Loading summary
Mr. Ballin
Hey prime members, you can binge episodes 57 through 64 right now and ad free on Amazon Music. Download the app today. Wonderful in the early spring of 1892, an older woman in a tiny Rhode island town shuffled into her kitchen at 1am to make a late night cup of tea. And as she passed by her front window, she saw a man riding on horseback down the dirt road outside, holding up a flickering lantern. She recognized this man. He was the only doctor in town, and she could tell he was headed towards a large farm at the end of the road, and the woman had heard rumors that the farmer's son was deathly ill. She knew a house call in the middle of the night was not a good sign, but she also knew the doctor could not save the farmer's son. However, she could. So she threw on her coat, lit her own lantern, and set off into the night. From Ballin Studios and wondry, I'm Mr. Ballin and this is Mr. Balin's Medical Mysteries, where every week we will explore a new, baffling mystery originating from the one place we all can't escape our own bodies. And for this week's special Halloween episode, we're exploring something even more the supernatural. For centuries, people believed that monsters, demons and other horrors could cause deadly diseases and all kinds of misery. Nowadays, we tend to reject those explanations as ignorance and superstition, but for one New England farming family in the 1800s, that distinction wasn't so clear. Were they being plagued by a mysterious disease? Or were they actually being preyed on by a creature thought only to exist in legend? So if you like today's story, tell.
Advertiser
The Follow button that you want to.
Mr. Ballin
Play the Floors Lava game with them, but be sure to hide thumbtacks all over the room before you start playing.
Advertiser
Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar. Whether you listen to stories. Motivation expert advice? Really any genre you love, you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, and new ways of thinking. Find the genres you love and discover new ones along the way. Explore bestsellers, new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks and originals that members can listen to all they want, with more added all the time. Audible makes it easy to be inspired and entertained as part of your daily routine without needing to set aside any extra time. There's more to imagine when you listen. One of my favorite audio titles is Definitely the Road, written by Cormac McCarthy. It's a thrilling but devastating story of a father and son migrating south for the winter while trying to avoid cannibals in a post apocalyptic landscape. I highly recommend a listen. As an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalogue, including the latest bestsellers and new releases. New members can try audible free for 30 days, visit audible.comballin or text ballin to 500500 that's audible.comballin or text Ballin to 500500 to try audible free for 30 days. Audible.comballin they say that time waits for no one, and neither should Payday to keep your money moving in the direction of your dreams, get Earnin' Earnin is an app that gives you access to your pay as you work up to $100 per day or up to $750 per pay period. Just download the Earnin app and verify your paycheck. Then access up to $100 a day as you work and leave an optional tip. Any money you access plus tips are automatically repaid from your next paycheck. Earnin is designed to support you in the short term and the long term. It's money at the speed of you get up to $100 a day of your pay within minutes of earning it, no mandatory fees and no credit check. Download Ernin today spelled E A R N I N in the Google Play or Apple App Store and when you download the Earnin app, type in Mr. Ballin under podcast when you sign up. It'll really help the show. Mr. Ballin under podcast Earnin is a financial technology company, not a bank, subject to your available Earnings Daily Max Pay Period max and location. See earnin.com tos for details. Bank products are issued by Evolve bank and Trust member fdic.
