, you’ll be able to crush anything.” – Joe [23:35]

• On healing as a parent:
  “Even the ways that we fuck it up will end up blessing our child...you'll do the best that you can. I will hurt my children. I will do something that messes them up. And from that place, they'll actually find a strength.” – Joe [62:11]

• On humility:
  “I love you, and I want the best for you. And I'm realizing maybe I was forcing some stuff. The good news is we can start from scratch.” – Joe [55:20]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [02:01] – The “kid first, player second” philosophy and father-son conflict at all levels
• [08:17] – Area Code Games anecdote: A dad lets go and feels relief
• [14:15] – Joe’s personal story: Soccer, pressure, and walking away from the game
• [19:20] – The “car ride home” and how performance defines the parent-child bond
• [26:11] – Matt’s hockey childhood: avoiding the dad on the glass
• [33:41] – Coaching for autonomy: “agency” as the core value
• [44:34] – “Let your kid flounder in front of you,” not fix everything
• [48:46] – Teaching athletes to notice, name, and process their emotions and feelings
• [56:52] – Modeling humility: changing direction as a parent

Overall Tone and Language

The episode is authentic, frank, and compassionate. Joe’s vulnerability and expertise combine with Matt’s relatable anecdotes and agent's perspective to produce a heartfelt, useful dialogue. There’s an emphasis on practical wisdom, reflective questions, and the recognition that nobody — parent or child — is perfect.

Practical Takeaways for Parents and Athletes

• The “tough love” or shame-based method can produce achievement, but at the cost of relationship, mental well-being, and long-term joy.
• The best gift a parent — especially a dad — can give is genuine presence, curiosity, acceptance, and the space for a child to pursue his or her own dreams.
• It’s never too late for parents to adjust course, admit mistakes, and model humility; this, in itself, is a powerful lesson.
• Athletes can also take agency by being honest with their parents and asking, “Why do you care so much?” in a spirit of discovery, not confrontation.
• The path to peak performance and a fulfilling athletic journey is paved with trust, emotional intelligence, and strong relationships, not just results or accolades.

For More Info

• Guest: Joe Martinez Gili – @johanspeaks on Instagram, dvlpmnt.studio, or johancalian.com
• Host: Matt Hannaford – Most Valuable Agent (YouTube)

This summary omits advertisements, intros, and outros, focusing solely on the insightful, actionable, and inspirational content.