Summary of "Death of a Dentist" - MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Introduction
In the gripping exclusive episode titled "Death of a Dentist," Ballen Studios delves into the harrowing true-crime story of Dr. John Yelnick, a beloved dentist from the rural town of Blairsville, Pennsylvania. Hosted by MrBallen, this episode meticulously unpacks the mysterious circumstances surrounding John's brutal murder and the subsequent investigation led by Corporal Janelle Lydic.
Background of Dr. John Yelnick
Dr. John Yelnick was a successful and charismatic dentist who had built a thriving practice in his hometown of Blairsville after graduating from dental school 13 years prior. Known for his exceptional rapport with patients, especially children, John amassed substantial wealth through shrewd investments in real estate, becoming a millionaire by his early thirties. His personal life, however, was tumultuous. John married Michelle in 1997, blending their families through adoption, but financial strains and marital discord began to erode their relationship. By the spring of 2006, John's once-promising life was unraveling.
“John thought Michelle was one of the most beautiful people in the world.” ([07:00])
The Day of the Murder
On the afternoon of April 12, 2006, John wrapped up his workday with a sense of foreboding. Despite professional success, he faced significant personal and financial challenges, including disputes with his business partner and a strained marriage. As he drove home from his dental practice, John's anxiety was palpable. His fears were not unfounded; he was deeply convinced that someone intended to murder him, a belief partly fueled by recent vandalism of his car.
The following day, April 13, 2006, marked the tragic culmination of John's fears. At approximately 3:30 PM, nine-year-old Zach Use, a neighbor, noticed something amiss at John's residence. “John's throat had been slit from ear to ear.” ([11:02]). Zach discovered John's mutilated body amidst a chaotic crime scene strewn with blood and personal papers, signaling a violent and personal attack rather than a random act of violence.
The Investigation Begins
Corporal Janelle Lydic, a detective new to homicide cases, was assigned to investigate John's murder. Confronted with a scene of extreme brutality, Lydic quickly recognized the need for a meticulous approach. Initial observations indicated that the murder was deeply personal—there was no evidence of robbery, and the violence suggested a targeted intent to kill.
Key evidence included:
- Divorce Papers: Found scattered on the floor, soaked in blood, highlighting the ongoing marital discord. ([14:31])
- $15,000 Check from Melissa Yus: Positioned conspicuously on the coffee table with a note requesting John to delay depositing it, raising questions about financial disputes and possible motives. ([15:27])
Witness statements further complicated the case:
- A neighbor reported hearing a scream around 1:30 PM and subsequently heard a heated argument where a man declared, “I'll never loan you money again.” ([13:21])
- Rumors emerged about Melissa Yus, a neighbor, allegedly having an affair with John, intensifying the list of suspects.
Interrogation of Suspects
Lydic's investigation naturally focused on two primary suspects:
-
Melissa Yus and Tom Yus: Melissa, whose name appeared on the $15,000 check, and her husband Tom, a Navy serviceman who had recently returned home. Neighbors alleged that Melissa and John were more than just friends, suggesting a possible affair that could have led to jealousy or financial disputes.
“Are you having an affair with John?” ([24:16])
Melissa vehemently denied any affair, while Tom evaded the question, repeatedly stating, “I really need to leave.” ([24:24]).
-
Michelle Yelnick and Kevin Foley: John's estranged wife Michelle and her new boyfriend, Kevin Foley, a Pennsylvania state trooper, quickly became suspects due to financial motives and their close association with John. Michelle stood to inherit over a million dollars from John's life insurance, and Foley had been heard expressing disdain towards John.
Lydic's Unorthodox Approach
Despite her inexperience with homicide cases, Corporal Lydic employed a methodical but unconventional strategy. Instead of promptly forwarding evidence to the state crime lab, she stored critical samples, including John's fingernail clippings, in the police station refrigerator. By withholding this evidence, Lydic aimed to maintain control over the investigation, fearing that higher authorities might jeopardize her progress, especially if they were inadvertently connected to the suspects.
Involvement of Psychics
As the investigation languished without substantial progress, Melissa Yus resorted to hiring psychic sisters in an attempt to find the killer. Although skeptical, Lydic allowed their involvement to placate the distressed families and buy time. The psychics provided no actionable insights, merely reiterating known facts about the crime scene and exonerating Melissa's husband, Tom. This move, while unhelpful, temporarily alleviated public pressure on Lydic.
“The psychics said they saw a knife and stab wounds and a bloody footprint.” ([36:05])
Breakthrough and Conclusion
After months of a stagnant investigation and mounting public scrutiny, the Pennsylvania Attorney General's office intervened, taking over the case. This intervention granted Lydic access to the FBI Crime Lab, enabling her to finally submit the withheld DNA evidence. The results were conclusive: the DNA found under John's fingernails matched Kevin Foley, Michelle's boyfriend.
Final Outcome:
- Kevin Foley: Convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
- Michelle Yelnick: Not charged in connection with the murder.
The case concluded with the revelation that Foley's motive was rooted in personal grievances and unfounded beliefs stemming from Michelle's earlier, but unsubstantiated, accusations against John.
“Kevin Foley was connected to Michelle and harbored deep resentment towards John.” ([29:32])
Notable Quotes
-
Corporal Lydic on Handling Her First Murder Case:
“So she placed the container inside of the refrigerator and then shut the door.” ([00:28]) -
Witness Account of Argument:
“I'll never loan you money again.” ([13:21]) -
Lydic’s Reflection on Investigation:
“I had never done a murder case before, but I was methodical by nature.” ([26:19])
Conclusion
"Death of a Dentist" serves as a compelling narrative of a meticulously handled investigation marred by initial oversight and personal biases. Corporal Janelle Lydic's determination, despite unconventional methods, ultimately led to justice for Dr. John Yelnick. This episode underscores the complexities of true-crime investigations, where personal dynamics and procedural decisions can profoundly impact outcomes.
“The killer was connected to Michelle.” ([36:57])
Disclaimer
While the story is based on true events, some details have been fictionalized to protect the identities of those involved and to enhance dramatic effect.
Further Exploration
For listeners intrigued by this case, MrBallen invites you to explore more of Ballen Studios' diverse range of podcasts, each offering unique and spine-chilling stories.