Mr. Ballin
This episode is called she Haunts Me. On a spring morning in 1889, a 29 year old doctor named Harold Metcalf was sitting in his parlor in the tiny town of Exeter, Rhode island when he heard his telegraph machine start clicking. He got up, walked over to the large metal machine and watched it slowly print text onto a long thin piece of paper. When it finished printing, Dr. Metcalfe tore off the paper and read the telegram. It was a message from one of his neighbors, a farmer named George Brown. George said in this telegram that his only son, 22 year old Edwin, had fallen ill and he desperately needed Dr. Metcalf's help. The doctor let out a long sigh. He knew the Browns well. They'd once been a happy family of nine, with George, his wife, their six daughters and their son. But Dr. Metcalf was all too aware of the tragedy that had struck the family over the Past few years, seven years ago, George's wife had come down with a mysterious disease that some locals called the White Death. It caused horrible symptoms like chronic fevers, extreme weight loss, and uncontrollable coughing. People with the disease grew pale and weak, and they got so emaciated that they looked like skeletons. It was like the disease literally drained the life out of them. Now, there were a lot of supposed treatments for the White Death. Things like riding on horseback every day or drinking brown sugar mixed with water. But Dr. Metcalf knew these remedies did not work. In fact, he knew there was just no proven way to cure the white death. Now, Dr. Metcalf had tried to help George's wife seven years earlier by prescribing healthy food and exercise, but she still just kept on getting sicker. And in fact, she would die a year later. And then almost immediately afterwards, one of George's daughters also began showing symptoms of the dreaded disease. And again, Dr. Metcalf tried to help, but there was nothing he could do. And she also died within just a few months. Even though Dr. Metcalf knew the White Death was basically incurable, he still felt guilty for not being able to help George and his loved ones. And now, after reading George's telegram, Dr. Metcalf feared that Edwin might be the latest member of the Brown family to contract the deadly disease. But there was only one way to find out. Dr. Metcalf quickly packed his medical bag, threw a saddle on his horse, and raced off towards the Browns farm. Fifteen minutes later, Dr. Metcalf trotted his horse along a thin country road in Exeter. To his right, he saw a vast field overgrown with weeds with a crumbling country house right in the center. It was once a prosperous farm, but was now abandoned. The site made Dr. Metcalf sad. He'd lived in Exeter his whole life, and he'd watched the quaint farming community turn into sort of a ghost town. The Civil War and the White Death had decimated the community, leaving only a third of the population alive. In fact, these days, the town was more commonly known by its nickname. Deserted Exeter. After riding for a few more minutes, Dr. Metcalf reached a modest house on 40 acres of farmland. He knocked on the door, and right away George Brown answered. He looked haggard, and he quickly led Dr. Metcalfe to Edwin's bedroom. Inside the room, the doctor saw Edwin's wife and five remaining sisters crowded around a big four poster bed. Edwin was lying on the mattress in plain sight, but Dr. Metcalfe barely could recognize him. The once Husky farmhand had become bony and pale. His cheeks were sunken, his eyes were glassy. And when he tried to speak, he fell into a violent coughing fit. It was obvious to everyone, including the doctor, that Edwin had been gripped by the White Death. As Edwin tried to catch his breath, his father, George, approached the side of the bed and looked at the doctor and asked if there was anything he could do. Dr. Metcalfe began rattling off his regular treatment plan, healthy food and exercise. But George stopped him. He said they'd already tried those things with his wife and his daughter, and they hadn't worked. There had to be something different they could try. Dr. Metcalf hesitated, but then he said, yeah, there was another option. But he told them it was an experimental treatment, and so he couldn't guarantee it would work. George said he didn't care at this point. He was willing to try anything to help Edwin. So Dr. Metcalf explained that some physicians believed that the White Death was caused, or at least was made worse, by living in humid climates like Rhode Island. So it might help if Edwin moved out of Rhode island and went somewhere with completely different weather. The doctor suggested Colorado Springs, Colorado, because it was a mountain town with very dry air and high elevations. And so it would be a drastic change from Rhode Island. But there was one really obvious problem. To get to Colorado, Edwin would have to travel 2,000 miles. And this would mean days and days of riding trains and horses, all while Edwin was severely ill. Like, it wasn't clear if he would live through the journey. Plus, his whole family couldn't just go with him. It would basically be Edwin and maybe his wife. And so, after explaining this experimental protocol, Dr. Metcalf went quiet and just watched the browns as they considered what he had just said. And it was obvious the entire family was very upset and didn't know what to make of this. But at the same time, they knew they had no other choice. And so, as the sisters kind of held back tears and whispered amongst each other, and as George looked up at the doctor, not sure what to say, finally Edwin, from the bed, croaked out the first words he'd said that day. He said that, yes, he and his wife would go to Colorado. Three years later, in January of 1892, Edwin held his wife's hand as they walked through the snow in the Rocky Mountains. The high elevation and dry air in Colorado Springs had worked like a charm. Edwin was back to feeling like his normal self again. After walking a bit longer, Edwin told his wife they should head back home for lunch. When they got to their house. Edwin's wife rushed inside out of the cold. But Edwin stayed for a second and checked the mailbox for any letters from his dad and sisters. And he found there was an envelope. So he opened it and he unfolded the note. Inside it was a handwritten letter from his father. And as Edwin scanned the paper, his face fell. The note said that one of Edwin's little sisters, 19 year old Mercy, had unfortunately passed away. Edwin knew that Mercy had been sick. She'd contracted the White Death almost a year earlier. He had tried to convince her to move out to Colorado with him and his wife because he knew that would cure this, but Mercy said she didn't think she could make the long journey and she didn't want to leave behind her sisters. And so she had stayed. But now Mercy was gone, and so Edwin knew he would need to head back to Rhode island and be there to grieve with his family. A few weeks later, back in Rhode Island, Edwin and his father braced themselves against the harsh winter cold in Exeter, and together they silently dug rocks out of the frozen ground. They were trying to prepare the field for planting in the spring. It was hard work, but the physical labor was actually a welcome distraction from their grief. Edwin pushed a sharp shovel into the ground, and as he wedged another rock out of the soil, he suddenly felt like a heavy weight was pressing down on his chest. He dropped his shovel and started coughing so hard that it stung his throat. He put a hand over his mouth to block the cough, and when he caught his breath and moved his hand away, he saw that his palm was now speckled with blood. When he looked up, Edwin saw his father staring at him with a horrified expression. They both knew what this meant now that he was back in Rhode Island. Edwin's case of the White Death had returned in March. About a month later, George woke in the night to the sound of his only son coughing violently. George jumped out of bed and rushed to the kitchen to grab a cup of water, and then made his way into Edwin's room, which was dimly lit by an oil lamp. Edwin had become so sick after contracting the White Death that he couldn't go anywhere, and he had been bedridden for the last two weeks here in Rhode Island. It was like all the progress he'd made living in Colorado had now been undone, and he was now sicker than he'd been before. He looked frail and gray, and George could see spots on the white bedsheet from where Edwin had been coughing up blood. George held out the cup of Water for his son, and Edwin grabbed the glass with shaky hands and drank it in between coughs. Then Edwin looked at his father, and in a hoarse and frightened voice, he said something that terrified George. He said, she was here. She haunts me. George just stared at his son. He had no idea what his son was talking about. But before George could ask, Edwin was gripped by another coughing fit. And the only thing George could think to do was send for Dr. Metcalfe. Less than an hour later, George stood by Edwin's bedside as Dr. Metcalf examined his son. Now, George knew his son was in very bad shape at this point, but he was still shocked when Dr. Metcalfe, after examining Edwin, turned to George and just said, it's in God's hands now. There was apparently nothing he or anyone else could do to help Edwin. George was beyond devastated. He had lost his wife, two daughters, and now he was just counting the days until his only son passed away, too. He felt totally powerless. But Edwin, despite hearing this grave news, was putting on a brave face. With his voice still hoarse from coughing, he asked his father if he had any whiskey. If his days were indeed numbered, well, they might as well enjoy the last few moments. George nodded and headed to the kitchen. And as he was taking glasses out of the cabinet for the whiskey, he heard a knock at the door, which was odd because it was well past midnight and he never had visitors this late. George set the glasses down, made his way to the door and opened it up to see six of his neighbors standing there on the porch. One of them, an older woman with graying hair, said they'd heard that his son Edwin was sick, and a few of them had seen Dr. Metcalf come over earlier, and so they were concerned. But they said they were not just here to pay their condolences. They were here to try to save him. George had to stop himself from letting out a very bitter laugh. He already knew no one could help his son. No one had been able to help anybody else in his family when they had the White Death, and it was just a matter of time before his son died. But he let the neighbors inside anyway, if only because seeing a few familiar faces might lift his son's spirits. When George and the visitors rounded the corner into Edwin's room, most of the neighbors went to Edwin's bedside to say hello. But the older woman walked directly towards Dr. Metcalfe and began speaking to him in a very hushed voice. George was curious, so he walked closer to listen, and he heard this woman tell Dr. Metcalfe that she actually knew how to cure Edwin. The doctor told her that was not possible. Nobody could cure the sickness. But the woman said Edwin was not sick. He was actually cursed by a vampire. George watched Dr. Metcalf's face go red with anger. He told the woman that she was being absolutely ridiculous. The doctor then looked over at George like he wanted somebody to back him up here. But George was desperate enough to consider anything at this point. And as crazy as a vampire's curse sounded, he didn't think it was that far fetched. And so he wanted to hear more from this woman. After all, the White Death had made his loved ones look like the life was being sucked out of them, Almost like a vampire was draining their blood. And just earlier that night, Edwin had said something to George that totally caught him off guard when he said, she was here. She haunts me. And so George wondered if maybe his son was referencing this vampire. And so George turned from the doctor to his son and asked him about what he had said earlier about somebody being in the room with him, somebody haunting him. And Edwin croaked out that earlier, when he was alone in the room, he had seen this woman standing in the corner of his bedroom, staring at him with cold, dead eyes. Now, he said he didn't know if this had been a dream or not, but it had felt so real that now he was scared to death from the experience. To George, his son's testimony only seemed to strengthen the neighbor's vampire theory. However, George told the older woman that he wanted proof that this really is what was going on, that a vampire was behind what was happening to his family. And so the older woman called over another one of the neighbors, a farmer that George sometimes shared crops with. And he told George and Dr. Metcalf that he'd seen cases like this before. He explained that sometimes when a person died, a dark supernatural force would take over their body and cause them to leech the life out of their surviving loved ones. Even from beyond the grave. These people were not really dead, the farmer said. They were vampires. At this point, the older woman interrupted the farmer and said to figure out which one of George's deceased family members was the vampire, all they had to do was exhume the bodies of his wife and two daughters. If one of the women's bodies hadn't yet decomposed, or if her heart still contained blood, that was a telltale sign that she was the vampire. To George, this whole process sounded barbaric. And he couldn't bear the thought of seeing his wife and children's decomposing bodies. But for all he knew, his neighbors could be right and this could be his only chance to save his only son. So George gave the neighbors his blessing to go dig up his family members bodies. And then George turned to Dr. Metcalfe and you know, said he couldn't go and see this and so asked the doctor to please go to the graveyard on his behalf. That way the doctor could be his eyes and also be the voice of reason.
Advertiser
Spark Something Uncommon this Holiday with just the right gift from Uncommon Goods. The busy holiday season is here and Uncommon Goods makes it less stressful with incredible handpicked gifts for everyone on your list. All in one spot. Gifts that spark joy, wonder, delight. And that. It's exactly what I wanted feeling when you shop at Uncommon Goods, you're supporting artists and small independent businesses. Many of their handcrafted products are made in small batches, so shop now before they sell out this holiday season. From holiday host and hostess gifts to the coolest finds for kids, to hits for everyone, from book lovers to die hard sports fans, Uncommon Goods has something for everyone. Not the same old selections you could find just anywhere. The variety is actually incredible. Seriously, name it. Clothes, games, stuff for your home, stuff for the outdoors, even experiences. And with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they give back $1 to a nonprofit partner of your choice. They've donated more than 3 million to get 15% off your next gift. Go to UncommonGoods.comballin that's UncommonGoods.comballin for 15% off. Don't miss out on this limited time offer. Uncommon Goods we're all out of the ordinary.
Ryan Reynolds
Hey, I'm Ryan Reynolds. Recently I asked Mint Mobile's legal team if big wireless companies are allowed to raise prices due to inflation. They said yes. And then when I asked if raising prices technically violates those onerous two year contracts, they said, what the are you talking about, you insane Hollywood? So to recap, we're cutting the price of mint unlimited from $30 a month to just $15 a month. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch $45 upfront.
Mr. Ballin
Payment equivalent to $15 per month New customers on first three month plan only taxes and fees, Extra speed slower above 40 gigabytes of detail. A few minutes later, Dr. Metcalf trudged through the dirt, lagging behind the neighbors as they made their way toward the Chestnut Hill cemetery. Between the seven of them, they had three small lanterns, one of which Dr. Metcalf was holding to light his way as the doctor walked along, he could hear the neighbors up ahead of him whispering about this vampire and what they were going to do. And it was hard for the doctor not to feel totally annoyed because he did not believe a curse was behind what was happening to George's family. But he reminded himself that George was utterly desperate and had really kind of convinced himself that maybe this curse really was the thing, and Dr. Metcalf didn't have the heart to just completely shoot it down. And so if this is what it took, going along with the neighbors to the graveyard to prove that George's son Edwin, was not suffering from some kind of ridiculous curse, then ultimately this was worth it. Eventually, the neighbors and the doctor reached the cemetery's iron gates, which creaked as the farmer pushed them open. To the right of the entrance, Dr. Metcalfe could see a stone crypt, and next to it, he could see the Brown family's plot. And it didn't take long for the group to locate the tombstones they were looking for. Dr. Metcalf stood a few feet away and watched while two of the neighbors held up lanterns and three others stuck shovels into George's wife's grave. They threw dirt to the side until eventually they unearthed her wooden coffin. The leader of the neighbors, the older woman who brought up the vampire curse, unlatched the casket, pulled it open, and revealed the dusty skeleton of George's late wife. She'd been dead for nine years, and so her body had, like Dr. Metcalf had expected, totally decomposed. To the neighbors, though, this only meant that George's wife was not the vampire, but one of the two daughters was. So they reburied the wife and dug up George's first daughter, the one who had died just a few months after George's wife. And again, when they opened up the coffin, it was just full of bones. And so they reburied the daughter as well. And then finally, the neighbors exhumed Mercy, the second daughter, who had died just eight weeks earlier. And what they found inside of her casket struck even Dr. Metcalf, the most skeptical person there, as absolutely inexplicable. Despite having been dead for two full months by this point, Mercy's body had not even begun to decompose. And to make things even stranger, Mercy's body was lying on its side as if she had literally turned over in her grave after being buried. The gray haired woman turned to Dr. Metcalf and pointed and said, look, there's your vampire. The doctor, who was admittedly kind of shaken up, still insisted there had to be Some kind of rational medical explanation for this. But the neighbors wouldn't listen. They had already begun performing a ritual that they believed would kill the vampire, break the curse, and save Edwin's life. The neighbors gathered up twigs and arranged them on top of a nearby boulder. Then the farmer flicked a match and kindled the flame into a small bonfire. And then Dr. Metcalf watched in stunned silence as the older woman pulled something out of a bag that she'd carried into the cemetery. And in the flickering light, he saw a flash of silver. And he realized what the woman had pulled from her bag was a huge kitchen knife. And then Dr. Metcalf looked on in horror as the woman stared, stuck that blade directly into Mercy's abdomen, slicing her stomach open. And then the woman reached up under Mercy's ribs and pulled out her liver and her heart. And then, after opening them up, both organs were indeed still full of coagulated blood, as though Mercy's body had been using these organs recently. At this point, the old woman placed Mercy's organs on top of the fire and let them burn down to ash. But after that, the ritual was not done. The older woman pulled something else out of her bag. It was a jar full of water, and she unscrewed the cap. Then she scooped the ashes of the organs and put them into this water, then closed the jar and shook up the contents. The woman said the ritual was almost complete. All they needed to do now was now have Edwin drink this entire concoction of water and. And his sister's burned organs. The neighbors turned and began marching out of the cemetery. And Dr. Metcalf, who was still just shocked by everything he had just seen, kind of chased after them, begging them to stop. But none of them even looked back. They were on a mission. A little while later that evening, Edwin was propped up in bed, feeling lifeless and miserable, surrounded by his father, Dr. Metcalf, and the group of neighbors. Edwin held the jar of black liquid in his hands, but he hadn't drunk any of it yet. Instead, he listened as Dr. Metcalf and the older woman argued. Dr. Metcalfe said that if Edwin drank that it would only make him sicker, but the older woman insisted it was the only medicine that would cure him. Edwin looked to his father for some advice about what to do, but George told Edwin it was up to him. Staring at the watery ashes of his own sister's heart and liver, Edwin almost began to gag. He couldn't decide what to do. If he drank this vile liquid, he could die. But if he didn't drink it, he would still very likely die. So he ultimately decided he had nothing to lose. He unscrewed the jar's cap, Brought the black water to his lips, and began to drink. But despite drinking his sister's burned liver and heart, Two months after this ritual, Edwin still died of the White Death. The ritual had not worked. And after losing his only son, George Brown's life continued to get worse. Over the next six years, three more of his daughters would die of the White death, leaving him with only one child, his daughter, Hattie. George lived another two decades. However, his one remaining child, Hattie, would outlive George by about another 40 years. She would die in 1954. But she lived long enough to actually see a cure developed for the White death. Because it would turn out the White Death was not some curse caused by a vampire. It was actually a very common and very deadly infectious disease called tuberculosis. And by 1954, a vaccine had been developed. But back in the late 1800s, tuberculosis was a global epidemic. It was highly infectious, often spreading amongst families or other tight knit social groups, and it accounted for 25% of all deaths in the northeastern United States where the Brown family lived. But despite how common it was, tuberculosis was very poorly understood. There were many different types and the symptoms could vary widely. So it wasn't always accurately diagnosed. And even when it was, there was no effective medications. So treatment was mostly guesswork. Although almost everyone in New England at the time knew someone who had died of tuberculosis, the Brown family had a uniquely horrible experience. They lived in an isolated, half abandoned community where superstition reigned. So when they started coming down with the so called White death, which was a nickname for tuberculosis, Their neighbors thought they'd become the victim of a vampire. And when they exhumed Mercy and found that her body had not decomposed, they took that as proof that she possessed supernatural powers and was behind the curse. But just like Dr. Metcalf suspected, on the night where they exhumed her, there actually was a rational explanation for why Mercy's body had not decomposed. Mercy died in the middle of the harsh New England winter, when the ground was so frozen that it would have been impossible to actually dig a grave. So instead of being buried underground in the cemetery next to her mother and sister, she was still buried in the cemetery, but above ground in that stone crypt where her body was naturally frozen and preserved. As for why her body appeared to have rolled over inside of her coffin, that was most likely because the neighbors had moved the casket as they opened it and sort of accidentally shifted her remains. However, Mercy's reputation as a vampire lived on, and her story made headlines all across the country. And in fact, in 1896, one article about Mercy the Vampire made it into the hands of an aspiring novelist named Bram Stoker. He would release Dracula one year later, and the book featured a young woman who was turned into a vampire and later had her body exhumed. The character's name was Lucy, a combination of Mercy and her middle name, which was Lena.
Advertiser
Hey prime members, you can listen to new episodes of Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries early and ad free on Amazon Music. Download the app today and also Wondry subscribers can listen to Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries ad free. Join Wondry plus today. Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey@listenersurvey.com.
Mr. Ballin
From Ballin Studios and Wondry. This is Mr. Balin's Medical Mysteries posted by me Mr. Ballin a quick note about our stories. We do sometimes use aliases because we don't know the names of the real people involved. And also in most cases, we can't know exactly exactly what was said in these stories. But everything is based on research and also a reminder. The content in this episode is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. This episode was written by Karis Alan Pash Cooper. Our editor is Heather Dundas. Sound design is by Andre Plus. Our coordinating producer is Sophia Martins. Our senior producer is Alex Benedon. Our associate producers and researchers are Sara Vitak and Taysha Palakonda. Fact checking was done by Sheila Patterson for Ballin Studios. Our head of production is Zach Levitt. Script editing by Scott Allen and Evan Allen. Our coordinating producer is Samantha Collins. Production support by Avery Siegel. Executive producers are myself, Mr. Ballin, and also Nick Witters for Wondry. Our head of sound is Marcelino Vilapondo. Senior producers are Laura, Donna Palavoda and Dave Schilling. Senior managing producer is Ryan Lore. Our executive producers are Erin O'Flaherty and Marshall Louie. For wondering.
Jake Warren
I'm Jake Warren and in our first season of Finding, I set out on a very personal quest to find the woman who saved my mom's life. You can listen to Finding Natasha right now exclusively on Wandery Plus. In season two, I found myself caught up in a new journey to help someone I've never even met. But a couple of years ago, I came across a social media post by a person named Loti. It read in part three years ago.
Mr. Ballin
Today that I attempted to jump off this bridge, but this wasn't my time to go. A gentleman named Andy saved my life. I still haven't found him.
Jake Warren
This is a story that I came across purely by chance, but it instantly moved me, and it's taken me to a place where I've had to consider some deeper issues around mental health. This is season two of Finding, and this time, if all goes to plan, we'll be finding Andy. You can listen to Finding Andy and Finding Natasha exclusively and ad free on Wondery plus. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcast, or Spotify.
MrBallen’s Medical Mysteries
Episode 56: "She Haunts Me"
Release Date: October 29, 2024
Host/Author: Wondery
In Episode 56, titled "She Haunts Me," MrBallen delves into a chilling tale from the late 19th century, intertwining medical mystery with supernatural folklore. Set in Exeter, Rhode Island, the story explores the devastating impact of a mysterious disease known as the "White Death" and the desperate measures a family takes to save their son, Edwin. This episode masterfully blends historical context with eerie suspense, highlighting how fear and superstition can intertwine with medical crises.
The episode opens in the spring of 1889, introducing Dr. Harold Metcalf, a 29-year-old physician in the struggling town of Exeter, Rhode Island. The town, once vibrant, has been decimated by the Civil War and the relentless scourge of the White Death—tuberculosis.
“For centuries, people believed that monsters, demons, and other horrors could cause deadly diseases and all kinds of misery.”
(00:00)
The stage is set for a nightmarish exploration of a family's battle against an incurable disease amidst growing superstitions.
Dr. Metcalf receives a late-night telegram from George Brown, a local farmer, pleading for help as his son Edwin has fallen ill. The Browns have endured significant loss over the years: George's wife succumbed to the White Death seven years prior, followed by one of their daughters. Despite Dr. Metcalf's best efforts, the remedies—healthy food and exercise—proved ineffective, leading to their untimely deaths.
“Even though Dr. Metcalf knew the White Death was basically incurable, he still felt guilty for not being able to help George and his loved ones.”
(04:20)
Determined to save Edwin, Dr. Metcalf proposes an experimental treatment: relocating to Colorado Springs, known for its dry climate, which was believed to alleviate tuberculosis symptoms. The journey of 2,000 miles is fraught with uncertainty, but George agrees, and Edwin temporarily regains his health.
Three years later, in January 1892, Edwin returns to Rhode Island after benefiting from the climate in Colorado. However, his recovery is short-lived as he contracts the White Death again. The family's grief deepens with the loss of another daughter, Mercy, who had refused to relocate, choosing instead to stay with her sisters.
“Edwin croaked out the first words he'd said that day. He said that, yes, he and his wife would go to Colorado.”
(04:20)
Tragedy strikes anew when Edwin, weakened by the disease, begins to suffer violently. In a state of despair, he confides in his father, revealing a haunting presence he perceives in his room.
“She was here. She haunts me.”
(16:58)
This eerie declaration ignites the neighbors' belief in a supernatural cause—a vampire curse—believing that a vengeful spirit is draining the life from the Browns.
Driven by desperation, George allows the neighbors to exhume the bodies of his deceased family members to identify the alleged vampire. Dr. Metcalf, skeptical but empathetic, accompanies them to Chestnut Hill cemetery. The neighbors uncover that Mercy's body had remarkably resisted decomposition due to the harsh winter conditions, not supernatural intervention.
“Mercy died in the middle of the harsh New England winter, when the ground was so frozen that it would have been impossible to actually dig a grave.”
(17:32)
Despite the rational explanation, the neighbors remain convinced of the vampire's existence and perform a grim ritual, attempting to exterminate the supposed curse by consuming Mercy's organs mixed with water.
Edwin, caught between fear and desperation, consumes the concoction, but the ritual fails to cure him. Tragically, Edwin succumbs to the White Death, and the Brown family's suffering continues. Over the next two decades, additional daughters fall victim to the disease, leaving only Hattie to witness the eventual medical advancements that would render the White Death manageable.
“Two months after this ritual, Edwin still died of the White Death.”
(27:44)
The episode concludes by revealing that the White Death was tuberculosis, a well-known but poorly understood and deadly disease during that era. The superstition surrounding vampires was a misguided interpretation of the disease’s severe symptoms, further exacerbated by the family's isolation and loss.
“The White Death was not some curse caused by a vampire. It was actually a very common and very deadly infectious disease called tuberculosis.”
(29:29)
"She Haunts Me" serves as a poignant reminder of how fear and lack of medical knowledge can give rise to supernatural explanations for natural phenomena. MrBallen skillfully narrates the Brown family's tragic story, highlighting the intersection of medicine, superstition, and human desperation. This episode not only entertains but also educates listeners on the historical context of tuberculosis and its profound impact on communities.
Mr. Ballin:
“Were they being plagued by a mysterious disease? Or were they actually being preyed on by a creature thought only to exist in legend?”
(00:00)
George Brown:
“There was nothing he or anyone else could do to help Edwin. It’s in God’s hands now.”
(17:32)
Edwin Brown:
“She was here. She haunts me.”
(16:58)
Narrator:
“The White Death was actually a very common and very deadly infectious disease called tuberculosis.”
(29:29)
Historical Impact of Tuberculosis: The episode underscores the devastating effects of tuberculosis in the 19th century, a time when medical understanding and treatments were limited.
Intersection of Medicine and Superstition: The Brown family's ordeal illustrates how severe diseases can be misconstrued as supernatural phenomena, especially in isolated communities.
Human Desperation and Belief: In the face of incurable illness, the family and community's turn to vampiric explanations reflects the deep psychological impact of loss and the lengths to which people will go to find hope.
Legacy of Misunderstood Diseases: The narrative connects historical misconceptions to modern understandings, showing progress in medical science and the importance of education in combating superstition.
Disclaimer: The content of this episode is based on historical events and thorough research. However, it is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.